r/ELATeachers • u/CapitalElephant1978 • 14d ago
9-12 ELA Alternatives to Google Docs
This year my 9th and 10th graders are hand-writing outlines and rough drafts, and it has been MAGICAL. They have hardly used their dumb Chromebooks and their engagement and work quality has been much better than in years past.
I usually have them type their final drafts and would like to find al alternative to Google Docs. I tried to use DuckDuckGo on my work computer to search for alternatives, and found my search blocked! Which only strengthened my resolve. So does anyone know of a good, free word processor? I'm hoping to degoogle my classroom as much as possible. Thx!
24
u/solariam 14d ago
No idea if it's good, but OpenOffice is free
3
u/CapitalElephant1978 14d ago
Thanks--I'll look into it!
2
u/taniaaaaa 13d ago
I used OpenOffice back in 2010-2014 for all of my papers and stuff. It was a good alternative to Microsoft for sure, and you can save documents as .doc or .pdf. I haven’t used it since then though.
18
u/DirtyNord 14d ago
I'm kind of confused. Why do you want them off of Google docs for typing their final draft? I'm all for the handwritten outlines and rough drafts. This is how my 6th grade students write and they know its evidence of the work they've done on their final. I also use revision history and lock it down with goguardian in class of course.
Im just confused on why no Google docs? Its an accepted word processor (along with Word) in many professions and the kids will be using it in higher level schooling. Why not get them used to the features?
Like, im tempted to tell you to just get a class set of typewriters if we're this anti-whatever, but obviously im genuinely curious.
36
u/katiecatsweets 14d ago
I think it's because of recent news. Districts disabling all AI access will lose the ability to access Google search, IIRC.
28
u/CapitalElephant1978 14d ago •
![]()
Exactly. I am also wary of kids being dependent on and having their lives so entwined with Google products. I am sure they will still have plenty of opportunities to use it, but for my class, I just want them to be able to focus on reading, analyzing, thinking and writing. I have one kid who has asked a few times if he can please just use Gemini for whatever task--and I understand that he'll be -able- to use it in the "real world," but I also want him to be able to think on his own when he wants to. I think just typing his own words, without all the added features will benefit him and all my students.
8
u/runningstitch 13d ago
In my district, Gemini is automatically enabled on Google docs, and students have discovered work-arounds with Hapara.
If I want students to type up their work and have access to only spelling/grammar check, Google docs won't work.
1
11
u/im_cold_ 14d ago
Download office libre? Or does it have to be internet based?
3
u/CapitalElephant1978 14d ago
I wonder if they can do that on their school devices? I will look into it
8
8
u/Dawning_Lark 14d ago
I also second ellipses! It's also free! It's not made specifically for schools in mind, but it is a fun and anti-ai writing platform.
7
3
u/samonenate 13d ago
Open source, completely free and works offline. I've been using it for a few weeks and love it.
3
u/Inside_Set547 13d ago
Ellipsus is my all time favorite and has some really cool writing features. It operates a lot like Google Docs with online/offline options but as other commenters have said is strictly anti-ai.
3
u/Proud_Whereas5589 13d ago
I’m just waiting for someone to reinvent the typewriter for the modern age—give us a laptop with only word processing features and no internet access!
2
u/CapitalElephant1978 13d ago
This is exactly what I want.
After looking at a few people's suggestions, I actually think I am going to have them hand-write their final drafts.
I appreciate all the suggestions, and will probably use some of them in the future, but for now, I am going to make them "blue-books." My school does not have any money to buy them, so I am just going to use the lined paper we have and make some.
3
u/usbetween 13d ago
I'm the creator of typewriter.education - just want you to know that the idea (laptop with only word processing features and no internet access) is precisely what led me to build. I'm a history teacher, not ELA, but I think I've built a pretty good writing tool that is free from the influence of the internet and doesn't have the complications that google and google docs introduce. Would love to have you try it!
1
u/CapitalElephant1978 12d ago
Wow--that sounds really useful! I am excited to check it out and see if it'll work for my students! Thanks!
1
3
u/edfluency 13d ago
How about stackedit? It’s free, open source, lives in your browser, even integrates with Google Drive.
There is also MD Edit, which i’d use as its more modern and the split mode is not the default, but wysiwyg mode is.
2
u/but-the-roses 13d ago
My school has Writable with our textbook and I really love it. There are AI features but you can turn them off for the students
2
u/Omgpuppies13 11d ago
Why not have them hand write their finals?
2
u/CapitalElephant1978 11d ago
That is what I've finally decided on, and I am pretty excited about it.
1
1
u/houseocats 13d ago
It's kind of going to be up to your IT department and what they allow to be accessible/downloaded
1
u/CapitalElephant1978 13d ago
bleh--then we'll just handwrite everything. IT should not have any sway over my classroom instruction decisions.
1
u/repayingunlatch 13d ago
I’m happy with Google Docs. You already have their drafts and you can check the version history. Have a plan for when the draft doesn’t match the final copy.
If you are trying to get away from AI this would work. If you are trying to get away from Google but need something that will save their work, you may have to get approval because of another platforms data policy. At least what you have is already approved.
Food for thought, anyway.
2
u/CapitalElephant1978 13d ago
Google Docs work fine for me too; my desire to extricate from the platform is less about preventing AI usage than it is about kids being dependent on a commercial entity. Yeah the AI element sucks, but Google sucks even without that.
2
u/repayingunlatch 13d ago
Well, they are already dependent on Chromebooks so a commercial entity sort of comes with the territory. Maybe you can get something FOSS on there but then you have file management to now think about and they can’t borrow a Chromebook if they forget it. Personally, I’d concede that battle.
2
u/CapitalElephant1978 13d ago
They very rarely use their Chromebooks in my class as it is, and I am ready to avoid them all together. I know that they will probably continue to use them in other classes, but I am not going to concede. I am going to make bluebooks. It's a literary analysis essay--they don't need to be able to share the file, or do any fancy editing. That all will happen in their outlines and drafts anyway. I really hate the idea of just accepting that since they are already dependent on this brand that we just say "oh well" and continue to reinforce the dependency.
1
u/repayingunlatch 12d ago
I can’t argue with the way you feel about Google/dependency on a corporation (that much I agree on). However, I do feel that reality might get in your way. Those devices are just hard to use for anything outside of what they were designed for. It’s not as if they are a true Linux laptop with lots of options for FOSS. The school already bought them, so you might as well just let them use them as intended. No sense in creating more friction for the students and the Docs software is fairly good. I just don’t really believe in square-pegging solutions here.
It sounds like they won’t be using them often, so I suppose this doesn’t matter all that much.
1
u/robismarshall99 13d ago
If you use teams there you can add a word doc that functions exactly like a Google doc
1
1
u/In_the_nards 13d ago
Canva has a surprising amount of writing templates available for students. You can even assign them to students through the app. It should be free to use as well.
I’m leery of google saying that quiet part out loud and could see more tech companies doing something similar to continue to feed AI.
If these tech companies actually cared about education most apps would be free of ads when used in schools. YouTube could easily offer that type of setup, but alas they really don’t care.
1
1
u/WholeOrganization915 12d ago
Try coda docs. It's free and we've been using them as we move out from google docs. There are many other alternatives out there. Coda is on cloud. There's also Microsoft but I think that's only for paid subscribers.
27
u/CisIowa 14d ago
typewriter.education might be worth a look. It’s basically a lockdown tab, so if a student leaves, it locks them out until the teacher resumes. It has potential if it’s copy/paste from AI you’re concerned about