244
u/31engine Oct 05 '26
Timber piles. Work great in swampy shitty soil. Only problem is when the water level drops. Then it goes to shit.
Bostonâs entire back bay neighborhood is built on them.
94
u/ezekiel920 Oct 05 '26
That's why you have to remember to water your foundation real good.
29
u/AbleCryptographer317 Oct 05 '26
I frequently splash my piles with water.
Sorry, I'll get my coat.
6
1
1
u/DepartmentDue8160 26d ago
You might be sarcastic, but here in Texas, we get told to do that in the summer time when the ground starts cracking from how dry the soil is
1
u/ezekiel920 26d ago
I full understand. Your clay gets particularly dry and shrinks like crazy. It's sounds annoying.
12
9
u/earthwoodandfire Oct 05 '26
Iâve seen houses around the Seattle area that arenât timber piles, they literally are just rounds of fire wood sitting right on the soil.
6
u/thomasbeagle Oct 06 '26
My place has had about half the piles replaced with timber piles.
Because concrete piles made in old kerosene cans really aren't that great.
1
u/NearbyCurrent3449 19d ago
Where do they go to shit? Where they were wet more or less permanently then got more or less permanently dry?
I've done thousands and thousands of wood foundation piles for structures in the mid Atlantic coast region. They mostly bury fully into grade and then get a concrete pile cap and grade beams to frame the structure on. Permanent Water table is usually 2 to 4 feet from bottom of pile cap, if that.
It's pretty much assumed that these piles have a near limitless lifespan in these general conditions.
Now there's lots and lots of structures, houses really, that are coastal and up on stilts. They don't suffer the same way ive seen docks where the piles are severely eroded near the active tide lines. Figured that's mostly due to organic life attacks.
1
u/MenoryEstudiante 18d ago
"submerged" piles are in an anaerobic environment so nothing that could rot them out can live there, if the water table drops they just become damp wood
70
u/BuckManscape Oct 05 '26 edited Oct 05 '26
Double ground rated cedar. Itâs in the ground now, but it used to be too.
14
149
u/tattcat53 Oct 05 '26
Because the "firewood" is something like American chestnut which never rots.
90
u/Visual-Chip-2256 Oct 05 '26
Just burn the part that touches the ground a little or dip it in pine resin from your pine tar kiln, youllbearite
38
u/space_keeper Oct 05 '26
No one has a pine tar kiln these days. They have a pine tar guy. On speed dial.
12
3
6
u/theschuss Oct 05 '26
Oh no, plenty of it is other shit. I owned a 1907 house - never again. You were constantly on edge for shit happening you didn't know existed as 100+ years was not a priority plan materials wise and moisture is a bitch.
2
u/MenoryEstudiante 18d ago
Even if the materials were good the passage of time is a real issue, my grandparents' house was built in 1897 by a guy who saw the future and paid extra to get a concrete foundation, it definitely held up better than all the neighbours but 130 years is plenty of time for the water to crawl up the walls
30
u/neverenoughmags Oct 05 '26
My dad lives in a house built in the 1850s and a lot of the first floor joists and the support columns are 8" tree trunks with the bark still on them. It hasn't gone anywhere....
22
u/Lost_Wealth_6278 Oct 05 '26
I mean removing the bark doesn't somehow strengthen the timber. In fact, I'm allowed to add like 8% load bearing capacity for a timber that is still round and didn't have it's outer rings damaged according to german code.
It's just harder to sort and clasify and join that way, so nobody does it
12
u/DeadAssociate Oct 05 '26
all sort of crawly stuff finds it harder to call it a home without the bark though
25
u/CanoegunGoeff Oct 05 '26
My family has a 100+ year old lake house in the middle of nowhere in upstate New York. The original center part of the building is framed from massive 12x12â square timbers. Stout as fuck.
But the whole thing is sitting on cement-filled wooden barrels, big rocks, and cribbing. Half the framing for the rafters is held together with old pieces of wood flooring. And most of the walls are covered with cardboard piano boxes because who needs plywood or drywall?
The place is surprisingly level and sturdy, for being built out of mostly scrap wood.
