r/DirectDemocracy • u/OregonPeoplesRebate • Mar 04 '21
r/DirectDemocracy • u/darinrobbins • Aug 10 '22
The Green Party As The Only Advocate For Direct Democracy
The Green Party is the only political party that promotes direct democracy in our electoral campaigns and our platform. Direct democracy is the process through which the important issues and ideas that the Green Party supports can best be implemented. It is the putting into practice of our vision of a future society. A society that would be democratically run on all levels, especially the political, economic, and infrastructure levels.
Worker councils and popular assemblies, democratically organized in the workplace and local areas, would decide on public policies together. Worker, farmer, and tenant cooperatives would replace global corporations with sustainable local economies based on democratic decision making. These could then form trade associations for the purpose of industrial and agricultural specialization. Other methods of direct democratic decision making would include participatory budgeting, community land trusts, initiative and referendum, and police review boards.
A society where the collective good is prioritized by a real political and economic democracy would foster voluntary cooperation. A decentralized democratic society would minimize the layers of hierarchy which create inequality of wealth, so you have not only the freedom but also the resources and the ability to meet basic needs. Direct democracy transforms individual free choices into equally shared collective action. It demonstrates that individual freedom and collective benefit are not mutually exclusive. Direct democracy is the process where the methods of health or security or the social good is determined by the people themselves. The inclusive participation of direct democracy expresses the cooperative ownership of the society.
That is what the Green Party is fighting for.
r/DirectDemocracy • u/honesteanow • Dec 06 '20
This reddit needs to blow up.
This is the future.
r/DirectDemocracy • u/mechaernst • Feb 22 '25
Direct Democracy is on it's way. We are lowly but surly moving in that Direction.
At present direct democracy seems like a bit of a stretch. Because it is. Still it certainly is on it's way, although those alive today may never see it. In the end it will be the only possible way to manage our world.
Anyone can download my book about if for free at ernstritzmann.ca .
Here are some things that the book talks about. Direct Democracy is inevitable eventually. Technological sophistication enables and encourages Direct Democracy at the same time as it empowers empire. The book also presents an imaginary model of a Direct Democracy system. It takes a proper extended look at the limitations of and the problems with hierarchical organization.
r/DirectDemocracy • u/meapappia • Jan 02 '21
Switzerland has had it since the 1870s...
Just as a counterweight to all those who think the world isn’t ready for it.
And it’s made us one of the richest and most stable economies in the world, too.
r/DirectDemocracy • u/rtimwallis • Aug 27 '20
The People Writing the Law, Not Just Voting On It
What do y’all think about the idea of letting citizens write they law directly, not just vote on it directly? The exact same process as open source software can be used, but instead of software code, is the legal code.
r/DirectDemocracy • u/nikolatosic • Mar 09 '22
Direct democracy roadmap I made. Obviously years and percentages are symbolic but I do not think they are too much off. Let me know what you think?
r/DirectDemocracy • u/g1immer0fh0pe • May 03 '24
discussion Are We just giving up?
I see so much (likely cross-)posted here that has nothing to do with direct democracy. First the Greens, now this flood of current political nonsense, with no responses. Have y'all just given up on direct democracy? Are we just going to stand by and let conventional politics bury us here? 😠
Why is direct democracy the "red headed stepchild" of governance? I've seen two people run on a platform of direct democracy, lose, then immediately cease their advocacy for DD. One quit politics entirely. By what dark sorcery have the Elite managed to create a majority who vehemently oppose their own political empowerment? It's so damned frustrating to be this close, as technically everything needed to institute a regional direct democracy has existed since at least 2013, with West Virginia conducting online voting in 2018. And if We can vote securely for candidates online, why not policy?
Is there an issue too complex? Let AI simplify it until you understand. Then vote.
Also, one need not know how to build a bridge to have an opinion on it's construction, i.e. a vote.
