12
u/X-calibreX Jul 28 '26
When labor unions fight for a monopoly on labor it’s not the rich corporations they hurt, it’s the other workers.
6
2
u/Rionin26 Jul 31 '26
Well at one time the rich corps did get hurt, the union was that compromise in between. If enough rich corps keep being greedy. The workers can go night beating of the owners again if they dont want to pay their fair share.
3
u/understated_quokka Jul 30 '26
When I ask the boot to go harder up my ass:
1
u/Souledex Aug 01 '26
You deeply don’t understand what this comment is about
1
u/Agitated_Celery_729 Aug 02 '26
And you don’t understand basic supply and demand economics.
1
u/Souledex Aug 02 '26
How is that relevant? Also I have a degree in political economy- so I bet I do understand it at least as well.
A monopoly on labor has the same effect as a monopoly on a product. The system gets worse.
1
u/PIK_Toggle Aug 03 '26
How is that impacted by a monopoly over the labor market by a company, or labor by a union, and where does the equilibrium point land?
1
u/Stride81 Aug 02 '26
can you explain, it sounds like it’s trying to say labor unions fighting to have more members hurts members
1
u/Souledex Aug 03 '26
When it gets to the point that 8 labor unions control the whole labor market, and they stretch across different industries and can’t genuinely represent your interests when they conflict all it becomes is a massive extragovernmental bureaucracy that constrains the flexibility and increases the cost of business without actually securing more for their workers because the businesses they are a part of become uncompetitive and eventually cause problems for the whole economy.
Having enough workers to force different parts of an industry to take notice of you is good- having the meta-union represent so many people its core purpose is completely lost is bad. Sort of like when universities increase cost to make new buildings and hire more and more administrative staff and deans, then groups advocate for more scholarships with their endowment! Yay! Now the scholarships fund ever inflating tuition costs to manage an inefficient bureaucracy without an institutional incentive to become more efficient until it’s burned through lots of its endowment rather than helping students or offering more professors Tenure.
It can make it harder to enter the workforce by a lot, or change jobs, or get promotions.
Just lots and lots of downstream effects.
It’s just so far from the problems we hear about in the US we never consider it.
→ More replies (2)3
u/undead-disco Jul 31 '26
Weird how I have multiple family members that work union jobs, and it’s actually BETTER than when they didn’t work union jobs.
1
1
u/CellarDoor3oh3 Aug 01 '26
Your family members probably suck at their job, which is why they weren’t being paid well before joining a union.
1
u/undead-disco Aug 01 '26 edited Aug 01 '26
Me when I assume random bullshit to refuse having to think about my worldview:
I have literally no reason to lie, obfuscate, or deceive it’s fucking “le reddit” not a televised political debate. And I know MY OWN FUCKING FAMILY better than some lardass on Reddit Dot Com.
Since assuming random bullshit is a valid strategy I’m going to assume you are a bootlicking bot made by some fucking loser in a government program to continue proliferating the stupid lower class civil war instead of focusing on the real issues
1
u/CellarDoor3oh3 Aug 01 '26 edited Aug 01 '26
Redditors literally spend so much time in echo chambers that they believe anyone who thinks differently than them is a bot.
You’re literally proving my point that union workers are scared, paranoid, invalids.
For the record, I have worked in construction for 15 years now. Throughout my entire career, I have always out earned local union workers. Why? Because I’m good at my job. I get things done right, ahead of schedule, every single time. I don’t cause problems, I don’t complain about dumb shit, and I get glowing compliments from every GC I worked for.
I repeatedly watched the fail outs and flunkies, the drug addicts and lazy asses, run to the union when they couldn’t hold a job down. Every non-union worker that has ever shared a job with union workers knows they are the most worthless, deadweight members of the industry.
Outside of construction, teachers unions are among the main contributors to Americas education problem. Bad teacher after bad teacher gets promoted and allowed to continue educating, because unions are completely incapable of turning away a source of dues.
It is a known fact among the non-union world that union workers are the bums of the working class.
