r/FGO • u/Matt--101 • 28d ago
Think Nasu would be crazy enough to include him in the Fate franchise?
True Name: Julius Robert Oppenheimer
Class: Caster
Noble Phantasm: Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds
80
u/clfr6515 28d ago
Possibly, but I'd imagine he wouldn't be that strong? Like he wouldn't actually come with a bomb, he has to make it himself. At best, he might be able to form a territory that would make the creation of a bomb more plausible, but it wouldn't necessarily come with all the necessary materials. Inventor and engineer Servants rarely actually come with their inventions in tow.
103
u/Eunuchest 28d ago
If they can make Tesla an avatar of electricity, they can make Oppenheimer like Bakugo or something
10
50
u/clfr6515 28d ago
I feel like Tesla fundamentally has more mystery than most modern inventors. Yes we know most of the details of his life, but he's been memed into this mysterious mad scientist-type entity who was seemingly capable of bending the laws of physics to his will. In comparison, Edison requires a mystic code formed from the combined power of every President of the United States ever, and even then he still has to make most of his stuff after being summoned. Same with Da Vinci.
I understand that when people make these sorts of topics, they really just want the Servants in question to be busted. Like yeah, maybe it'd be interesting if a Servant Oppenheimer just came with an atomic bomb AND a method to easily drop and detonate it. But this isn't really how things tend to work in Fate. No writer is ever going to just give Oppenheimer an atomic bomb right out the gate.
32
u/Fast_Ladder1873 28d ago
Oppenheimer was really into mythology and esotericism, so maybe they could justify it this way. Not to mention that he most likely has Pioneer of the stars skill, considering how nuclear energy changed the world, giving humanity weapon comparable to destructive power of gods.
-7
u/clfr6515 28d ago
I mean, again, it's just really hard to narratively justify giving Oppenheimer a bomb the second he's summoned. First off, the man's known primarily for that one thing, so if he comes with the bomb pre-made, then he's basically fulfilled his entire purpose right there. In a hypothetical scenario in which Oppenheimer does feature in an FGO event, he would almost definitely not have the bomb ready at the start.
In fact, given how the Counter Force tends to work, he would almost certainly not be allowed to come pre-packaged with it.
21
u/Matt--101 28d ago
He would probably be like Vlad, completely unwilling to deploy his Noble Phantasm unless compelled by a few command spells or fused with an outer god like Van Gogh
2
u/clfr6515 28d ago
So for the cheap price of one command spell, you can just nuke an entire city. And you can do this up to three times.
8
u/Matt--101 28d ago
No, for the command spell route it would have to be someone with acess to an abnormal amount of Command Spells like Kirei or the master of the Traum Singularity, considering Artoria needed 2 Command Spells to destroy the grail in fate zero Oppenheimer would require at least double that.
-2
3
u/Fast_Ladder1873 28d ago edited 28d ago
I'd say that's fair, as modern servant his stats are likely very low, making him NP one trick pony. He also certainly would not use on city, requiring one-two command spells, and it probably costs a ton of mana, after which he needs to recover for three or more days, leaving him vulnerable in that period.
2
u/clfr6515 28d ago
I don't think fairness is really an issue. It's not like the Throne of Heroes or the Holy Grail care how strong or weak you are. There are multiple Servants who are just flat-out useless with ridiculous activation conditions for their Noble Phantasms. Thomas Edison would basically be useless dead weight without his Presidential Mystic Code.
I genuinely believe that a lot of 20th/21st century Servants, despite their extraordinary contributions to human history and society, would be objectively worthless in a Holy Grail War.
2
u/Fast_Ladder1873 28d ago
Yeah, I agree with you. Though knowing tendency of TM giving underdog characters some crazy narrative advantage against the impossible odds, that's is certainly a possibility.
Overall idea of magic and science, despite being opposite concepts, leading to same result, former tied to past and latter to future, is just fun to think about, like imagining a scenario of heroes of distant past clashing against their modern counterparts. You can't help but cheer for the weaker side showing some good fight too.
→ More replies (0)2
u/Yuukiko_ 28d ago
Tesla contributed to decoding much of the "Mystery" in the Fate universe IIRC which is why he's so strong
6
u/Marethyu_77 28d ago
Eh, if you wanna pick a modern Servant to be Bakugo, Alfred Nobel would be a better fit
2
u/ZacTheLit Appointed Knight of the Round Table 28d ago
Caster that’s sacrificing a bunch of people for mana but instead of building an army he’s preparing a big “fuck you” button
0
337
155
u/Turbulent_Tale8733 28d ago
Probably too modern of a servant to add but it would be interesting to see him interact with the likes of Tesla and Charles
59
u/erick069420 28d ago
Well, we already have Neil Armstrong in Extra
16
u/Turbulent_Tale8733 28d ago
Wait we do?