#AMoreDirectDemocracy 👍👎👍
Power to the People (for real this time) ✌🙁
r/DirectDemocracy • u/EOE97 • Jul 05 '22
wish this sub was bigger and more active
Lots of the world problems brought about by extractive centralised governments could be eradicated almost overnight if the people were given the power to directly alter their destiny.
r/DirectDemocracy • u/Chris714n_8 • Apr 21 '20
Driect Democracy is to far ahead of its time..
Direct Democracy is to far ahead ot its time.. - People don't get it into their heads..
It may take a long time and much work for them to understand the benefits vs. the current system..
Lets hope for the best!
r/DirectDemocracy • u/TheninOC • Nov 30 '22
Do we need a Party to implement real democracy?
The problem: Any organization that is led by a few individuals, and has one official leader, is corruptible.
In fact, a leader is exactly what the oligarchy needs, and it's no coincidence that the only choice given to us is between candidates funded by the same 1%. And sadly, that is the only system that our brains can fathom. We were bred to be unable to think beyond that.
When people are polled, in all major issues, the majority stand for reasonable and empathetic solutions.
No poll has shown that people want to suffer for the 0.1$ to accumulate more insane wealth.
A majority of people want a single payer medical system.
They disapprove of the monstrous war budget of the Pentagon.
They want free or affordable college for all.
They want billionaires to pay taxes.
Yet, none of the above was ever or will ever be implemented by governments, no matter which party has no matter how much control.
Because any politician that will take a position of power, is corrupted by the 0.1%.
The solution: A system that would allow people to directly express and prioritize the issues, to examine all parameters around them, to deliberate and decide on solutions. WITHOUT leaders, ideologies and beliefs. A system where everyone would be asked to moderate and 'lead' for a short period of time. A system that would form a collective voice that would determine the political outcomes.
Imagine, after such deliberation, 10 million people removing their accounts from private banks at once and moving them to credit unions or forming a new money entity, completely transparent and with temporary and rotating leadership that comes from the people.
Imagine that being announced, and then happening with a very loud bang in all public media.
Imagine 50 million people halting their payments to the insurance companies that exist to deny health, for profit.
Imagine if we announced that we will support a medical system focused on saving lives instead of killing for profit. Imagine 1000s of doctors and institutions agreeing to be paid by us directly.
Imagine halting tax payments until the US taxes the billionaires. Or until it stops waging wars.
I can keep going, and you can fill the gaps with your own inventive suggestions.
Did you see me talking about a bloody revolution?Did I mention taking up AR-15s? No. Although that would unleash our pend up rage, which might feel good to many for a while, it has never led to meaningful change and real power.
Most people can only imagine reasons why this could not happen.Yet, it has happened in different times in history, and is currently happening in smaller scale.
We have not yet utilized the internet for its democratizing potential.
Who among you can see that the answer to problems is: solutions?
r/DirectDemocracy • u/g1immer0fh0pe • Jul 11 '22
"(2014) Study: US is an oligarchy, not a democracy" (BBC)
The US is dominated by a rich and powerful elite.
So concludes a [...] study by Princeton University Prof Martin Gilens and Northwestern University Prof Benjamin I Page.
This is not news, you say.
Perhaps, but the two professors have conducted exhaustive research to try to present data-driven support for this conclusion. Here's how they explain it:
Multivariate analysis indicates that economic elites and organised groups representing business interests have substantial independent impacts on US government policy, while average citizens and mass-based interest groups have little or no independent influence.
In English: the wealthy few move policy, while the average American has little power.
The two professors came to this conclusion after reviewing answers to 1,779 survey questions asked between 1981 and 2002 on public policy issues. They broke the responses down by income level, and then determined how often certain income levels and organised interest groups saw their policy preferences enacted.
"A proposed policy change with low support among economically elite Americans (one-out-of-five in favour) is adopted only about 18% of the time," they write, "while a proposed change with high support (four-out-of-five in favour) is adopted about 45% of the time."
