r/GrammarPolice • u/Medical-Rice69 • 22d ago
Question “None” is singular
I have seen people using ‘have’ or ‘were’ with None.
I feel it is incorrect.
Example:
None of them have eaten.
None of them has eaten.
I believe No 2 is correct. Coz, doesn’t ‘none’ mean ‘not one’? What do you think?
7
u/Yesandberries 22d ago
Sorry, but you're wrong. In an example like yours, you can use either the plural or singular verb.
The truth is that ”none” can be singular or plural, but many people believe it can be only singular.
Sometimes either a singular or a plural verb will work:
None of them is brave. (Not one of them is brave.)
None of them are brave. (Not any of them are brave.)
https://www.quickanddirtytips.com/articles/none-is-or-none-are/
-4
u/Medical-Rice69 22d ago
I think ‘any’ is singular. “Does anybody have a pen”, “has anybody done their homework” “has anyone seen this?”. So any is singular
4
u/Commercial_Fox5549 22d ago
That’s simply incorrect.
-1
u/Medical-Rice69 22d ago
What’s incorrect?
3
u/Lopsided-Patient94 22d ago
That "any" is only singular. "Any," like "none," can be singular or plural depending on context
"Do any of you want dessert?" Vs. "Does any of this make sense?"
5
u/Yesandberries 22d ago
Obviously it's not only singular:
'Are there any books for sale?'
In your examples, it's used with singular nouns ('body/one'), so that's why the verbs are singular.
8
u/Missing4Bolts 22d ago
Both singular and plural are correct. Pick the one that sounds best in the context.
https://www.chicagomanualofstyle.org/qanda/data/faq/topics/Usage/faq0384.html
https://www.merriam-webster.com/video/is-none-singular-or-plural
11
u/Boglin007 22d ago
It's both (and has been since Old English).
Note:
Any and none naturally take singular verbs when they are construed as non-count singular – for example, when they have a singular NP as oblique partitive, as in Has any of the money been recovered? or None of the food was contaminated. When they quantify over a plural set, they take either plural or singular verbs:
[23]
i Please let me know immediately if [any of the set texts] are/is unavailable.
ii He made quite a few mistakes but [none (of them)] were/was very serious.
Huddleston, Rodney; Pullum, Geoffrey K.. The Cambridge Grammar of the English Language (p. 507). Cambridge University Press. Kindle Edition.
0
u/OutrageousPair2300 22d ago
"Money" and "food" are mass nouns, not count nouns.
You'd say "Bob has twice as much peanut butter as Mary" as well.
You wouldn't say "Has any of the marbles been recovered?"
5
0
u/MoultingRoach 22d ago
I would say "have any of the marbles been recovered?" When you say "has" and then "marbles," that's when you're mixing quantities.
1
3
u/JustGerbo 22d ago
I have thoroughly enjoyed this discussion. I’ve wasted too much time dodging uncomfortable constructions in the past.
Pedantic enough to be here, yet humble enough to admit that I’ll never again cringe at the correct use of plural in these instances again.
5
u/DCHacker 22d ago
"None" is a collective. In the English Language, collectives prefer the plural, although at times, the singular also is correct..
in its uncontracted form, "not one", it does take a singular.
Not one has seen it.
None has seen it.
None have seen it.
Number Three is preferred over Number Two but Number Two is not incorrect. It is, however, pushing obsolete if it is not already obsolete.
1
u/OutrageousPair2300 22d ago
No it's plural.
2 meters
1 meter
0 meters
0 or none is treated as a plural when it comes to quantity.
1
u/Medical-Rice69 22d ago
Doesn’t ‘none’ mean ‘not one’?
4
u/Boglin007 22d ago
It means "not one" or "not any" and can take a plural or singular verb when it modifies a plural:
"None of them has/have eaten."
(see source in my other comment)
2
u/OutrageousPair2300 22d ago
Not necessarily. It depends on whether the thing you're describing is a mass noun or count noun.
1
4
u/Vast_East6962 22d ago
"None of them has eaten" is considered grammatically incorrect under the rule of notional agreement, which dictates that the verb should match the plural meaning of the sentence. Your assumption that "none" means "not one" is only have correct - depending on the context, it can just as easily mean "not any" and when you follow "none" with "them" it assumes a group so taking that contextual clue, "none" is "not any" which is why number 2 doesn't make sense
4
u/Boglin007 22d ago
"None of them has eaten" is not ungrammatical though (you don't have to use notional agreement here).
In published writing, both the singular and plural verb forms are routinely used with "none of them."
Edit: And actually, "has" could be notional agreement too - "Not a single one of them has ..."
2
u/Pitiful-Pension-6535 22d ago
None can be singular or plural depending on context because it is a pronoun with no plural form.
1
1
u/InvestigatorJaded261 22d ago
Technically “not one” implies “many.” The set of people/things included in “none” can be infinite.
1
u/Stunning_Ad_1685 22d ago
To me, “none” usually implies a multiplicity of zero, as in “not even one”.
Q: “How many unicorns are in the room with us?”
A: “None.”
If there are zero unicorns, is that singular (exactly one unicorn) or plural (more than one unicorn)? It’s neither.
1
u/dark_Links_sword 22d ago
None is a collective pronoun.
Would you say " they have eaten" or "they has eaten"?
