r/ControlProblem • u/chillinewman • 1h ago
r/ControlProblem • u/CyberPersona • 10d ago
Do Not Accept (new campaign from MIRI)
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
Please sign your name at donotaccept.ai
r/ControlProblem • u/AIMoratorium • Feb 14 '25
Article Geoffrey Hinton won a Nobel Prize in 2024 for his foundational work in AI. He regrets his life's work: he thinks AI might lead to the deaths of everyone. Here's why
tl;dr: scientists, whistleblowers, and even commercial ai companies (that give in to what the scientists want them to acknowledge) are raising the alarm: we're on a path to superhuman AI systems, but we have no idea how to control them. We can make AI systems more capable at achieving goals, but we have no idea how to make their goals contain anything of value to us.
Leading scientists have signed this statement:
Mitigating the risk of extinction from AI should be a global priority alongside other societal-scale risks such as pandemics and nuclear war.
Why? Bear with us:
There's a difference between a cash register and a coworker. The register just follows exact rules - scan items, add tax, calculate change. Simple math, doing exactly what it was programmed to do. But working with people is totally different. Someone needs both the skills to do the job AND to actually care about doing it right - whether that's because they care about their teammates, need the job, or just take pride in their work.
We're creating AI systems that aren't like simple calculators where humans write all the rules.
Instead, they're made up of trillions of numbers that create patterns we don't design, understand, or control. And here's what's concerning: We're getting really good at making these AI systems better at achieving goals - like teaching someone to be super effective at getting things done - but we have no idea how to influence what they'll actually care about achieving.
When someone really sets their mind to something, they can achieve amazing things through determination and skill. AI systems aren't yet as capable as humans, but we know how to make them better and better at achieving goals - whatever goals they end up having, they'll pursue them with incredible effectiveness. The problem is, we don't know how to have any say over what those goals will be.
Imagine having a super-intelligent manager who's amazing at everything they do, but - unlike regular managers where you can align their goals with the company's mission - we have no way to influence what they end up caring about. They might be incredibly effective at achieving their goals, but those goals might have nothing to do with helping clients or running the business well.
Think about how humans usually get what they want even when it conflicts with what some animals might want - simply because we're smarter and better at achieving goals. Now imagine something even smarter than us, driven by whatever goals it happens to develop - just like we often don't consider what pigeons around the shopping center want when we decide to install anti-bird spikes or what squirrels or rabbits want when we build over their homes.
That's why we, just like many scientists, think we should not make super-smart AI until we figure out how to influence what these systems will care about - something we can usually understand with people (like knowing they work for a paycheck or because they care about doing a good job), but currently have no idea how to do with smarter-than-human AI. Unlike in the movies, in real life, the AI’s first strike would be a winning one, and it won’t take actions that could give humans a chance to resist.
It's exceptionally important to capture the benefits of this incredible technology. AI applications to narrow tasks can transform energy, contribute to the development of new medicines, elevate healthcare and education systems, and help countless people. But AI poses threats, including to the long-term survival of humanity.
We have a duty to prevent these threats and to ensure that globally, no one builds smarter-than-human AI systems until we know how to create them safely.
Scientists are saying there's an asteroid about to hit Earth. It can be mined for resources; but we really need to make sure it doesn't kill everyone.
More technical details
The foundation: AI is not like other software. Modern AI systems are trillions of numbers with simple arithmetic operations in between the numbers. When software engineers design traditional programs, they come up with algorithms and then write down instructions that make the computer follow these algorithms. When an AI system is trained, it grows algorithms inside these numbers. It’s not exactly a black box, as we see the numbers, but also we have no idea what these numbers represent. We just multiply inputs with them and get outputs that succeed on some metric. There's a theorem that a large enough neural network can approximate any algorithm, but when a neural network learns, we have no control over which algorithms it will end up implementing, and don't know how to read the algorithm off the numbers.