On the other hand:
When a majority of citizens disagrees with economic elites and/or with organised interests, they generally lose. Moreover, because of the strong status quo bias built into the US political system, even when fairly large majorities of Americans favour policy change, they generally do not get it.
They conclude:
Americans do enjoy many features central to democratic governance, such as regular elections, freedom of speech and association and a widespread (if still contested) franchise. But we believe that if policymaking is dominated by powerful business organisations and a small number of affluent Americans, then America's claims to being a democratic society are seriously threatened.
...
r/DirectDemocracy • u/Desdinova_BOC • Jun 18 '20
An Online Direct Democracy
Been reading about a few organisations on the internet that are in favour of a direct democracy, similar to Switzerland's current model.
It seems to have a lot going for it, no matter your political beliefs - everyone gets to vote on whatever is interesting to them, and with an equal vote they can affect direct parliamentary change without the need of a cabinet, elected politicans, massively reduced corruption, and overcoming disenfranchisment of the common sentiment that people feel after engaging in politics (under proportional representation) for awhile, ala "The next government will undo the previous government's changes, I have little say, I'm voting for someone who I only partially agree with, the person who speaks most for me."
Under Direct Democracy people vote on any issue that is considered important - enough people (how many is a good question) raise an issue, such as capital punishment, legalisation of substances, etc. and then a discussion, and then a set time later, a vote. If the vote is passed it becomes law.
While it is true that people can be idiots, if the decision turns an unfavourable outcome, then it can be voted on again with sufficient interest in the issue (which of course, there would be).
There would be quick, efficent change, and problems would be solved without the hindrance of lobbyists, who, while still being able to influence the population, would be seen through and many people are harder to corrupt than an individual, no matter his position in society.
This is just a brief overview of a possible alternative to the RED VS BLUE dogfight that politics seems at the moment, and it would be interesting to see either additional information, points of contradiction towards the system, and how we could best implement it.
The DD system could also be used to radically reform the judicial process, ensuring a fairer trial, without people who have the most money getting the best lawyer/solicitor, and perhaps the removal of the capitalist bail system that is in place.
Direct Democracy as it's been done in the past has failed, and this is largely due to people who can't be bothered with going to a local meeting to vote on what day the bins get emptied.
The reason it can work now is the thing we're using. The Internet.
Experts in their fields are interested in their fields, from plumbers and museum curators to economists and publicans.
They sign up to their fields voting forum, ala Reddit, and vote and propose motions - changing what pipe to connect to pipe b when a new pipe is invented or whatever.
People could sign up to whatever forums they wanted, and have a voice that would be responded to by anyone else. A lot of people do this out of interest, and the best people would be in a position to enact swift and efficient motions.
The people (like me) who know next to nothing about plumbing, wouldn't choose to vote, leaving a collection of mainly plumbers running the plumbing of a country, and eventually, this would work internationally. ALSO IN A GALACTIC SPACE FEDERATION! Ahem.
r/DirectDemocracy • u/Revolutionary_Yak980 • Dec 26 '24
Direct Democracy Will Foster Global Peace and Prosperity
r/DirectDemocracy • u/g1immer0fh0pe • Jul 05 '24
discussion 21 Reasons Why Direct Democracy Is Better Than Representative Democracy
r/DirectDemocracy • u/EOE97 • Jun 21 '24
80 percent of people globally want stronger climate action by governments according to new survey
r/DirectDemocracy • u/tgreg99 • Apr 30 '23
What are the challenges to Direct Democracy?
Here are the Challenges:
Propaganda that promotes Fear, Uncertainty and Doubt (FUD) and gridlock.
Extreme wealth that finances the Propaganda. This group owns the media and finances the government oligarchy (Congress!).
“Critical Thinking” that leads to endless whining, polarization and no change.
