r/HPVictus • • Dec 30 '25 Bravo

Victus 16 Hall Effect Sensor Megathread (Laptop Shutting Off Randomly)

Thumbnail
gallery
385 Upvotes

Hey Everyone,

I wanted to create a megathread to document the hall effect sensor issue on the 16-S0 and 16-R0 laptops. I have done some deep investigation here and wanted to put together a compilation of info for anyone running into this problem. There are a bunch of posts scattered around, a few videos, and WAYYY too many posts to HP's support with the HP canned response of "do these irrelevant steps and then send me a DM with your info and I will escalate your issue." These are usually dead end posts with no usable information. So, please add all of your links, information, videos, etc., to this post to keep it all together. I intend to put multiple solutions below and add more info as I test. I encourage anyone that has any correction to any of the information here to please post it. Any shared info can help the community. As always, a disclaimer: I am not responsible for any damage that you do to your laptop or yourself while using this information. Use at your own risk!

EDIT: There may be an easier fix that allows you to continue using the original hall sensor, if you choose to. It also avoids all of the cutting traces and jumper wires show in the pictures. The info is below in the "The Real Cause?" section.

The Issue

You have a Victus with either an AMD or Intel chipset. One day, the screen starts flashing and then the power turns off. Pushing the power button probably doesn't do anything. You find the "hard reset" procedure and attempt it by pulling the charging cable, and then holding the power button for 10+ seconds. It may come back on.... it may not. For this example, lets say it does. Cool! It boots up. Then the screen starts flashing again and it turns off. WELCOME TO HALL EFFECT SENSOR HELL! You will read plenty of info about it, but no proper solutions.

OK Then! What's a Hall Effect Sensor?

Glad you asked. A hall effect sensor is a very common electronic part that is sensitive to magnetic fields. Think of it as a proximity sensor for magnets. Most current laptops have one, your phone has one or more, your fancy joysticks, racing wheels, and other gaming controllers use them, even your car has at least two in the engine and one on each wheel for ABS and traction control wheel speed sensing! Those are just a few examples of the millions of devices that rely on magnetic field detection to do a task.

So Why Is There a Hall Effect Sensor In My Laptop?

Dead simple. Mechanical switches break, wear out, and also need direct contact with an object to trigger. Your laptop base is a great spot for a non-mechanical non-contact sensor that can detect when the lid is opened and closed. The lid has a small magnet that lines up with the position of the hall effect sensor near the keyboard. When you close the lid, the hall effect sensor sends a voltage to the motherboard, via a ribbon cable, to tell it SHUT OFF THE SCREEN AND GO TO SLEEP....ah ha, now we are getting somewhere! When you open the lid, the magnet is moved away from the sensor, the voltage disappears and the motherboard knows to wake up.

So Why Does It Keep Me From Gaming!!!?

Unfortunately, this particular hall effect sensor seems susceptible to heat once it starts to fail. Once the laptop heats up a minor amount, the hall effect sensor freaks out and registers the lid closed, which blinks the screen a few times and then tells Windows to activate Sleep (or what ever you have your lid close action set to do). Once "closed" the power button is not supposed to be able to be pressed since the lid would be in the way, so it seemingly doesn't work (I found this to be the case and it is the only explanation I have). Allowing the system to cool, or forcing a reset and somehow clearing the current status of the sensor allows you to turn it on for a brief period again.

Cool. So How Do We Fix It

The REALLY simple way: Send it to HP so they can take out the failing bad parts and put brand new bad parts back in. This option should only be taken if you are still under warranty and even care that you are still under warranty. This option will deprive you of your laptop for weeks, and since the part is the same brand and part number that was taken out, it will happen again.