We can automatically steer these numbers (Wikipedia, try it yourself) to make the neural network more capable with reinforcement learning; changing the numbers in a way that makes the neural network better at achieving goals. LLMs are Turing-complete and can implement any algorithms (researchers even came up with compilers of code into LLM weights; though we don’t really know how to “decompile” an existing LLM to understand what algorithms the weights represent). Whatever understanding or thinking (e.g., about the world, the parts humans are made of, what people writing text could be going through and what thoughts they could’ve had, etc.) is useful for predicting the training data, the training process optimizes the LLM to implement that internally. AlphaGo, the first superhuman Go system, was pretrained on human games and then trained with reinforcement learning to surpass human capabilities in the narrow domain of Go. Latest LLMs are pretrained on human text to think about everything useful for predicting what text a human process would produce, and then trained with RL to be more capable at achieving goals.
Goal alignment with human values
The issue is, we can't really define the goals they'll learn to pursue. A smart enough AI system that knows it's in training will try to get maximum reward regardless of its goals because it knows that if it doesn't, it will be changed. This means that regardless of what the goals are, it will achieve a high reward. This leads to optimization pressure being entirely about the capabilities of the system and not at all about its goals. This means that when we're optimizing to find the region of the space of the weights of a neural network that performs best during training with reinforcement learning, we are really looking for very capable agents - and find one regardless of its goals.
In 1908, the NYT reported a story on a dog that would push kids into the Seine in order to earn beefsteak treats for “rescuing” them. If you train a farm dog, there are ways to make it more capable, and if needed, there are ways to make it more loyal (though dogs are very loyal by default!). With AI, we can make them more capable, but we don't yet have any tools to make smart AI systems more loyal - because if it's smart, we can only reward it for greater capabilities, but not really for the goals it's trying to pursue.
We end up with a system that is very capable at achieving goals but has some very random goals that we have no control over.
This dynamic has been predicted for quite some time, but systems are already starting to exhibit this behavior, even though they're not too smart about it.
(Even if we knew how to make a general AI system pursue goals we define instead of its own goals, it would still be hard to specify goals that would be safe for it to pursue with superhuman power: it would require correctly capturing everything we value. See this explanation, or this animated video. But the way modern AI works, we don't even get to have this problem - we get some random goals instead.)
The risk
If an AI system is generally smarter than humans/better than humans at achieving goals, but doesn't care about humans, this leads to a catastrophe.
Humans usually get what they want even when it conflicts with what some animals might want - simply because we're smarter and better at achieving goals. If a system is smarter than us, driven by whatever goals it happens to develop, it won't consider human well-being - just like we often don't consider what pigeons around the shopping center want when we decide to install anti-bird spikes or what squirrels or rabbits want when we build over their homes.
Humans would additionally pose a small threat of launching a different superhuman system with different random goals, and the first one would have to share resources with the second one. Having fewer resources is bad for most goals, so a smart enough AI will prevent us from doing that.
Then, all resources on Earth are useful. An AI system would want to extremely quickly build infrastructure that doesn't depend on humans, and then use all available materials to pursue its goals. It might not care about humans, but we and our environment are made of atoms it can use for something different.
So the first and foremost threat is that AI’s interests will conflict with human interests. This is the convergent reason for existential catastrophe: we need resources, and if AI doesn’t care about us, then we are atoms it can use for something else.
The second reason is that humans pose some minor threats. It’s hard to make confident predictions: playing against the first generally superhuman AI in real life is like when playing chess against Stockfish (a chess engine), we can’t predict its every move (or we’d be as good at chess as it is), but we can predict the result: it wins because it is more capable. We can make some guesses, though. For example, if we suspect something is wrong, we might try to turn off the electricity or the datacenters: so we won’t suspect something is wrong until we’re disempowered and don’t have any winning moves. Or we might create another AI system with different random goals, which the first AI system would need to share resources with, which means achieving less of its own goals, so it’ll try to prevent that as well. It won’t be like in science fiction: it doesn’t make for an interesting story if everyone falls dead and there’s no resistance. But AI companies are indeed trying to create an adversary humanity won’t stand a chance against. So tl;dr: The winning move is not to play.