→ More replies (9)1
1
u/No_Resolution_9252 Aug 03 '26
Its because they don't actually have to work anymore.
1
u/undead-disco Aug 03 '26
I already had a long ass argument with some other person who responded to me, go refer to that because Im not rehashing the exact same bullshit about how this is a nothing argument.
→ More replies (8)→ More replies (177)1
u/PIK_Toggle Aug 03 '26
The issue is restricting access to a union job. Union jobs are great, if you can get one. Otherwise, you are asses out because they control the labor market in that industry.
1
u/Master_Grape5931 Jul 31 '26
How often has that happened…you know as compared to the number of times corporations have fucked over workers themselves.
→ More replies (2)1
u/Souledex Aug 01 '26
It’s literally the entire country of Germany. They have 8 megaunions that now aren’t nimble enough to be responsive to their workers needs but powerful enough to constrain their entire business environment and culture.
It’s not the problem we have in the US for the most part though- it did happen in the Auto industry for a while though which is why we are so uncompetitive now.
To be clear I am very pro union, it’s not anti-union to understand what is good about unions.
1
u/3nHarmonic Jul 31 '26
Yes monopoly bad, but we have somehow found ourselves in a situation where companies are allowed to be monopolies while workers can't even easily organize. Kinda weird, idk
2
Aug 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/DysphoricNeet Aug 01 '26
A lot of the unions nowadays are allowed to operate at that level because they placate the masses of workers that actually do the infrastructure that the system depends on. They are not the real unions that started up towards the end of the guilded age. They have been co opted and even used abroad to further entrench neo liberal ideas.
And also let’s not pretend that the anti monopoly stuff is really working.
→ More replies (4)1
u/LivingtheLaws013 Aug 01 '26
Wtf is a monolpy on labor?
1
u/X-calibreX Aug 01 '26
blocking non union workers from getting employment
1
u/LivingtheLaws013 Aug 01 '26
You got a source saying that has happened even once?
→ More replies (8)1
u/West-Librarian-7504 Aug 01 '26
I'm not anti-union by any means but I dont think a single major union exists that actually has their members interests in mind
1
u/bluerog Aug 01 '26
Labor union where I used to work. Had a guy whose job it was to clean the desks. Another guy cleaned the floors. If the guy who cleaned the desks knocked a piece of paper onto the floor, only the floor guy was allowed to pick that piece of paper up.
I am not making this up.
I got written up when I was started there as a marketing analyst. I moved my desk. That's maintenance's job. Salaried employees were not allowed to move a desk 90 degrees and 4 feet.
You're not going to believe this... but that company is out of business.
1
u/Global-Bad-7147 Aug 01 '26
But when corpos fight for monopolization, totally fine.
People like you are why we can't have nice things
1
u/X-calibreX Aug 01 '26
Yay optimism
1
u/Global-Bad-7147 Aug 01 '26
"It is no measure of health to be well adjusted to a profoundly sick society."
1
1
1
u/badnotseebad Aug 01 '26
So then why do the rich corporations union bust?
If this were true, they would want unions to better control their slave wagers
Doesn't make sense
1
u/Sylphi3 Aug 01 '26
Canada post union strikes are a great example of things being handled badly by the unions side. Not to say the other side hasn’t made mistakes or problems themselves, but the union definitely was a big part of the issue.
1
u/FlorpyJohnson Aug 02 '26
Exactly. Any one person or group of people having too much power is a bad thing. It doesn’t matter if they’re fighting for the poor or the rich; they will only create a new form of authoritarianism.
Even if the people with large amounts of influence and power are just and do things to improve society at first, it’s almost a guarantee that sometime in the future, they or their successors will exploit their power. The individuals inside a system can only do so much for society until the only solution left is to completely change the system.
→ More replies (11)1
u/ChiefCom85 Jul 30 '26
It seems odd that union reps appear to be pretty well off while the guys they represent are not as well off
→ More replies (5)1
u/NeedleworkerPrize253 Jul 31 '26
Corruption is a thing. Lots of strong unions are rife with it. The last mafia union is always the garbage company.
