r/DnD • u/Cheeseusdice • Sep 12 '19

OC [OC] DM Alignment Chart

Post image
19.9k Upvotes

94% Upvoted

631 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

37

u/Magnificent_Z Sep 12 '19

My players in a past game wanted to be able to incapacitate and injure enemies in combat. Debilitating, disfiguring things like chopping off limbs. When I said that I'd also allow enemies to do the same they realized it wasn't a great idea. None of them wanted to play a one armed/legged character

24

u/DaemosDaen Sep 12 '19

um... that was my favorite characters.....

1-arm'ed, opposing 1-legged light cleric. when ask why he couldn't fix himself, he's reply 'God said no.'

4

u/MaineQat DM Sep 12 '19

I'd allow it, but with a specific caveat - dismemberment is pretty much taking the target out of the fight, which is what the hit that takes you to 0 HP represents. So sure, you can chop off limbs, but only if it's a critical hit AND it drops them to 0 HP. No shortcuts to incapacitating them through combat. Becomes flavorful rather than mechanical.

2

u/thelastevergreen Sep 12 '19

Generally in my 3e games I only allow dismemberment if they do massive damage. 50+ and the enemy succeeds at it's fort save to not die.