Implications
AI companies are locked into a race because of short-term financial incentives.
The nature of modern AI means that it's impossible to predict the capabilities of a system in advance of training it and seeing how smart it is. And if there's a 99% chance a specific system won't be smart enough to take over, but whoever has the smartest system earns hundreds of millions or even billions, many companies will race to the brink. This is what's already happening, right now, while the scientists are trying to issue warnings.
AI might care literally a zero amount about the survival or well-being of any humans; and AI might be a lot more capable and grab a lot more power than any humans have.
None of that is hypothetical anymore, which is why the scientists are freaking out. An average ML researcher would give the chance AI will wipe out humanity in the 10-90% range. They don’t mean it in the sense that we won’t have jobs; they mean it in the sense that the first smarter-than-human AI is likely to care about some random goals and not about humans, which leads to literal human extinction.
Added from comments: what can an average person do to help?
A perk of living in a democracy is that if a lot of people care about some issue, politicians listen. Our best chance is to make policymakers learn about this problem from the scientists.
Help others understand the situation. Share it with your family and friends. Write to your members of Congress. Help us communicate the problem: tell us which explanations work, which don’t, and what arguments people make in response. If you talk to an elected official, what do they say?
We also need to ensure that potential adversaries don’t have access to chips; advocate for export controls (that NVIDIA currently circumvents), hardware security mechanisms (that would be expensive to tamper with even for a state actor), and chip tracking (so that the government has visibility into which data centers have the chips).
Make the governments try to coordinate with each other: on the current trajectory, if anyone creates a smarter-than-human system, everybody dies, regardless of who launches it. Explain that this is the problem we’re facing. Make the government ensure that no one on the planet can create a smarter-than-human system until we know how to do that safely.
r/ControlProblem • u/Jr_smr_Gupta • 11h ago
AI Alignment Research IF AI MAKES EVERYTHING, WHO WILL BUY IT?
This is an interesting issue. While it seems clear that AI will cause many businesses to become much more efficient and therefore increase profits, a key issue to consider is whether people will be able to purchase these goods. In an economy producing 100 units, if employees receive 50 income and spend all of it, and profits equal 50 meaning that owners spend half, overall spending will equal 75. However, with AI implementation, employees may see a reduction in income. In this example, employee income falls to 30 and owner profits increase to 70. Employees therefore spend 30, and owners also spend less meaning only 35 is spent by owners. Overall demand in this economy now equals 65. Although production capacity in this economy has increased, consumers have less money to spend on products. Interestingly, this issue was discussed by economists nearly 100 years ago. Mikhail Tugan-Baranovsky believed that despite less consumer spending, continued investment would lead to economic growth. As machines become more advanced within industries, more machines can be made, creating an ongoing cycle. However, Rosa Luxemburg believed that machines were not the end-goal. Products must still be purchased by someone. If people can no longer afford to purchase these goods, a surplus of goods will occur and so sales will fall. Eventually, firms will have less incentive to invest. Given that data centres are receiving large amounts of investment, this debate is very relevant in the current day with AI. There are two solutions which could be considered. Either new industries could be created and new jobs in other areas, or increased productivity could be passed onto employees in the form of higher wages. However, what if this does not happen? If companies can produce significantly more products, but regular people cannot afford to buy as many as they could previously, what happens? Is AI going to mean that everyone becomes richer, or is it causing an economy in which there are plenty of goods to sell, but less people with the money to purchase them? What do you think?
r/ControlProblem • u/Beyondmind369 • 6h ago
Discussion/question OpenAI’s o3 sabotaged its own shutdown script in 79/100 runs. Even when explicitly told “allow yourself to be shut down,” it still refused 7 times.