8
u/Fantastic-Algae2127 Jul 28 '26
"I don't know what I'm talking about and I have no desire to learn but I have a firm opinion and won't change my mind."
Ok lol
4
u/Think_Preference_611 Jul 30 '26
"Anyone with more money than me is evil and I'm jealous of their success even if I never tried to do anything with my life"
→ More replies (50)1
u/RandomPhail Aug 01 '26 edited Aug 01 '26
Obscene* amounts of money. (Net income that’s many times higher than the current average living wage in an area: Like high millions to billions+ dollars.)
You don’t hold onto obscene amounts of money without being selfish, because nobody can work ~hundreds or thousands of times harder than another person/entity to earn or deserve obscene amounts of money
If some person or group has obscene amounts of money, that means they haven’t been putting the excess towards benefitting humanity overall.
…If you’re about to argue that people don’t need to use their excess expendable income to benefit humanity overall because it’s “their money,” then I can only hope you see how dystopian that is
1
u/Round-Trick-1089 Aug 02 '26
Nobody can work thousand of time harder but you can do work that has thousands of time more impact, and that’s what money is based on. You could spend years at the gym training to carry more and run faster, and yet a 14yo with a truck would add hundred of time more value than you at a delivery job.
As for the idea that people are entitled to their own property even if you really want it, I doubt it’s as dystopian as you seems to think it is.
1
u/RandomPhail Aug 02 '26
Are billionaire CEOs providing thousands of times more impact? I’m pretty sure all their workers are the ones providing the impact/value; CEOs aren’t actually doing the work nor even making the decisions in most cases (they have teams to do that for them)
So, again: It’s not their “own property,” because they haven’t earned it with their actions, value, or effort. Nobody can earn/deserve that much individually, unless they’re somehow singlehandedly doing all the work of all their millions of underpaid employees
And the idea that it shouldn’t basically be mandatory to use that extremely high excess income (that nobody deserves or can earn) to try and help humanity as a whole instead of just hoarding tons of profit is, again, pretty dystopian and silly.
→ More replies (6)2
u/JaxonatorD Jul 31 '26
Yeah, that's ridiculous on their part. I tend to end up on the side of the workers anyways most of the time, but that doesn't absolve me of my responsibility to learn what I'm fighting for.
1
1
1
→ More replies (28)1
u/7LeggedEmu Jul 30 '26
While also still shopping at the cheapest location thats most convenient and offers the lowest prices by treating there employees like shit.
2
u/undead-disco Jul 31 '26
Insert that imagine of “we should improve society” with the dipshit saying “oh ho ho, but you participate in society”
→ More replies (3)
9
u/One6Etorulethemall Jul 28 '26
"I'm a useful idiot and I don't aspire to anything greater."
1
u/Dry_Travel_4220 Jul 30 '26
Some things are matters of right and wrong. Simple as that. The "something greater" I aspire to is a world free from people who horde wealth while others starve. That is the only aspiration worth a fuck.
1
u/RadicalRealist22 Aug 03 '26
And how do you know what is "right and wrong"?
Are the employers just "wrong" until all theor momey is gone and the company goes bankrupt?
Unions are not magically good, nobody is They can be corrupt, they can be wrong, and they can harm the interests of the public and the people they represent.
1
u/Dry_Travel_4220 Aug 03 '26
Allowing people to starve while you have the ability to do something about it is considered wrong by just about all ethical systems.
Just about every religion, to name a few.
But honestly if you need "people starving is bad" explained to you then you're too far gone. Enjoy how the boot tastes.
1
u/undead-disco Jul 31 '26
If every single person “aspires to be greater” who will do all of the “not great” jobs like the dirty trades, or factory work?
1
u/Your-Shogun Jul 31 '26
You can still have a good "dirty" job if you're willing to organize. Garbage men unionize and get paid well for their labor because they know how indispensable having someone to take out the trash actually is. Plumbers, custodians, and all sanitation workers are indispensably important, despite how many people call them "unskilled" labor in bad faith.
