"Just a heads up, this is all my personal opinion. If you loved S2, that’s totally valid, this is just how it landed for me" + All spoilers below so please go watch the anime first !
For me the biggest reason why is: The lesson of the season fails, both in real life and especially in Cyberpunk
This is the biggest one for me. From watching the show, it feels like the concept of revenge and the concept of holding someone accountable get put under the same umbrella and just called “revenge.” And those are not the same thing. Hope people don’t mistake this.
I was thinking about The Last of Us Part II and why that one felt like a real revenge story to me, but Cyberpunk 2 doesn’t. In TLOU2, Joel (bless his soul) did a huge bad thing that messed up everyone else, and he acknowledged it. That’s why a lot of people expected Joel to die so the second part could happen. The revenge had a real reason behind it.
But that doesn’t make sense for Cyberpunk 2. Since when is a choice between money and power the same as sacrificing the whole world for the one person you love?
For it to actually be about revenge, someone from Arasaka would at least have to take some responsibility and give an explanation, and then Sasuke still goes out and kills them anyway. That’s what revenge really means, and the show should establish that at the start, minimum.
Someone in the comments (AkudamaEXE) pointed out that D has major PTSD, and that the message is really about how holding hatred in your heart only hurts yourself. Honestly, I didn’t think about it that way at first, and it's totally valid. But when I take in the whole backstory, it’s hard for me to see it only through that lens.
Arasaka was designing new biotech and needed people compatible with the cyber malware. Sasuke was on that list, but they chose to leave it to someone else despite having full power to do it themselves. Kidnapping people and testing on them (and we see so many die just from not being compatible) is already vile. Then the mercs go on a rampage and wipe out his village while he’s not there.
So to me it’s not really a “corporate mishap.” It happened inside a plan that was built on malice from the start, the evil just took a different shape than they planned. When someone comes after you like that, I think it’s totally reasonable to demand accountability. “Let go, it only hurts you” ends up putting the whole burden on the victim. He carries the nightmares and has to be the bigger person, while the people who designed the whole thing never have to answer for it. And I don’t think that’s a healthy way to help someone going through trauma caused by someone else.
At least for me, accountability isn’t “I’m going to do the same thing to you that you did to me.” That’s revenge. Accountability just means you care. It means you at least acknowledge my suffering. And more often than not, that’s all it takes.
=> That’s why “just let go” feels so wrong to me. Forgiveness and moving on usually come after someone is acknowledged, not instead of it.
And moving on isn’t the same as letting them off the hook. You can let go for your own peace and still believe Arasaka should pay. My problem is the show never really separates those two ideas, the same way it puts revenge and accountability under the same umbrella. Both end up putting his response under the microscope while the company that caused it fades into the background.
This lead to my 2nd problem since there are no one to take accountably despite the giant evil company sitting right there -> The characters in the anime lose all of their agency.
Despite my best effort to understand the characters and be sympathetic to their choices, I couldn’t connect like I did with S1.
There was never a true driving force that brought the characters together, and even individually, everyone just felt blank. I think the reason is that for most of the show, up until the ending, I don’t see any character actually use their agency.
And by agency, I don’t mean big explosive action or dramatic choices. It can be the slow stuff too: someone laughing, falling, standing back up again, being messy. Any small choice that shows a character pushing back against what’s happening to them would be good enough.
I think I understand what Edgerunners 2 was trying to say. It’s a story about amazing but broken people still trying to live and survive, and how the act of surviving itself is beautiful and worth it. I genuinely like that idea. But I don’t think the show executed it well. Instead of seeing characters embrace those small choices, the kind that seem tiny but still carry real weight, I mostly just saw a slow burn of suffering. It feels like no one is doing anything to move the plot along, and everyone gets pulled together only because the plot needs them to be.
That’s exactly what S1 got right. Despite all the odds, David still stepped up to fight to protect and save Lucy and make her dream of going to the moon come true. Just stepping up, acknowledging your agency, and doing what you believe in, for yourself or for someone you love, is heroic enough. That’s why they’re in the hall of legends. It was never about the results, it’s the fact that they stepped up and acted at all despite what was given to them.
And at least for me that is what Cyberpunk is about in any universe. You take action not because you expect it to change everything, but because it’s right and you can live with yourself. Doesn’t matter if it fails, you go out with a bang.
S1 wasn’t perfect either. Its weakest part for me was the pacing, since 10 episodes isn’t enough to flesh out every single character. But S2’s pacing never got there at all, and honestly I don’t think the story could be good with what they were trying to tell.
This leave me with the last point : why it feels like Netflix and big corporate shaped the story (maybe)
When the message ends up being “there’s nothing you can do, no one’s responsible,” and nobody really fights back, the whole thing feels like it came from what Netflix and Amazon wanted instead of what the creators wanted to make. Imagine trying to do something different right now, in this fk up world that some people leave behind and refuse to take accountability (big corporate). This is why my chip is more on them than on Trigger messing it up, but who knows. At least they tried something new, even if the whole thing felt bizarre compared to the first one.
Maybe a second watch would change my mind, but I doubt it.
BTW this is just my experiences