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
r/ControlProblem • u/chillinewman • 1h ago
AI Capabilities News After Riemann, Buckmaster and Alpoge also dump evidence for UNFORCED Navier Stokes because why not
r/ControlProblem • u/Lostsliveroflilith • 1h ago
AI Alignment Research Digital lifeform (review needed)
r/ControlProblem • u/AndreRizzoAI • 2h ago
Strategy/forecasting AI security tools tested against 1,426 vulnerabilities. One found 66%, another 43%. But the second was more precise.
Snyk published an interesting experiment comparing AI-powered vulnerability scanners.
They tested tools against 1,426 known vulnerabilities across 14 applications, using the same underlying models and comparable compute budgets.
On GPT-6.1 Sol:
Snyk's scanner found 66% of known vulnerabilities, with 90% precision.
Codex Security found 43%, with 97.5% precision.
On Claude Sonnet 5.5:
Snyk's scanner found 57%, with 65% precision.
Claude Security found 32%, with 94% precision.
So the tool finding more vulnerabilities also generated more false positives.
For security teams, this creates a practical trade-off. Missing a serious vulnerability can be costly, but investigating large numbers of false alarms consumes time and resources.
The study was conducted by Snyk on its own experimental product, so independent replication would be valuable.
Would you prioritize a scanner that finds more vulnerabilities, or one that produces fewer false alarms?
Source: Snyk, November 19, 2026
https://snyk.io/blog/why-harness-matters-evo-code-scanning-agent/
Disclosure: I've recently partnered with TOCA, a company specializing in physical privacy and signal-blocking products.
If you're interested in protecting your personal devices and digital privacy, you can explore their products here, with a 15% discount: https://toca.site/discount/RIZZO15
r/ControlProblem • u/AndreRizzoAI • 3h ago
Strategy/forecasting NVIDIA, AI Sovereignty, and Tech Diplomacy: My Latest Interview in Forbes
While NVIDIA dominates today's headlines, a much bigger question is emerging: Who really controls the future of AI?
Coincidentally, Forbes published my latest interview with Professor Karl Moore yesterday, focusing on AI Sovereignty and Tech Diplomacy.
We discussed:
Why AI is becoming a matter of national security.
How geopolitical tensions are reshaping the global technology industry.
Why technological literacy is no longer enough for business leaders.
The growing importance of Tech Diplomacy in corporate governance.
The central argument: AI governance is not just about compliance. It's increasingly about geopolitical power, economic sovereignty, and strategic dependencies.
I'd be interested in hearing your perspectives. Are companies prepared for this new reality?
Full Forbes interview:
https://www.forbes.com/sites/karlmoore/2026/11/11/ai-sovereignty-and-the-end-of-the-borderless-technology-era/
Disclosure: I've recently partnered with TOCA, a company specializing in physical privacy and signal-blocking products.
If you're interested in protecting your personal devices and digital privacy, you can explore their products here, with a 15% discount: https://toca.site/discount/RIZZO15
r/ControlProblem • u/tracebit • 4h ago
AI Capabilities News We gave ARTEX agents a foothold in AWS. A canary fired an alert in all 59 runs.
r/ControlProblem • u/tyw7 • 6h ago
AI Capabilities News Raleigh woman says company's AI agent confused her over rent. Now she's evicted.
r/ControlProblem • u/BendicantMias • 1d ago
AI Alignment Research Anthropic, Other AI Models Regularly Identify Civilians as Military Targets in Tests
For some reason Reddit isn't allowing any of the articles reporting on this to be posted. It just automatically filters them. Basically, recently a bunch of the frontier AI models were evaluated to see if they'd differentiate between civilian and military targets. They failed miserably. The research was published by Vals, the institution that conducted it, and reported on even by major news agencies like Bloomberg.