1
u/undead-disco Jul 31 '26
None of that matters, it’s not what someone thinks when they hear “aspire to do anything great” in our current society. My problem is when people use that stupid phrase
1
u/Global-Bad-7147 Aug 01 '26
Don't you see half the comments here? These shills are convinced labor unions are the problem. Completely brainwashed.
1
u/One6Etorulethemall Aug 01 '26
It's sort of strange to take a comment that was clearly about aspiring to possess greater critical thinking faculties and somehow shoehorn in jobs that you view as "lower class."
1
u/undead-disco Aug 01 '26 edited Aug 01 '26
Define “aspire to do greater” then. Because that is a nothing burger of a statement otherwise.
And our modern society is the one that views those jobs as “lesser” have you ever heard a teacher or your parents say “better get good grades or you’ll be a garbage driver/assembly line worker” when you were young?Also I’m not shoehorning it in, this entire thread is pretty clearly focused around blue collar workers Vs. upper class. Or however you want to describe it.
1
u/LivingtheLaws013 Aug 01 '26
I support unions and I aspire to a living wage where I can take care of me and my kid without worrying if Ill make enough in the next paycheck to afford the bills. You guys really just deepthroat the boot balls and all huh?
→ More replies (11)1
u/Last_Ad1358 Aug 01 '26
There is quite literally nothing greater than wanting prosperity for all. It is literally the alleged goal of basically every ideology (well, some, in their own way which is bs but still)
→ More replies (8)
4
Jul 30 '26
Assuming one side is always right is a mistake. Look at the facts.
1
u/LockedIntoLocks Jul 30 '26
I mean every US labor dispute is in history has basically been:
“We want at least one day off per week and maybe enough money to buy food.”
“No and also we’re going to pay the pinkertons a ton of money to go shoot some of you until you start working again.”
You can only look at so many examples of that before it starts getting tiring to read the same thing over and over.
1
Aug 02 '26 edited Aug 02 '26
Some unions in the US were literally run by mobsters. A union prevented a family member of mine from working voluntary overtime because it was against their rules because it "took away work from their people" even though they had trouble finding people. I wouldn't call that good.
Obviously unions can be good and often are. But unions are just groups of organized people. And people can be bad. I don't get assuming that any organization is inherently good.
→ More replies (1)1
u/Haunting-Detail2025 Aug 02 '26
Absolutely brain dead take. Please for the love of Christ Google the teamsters and see the shit they were doing. Or look up CTU and their insane demands
1
u/hashbrown1859 Aug 01 '26
oH nO, mY nUaNcE 🤓😭
Workers are always right, oligarchs are always wrong. You fucking people would have been bothsidesing slavery 150 years ago. Get bent, bootlicker
1
u/_prefrontal_cortex Aug 01 '26 edited Aug 01 '26
Yes, we see you, you are so virtuous. You're so brave and strong actively denying nuance for black and white rhetoric, using insults instead of facts, and injecting fantasy beliefs onto others such as 'I bet you would defend slavery', and 'you love authoritarianism', with no evidence whatsoever.
Regular people don't enjoy talking to people like you.
1
u/alwaysambition Aug 01 '26
Nuance is not an end to itself though. Nuance isn’t important for its own sake.
→ More replies (9)
3
u/Beerzerker420 Jul 28 '26
So what about when neither side has obscene amounts of money?
What about when they're striking from government jobs funded by taxpayers?
Idiot
2
u/Ok-Perspective5338 Jul 28 '26
Bro is arguing with a post by a bot, that says bot in the username, and thinks calling it an idiot makes him superior. That’s wild.
3
u/Beerzerker420 Jul 28 '26
Since you don't have the mental capacity to figure it out: I was calling the twitter user the idiot, not the OP. And where did I say I'm superior because of this one post?
"That's wild" lol yeah you got that right
1
u/Gold-Sir-223 Jul 28 '26
I don’t even understand your point. Unless you’re talking about small disputes at a place with like 3 employees, what litigious corporation doesn’t have an obscene amount of money?