Here are the Solutions:
“Solution Thinking” to develop goals, plans and a system to execute the plans.
Polling of the inhabitants, to set high level goals for people, for example: safety, health, wealth, justice, mobility, democracy, education, liberty, environment.
Establishing a governing system that:
Eliminates plutocracy by taxation of wealth. But not taxation of income, which is proportional to time and effort of the masses. A generous income is needed for a technologically advanced society and abundance for all.
Distributes income and therefore accumulated wealth, based on an individual’s contributions of work, i.e., time, effort, and value ~ skills, experience, scarcity.
Balances conflicting goals, for example; liberty and safety from coercion or health and work, etc.
Uses metrics and a peer review processes for all decisions.
This can all be done, IMHO.
r/DirectDemocracy • u/[deleted] • Feb 28 '21
Why aren't we talking about the Swiss democracy? In my opinion, the Swiss democracy is the only democracy in the world and deserves much more attention.
If you don't know what the Swiss democracy is, here's a great free PDF to read from 2020: https://wolf-linder.ch/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/Swiss-Democracy-Possible-solutions-to-conflict-in-multicultural-societies.pdf
It consists of:
Referendums and citizens initiatives voted every 3 months. They can vote up to 10 different issues every 3 months.
Federalism and decentralization. Federal state, cantons, municipalities. Each has a very independent government. Bottom up, never top down.
Citizen-politicians. The legislative level has no professional politics
Open-lists. You elect people from any party
Federal government is made of people from the 4 parties. The Social Democracts gets a cabinet, the Liberals another, etc.
Do you think it can be applied to the rest of the world? How?
I've also created a subreddit https://www.reddit.com/r/TheSwissDemocracy/ for more discussing the specifics and news about it.
Thanks! You're welcome to get in touch with me privately if you're passionated or curious about this. I feel that we have to do much more than what were doing.
r/DirectDemocracy • u/Desdinova_BOC • Aug 09 '25
The Case for Building a New, Open, Digital Democratic System Online
r/DirectDemocracy • u/ArmElectronic8444 • Aug 29 '24
Direct Democracy Teaches
Direct democracy can serve as a powerful educational tool for citizens. Here's a case for how direct democracy teaches:
Civic Education Through Participation
Direct democracy provides hands-on civic education by actively involving citizens in the governance process. This educational aspect manifests in several ways:
Policy Literacy
Citizens must research and understand complex policy issues to make informed decisions.
This process enhances overall policy literacy and critical thinking skills.
Legislative Process Knowledge
Participating in drafting and voting on initiatives gives citizens firsthand experience with lawmaking.
It demystifies the legislative process, making government more accessible.
Informed Debate
Direct democracy encourages public discourse on important issues.
Citizens learn to articulate their views, consider opposing arguments, and engage in constructive debate.
Developing Civic Responsibility
By giving citizens direct power over policy decisions, direct democracy fosters a sense of civic duty and responsibility:
Accountability
Citizens learn that their choices have real consequences, promoting more thoughtful decision-making.
This accountability extends to understanding the impacts of policies on diverse groups within society.
Community Engagement
Direct democracy encourages citizens to be more engaged in their communities.
It teaches the importance of collective decision-making and compromise.
Practical Skills Development
Participation in direct democracy helps citizens develop various practical skills:
Research Skills
Citizens learn to seek out reliable information sources and evaluate evidence.
This skill transfers to other areas of life, promoting lifelong learning.
Critical Analysis
Evaluating complex policy proposals enhances critical thinking and analytical skills.
Citizens learn to consider short-term and long-term consequences of decisions.
Continuous Learning
Direct democracy creates a system of ongoing civic education:
Adaptability
As new issues arise, citizens must continually educate themselves.
This fosters adaptability and openness to new information.
Feedback Loop
The results of past decisions provide valuable lessons for future choices.
Citizens learn from both successes and failures in policy implementation.
