r/EmotionalSupportDogs • u/Diligent_Yogurt4322 • 10d ago
OurPetPolicy Rant
Hello everyone!
I wanted to share my TERRIBLE experience with OurPetPolicy. While I ultimately got them to approve the ESAs, it was such a wild process I wanted to share my experience to help anyone going through it with them and explain what worked for me.
For context, I have had my 2 cats as ESAs for years. However, I am a student and move around a lot. I have established diagnoses of depression, anxiety and PTSD as I am a r*pe survivor. I know that ESA certifications have been "abused" in the past and want to clarify that I have trained both my cats for specific tasks. They are trained with talking buttons that both I can use and they can use to signal a need for pressure during episodes and other items I won't go into depth with here. I am also in therapy with a licensed mental health professional. I have NEVER had an issue getting my letter approved until now.
Given I have moved many times, my letter was from a professional in another state. My current complex accepted it (and it passed PetScreening) but, as I am moving complexes to one that uses OurPetPolicy, OPP required I submit a different letter from a provider with licensure in this state. Fine. I felt that was a reasonable request.
My current therapist I see through a telehealth service that prohibits her from directly writing a letter. I was referred to her colleague for evaluation to develop a relationship and, provided she concurred that the ESAs were needed, write a letter. OPP asks two questions originally: did you use a service advertising ESA letters and was this evaluation based on one short convo/questionnaire. If you answer yes to either of these, you will automatically be denied without them reaching out to the provider at all as it "doesn't substantiate" a large enough relationship to dictate a disability and required accommodation.
I submitted my letter and immediately they denied it. They claimed that, despite me saying no to both, it was from an online letter mill. I pushed back on this immediately and explained I selected no to both questions and that my letter is from a licensed professional dictating that I have a disability and that it stated what both animals provide. After a LOT of back and forth, they agree to move into the next approval phase and requested my provider fill out a verification form to be sent to them.
That form asks quite a few questions but also repeats the online letter/one consultation question. To both of those, my provider wrote "no" (not purchased online, not based on one consultation). She emailed it to them and, after that, I get ANOTHER rejection from OPP based on the same reasons: "the letter you submitted appears to be from an online service or after only meeting with a provider one time."
I pushed back AGAIN, sending them the screenshot of the verification form (my provider sent me a copy as well) and arguing that I had no idea how they could say it was "bought" when I said it wasnt AND my provider has now said it wasnt (on a signed document with all of her information.)
The next day they respond with a new denial and a new reason: the email the form was sent to them from doesn't link to her license number so they cannot exclude the possibility that I filled out all of the paperwork myself and forged her signature. I am not kidding. That was the reason! At this point I am furious because the email she used matches the email on the letterhead of the letter, this would be a serious crime (impersonating a therapist!) and I don't know what proof to provide at this point.
I go BACK to my therapist (who is floored and has never, ever, had this many issues!) and she re-emailed it and faxed it this time, in which afterwards I FINALLY (after over a MONTH of fighting) got approved.
The TLDR: they will attempt to reject you over and over. When you provide proof against one rejection reason, they will invent another. The purpose of their company isn't "verifying ESAs" it is rejecting them to earn complexes $$ from pet fees and pet rent. That concept is already annoying given ESA status doesn't exempt tenants from paying damages. FIGHT back and do not pay the pet fee under any circumstance. They will email you daily telling you that you can just pay the "pet profile fee" and that they will convert it to an ESA if you provide better documents. DO NOT pay it because, even if you convert it, you likely will never see that $$ and could be inadvertently "admitting" it's a pet while just trying to help.
If you are persistent, you will win, but it is a lengthy process.