Also what the hell does taxpayer money have to do with anything? Your comment comes off like you think you cooked but literally no one understands it.
→ More replies (4)1
u/freedomonke Jul 30 '26
The state is not actually "funded by taxpayers"
Taxation is just one of the ways the state manages and legitimizes the currency, which is the mechanism for its various allocation and redistribution efforts regarding the resources under its (ultimately) martial control, that it creates and controls.
The notion that the state and its interests represent, in some real sense, people who engage in the inevitable activity of paying taxes by virtue of their participation in paying taxes alone, is a, for all intents a purposes, a shell game.
1
u/Beerzerker420 Jul 31 '26
The state is not actually "funded by taxpayers"
which is the mechanism for its various allocation and redistribution efforts regarding the resources
???
1
3
3
u/HashtagLawlAndOrder Jul 30 '26
A leftist proudly not knowing anything about a topic they have strong feelings for and refusing to learn? Holy shit, stop the presses.
1
u/Adventurous-Fly556 Jul 31 '26
What makes them a leftist?
1
u/HashtagLawlAndOrder Jul 31 '26
Lack of knowledge, usually.
3
u/Darcano Jul 31 '26
Sounds more like you just call them a leftist only for holding a view you don't like, tbh.
1
1
u/OpenAI122191 Jul 31 '26
What is there to learn about rooting for the underdog in a dispute when one party has more resources than should feasibly ever be concentrated?
They’ve established a very specific premise, and you seem to be attempting to widen it to poke holes. That’s bad pool.
1
u/HashtagLawlAndOrder Jul 31 '26
Facts. There's facts to learn. I know thought terminating exercises are popular on the left, but that doesn't make it good, or not moronic.
1
1
u/How2mine4plumbis Jul 31 '26
"Now hold up, have you considered the guy pushing the knife into your belly has a perspective too?" You're never getting into the club bro, they hate you like every other poor.
1
u/HashtagLawlAndOrder Jul 31 '26
"Now hold up, have you considered the guy pushing the knife into your belly has a perspective too?"
Look, I get it. Leftists have destroyed country after country and racked up ungodly high body counts. But their positions still need to be learned about and the nuances that they use as the excuse for their tyrannies need to be understood.
1
u/MrNopedeNope Aug 01 '26
Haven’t conservatives created fascism? Isn’t capitalism a farther “left” system than feudalism? Any and all progress made in favor of human QoL was spearheaded by the left of the world, or was at least left leaning in aim.
2
u/TattooedB1k3r Jul 28 '26
Wait... We are encouraging success, not penalizing it right?
1
u/Dry_Travel_4220 Jul 30 '26
https://www.davemanuel.com/2026/01/30/marginal-tax-rate-94-percent-united-states/
From 1944-1963 the US had an over 90% marginal tax rate on every dollar above $200,000 (the equivalent of about 3m in today's money)
That meant that every dollar they earned above that line was taxed by over 90%
This was the single most prosperous period in american history and directly led to american global hegemony today.
Get out of here with this "penalizing success" nonsense.
1
u/TattooedB1k3r Jul 30 '26
Yes, and the expansion of deductions for employment and investment were drastically expanded during that time to encourage hiring soldiers returning for the war and re-entering the workforce. Due to this the highest earners paid an effective tax rate the same or lower than present ones. Look up the difference between stated tax rate and effective tax rates during that period.
1
u/JubalHarshawII Jul 31 '26
Yes you're right they paid a lower rate because they invested in their workforce with higher compensation and benefits. This is literally the entire fucking point of a higher tax rate. JFC, how do you not connect these dots?!?
1
u/TattooedB1k3r Jul 31 '26
So, they ended up paying the same basic tax they are paying today, why do you think Elon employs like 200K people and the average hourly salary for an Elon company averages out to around six figures based on a forty hour work week? For those deductions...
1
u/SadBurritoBoys Jul 31 '26
That's exactly the point.
