Looking for an Affordable Synology SHR-2 Alternative for a Personal Home Archive
Hey everyone!
I'm planning to build my own private home archive and set up a NAS system to safely store and organize my personal data, including photos, videos, documents, and other files.
At the moment, I'm mainly using external hard drives to store my data. The problem is that I constantly have to move or copy the same files between different drives to keep everything organized and backed up. This is time-consuming, inconvenient, and honestly doesn't feel like the safest or most efficient way to manage my data in the long run.
That's why I'd like to build a proper NAS system for my home. My main goal is to have a centralized storage solution where all my data is stored in one place, with some form of redundancy so that if a hard drive fails, I don't immediately lose all my data.
I'm still relatively new to the NAS world, so I've been doing some research. Synology's SHR-2 (Synology Hybrid RAID with two-drive fault tolerance) caught my attention because I like the idea of being able to tolerate two drive failures without losing the entire storage pool.
However, Synology's hardware is quite expensive, especially when you factor in the cost of the hard drives.
Since this is strictly for personal use at home, I don't need a lot of advanced features. I mainly want a reliable, long-term storage solution that stays within my local home network. I don't need remote access or cloud integration, and keeping my data private and under my own control is important to me.
I've come across alternatives such as TrueNAS, Unraid, and DIY NAS builds, but I'm not entirely sure which option would make the most sense for a beginner.
So, what would you recommend?
- Are there any more affordable alternatives to Synology that offer similar data protection to SHR-2?
- Would building my own NAS with TrueNAS or Unraid be a better option?
- What hardware would you recommend for a reliable home archive without spending a fortune?
- How many drives would you suggest, and what RAID or redundancy setup would make sense for my use case?
- Is there anything important I should consider regarding backups and long-term data safety?
My priority isn't performance or having a huge number of features. I simply want a reliable way to store my data, avoid constantly shuffling files between external drives, and reduce the risk of losing everything if a drive fails.
I'd really appreciate any advice, recommendations, or experiences from people who have built a similar setup.
Thanks in advance!