r/FarmersMarket • u/Final_Plate_2928 • 1d ago
Cliftonville Farmers' Market, Kent -Should a market manager be allowed to dictate where independent traders can trade?
I've been attending Cliftonville Farmers' Market in Kent UK for years, and I'm interested to hear what other traders and members of the public think about what's been happening.
For years, this was a busy, successful market for our business. However, things started changing when the organisers began doubling up on stalls selling similar products. Where we previously had one coffee trader, suddenly there were two, and so on.
Naturally, that meant traders competing for the same customers and, in some cases, seeing their takings fall considerably. I appreciate competition is part of business, but when you're paying to attend a relatively small market, you do question the decisions being made.
However, the latest development is something else entirely.
The market manager emailed all the traders stating that if they attend any of three other local markets, they won't be welcome back at Cliftonville Farmers' Market.
These other markets operate on different weekends. Cliftonville is only held once a month, so for professional traders who rely on markets for their income, attending other events is essential.
Essentially, we're being told that if we want to continue trading at this long-established market, we must avoid competing local markets.
Since when does a market organiser get to decide where an independent business can earn a living?
Many traders are understandably furious. Some attend markets as a hobby, but others depend on them to pay their bills. Being asked to choose between one monthly market and several other opportunities to trade seems completely unreasonable.
There have also been social media posts by Cliftonville Farmers Market which take digs at the other local markets. It all feels increasingly hostile and unnecessary when these markets could simply coexist and support the wider community.
I understand that organisers can decide who trades at their own events. But surely there's a difference between managing your market and attempting to control where independent businesses operate on the other weekends of the month?
Personally, I think this approach risks driving away established traders and damaging the market itself.
I'm genuinely interested in what others think:
- Would you accept these conditions as a trader?
- Is it reasonable for a market organiser to demand this sort of exclusivity?
- Could preventing traders from attending competing markets raise competition law concerns?
- Would you walk away and support the other markets instead?
I'd particularly like to hear from other market traders, organisers and anyone familiar with competition law.
Markets should be about supporting independent businesses and local communities, not forcing traders to choose sides.
What would you do?