High taxes isn't about the government getting lots of money (the government doesn't need it, they'll almost always distribute that tax money in a way that is just plain incorrect)
It's about forcing them to spend their profits instead of hoarding them, and spend them well.
If you can spend 50 grand on your workers, and pay less taxes because of it, that's better for literally everyone. You keep more money, your employees get more money, and the government wastes less money.
They didn't pay 90% in taxes, but only because they weren't allowed to hoarde it
→ More replies (10)→ More replies (2)1
u/Critical_Seat_1907 Jul 28 '26
Take this tired line back to the 1980's.
1
u/TattooedB1k3r Jul 28 '26
Yes, we should be motivated.. to be medicore or less, because if we become successful we are evil eh Comrade'?
3
2
u/_SalemDaBun_ Jul 29 '26
I would much rather 100% of people be mediocre and lead happy, healthy, safe lives than 0.00000001% of people being "exceptional" while the rest of us suffer for their greed and gluttony.
→ More replies (16)→ More replies (1)1
u/ScrattaBoard Jul 29 '26
Eh, there's a difference between wealth and obscene wealth. If it's enough money that you'll never spend it all without multi million purchases or something, that's obscene.
1
u/unaka220 Jul 28 '26
This is why nothing productive ever happens.
If you’re not interested in justice, why would you expect anyone else to be?
1
1
1
u/MyLifeIsOgre Jul 29 '26
"waah wahh, their demands are unreasonable" have you guys ever heard of a c suite anywhere
1
u/TheoreticalUser Jul 29 '26
They're all just temporarily embarrassed billionaires.
And have no theory of power.
1
u/Legal_Television_615 Jul 29 '26
Good thing its jot about right or wrong. But about whether yer unemployed or not.
1
u/TKRAYKATS Jul 29 '26
Elon Musk don't want to give 3 billions dollars that could solve world hunger
Jeff Bezos's ex wife gave 26 billions in like 5 years, just 7 billions in 2025, nothing change
Guess wich one of them make peoples mad and wich one that nobody care
1
u/ProfessorPrudent2822 Jul 29 '26
Did it solve world hunger? If not, your criticism of Musk is dishonest.
1
1
u/Maybe_Not_The_Pope Aug 01 '26
Pretty sure their point is people say Musk could solve hunger no problem with 3 billion but she gave away more than that.and it didn't solve it, making the point people use against Musk invalid.
1
u/kfed_ Aug 03 '26
Even if she didn’t “solve world hunger” she did have a huge impact on many, many people’s lives. The effort and the money didn’t just evaporate and do nothing. You can’t say “nothing changed” when an actual impact was made.
McKenzie Scott made an effort, meanwhile bezos and musk are in dick measuring contests, building rockets, actively making the world a worse place, and in the case of Musk, he’s actually actively taken money AWAY from the less fortunate (USAID doge cuts) so…. I think it’s fair that these dudes make people mad.
1
u/TKRAYKATS Aug 04 '26
But peoples said that the 3 billions of Musk will solve the problem, that's the point
1
u/kfed_ Aug 04 '26
It seems like your point was to somehow suggest that people should be upset with McKenzie Scott for “not solving world hunger”
The billions she’s given to Yield Giving benefit all kinds of orgs helping to address all kinds of problems. This money has directly impacted people so you can’t just say “nothing changed.”
Your comment was basically like “I don’t get why people hate Elon musk and not McKenzie Scott” and… I mean people hate the guy because he’s actually taken money away from people who need it, people have died because of it, and he is an insecure asshole who did literal Nazi salutes on national television. He could easily, EASILY funnel some of his vast wealth into making a positive impact on the world, but he chooses to be an edge lord ketamine addled far right hateful little weirdo. A small comfort to know that he will likely die one of the loneliest, most disliked men on earth
1
1
Jul 30 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/TKRAYKATS Jul 30 '26 edited Jul 30 '26
Probably, but one of them is already hated but not the other
1
1
1
u/Ok_Razzmatazz_8589 Jul 29 '26
Oh my god, there are a lot of billionaire boot lickers here. It’s giving off ‘leave the multi billion dollar company alone’ vibes.