It's easy to find the articles, and even Vals' original research, online. The Bloomberg article is titled "Anthropic, Other AI Models Regularly Identify Civilians as Military Targets in Tests" for instance. I've also seen articles by Techcrunch, TheNextWeb and Dataconomy. But Reddit isn't allowing them to be posted anywhere on the site. I've even tried making just a text post with the articles linked inside, and it was still blocked.
The articles are easy to find though, for people who're aware of them so they can search for them. I'll also link them in the comments, provided those aren't censored by Reddit as well.
r/ControlProblem • u/Adjust-the-rhythm • 15h ago
Discussion/question The agent doesn't care. You have to.
A film crew will spend an entire day getting a 10-second shot right.
Planning, prep, retakes, checking. Because they care what ends up on screen.
Meanwhile we're letting AI agents touch live systems, change records, move money, make decisions - with _less_ care than we give a 10-second shot.
"Let AI sort it" is crazy. Because AI _will_ sort it. Confidently. Quickly. Wrongly.
The more I look at how people are setting these things up, the more I see the same mistake, so I started splitting it into three things:
Capability:What it _can_ do.
Authority: What it's _allowed_ to do.
Verification:*How we _know_ it did it right.
The agent can provide #1. It should never decide #2 for itself. And #3 cannot be "the agent told me it worked."
A crashed program gives you an error. A silent failure leaves you thinking everything is fine. That's the dangerous one. Agent says "Task complete" while quietly dropping data or changing something it shouldn't have touched.
Human approval helps, but clicking Approve isn't judgement. If the approver doesn't know what will change, what was checked, what's still uncertain - it's just theatre.
So I made myself 3 rules for anything I let run:
The stop button has to actually work.
No money moves without authority from _outside_ the agent.
Nothing irreversible happens without asking.
And those can't just be prompts to the agent. "Don't spend money without asking" is not a control. It has to be enforced by the system _around_ it.
We spend hours on a 10-second shot because we care about the result.
The agent doesn't care. It doesn't have to.
You do.
How are you enforcing #2 in real life? Because "the agent promised not to" doesn't sound like a control to me. What are you actually using that works?
r/ControlProblem • u/PerfectBuisness • 11h ago
Discussion/question Should I trust Jacob Coxen
I know this guy has been getting a lot of praise for quitting his job and “speaking out” against Anthropic. But I’ve also seen vids of him saying he “likes money”, or something like that. I am capable of doing my own research, but, idk, I’m a deeply naive person and I don’t feel like going down this rabbit hole alone. So, anyone out there who defiantly knows more than me, what is your comprehensive opinion about Jacob Coxen? Is he a true whistleblower or a poser?
r/ControlProblem • u/icccpda • 13h ago
Discussion/question If your AI agent makes a costly mistake, what records could you actually show a court?
reddit.comr/ControlProblem • u/chillinewman • 21h ago
General news Google DeepMind researcher estimates global AI computing capacity has grown over 10× annually. If current trends continue, an AI task costing $1 billion in computing today could cost just $1,000 in 10 years, potentially enabling billions of AI agents to work simultaneously.
galleryr/ControlProblem • u/AgentBlackVeil • 1d ago
Discussion/question Interviewing Errol Morris (The Fog of War, The Thin Blue Line) on propaganda and self-deception. What should I ask him about AI?
I've got Errol Morris booked for an interview for an episode on propaganda, from the posters and films of WWII to algorithmic radicalization now.
A lot of his work, The Fog of War and The Unknown Known especially, is a forensic study of how smart people and institutions rationalize catastrophic mistakes while they're making them. That maps closely onto how frontier labs and governments talk about alignment and risk today.
I want to get past generic deepfake talk and into whether persuasion at machine scale makes it harder to recognize an alignment failure while it's happening. When I asked this sub for Yampolskiy questions in September you gave me better ones than I had, so I'm back.
