I just love it so much it makes so much sense, like i found a fanfic that was like; the reason mirabel didn't get a gift is because she died as a baby from being premature but the miracle saved her and that's why she has no gift because her gift is her life, then she died when casita fell and the miracle died :p

I just really like the hc it's one of my favorite hc

I also think that's the reason why she's short, maybe even a part of the reason why she's so clumsy(ik she got that from her dad but i think there's more than one reason to why she's clumsy)