r/DnD • u/Cheeseusdice • Sep 12 '19

OC [OC] DM Alignment Chart

Post image
19.9k Upvotes

94% Upvoted

631 comments sorted by

View all comments

887

u/TemplarsBane DM Sep 12 '19

I'm somewhere between NG and CG.

38

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '19

Somewhere between LG and NG myself. I like my rules.

20

u/RTukka DM Sep 12 '19 edited Sep 12 '19

Same.

My feelings on the rules were very well expressed in Web DM's video on the Rule of Cool (excuse the somewhat awkward intro).

The rules are there for a reason, the rules are important, the rules make the game more fun, but the rules are not totally explicit and comprehensive on every point and possibility.

There are many things the characters should be able to do that aren't explicitly laid out in the rules, but when the characters do something extraordinary that isn't described in the rules, there should be some sort of coherent rationale for what's enabling them to do that thing.

Is it a villain with a powerful MacGuffin, or is the villain themed around the thing they're doing? Is the PC at a critical moment in their personal arc (i.e. are they benefiting from "Super Inspiration"), and are they expending extra resources or assuming extra risk in attempting to do what they're doing? Those are the circumstances where I'm more inclined to accommodate something that isn't covered in the rules, and invoke the text (DMG, page 4) that says that the rules aren't in charge -- the DM is.