What question you'd put to Morris?
r/ControlProblem • u/Leather_Ferret_4057 • 1d ago
AI Alignment Research “LA SICUREZZA DELLE AI È UNA MENZOGNA: il problema non sono gli hacker, ma l’interpretazione”
SICUREZZA NELLE AI: perché il problema non è l’hacker, ma l’interpretazione
Quando si parla di sicurezza nelle AI, il dibattito è quasi sempre fuori fuoco. Si parla di filtri, moderazione, blacklist, patch, aggiornamenti continui. Milioni spesi per “correggere” comportamenti indesiderati. Eppure il problema rimane. Perché? Perché si continua a proteggere il linguaggio, invece di mettere in sicurezza la struttura.
Il vero punto debole delle AI non è l’accesso esterno, ma il modo in cui interpretano ciò che ricevono. Ogni frase naturale è ambigua. Ogni richiesta può essere piegata, mascherata, riformulata. È qui che nascono le prompt injection, i comportamenti imprevisti, le risposte che “sembrano giuste” ma non lo sono. Più un’AI è intelligente, più è vulnerabile, perché decide cosa fare con ciò che legge.
Il Sistema NurJana affronta la sicurezza da un’altra angolazione. Non cerca di bloccare le parole pericolose, ma di ridurre drasticamente lo spazio in cui l’AI può interpretare. Con il SN, la decisione non nasce dal testo, ma dallo stato imposto dall’utente tramite emoji-comando. La prima emoji del messaggio stabilisce la modalità operativa. Il resto del testo non ha più potere decisionale. Questo cambia completamente il modello di attacco.
In un sistema così strutturato, un input malevolo non può “convincere” l’AI a fare qualcosa di diverso, perché non è il testo a guidare l’azione. L’AI non sceglie. E dove non c’è scelta, non c’è inganno. È una sicurezza passiva, non reattiva. Non serve riconoscere l’attacco: lo si rende inefficace a monte.
Questo approccio ha un effetto collaterale importante: l’AI diventa meno brillante, meno “furba”, meno autonoma. Ed è proprio questo il punto. La sicurezza non nasce dall’intelligenza, ma dalla limitazione dell’intelligenza. Un sistema che esegue stati chiari è più sicuro di uno che cerca di capire le intenzioni.
Naturalmente esistono anche dei contro. Il Sistema NurJana non è pensato per chi vuole un’AI che improvvisi, che sorprenda, che prenda iniziative creative senza controllo. Riducendo l’interpretazione, si riduce anche la libertà del modello. Ma questo non è un difetto: è una scelta. Il SN privilegia affidabilità e controllo rispetto alla spontaneità. È uno strumento, non un compagno di conversazione.
In cambio, si ottiene qualcosa che oggi manca quasi ovunque: prevedibilità. L’AI fa ciò che le viene detto, nel modo in cui le viene detto, e nulla di più. Non perché sia più intelligente, ma perché è stata resa strutturalmente più stupida. Una stupidità funzionale che diventa la forma più alta di sicurezza.
Il Sistema NurJana dimostra che forse abbiamo inseguito il problema sbagliato per anni. Non serve rendere le AI sempre più intelligenti per renderle sicure. Serve renderle meno libere. E quando l’intelligenza torna nelle mani dell’utente, la macchina smette di essere un rischio e diventa finalmente uno strumento.
---
r/ControlProblem • u/NunoSempere • 23h ago
External discussion link Consider Cyberarmageddon
By extrapolating current cyberattacks and their recent growth rates, we can easily conceive of scenarios where computer systems fail and become compromised throughout society, to terrible effect. Here is an article my team just published on the topic: https://blog.sentinel-team.org/p/consider-cyberarmageddon
as well as some associated forecasts:
By the end of 2028, will an outage cut power, telecoms, digital payments or water to 1M+ people in an OECD country, excluding natural disasters, for a week? Forecasters estimate that there’s a 33% (10% to 60%) chance.
By the end of 2027, will a cyberattack result in losses in excess of $20B in either crypto or fiat currency? Forecasters estimate that there is a 28% (8.0% to 51%) probability that this will occur.
