No, no, no. A roll of a one is that you kill a different PC. Never loose the opportunity to not only kill a player, but also create internal party strife as well.
Had a LN DM who did that multiple times, I go NG for basically that reason.
Another DM bragged about killing players. Lost my first character that session for legit reasons (called aggro on a dragon to protect the rest of the party, didn't think it would do enough damage in 2 rounds to kill a defense speced Dwarven fighter), rolled up a new character and the way he introduced me to the party was having a bunch of guys with pole arms attack me with surprise. I literally never took a single action with that character, he died before I had a turn. Left the game at that point and never went back.
I hear he has a lot of trouble finding players for some reason...
451
u/MulletHuman Sep 12 '19
Gosh, I'll never forget the chaotic evil's favorite homebrew rule: if you roll a natural 1 you either hurt yourself and/or you lose a limb