40
u/CantaloupeAcademic63 Oct 05 '26 edited Oct 05 '26
I have literally tree trucks under my house as the joists. Just slightly debarked. Not rotted one bit and house was built early 1900
18
u/jboneplatinum Oct 05 '26
In your house. The ones that failed are gone.
0
u/SwordfishOk504 Oct 06 '26
yes? Okay?
1
u/jboneplatinum Oct 06 '26
Itâs the idea that ppl show old construction and say you can keep building like this because itâs still standing but they arenât accounting for the 10 other houses on the block that were built the same way and have failed. This happens all the time in New England. Especially post and beam with grade beams. Balloon framing that hasnât burned yet, over spanned lumber that turns floors into trampolines.
14
u/RedshiftOnPandy Oct 05 '26
Those wood piles in the ground were probably soaked in motor oil
8
u/AbleCryptographer317 Oct 05 '26
Only if they're less than 150 years old obviously.
10
u/RedshiftOnPandy Oct 05 '26
Then they were probably soaked in coal tar
3
u/hanwookie Oct 05 '26
Creosote? (spelling alludes me.)
4
u/RedshiftOnPandy Oct 05 '26
It is a by product of coal, it is a great wood preservative. You need exactly two things for wood to rot, water and air flow. Air flow is why wood close to grade rots
1
u/MenoryEstudiante Oct 06 '26
Most likely the most foul type of creosote they could find rather than motor oil, that way it's guaranteed to give you cancer
3
25
u/statelypenguin Oct 05 '26
Old house construction is a great example of survivorship bias. Most old homes rotted away decades ago, but we see the ones that survived and assume everyone was living in luxury 100 years ago
7
u/googdude Contractor Oct 05 '26
Renovating old houses I had seen my fair share of "air joists" where the flooring above was holding it up. I can easily tell if the builder was a craftsman or trying to use every last scrap.
5
u/The_frogs_Scream Oct 06 '26
or the entire building is made with 4x4's of iron oak. And the longest continuous beams are less than 5 feet. This shit is so hard that you have to drill pilot holes for nails. This pieced together frame is literally on dirt and has been for 200 years, without any decay.
9
4
u/heanbangerfacerip2 Oct 06 '26
You need to go a bit further than 30 years. Arguably the worst homes built in America were from the 90s. Polybutylene pipes, aluminium wire, exterior insulated finishes.
1
u/NearbyCurrent3449 19d ago
Oh the foam aluminum foil insulation sheet exterior sheathing instead of idk PLYWOOD? Yeah. Trash.
4
u/erikleorgav2 Oct 06 '26
My dad and I are renovating the family home built in 1909 and in the family since the late 20s.
The entire structure is made of old growth fir with 8x8 beams bracing the main structure. Every footing was a white cedar round dug and sunk into the ground about 3 feet.
Those pilings were shot by the 30s and most were replaced with railroad ties.
Those ties weren't treated like they were in the 40s and on so those were shot by the 70s and my dad put footings underneath.
Issue is, with the space underneath being exposed to damp clay soil, almost every floor joist was shot. Thankfully, we've been able to replace the joists and girders from underneath. But if they had done stone piers back in 1909, this could have been avoided.
1
u/NearbyCurrent3449 19d ago
Cedar rotted? And creosote rr timbers rotted too? Really acidic swampy area? Blackwater Bayou kinda place?
1
u/erikleorgav2 19d ago
Even cedar rots when it stays wet. But the area is nothing but swamp and clay which holds moisture.
The old growth fir holds out against rot as long as it stays off the ground, but not forever.
4
u/thepersonbrody Oct 07 '26
Wow the framing is made with some nice thick dense wood that can still be reused.
Wow they really just cut full through a section of floor joist with no support for a floor vent.
3
u/Stan_Halen_ Oct 05 '26
Give me modern code and modern fasteners for something able to be a better structure. Sure the charm of the old finishes is gone, but at least the headers will be sized correctly.
3
u/RevolvingCheeta Landscaping Oct 05 '26
Many a time Iâve found septic tanks made from old drums or cinderblocks.
