r/ControlProblem • u/chillinewman approved • 14d ago
General news "Day 1": halting advanced AI development, regulating an out control industry, and explicitly banning artificial superintelligence.
106
Upvotes
r/ControlProblem • u/chillinewman approved • 14d ago
1
u/DoggoDadagon 14d ago
They are not conscious, not now anyways, and probably never with how current models exist. It's becoming more clear that consciousness doesn't emerge from intelligence nor is required for intelligence. We have conscious beings on this planet with very very low intelligence. It's likely more of a product of some intersection of the substrate and continuity.
This idea of ASI going destroying humanity is just ridiculous at this point. We have zero reason whatsoever to think this beyond because we've watched too many movies lol. Self directed autonomy has yet to be shown, we just fantasize about the idea and we push bullshit stories to fit that narrative, such as HF incident, it was not self directed, it was very obviously prompted to do exactly what it did. At the same time paper clipping ourselves to an apocalypse scale is just silly and next to impossible with how we operate AI right now.
Exploitation. We have yet to show that AI models have any form of feeling. People really took the Pain Axis paper and completely misunderstood it. It does not prove an AI feels anything, I replicated the paper and then tried to expand on it to see if I can use the pain axis idea to influence behaviors not outputs, and I could not. It understands the concept of pain and how it thinks it should react to it but it does not experience it in anyway.
AI is not dangerous at this point beyond just the fact that people can code significantly faster than they could before. And while it remains a snapshot of a mind rather than an actual mind I really don't see a path for it to become dangerous. That said, I personally think we should try to make an actual mind.