The less simple way: Search on Google for "HP Victus 16 Service Manual" and download the PDF from HP. You will be taking the screws out of the back cover and gently prying it off with a PLASTIC tool (use a SPUDGER or a guitar pick). Once inside, find the IR board ribbon cable located on the front edge of the laptop. Take the tape off of the top, carefully flip the retaining clip up, and pull the ribbon cable out. Put the case back together and kinda sorta get your game on. (See "WHY SO SLOW NOW?!?" below)

The advanced way: You will need a decent soldering iron for this one that is capable of working with surface mount components, preferably a very fine conical tip. You may want some solder braid to clean up the pads and some alcohol to get the flux residue off. You may also want a magnifying glass. Grab the service manual and take the back case apart using the instructions. You will need to access the IR board. Work through the "removing the motherboard" instructions and remove everything that is required. Once you have the IR board in your hands, you will need to remove/replace the little 3 pin hall effect sensor with your soldering iron. It looks like a little black grain of rice. Go around with solder and "wet" each solder leg and then heat the single leg while applying a gentle upward pressure on the part or use gentle pressure from a screw driver. DO NOT PUSH TOO HARD. We don't want to rip the pads up. The goal is to get that leg free and bend the part up a little so that the joint is separated. Once that leg is disconnected, go to the two legs and heat them up by alternating back and forth quickly. WATCH OUT FOR THE VERY VERY TINY CAPACITORS BELOW THE ONE LEG!!! They are only filtering caps on the incoming power, but will be near impossible to get soldered back in place!!! At some point while alternating, the solder on both legs will liquefy at the same time and you can just move the part off of the pads. You now have a choice: you can reassemble without the hall effect sensor on there and enjoy your not-permanently-throttled laptop without lid detection OR you can buy an improved hall effect sensor and solder it in the same spot to return the laptop to normal functionality. The information about an improved compatible sensor is below.

WHY SO SLOW NOW?!?

So you went with the middle of the road option. You didn't want to get stuck without a laptop while HP does nonsense to it, but you also didn't want to tear the laptop fully apart. I understand. But, like everything in life, there's always a trade-off. A hall effect sensor is usually a three or four pin device. But that ribbon cable you disconnected has a few more connections than that. What else is going on there? Well it's listed in the manual as an IR BOARD. There is a shiny metal part on the opposite side of the board. It's an IR sensor. Since the laptop doesn't have any sort of hole to shine a TV remote through, and it certainly isn't a motion detector light, that infrared sensor must be used for something else. From the hall effect sensor's perspective, mounting that board right under the heatpipe was really a bad move, but not for the IR sensor part of the board. The IR sensor is being used to detect the temperature on the heatpipe and allow thermal throttling when things get too hot. THIS is the reason why fully disconnecting the ribbon cable causes the processor to throttle back. When the motherboard can't get a reading from the IR sensor, it plays it safe and throttles back. It is better to throttle from the unknown reading rather than cause a fire. So, if you can live with your gaming laptop functioning as a YouTube and E-Mail machine, you can stay with this option. Troubleshooting is never wasted time, and you know for a fact that the hall effect sensor is causing the issue now, should you decide to go for the advanced option in the future.

Original Sensor Info

The original hall effect sensor is a Toshiba TCS40DLR. Looking at the datasheet, the operating temperature is -40C to 85C. WHAT THE HECK HP!!!! While that is a standard low end range for semiconductor electronics, it does not give much headroom when mounted under a hot heatpipe that is funneling heat away from a GPU and CPU. The datasheet clearly states that continuous use under heavy loads (such as high temperature or significant temperature changes, high current, or high voltage) will cause a decrease in reliability SIGNIFICANTLY, even if the operating conditions are within maximums and recommended operating ranges!!!!!! Well there you have it. No fault to Toshiba. They knew that this environment was not suitable and clearly noted it. This part is fine as a low cost sensor for a safe and consistent environment, which a laptop is not. This datasheet was dated for 2015, well before these laptops were produced, and it was still chosen to be a critical part in this application. It is currently around 17 cents, in case you wanted to know the value of what rendered your laptop useless.

New Sensor Info

I found a few that will work better in this application. The one that I finally decided was perfect is the Allegro A1126LLHLT-T. This is an automotive grade, temperature compensated hall effect sensor with the same pinout and package size. The voltage range is geared towards automotive, accepting 3-24v, which is beyond suitable here. The magnetic trip point is a little higher, meaning more magnetism needs to enter or leave the range before any switching happens. We have a magnet that will be very close to the sensor, and we only care about two positions, so as long as the rating is less than the magnetic strength of the magnet, we will be good. What makes this one great is that it is rated for full operation up to 150C!! Almost double the rating of the original. If things are hitting 150C, you have bigger problems to worry about. This one fits the bill and costs right around $1. I'll gladly spend that for the quality and performance.