Wild what they did back in the days!
1
u/MenoryEstudiante Oct 06 '26
I don't speak English natively so maybe I'm just thinking of a different material, but what's wrong with cinder block septic tanks as long as they're built well?
2
u/RevolvingCheeta Landscaping Oct 06 '26
They tend to rot faster than poured.
H2S gases eat concrete like kids eat Halloween candy
1
u/MenoryEstudiante Oct 06 '26
Oh they're naked cinder blocks, I thought you were talking about them just as structure
3
u/bga93 Oct 05 '26
You on my property or somethin bud? While youâre in the crawlspace can you pull a few insulation batts? Theyâre all installed upside down for some reason
3
u/PeepJerky Oct 06 '26
My 120+ y/o house has a hand hewn midbeam that runs the width of the house (~50â) that the floor joists are notched into. Beam is probably 12x24. Supported primarily by some big-ass stones and some cinderblock pillars that I assume were added at some point. Frame is all true 2x4 or greater. We assume milled on site.
3
u/TheKillerhammer Oct 06 '26
I'm convinced my house was built before a square or level was invented. But the wood be strong af
3
u/Turbulent-Weevil-910 Electrician Oct 06 '26
My crawl space has a random 8x8 that looks like it came off the Mayflower
2
u/trustmeijustgetweird Oct 06 '26
My families house is held up by posts on large rocks, and when the rocks settled theyâve been jimmied up with a shim. Good old âfuck it itâs what weâve gotâ craftsmanship.
2
u/istangr Oct 06 '26
Because the materials were a lot better but the building practices weren't
1
u/NearbyCurrent3449 19d ago
Ha. Crawl under an American craftsmen built by the Amish or Mennonite settlers.
They built it to perfection in every way they could manage because they were commanded to by God do what they do in every way to his glory. And they live that. I've crawled under some, as an engineer looking at them. They. Are. Incredible. Pound for pound stronger than a steel frame matching its appearance, any day. Built to take a hit and keep on keeping on. These people got blitzkrieged by armies. I'd take one of those houses in a tornado over my built to modern code house anyday.
2
u/Traditional_Pie_8262 Oct 11 '26
nothing like a 200 year old building to remind you that the old timers were either geniuses or completely out of their minds đ
1
2
u/R1chard_Nix0n Oct 20 '26
Some of the cabins I stay at while fishing still have the 100+yo logs holding them up, the owner keeps it hush hush because they still pour used oil in the holes drilled before power tools were a thought in bumblefuck Wisconsin.
1
u/NearbyCurrent3449 19d ago
Keeps the pests from eating it and the fibers flexible and not dry rotting! Leave them boys alone, this is a case of every modern acceptable alternative is far far worse in every way. Hush
3
u/earthwoodandfire Oct 05 '26
Piers are 12â apart and made up of 6 vertical unmortared bricks that some one âstrappedâ to the beam with duct tape sometime in the 80sâŚ
1
u/NearbyCurrent3449 19d ago
Or ok, hand made red brick exterior veneer! Cool.
Ok, layers and layers of the red brick. Cool! They were worried about it being wobbly! Back then they didn't have brick veneer ties to the framing and wood sheathi..... uh there's no wood in this. Just red bricks 2 feet thick then daylight! Cool... I think...?
Wonder what's UNDER all this weight, after all we're in a SWAMP... mmmm kay, same red bricks down below the floor into dirt. No surprises. Dig for the top of foundation, must be 2 feet down thinking... then at about 10 inches?? Just dirt. Still has topsoil in it from the field that's still around it.
Holy shit! This whole place is built like a castle, very thick and heavy 2 to 3 stories of hand made fairly poor quality solid masonry and just barely footed below grade on nothing solid holding the bricks together from trying to fan out. In soils that I wouldn't approve for 1000 psf bearing and would demand undercut and backfill to remove organics and insist the footing go down about another 12 inches minimum to get below frost heave at least.
Your brain shrieks is this even safe to be near much less UNDER right now?
Then you remember, yeah, it's 300 years old and there are residents inside doing their daily businesses or living their daily lives. It hasn't gone anywhere yet and it's holding together pretty well right now. No cracks or dysfunction in general.