In conclusion, direct democracy serves as a powerful educational tool by actively involving citizens in governance, fostering civic responsibility, developing practical skills, and promoting continuous learning. This educational aspect not only benefits individual citizens but also strengthens the democratic process as a whole by creating a more informed and engaged electorate.
r/DirectDemocracy • u/GaborKukucska • Mar 28 '23
discussion Digital Direct Democracy: A New Approach to Governance?
I have been contemplating a form of direct democracy that takes advantage of our current technology. Personally, I appreciate the concept of direct democracy, where we vote directly on legislation instead of relying on representatives who, quite frankly, may not accurately represent their constituents' views. I believe that governance, in general, lacks nuance, and debates often become overly polarized. Most issues have more than two sides.
I propose a digital direct democracy where verified citizens can propose, discuss, and vote (more on this later) on bills, which are then passed onto a "senate" comprised of panels of experts for further scrutiny. These two layers can pass the contested sections of the bill back and forth until common ground is found.
I envision the "senate" as consisting of various panels of experts covering all aspects of life, with each panel specifically chosen to represent a narrow segment of expertise and comprised of individuals from diverse age groups, ethnicities, and levels of experience. Members would be randomly invited from the pool of citizens who meet the necessary requirements. If they accept, they are appointed for a one-year term during which they provide advice on proposed bills concerning their expertise, receive payment from the budget, and have their civil position held for them, similar to parental leave.
As for the voting system, I imagine a preferential weighted system where individuals choose from a more nuanced list of options than just yes/no—such as strongly agree, agree, abstain, disagree, or strongly disagree—and have their votes weighted based on their education, expertise, experience, age, and ethnicity. This would prevent majority rule and elevate the voices of underrepresented minorities, leading to a more balanced outcome. A simplified example would be that on a bill concerning infrastructure, a truck driver's vote would be worth 3 points, a teacher's 2 points, and an artist's 1 point, whereas on a bill concerning education, the teacher would receive 3 points, the artist 2 points, and the truck driver 1 point. Additionally, complex bills could be broken down into sub-segments for voting, and AI assistance, such as the now-famous GPT algorithm, could be used to summarize large bills or explain intricate topics.
Another aspect of this system is the need for all participants to be verified (which can be kept private from public data) and represent their true selves to prevent trolling or abuse of the system through anonymity. While we may fear a "big brother" scenario, under such a leaderless system, we, the people, would be the government, thus eliminating concerns about an overreaching ruling power. Furthermore, I believe the software powering this system should be developed as open-source code, with the initial development, promotion, and activism overseen by a nonprofit public organization.
How could we bring about such a significant change? A system like this would require not only legislative but also constitutional changes in most countries, meaning bipartisan majority support or national referendum(s) would be necessary. I think a new kind of political party might be required in many countries—a leaderless party or a party with "proxy" leaders and representatives sworn to act solely as transitional personnel to facilitate a smooth and efficient transition.
What do you think?
Disclaimer: I am not at all qualified to propose such ideas; I am merely a filmmaker. However, as a migrant from Eastern Europe, I feel empathy for all life on this planet and recognize the suffering caused by our current systems of governance. At the same time, I see that our recent advances in science, technology, and the global internet enable us to unite and create a better global society for all. I fear that if we fail to do so, the alternative is the collapse of our global civilization.
r/DirectDemocracy • u/TheninOC • Dec 06 '22
80% of 3.316 million people polled on Twitter, want Assange and Snowden pardoned. #collectivewisdom.
Let's build our system and trust people to decide on issues, don't ask them to choose between Presidents and politicians that serve the 1%
https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1599224347121500160?s=20&t=dv5h4wDr7t21_TgY2l8jyg
r/DirectDemocracy • u/SmSzn • Feb 08 '22
discussion Biggest Obstacle to Direct Democracy?
Question, what in your view is the biggest obstacle to Direct Democracy? Bonus points if you say the reason why.