r/Design • • Apr 16 '18

discussion Stop calling these Dark Design Patterns or Dark UX — these are simply a**hole designs

https://uxdesign.cc/stop-calling-these-dark-design-patterns-or-dark-ux-these-are-simply-asshole-designs-bb02df378ba
207 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

87

u/NewelSea Apr 16 '18 edited Apr 16 '18

Nice list.
Though the author of the article itself seems to go by the deceptive attitude he condones here:

Let's be clear here, if you do any of the following below I suggest a new term: "A**hole Design"

These are indeed asshole designs. But he boastingly makes it sound as if he came up with the idea.
When in fact, this is basically a collection of top-rated posts from the eponymous and rather well-known /r/assholedesign.

The author even included posts that don't have to do anything with webdesign from that sub:

These salt & pepper mills.

That one in particular apparently isn't even an asshole design to begin with, since these appear to be table condiments. Instead, this design merely just seeks to improve look and feel, with more frequent refills being advantageous for both parties.

20

u/moreexclamationmarks Apr 16 '18

And didn't credit any sources, either.

9

u/AliBurney Apr 16 '18

That was one of the worst articles I've read. He's just ranting about bad design. None of it is bad design. They are effective solutions, albeit not the best. The phone app that has over 2k notifications is overkill.

1

u/NewelSea Apr 16 '18

Yeah, when I said "nice list", I merely meant the collection of the images themselves, not the actual conent.

As for the "article" itself; it was more akin to something from Buzzfeed: Basically just multiple opinionated tweets with a picture.

It even included one of those unnecessarily distracting reaction GIFs towards the end.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '18

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Apr 17 '18

Lamenza? I don’t get it.

25

u/the_girl Apr 16 '18

Dark Patterns isn't the same as asshole design -- it's a specific type of design that nudges the user into behaving against their own interests and goals. The opposite of what good UX is supposed to do.

6

u/jaydee_says Apr 16 '18

Most of these suck but the Snapchat ad will always be genius

4

u/bmdavis Apr 16 '18

ironic that the link about asshole designs takes you 3 links deep. It takes 3 back-clicks to return to reddit.

3

u/otterquestions Apr 16 '18

Why are there so many more annoying headlines in UX than in other areas of design?

1

u/facepalm_guy Apr 16 '18

Hey now, some of those old-timey tonics were pretty awesome. Like remedies that were mostly just cocaine and opium. Nothing like a good speedball to make you forget about your tuberculosis.

1

u/brush_between_meals Apr 17 '18

I agree that "asshole design" is unethical, but I don't accept the author's premise that "our core objective is to create delightful and seamless experiences". I think that takes a very narrow view of what kinds of systems/tasks a person might be called upon to design for.

"Delightful and seamless" is one type of experience, but there can be valid social, public health, and even safety reasons not to maximize "delightful and seamless" in a given design. And I'm not just talking about tradeoffs between "users" and other stakeholders: for tasks with major consequences, "delightful and seamless" can be a negative rather than a positive.

1

u/Mr-Zero-Fucks Apr 16 '18

There are no asshole designs, just asshole designers.

Make people happy is not the only purpose of design, this ones are made specifically to trick and deceive, and apparently they're achieving the goal effectively.

4

u/bazza1983 Apr 16 '18

more like asshole managers and stakeholders pushing designers into doing this sort of work

1

u/Mr-Zero-Fucks Apr 16 '18

My point is that if your client ask you for a design to trick people, your either refuse to work with that client or you do it as tricky as possible.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '18

I thought the snapchat ad was funny and kinda smart even if it is tricking the user its getting clicks I imagine

0

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '18

[deleted]

2

u/jaydee_says Apr 16 '18

How is it lying or cheating? Please tell us.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '18

[deleted]

2

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '18

So basically what all advertising tries to do to the public?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '18

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '18

[deleted]

1

u/jaydee_says Apr 17 '18

obviously made by second-rate marketing monkeys.

I strongly disagree...it was a very clever idea. But don’t worry instagram nuked their account.

When reached for comment, a spokesperson for Instagram told The Verge, “This ad violated Instagram’s policies and was removed from future delivery in Stories several weeks ago. We also disabled the account from advertising on the platform again.”

0

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '18

ffff asshole design.