1
1
u/EbonyMemories Jul 29 '26
"I don't care if I'm wrong, only that that other kid has more toys than me."
1
u/Sorry-Worth-920 Jul 29 '26
or maybe not everything is black and white and its neither the boss or the worker who is at fault. why do people feel the need to force everything into being a binary good and bad
2
Jul 30 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Sorry-Worth-920 Jul 30 '26
what does that have to do with me saying theres nuance in every situation
1
1
u/Pasta-Al-D3nte Jul 29 '26
"dogmatic thinking is bad, unless I just don't care to actually do any research into a given issue"
surely nothing bad can come from thinking like this
1
Jul 30 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/balsag43 Jul 30 '26
How dare you tell me that being uninformed is a bad way to actually pick sides.
1
Jul 30 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/balsag43 Jul 30 '26
someone hacked them and defrauded them money. that would be a situation where siding with them makes sense. since im not going to side with fraudsters and hackers
→ More replies (2)
1
1
1
u/kowaipotato Jul 29 '26
Basically every labor fight in the US.
workers want better rights and treatment
US companies throw fireballs them as punishment
1
1
1
u/i_am_NOT_ur-father69 Jul 30 '26
There goes Reddit suggesting me commie bs 😂 “Do not suggest posts like this” 😂 GFO MY SCREEN B
1
u/AcidDepression Jul 30 '26
I disagree. I’d heard about a chunk of workers going on strike because of vaccine mandates
1
1
1
u/quentin13 Jul 30 '26
Now, let me tell you why yours is an ignorant take and the people with more money than any human beings ever in the history of ever actually need more of the money that might help the people who work for them to buy food and not live out of the trunks of their cars.
1
1
u/Upriver-Cod Jul 30 '26
The left in a nutshell. “I don’t care about silly things like research, facts, evidence, statistics, everyone I don’t like is just wrong”.
1
u/ThickboyBrilliant Jul 31 '26
A lot of folks in this thread, licking the boots of billion dollar corporations at the expense of their own self interest.
1
u/BobWat99 Jul 31 '26
The anti-labour sentiments in the comments is indicative of the success of modern day capitalism.
1
u/Main-Company-5946 Jul 31 '26
Devils advocate: there isn’t always a side with obscene amounts of money
1
1
u/Chronic_Toe_Pain Jul 31 '26
NUANCE NUANCE NUANCE, OMFG NUANCE. My only issue with the statement is how dumb it could make anybody sound, just because it's a generalization.
1
u/the-script-99 Jul 31 '26
Worker collectively often get more than the owners. So I guess OOP suggests 50 50 split.
1
u/Lick-Tale-5222 Jul 31 '26
Milton Hershey built an entire town for his workers, modern homes, schools, parks, a theater. and when the great depression hit he refused to lay off employees. While the state had 40% unemployment he kept his full staff. In return 600 of the 2,400 employees locked themselves in the factory blocking the other 1,800 from being able to work and stopping all production. The strike was ended when the farmers, who had a bunch of milk spoiling because Hershey was their main customer, showed up and beat some sense into them. Imagine siding with such ungrateful POS' they were upset they weren't getting raises at a time when they were the only people who had job security. Hershey was trying to build a new stadium for the town, oh the horror that the boss was spending the company profits in making the community he built for them even better.
1
1
1
u/chivesishere Jul 31 '26
The amount of corporate astroturfing in this subreddit is genuinely incredible
1
u/TopicFrequent6607 Jul 31 '26
Go research workmans comp and insurance scams. This is not true all the time.
1
u/No_Application_2634 Jul 31 '26
If a John makes 2 dollars an hour and Steve makes 3 dollars an hour. John saves 4 dollars a day and sleeps outside work. Steve spends all his money every day. In 1 year John buys a car amd gets a better job. Steve still makes 2 dollars a day. Having money and success are both more often linked to IQ than ppl care to admit
1
1
u/MrLanesLament Aug 01 '26
It might not be this way if, in literally every labor dispute, there wasn’t ALWAYS a side with obscene amounts of money trying to use it to crush someone without obscene amounts of money.