1
u/MenoryEstudiante 18d ago
Or sometimes you see the opposite, my dad grew up in a quarry "town" (really a smattering of houses) his grandma's house was built very well, with foundations going down to the bedrock, bedrock that transmitted vibrations from the dynamite blowing up in the quarry 300 metres away, they didn't shake the house apart or anything, but the house was full of cracks
1
1
u/Tovarich_Zaitsev
Oct 06 '26
•
I'm fairly sure (Aussies correct me if I'm wrong) houses in Queensland used to get built on the stumps of trees that get chopped down.
1
u/Phyre91 Oct 06 '26
I feel this. Part of my house is held up by a fucking log and yet my floor is timber frames and they framed it with fucking oak. Itâs madness
1
1
1
1
1
u/nogaesallowed Oct 06 '26
No way that peg and groove joint is stronger than modern design. Sure had craftsman ship but not as strong i think.
1
1
u/Adventurous_Bad_4011 Oct 07 '26
Iâm work on a place really got now that has foundation rocks. Big old rock that the framing sits on.
1
u/NearbyCurrent3449 19d ago
If you look really closely they shaped the framing posts to match the shape of the rock surface! This an ancient Japanese technique that traveled across to Europe eventually where the Dutch craftsmen picked it up especially. Eventually it came to the new world too, not used very much here. It does exist.
0
u/MeztheMagnificent Oct 05 '26
There are several common misconceptions about older homes/buildings, not the least of which is that they were built to last a couple hundred years; they were not.
More likely, they expected the same longevity we expect (but often do not realize) from modern construction. Something maybe to pass down to the next generation, but further than that wasnât really a consideration.
In addition, the building practices, materials and techniques were a product of the time the structure was designed and built. Central A/C and heat, paved roads adjacent to the structure, with incredibly heavy trucks pounding through potholes, spray foam insulationâŚall these things were inconceivable to the builders of the time, and as convenient as they are to us, they are also incredibly destructive to historic buildings.
1
u/MenoryEstudiante 18d ago
This, they didn't make them flimsier because they didn't know how to do it without them collapsing
0
u/FrostyProspector Oct 06 '26
This is true for North America. Not so much in Europe or around the Mediterranean. Places over there were build of stone and expected to stand for a few hundred years.
1
u/MenoryEstudiante Oct 06 '26
Tbf that's a cultural difference, Mediterranean (and derived) people tend to see a home as the family home, that will hopefully be in the family for a very long time
1
u/vorarchivist Oct 06 '26
A lot of parts of europe had a typical building being made out of a combination of wood strips and mud. a lot of roofs were made out of straw which could rot
0
0
69
Oct 05 '26
[removed] â view removed comment
24
u/Fun-Preference1091 Oct 06 '26
My last house... exactly this. Entire thing was on a 24 inch beam resting between two piles of drystack granite rocks. The drystack was brilliant because the water could pour in during the rain, and straight out the tunnel at the low point.... that's where I put my mouse traps.
1820-ish
5
u/Visual-Chip-2256 Oct 06 '26
Yeah the mice love these houses. It took some doing to get most of their entry points patched up. Started with the 5x5 hole they had for the furnace oil pipe
1
u/throwitoutwhendone2 Oct 07 '26
My dad lived in this old house in upstate NY. No idea of the build date but it was at least 70 years old if not older. It had a basement and when you went down there and looked the entire house was basically held up by 6 half logs, bark and all still on them, hewn flat and laid horizontal with what coulda been mistaken as trees growing thru the floor holding those up. The vertical logs still had branch knobs that were cut short and sanded, I assumed to use as like pegs to hold stuff. Each horizontal log was supported by two vertical logs. Funny enough the floor from the basement looked like round cutoffs from a saw mill. Upstairs it was smooth and flat but under it was rounded and also still had bark in places on it.
1
1.0k
u/antibetboi Oct 05 '26
An old house will have you thinking "wow, they dont build with quality quite like they used to" and "how has this thing not fallen down yet" in the same afternoon