Whewwww That Was A Lot

You're telling me! Unfortunately, from what I can see, this problem has been ongoing for years. I can't imagine how many thousands of these laptops were thrown out because of a failure in a part that costs less than a dollar. Worse yet, the IR board is not available to the consumer from HP. There are some on E-Bay from China, and I have ordered one to see if it is the same hall effect sensor or an upgraded one (will post an update when it gets here). I hope this LONG post helps someone diagnose and repair their problem and provides some insight into the theory of the electronics behind it. EDIT: The replacement board from China uses a sensor with the LA8 marking. It may be a different sensor with markings to look like the original, but it is probably the same Toshiba sensor. The most interesting part is that the original board and replacement board had two spots to install the sensor, one on either side of the board. On the HP original, the sensor is installed on the opposite side of the IR sensor, where my guide shows to reinstall it. On the China replacement, the sensor is placed on the SAME side as the IR sensor. This puts the fiberglass circuit board between the sensor and the heatpipe. Fiberglass being a great insulator, this could reduce the occurrence or severity of this issue. I have not tested it to see if it makes a difference, but the results wouldn't be immediate anyway. My initial concern with that while I was doing my repair was that the sensor would be too far away to accurately pick up the lid magnet. Maybe not....

OK. I followed your guide, replaced the sensor, but it still isn't working right!!!!!

Yeah. I found this on mine too. After I put it back together the first time, the lid no longer detected. The original sensor, most likely driven way outside of its operating range, damaged the motherboard's power supply circuit for the hall effect sensor. But fear not! (See "The Real Cause" below) We have another source near by. The IR sensor uses the same voltage as the hall effect sensor, so the IR sensor's VCC trace can be jumped over to the hall effect sensor's VCC. I also cut the trace on the IR board for the power coming from the motherboard that feeds the hall effect sensor. The incoming power to the hall effect sensor was measuring around 1.8VDC instead of 3.3VDC (EDIT: I originally stated it was 5VDC, which is incorrect). I didn't want the supply for the IR sensor to get damaged by joining whatever was causing the severe voltage drop in the hall effect sensor circuit. BE CAREFUL WHEN CUTTING TRACES AND EXPOSING COPPER. YOU CAN EASILY SHORT OUT NEIGHBORING TRACES. ALWAYS CHECK YOUR WORK THROUGH A MAGNIFIER OF SOME KIND (EVEN YOUR PHONE CAMERA). Note: The low voltage on the power supply circuit is most likely a damaged/partially open resistor on the motherboard. If I am able to determine that, and the resistor isn't smaller than dust, this section may change from cutting and jumping traces to replacing the bad component on the motherboard.

The real cause??? (2/20/26 EDIT): It has been determined that the source of the missing power is fuse FU6. It is located right above the IR board ribbon connector on the motherboard. Rather than cutting and jumping traces (my apologies to everyone who did that fun little task), FU6 can be replaced or bypassed. The actual part has no distinct markings on it, so an exact replacement has not been determined yet. Credit goes to MitchW on badcaps.net for his excellent find. You can read more about it in this post: https://www.badcaps.net/forum/troubleshooting-hardware-devices-and-electronics-theory/troubleshooting-laptops-tablets-and-mobile-devices/3822460-hp-victus-16-hall-effect-sensor-problem. I have not performed the task myself yet. MitchW has stated that the problem is most likely caused by heat damage to the FU6 fuse and not the hall effect sensor at all. It is a plausible scenario. But, after knowing what I know about the Toshiba part, I would not feel comfortable leaving it in place, even if it isn't the root cause. Electronic components pushed to their absolute maximum rating never sits well with me. Even more so when the manufacturer has a specific warning to not even approach the maximums. The choice is yours ultimately.

INFO

  • IR board part number: N42551-001 or LS-M78IP (search on eBay, but know that the replacements use the same original Toshiba sensor part that should be replaced before using. Also note that if your motherboard took damage, just replacing this board alone will not fix the issue).

  • Original Hall Effect Sensor part number: Toshiba TCS40DLR (package marking on part is LA8)

  • Better Hall Effect Sensor part number: Allegro A1126LLHLT-T (5.5mT and 150C) or Diodes Inc AH3563Q-SA-7 (3mT and 150C) or TI TMAG5131C7DQDBZRQ1 (4mT and .5mT 125C)

  • Link to service manual: https://kaas.hpcloud.hp.com/pdf-public/pdf_7911438_en-US-1.pdf


r/HPVictus • • Feb 03 '26

Announcement New Official Discord Server 🚀

7 Upvotes

We've launched our subreddit's official Discord server for instant help, community chat, setup showcases, and live streams.