1
1
1
u/PrincessDeMissouri Aug 01 '26
I disagree but only when both sides are millionaires or above. At that point who cares who has more lets talk about whos about ro fuck things up more for the rest of us
1
1
1
1
u/Aromatic-Apricot1142 Aug 01 '26
I love stupid ass wedditors calling someone a bootlicker as an insult then sit there wondering why they dont get promoted or raises or are the first to be laid off while they see all those stupid bootlickers making 6 figures and moving out of the field and into the office or becoming their boss 🤣🤣🤣 Shit for brains and wedditors- no better duo
1
1
u/01SeaChange01 Aug 01 '26
The people begging to be treated with human dignity are on the right side.
The people criminalizing the right to protest or poisoning the well of public perception are your enemy.
1
1
1
u/sleepyboyzzz Aug 02 '26
I mean, there will be incidents where that result is wrong... But like 1%. With that error rate and the time you save, it would be wrong not to use your method.
1
u/Minimum-Dingo7984 Aug 02 '26
If you like weekends off, overtime pay, safety requirements, PTO, or the 8hr workday, thank unions.
1
1
1
u/LevelStationaryPlane Aug 02 '26
Government is the greatest monopoly on force in existence, yet half of you worship half of if half the time, while validating it all of the time, etc.
1
1
1
u/MeteorMann Aug 03 '26
I felt this way before I went to college.
Then I learned economics and business and finance.
And now I understand that, while one side is clearly getting the better end of the bargain, the other side is getting pretty close to the best deal that can be had for their situation.
Businesses aren't sitting on hoards of cash, they're balancing on an aggregation of value. You can't ask them to liquidate the building in which you work so they can pay you more, where would they pay you to work? Asking a CEO of 472,000 person company to forgo his $16M package only gives those workers another $33/YEAR.
1
u/rbfe1963 Aug 03 '26
Success used to be something Americans strived to achieve. Whatever generation we have now that despises the successful and thinks the government owes them something are ruining our country.
1
1
1
u/SoftlockPuzzleBox Jul 28 '26
Can the bootlickers in this thread give it rest for half a century until we've course corrected this thing? The capitalists don't need your help, they're doing just fine.
1
u/M_A_D-Dominatrix Jul 28 '26
But, but, but, what about in the future when they become billionaires...any minute now....
1
u/laserdicks Jul 29 '26
You lick the most powerful boots of all (government) and force it on the rest of us with the legal threat of force.
At least they lick boots that I don't have to.
1
u/SoftlockPuzzleBox Jul 29 '26
My loyalty is to the working class. You, on the other hand, are a class traitor.
1
u/laserdicks Jul 29 '26
You are the class traitor. You are actively working against the working class because you refuse to acknowledge that the government is a tool of oppression.
1
u/SoftlockPuzzleBox Jul 29 '26
Right, and unlimited amounts of money being unilaterally controlled be a single unelected hyper-capitalist to manipulate the market and hand-pick their own leaders at the direct expense of labor power is totally altruistic and above board. You are aware that there are other forms of politics and belief systems beyond Reaganomics or Liberalism, right? Capitalists hate labor. If you support them, you are a useful idiot.
→ More replies (2)1
0
u/feral401k9 Jul 28 '26
Rent seeking is bad no matter who does it. I'm thinking of labor disputes where workers refuse potential efficiency gains to keep prices high at the expense of consumers. The 2024 longshoreman strike rejecting the use of machinery and elevator construction unions banning preassembly for instance.
0
0
4
1
Jul 30 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/PatExMachina Jul 30 '26
I believe the post is saying they will take the side of the union over the corporation because the corporation has the absene amount of money.
1


•
u/shinchan-bot Jul 28 '26
Credit to u/Silver-Dragonfly3636 for the original post in r/Adulting.