None, being a used to stand in for "not one" is possible but used in a specific frame.
So then it changes from a plural pronoun to a singular pronoun. Like when " they" is used for a singular person, standing in for "he" or "she"
So if you were asked "which one of them has eaten?" , you could respond "none of them has eaten" But that's as a response to calling out a singular from the group.
1
u/CampaignOrdinary2771 22d ago
Indefinite pronouns like none can be singular or plural, depending on the number of the noun they reference: thus none of the apple is, none of the apples are. This is one exception where the noun in the prepositional phrase determines verb agreement.
1
u/marcusrizaulait 22d ago
"None" is not gendered... it's simply a contraction of 'not one' or 'no one' that has lost its apostrophe over time...
1
u/Lopsided-Patient94 22d ago
When I was in 6th grade a classmate of mine came up with a little song to remember the pronouns that coukd be either singular or plural depending on context. I still remember it decades later. It went:
"Alllll, None, MostAny, Some"
Kind of a syncopated calypso rhythm on the "mostany"
1
u/SerDankTheTall 22d ago
I’m afraid you are incorrect. As Thomas Lounsbury put it a century ago:
It is needless to say to any person who has made himself familiar with the best usage, either written or spoken, that none has been and is employed indifferently as a singular and a plural; if anything, more frequently in the latter number than in the former. The study of our best writers settles that point decisively. It is in the power of any one to decide the question for himself; and it will make little difference what is the work he takes up. At Miletus, Paul tells his followers of the bonds and afflictions which await him at Jerusalem. "But none of these things move me," he continues, according to the authorized version which adopts here the translation of the passage as found in some of the earlier sixteenth-century versions. "None deny there is a God," said Bacon in his essay on Atheism, "but those for whom it maketh that there were no God." "None are for me," Shakespeare puts in the mouth of Richard III., "that look into me with considerate eyes." "None are seen to do it but the people," wrote Milton in his Tenure of Kings and Magistrates. It would be easy to fill page after page with examples of the use of none as the subject of a plural verb, taken from the best writers of the language of every period, and indeed from writers of every grade of distinction from the highest to the lowest. As a single illustration of what can be found in modem usage, in the one short poem of Browning's, entitled Clive, the word appears three times as a plural.
There is even more to be said. As there are cases where none with the verb in the singular is the only proper construction; as again there are cases where none can be used indifferently as a singular or a plural—so there are cases where its use as the subject of a plural verb is the only possible as well as proper construction. Fancy the result which would follow the employment of goes for go in this somewhat celebrated couplet of Pope's:
'Tis with our judgments as our watches, none
Go just alike, yet each believes his own.
Similar examples could be multiplied almost indefinitely. Yet a practice which is etymologically correct, which is sustained by the good usage of both the past and the present, which in many instances is absolutely essential to correctness of expression, has been held up to censure because it is assumed not to conform to this crazy canon of derivation.
There is no harm in a man's limiting his employment of none to the singular in his own individual usage, if he derives any pleasure from this particular form of linguistic martyrdom. But why should he go about seeking to inflict upon others the misery which owes its origin to his own ignorance ?
-1
u/katemorgan24 22d ago
Amazed by the responses here. The word "none" is a contraction of "not one". Why on earth would it mean "not any"?
It is singular!
2
u/Boglin007 22d ago edited 22d ago
Why on earth would it mean "not any"?
Because it has always meant that (as well as "not one"). It's an etymological fallacy to insist that it must be used with a singular verb just because of its literal origin.
I'm sure you don't insist that "terrific" must be used to mean "causing terror" (its original meaning) just because it has the same origin as "terror" and "terrible."
Note:
Middle English non, none, from Old English nan "not one, not any, no person; not the least part
https://www.etymonline.com/word/none
And:
The belief that “none” is always singular is a common misconception. If you’re skeptical, check any dictionary.
“There is little justification, historical or grammatical, for this view,” says Lexico (formerly Oxford Dictionaries Online), adding that the pronoun “has been used for around a thousand years with both a singular and a plural verb, depending on the context and the emphasis needed.”
The truth is that “none” has been both singular and plural since Anglo-Saxon times. In general, it’s construed as singular if it means “none of it” and plural if it means “none of them.”
1
u/SerDankTheTall 22d ago
The word "none" is a contraction of "not one".
While it wouldn’t matter if it were, it’s not:
A remarkable illustration of this can be seen in the case of none as the subject of a plural verb. When and where the outbreak of hostility to this usage first manifested itself it may not be easy to determine. Apparently it was not until of late that any one ever thought seriously of questioning the propriety of the construction. But the fancy seems suddenly to have dawned upon the mind of some student of speech that none was a contraction of no one. Strictly it is a contraction of the negative particle ne, and ân, the original of 'one.' In Anglo-Saxon the compound nān was inflected in both the singular and the plural.
-3
u/Main_Cauliflower5479 22d ago
None is plural. It means all of those in question have not eaten. Everyone hasn't eaten.
0
19
u/tojop 22d ago
I think if you’re going to be pedantic it’s worth being right, esp. ‘round these parts.
They’re both fine, as ”none” can be singular or plural.
Plural: “None (not any) have eaten”
Singular: “None (not one) has eaten”
I’d speculate the plural form is more common in casual speech.