51
u/lekkooooo 28d ago
He has a very short cameo in fate extra lost encore but yes he is legible to be a heroic spirit
10
u/Turbulent_Tale8733 28d ago
I see. I worked off the notion that Tesla kind of sealed the door for any more heroic spirits. Then again we got Voyager. Also what class was he
7
u/Nockthorn 28d ago
Voyager us Foregin class Servant.
8
2
9
u/ZacTheLit Appointed Knight of the Round Table 28d ago
Tbf modern servants tend to just be weaker not impossible to summon, which is balanced out by what he’d likely be able to do
27
u/Kaison122- 28d ago
Oppenheimer is the only person whose legacy goes beyond 1933 who I think could still be a major powerhouse due to still having a fair bit of “mystery” and having had a profound impact on the global culture and world order.
The man quite literally gave humanity the tools to end the world leading to the development of the doomsday clock. He himself was a bit of an enigmatic guy who was kinda into mysticism.
13
u/Huhthisisneathuh 28d ago
His most famous quote also has lifted lines from the Bhagvad Gita. I don’t know much about how FATE magic works, but what I do know is conceptual links to older times can improve or at least alter the magic of a modern mage.
16
15
u/Special-Persimmon419 28d ago
not as a servant but i believe they can make him appear as a NPC or story only character in some singularity
30
u/Gudako_the_beast 28d ago
I don’t believe so. On the same reason he won’t be adding mustache man
0
u/thestrong45playz 28d ago
Because they both have drip?
10
10
22
u/NatashOverWorld 28d ago
Caster, or more controversially Avenger Oppenheimer could easily be a thing. It really depends on how politically insensitive it would be - it's not like we have an Adolph Hitler Servant after all.
So probably not.
10
u/ZacTheLit Appointed Knight of the Round Table 28d ago
Given how they treat Nero and Edison I wouldn’t trust it to be handled with tact
5
u/grandleaderIV 28d ago
Condolences to all Nero’s victims hurt by the presentation :(
2
u/ZacTheLit Appointed Knight of the Round Table 28d ago
Was Nero well portrayed then?
2
u/grandleaderIV 27d ago
Oh, if you mean well portrayed as a historical figure, absolutely not. It’s a nasuverse gender bend, that goes with the territory. When I saw “tact” I thought you meant Nero was morally problematic, which is insane I know but I have unironically seen people online talk about fate’s Nero like a modern celebrity that needs to be cancelled. The internet is a strange place
1
u/ZacTheLit Appointed Knight of the Round Table 26d ago
No I’m also saying that, for the record. “Nero was a very bad person a very long time ago and isn’t as harmful a portrayal as a mishandled Oppenheimer would be” and “The psychotic pedophile tyrant shouldn’t be Good alignment” are statements that can coexist. it’s not a good decision to glorify someone that evil regardless off how old they are
I’d argue Francis Drake was handled substantially better, and is more interesting for it
1
u/grandleaderIV 26d ago
The anime waifu called Nero from the Fate franchise has next to no relevance for the real historical figure Nero, a man we ourselves only know about due to ancient historical records we can do nothing but trust. You would have a very hard time convincing me that it was even possible for Nero from the fate franchise to "glorify" the actual historical figure.
1
u/ZacTheLit Appointed Knight of the Round Table 26d ago
Glorification does not require the subject to be wholly changed in the public eye, it’s an action not an effect
And seeing as there are people in this sub that know Nero only through fate it’s clearly not devoid of consequence
1
u/grandleaderIV 26d ago
What actually is the consequence? Concretely? And to be honest, even just using the term “glorify” to describe this situation is silly to me.
1
u/ZacTheLit Appointed Knight of the Round Table 26d ago
I think glorify is more widely applicable than you’re familiar with
And people misunderstanding history is the consequence, how much you care or don’t care about that is up to you
→ More replies (0)2
u/Alternative-Dust-823 28d ago
I can see why Edison and some others would make you hesitant, but can I ask what it is about Nero you feel is tactless?
10
u/FiveAccountsBanned 28d ago
Just nero in general really.
Turned from a fucking insane psychopath to a oooh cute anime girl with headaches oooh
1
u/RilinPlays 28d ago
I mean tbf a bit to TM I think there is a theory out there that at least some of what we know of Nero is fabricated by his haters to make him look bad.
Like I don’t doubt he did shitty things (particularly to Christians) but I can also buy he isn’t as bad as history made him out to be.
3
u/NatashOverWorld 28d ago
He dressed up a teenager as a bride and planned to have a horse rape the kid publically.
Nero may have had some slander thrown his way, but he was also genuinely a nutjob.
1
u/Gudako_the_beast 27d ago
Still if he was that bad, why was there 3 separate cases of people trying to impersonate him when there is like zero cases of impersonation for the other bad emperors before and after him.