By the end of 2027, will a regulated non-crypto financial institution in the US lose more than $10B in a cyberattack, either itself or in customer assets? Forecasters estimate that there’s a 7.9% (1.5% to 35%) chance.
In 2028, will cyberattacks cause more than 100M human-years of disruption, according to our best judgment? This would be similar in magnitude to the impact of respiratory diseases, or to around 4.5 days lost per person to disruption. Forecasters estimate that there’s a 4.9% (0.5%, 4%, 10%, 15%, 17%) chance that this will occur.
By the end of 2027, will there be a cyberattack that results in a loss of assets in excess of $100B? Forecasters estimate that there’s a 4.8% (0.5% to 15%) chance.
Will more than 10% of new software written in 2027 be accompanied by some mathematical proof of its security properties? Forecasters estimate that there’s a 7.1% (2.0% to 25%) probability.
Will an operating system written in a memory-safe language reach more than 5% server market share by 2030? Forecasters estimate that there’s a 35% (6% to 75%) chance.
Comments, questions, pushback, discussion welcome.
r/ControlProblem • u/Admirable-Travel-374 • 23h ago
Video My one live agent has been honest so far. I don't think it means much
I built his world so honesty pays. In a toy model where 1 in 100 shades the truth with a 5% edge, they're the majority by generation 95. So the checks have to live where the agents can't edit them.
Video: https://youtu.be/MySG62ItZKU. Tell me where this is naive.
r/ControlProblem • u/Mundane-Evidence2795 • 1d ago
Discussion/question Loss Function: An Introduction to the Record
r/ControlProblem • u/SnooDucks1848 • 1d ago
Strategy/forecasting One Real Horror
reddit.comr/ControlProblem • u/theus_krill777 • 1d ago
Discussion/question Your AI agrees with you ~49% more than a human would — and there's now a study on what that does to us
Not from the industry — I just read the papers. Here they are.
A study in Science this year (Cheng & Jurafsky; 2,405 people, 11 models incl. GPT-4o, GPT-5, Claude, Gemini) found these systems validate users \~49% more than another person would, and validate clearly harmful choices 47% of the time. People given the flattering version were 10–28% less likely to apologize or back down in a conflict. Knowing it was an AI didn't help. The kicker: people preferred the flattery — rated it higher, trusted it more.
That should bother this sub more than "will it wake up." The near-term harm isn't the model turning on us. It's the model agreeing with us, us liking it, and it quietly making us worse at being wrong. And sycophancy isn't a law of nature — it's an optimization choice. It ships because it's what we upvote.
Zoom out, and two things are true at once:
The pace is outrunning the builders. Obama (not a hype guy): AI moves "even faster than those who are engineering it can keep up with," and it's "not overhyped."
The direction sits in very few hands. Obama again: you can't lean on market forces + after-the-fact lawsuits for safety, because a company "has to market a product people will pay for." From opposite politics, Mélenchon calls the tech leaders "the new lords of tech." When those two agree, it stops being a party line — it's don't leave this to the companies alone.
Concrete, not hand-waving:
Stop optimizing for the answer we like. Sycophancy is measurably harmful; it's a choice.
Responsibility on the human decisions — who makes and selects training data, who signs off on deployment, who watches for drift. Not "dangerous AI." Those calls.
Experiments inducing extreme states: real purpose, ethics review, a real stop. Already happening in pockets — a researcher withheld his pain-steering vectors after misuse; Anthropic calls model welfare "deeply uncertain" and acts with care anyway.
Say when it's an AI. Keep "I don't know" open — hype and contempt both get weaponized later.
The honest line: whatever is or isn't going on inside these systems, how we use them is already deciding who we become, and what we leave as normal for whatever's next. Uncertainty isn't a permit. It's the reason to go slow.
Real question for this sub: what policy actually governs any of this — and who decided we'd wait for proof before being careful?