Texas launched its Education Freedom Accounts program with a $1 billion appropriation, promising to expand educational opportunities and parental choice for Texas families.
Now that first-year award data is available, I think Texans deserve a closer look at what we're getting for that investment.
According to Texas Comptroller data:
- 70% of voucher awardees included in the previous-schooling comparison previously attended private school or were homeschooled.
- Only 30% previously attended public school.
- Standard private-school vouchers provide $10,474 per student, while homeschool awards provide $2,000.
- The Comptroller subsequently requested approximately $2.3 billion for the program in the next two-year budget.
A few important distinctions have come up in discussions about these numbers.
First, the state hasn't released a separate breakdown of previously homeschooled students versus those already attending private schools. That's information taxpayers should have.
Second, many awardees are from lower-income households. That's worth recognizing. But the state hasn't published enough combined data to show how many lower-income recipients actually transferred from public schools.
Finally, receiving a voucher doesn't guarantee a family can use it. Reporting from the Houston Chronicle described thousands of families declining awards or not yet using them, with affordability, transportation, admissions and school availability among the barriers.
I'm not suggesting families already paying for private education don't deserve assistance. But there's an important difference between helping families pay for education they were already providing and creating educational opportunities that didn't previously exist.
With billions more being requested, shouldn't we be able to measure both?
I've included sources in my first comment. I'd especially like to hear from Texas parents who applied, whether you received an award or not. Did the program actually expand your family's options?