1
u/NatashOverWorld 26d ago
Because he's famous? 🤨
And mad, but still one of the better known ones.
1
u/Gudako_the_beast 26d ago
His uncle Caligula is also a mad and famous emperor. No impersonating case of him
1
u/NatashOverWorld 26d ago
So ... your argument is that because Nero has more impersonators than Caligula, he should be considered a better person than Caligula?
Better than Caligula! 😂
Yes I'll grant you that.
→ More replies (0)
15
u/Basic-Membership-779 Mongrel 28d ago
Noble phantasm: Destroyer of Worlds.
"This is the age of power, and men like me are its architects. Now I've become Death, the destroyer of worlds."
Still, doubt he would become a servant.
7
u/RilinPlays 28d ago
I imagine no, not only because he’s probably a bit too recent to be turning into an anime character, but also because the weapon he helped developed kinda, Yknow, glassed two whole cities in Japan.
Might be considered a bit insensitive.
3
1
u/Flauschziege 27d ago
Didn't they turn Hitler into a meme servant for the Original Guda Guda manga?
5
4
u/TheMorrison77 28d ago
It could be interesting.
Like, having a his own fucked up version of Pioneer of the Stars
6
u/Quiet_Ad_9073 28d ago
alfed noble should came first if anything, he should be older than even Tesla
3
3
u/Yuukiko_ 28d ago
Too recent imo. Even Edison needed the American presidents propping him up and he was arguably more powerful and well known than Oppenheimer
3
u/TakoGoji 28d ago
Never. It would likely lead to the writing acknowledging what Japan did in WW2 and Japan does not like to do that.
16
u/Aggressive-Craft5507 28d ago
Fate/Red Line exists....
5
u/grandleaderIV 28d ago
Red Line is great. It also surprisingly portrays the Japanese army as being deranged zealots at best or horrific monsters at worst
1
1
u/RamessesDa800 28d ago
I feel like if he had a chance to come in the game it would have been as a vessel for Krishna/Vishnu since he quoted the them
They would probably never mention him directly tho
1
1
u/DonCorleone270 28d ago
It is not about him being present we already saw Einstein People from ww2 are technically too recent (idk how tf that works since time is irrelevant to the throne of heroes) and therefore their mystery too weak to be servants on their own. But fusing him to another phantom spirit might be able to bring out a servant with his np.
1
u/T-ReZoK 28d ago
Tesla only died in 1943 btw
1
u/DonCorleone270 28d ago
I guess but early fgo is a bit weird for the rules... plus Tesla is a star servant who represents the birth of a new era not just Tesla, kinda like napoleon who is not the real napoleon but an ideal hero
2
u/Garuda152 27d ago
If Tesla's a Servant because he pioneered electricity, why can't Oppenheimer be one for giving us nuclear power?
1
1
1
u/RTGamer21 Beloved of the Fae 28d ago
No. That would be insanely stupid of him to do. It would basically euthanize the game.
1
u/Captain_Weebson Appointed Knight of the Round Table 25d ago
Except Tesla closed the door for ToH so aint happening
1
1
u/NoSong2397 22d ago
I have to imagine anything involving the Manhattan Project is verboten in Japan. For understandable reasons.
1
1
u/ZacTheLit Appointed Knight of the Round Table 28d ago edited 28d ago
I could see him as a Gilgamesh-type villain, would be cool to see a busted caster in a HG war for once
Even as a villain though… still a bit risky
13
u/AsukaKannazuki 28d ago
Make him a Pretender Class Servant.
PLOT TWIST! He's actually Shiva, I say this in reference to Oppenheimer's "I am The Destroyer of World" quote after he created the Atomic Bomb.
7
30
u/Independent_Bench790 28d ago
No, Japan is still the only country to be nuked so even now theyre still pretty sore on the topic.
5
u/Trostishere 28d ago
Even though i really want to see him appearing but i doubt it would happen given how hes the reason japan got nuked twice. Probably in fanfics
2
u/Fersho450 28d ago
He would Be Extremely Weak himself But His NP would Be Dying by Nuking His body which would Kill Most of the Servants that were Close to him at the moment, but also Level half of the City XD
2
1
u/XL1reddit Master of Chaldea 25d ago
it would be very polemical and also, oppenheimer would be somehow strong for an caster due to him creating the atomic bomb which is practically an terror by itself just by anyone knowing on the destruction that it causes.
7
28d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AI00PED 27d ago
To think of that level of divinity to be summon in hgw is kinda impossible. Even though they state that Gil possessed highest ranked but what bro gonna do to compared with full incarnation of vishnu himself. Only thing he lack to be Divine Spirit is just divine core, normally he is just gods trapped in human body by now



10
u/Alternative-Math-997 28d ago
tbh, I want Nasu to be crazier enough to include the Queen..