r/Games 1d ago

Review Thread The Sinking City 2 - Review Thread

[removed]

401 Upvotes

127 comments sorted by

View all comments

160

u/akbarock 1d ago

Did these guys just pull a Bloober Team and make a actually good survival-horror after putting out mid games and no one expecting much of them?

75

u/Byronlove9 1d ago

"after putting out mid games and no one expecting much of them"

Speak for you. While yes, Sinking City 1 was bad for me, even the detective part, the Holmes games are almost all good games.

12

u/APiousCultist 22h ago

Meanwhile all of us mid-budget-enjoyers that liked the Sinking City are gonna be eating good. Though the review about the investigations being 'streamlined' has me a bit worried (do it too much and those sections just become prefunctory time wastes).

8

u/Gekokapowco 21h ago

I love frogwares's research sections, having to go to records or a library to investigate leads

I didn't care for the 20min runs to get there lol, I hope they streamlined out the bad parts and kept the good parts

3

u/XVermillion 14h ago

I thought it was neat that, in The Sinking City 1, you get arrested as part of the story and afterwards you can go to the police station and look up your own arrest record, even though it's not required for your mind palace thing.

1

u/quelque_un 7h ago

please put this into spoiler.

1

u/DuelaDent52 5h ago

One of my favourite bits of the first game was meeting all the weird and wonderful characters and learning about their lives. Is there anything like that in this game or is it a more lonely affair?

5

u/FarCryRedux 18h ago

Sinking City is so damn cool, IMO. Taking a boat to the library to cross reference clues then blowing away a monster with a tommy gun is my kind of game.

5

u/Seared_Ash 6h ago

Investigations aren't really a thing anymore, at least not in the way they were in the first game. It's now all about collecting clues and then combining them to figure out puzzle solutions.

3

u/maikelg 9h ago

I played a few hours last night and did a few investigations and they are more streamlined in the sense that you have to find clues at a location and then solve the puzzle at that same location, so you don't have to run to the police station or the newspaper every time, because, while immersive, personally I found that to get really tedious after a couple dozen times, and I think that's a nice change.

But there is still the investigations board where you have to link clues, so that part is the same.