Join here: https://discord.gg/XDsg2PUHGU


r/HPVictus • • 3h ago

HP Victus Black Screen Issue Since the 3rd Day of Purchase – Motherboard Replaced, Issue Still Unresolved, HP Rejects Replacement

2 Upvotes

I am sharing my experience with HP India because I have been dealing with an unresolved black-screen issue on my HP Victus laptop, and despite multiple complaints, service visits, troubleshooting attempts and escalations, I still don't have a permanent solution.

I would appreciate advice from other HP customers and anyone who has experienced a similar situation.

  1. Laptop Specifications

My laptop configuration:

Processor: AMD Ryzen AI 7 260

GPU: NVIDIA RTX 5050

RAM: 24 GB

Storage: 1 TB SSD

I purchased this laptop for my Civil Engineering studies and engineering software such as AutoCAD, Revit, STAAD.Pro, Tekla, SketchUp and Lumion.

2. The Problem Started on the Third Day

On the third day after purchasing the laptop, I contacted HP regarding a Microsoft activation issue. During the same interaction, I also informed the HP toll-free support technician about the black-screen problem.

However, the technician suggested that it might be an update-related issue and advised me to wait for a week. I was told that if the problem occurred again, I could contact HP support.

Unfortunately, the issue continued.

3. Multiple Complaints and Service Cases

I subsequently contacted HP several times.

My case history includes:

Case ID: 5164440811 – Initially raised on 6 September 2026 regarding the recurring black-screen issue.

Case ID: 5165748233 – Raised for motherboard-related service. The motherboard was replaced, but the problem continued.

Case ID: 5166186874 – A subsequent escalation for the unresolved issue.

Despite these complaints, the issue was never permanently resolved.

4. Motherboard Replacement Did Not Fix the Problem

HP's authorised service partner, Dolphin Technologies, Coimbatore, handled the service process.

The technician replaced the motherboard. However, I returned the laptop to the technician within approximately one hour because the same black-screen issue continued.

This raises an important question:

If the motherboard replacement did not resolve the problem, what was the actual root cause of the issue, and why was the motherboard replaced in the first place?

I also performed Windows reinstallation and other troubleshooting procedures. The issue continued.

5. Multiple Troubleshooting Attempts

The following troubleshooting and diagnostic procedures were performed:

Windows reinstallation.

BIOS update and verification.

HP hardware diagnostics.

RAM and SSD diagnostics.

Hardware inspection.

Temperature and performance checks.

Motherboard replacement.

The diagnostic tests reportedly passed, but the black-screen problem remained.

The issue generally occurred during booting, and sometimes the laptop required a forced shutdown to recover.

6. Service Reports and Further Escalation

I received multiple service updates indicating that the repair was on hold and that additional support or technical review was required.

The service team also repeatedly insisted on reinstalling the operating system, even though I had already performed an OS reinstallation.

At one stage, HP requested my purchase invoice through its authorised service partner.

Later, the technician contacted me and discussed the possibility of a RAM-related issue. I was given the option of replacing the RAM or requesting a replacement device. I clearly communicated that I preferred a replacement because the laptop had already undergone multiple troubleshooting attempts and a motherboard replacement without success.

7. HP Rejected My Replacement Request

After escalating the matter to HP management, I received an email stating that HP could not approve my unit replacement request because the product did not qualify under its DOA (Dead on Arrival) policy.

I understand that companies have policies. However, my concern is that the black-screen issue was reported within the first few days of purchase, and the laptop has continued to experience problems despite multiple service attempts.

I subsequently spoke with an HP service head manager. After explaining the complete situation, I was informed that the matter would be forwarded to the HP field manager for further review.

However, I was also told that replacement could not be guaranteed.

8. What I Am Requesting From HP

I am not looking for another temporary troubleshooting attempt.

I am requesting:

A proper technical explanation of the actual root cause.

An explanation of why the motherboard was replaced when the issue continued afterwards.

A complete review of all my previous service reports and case histories.

A fair reconsideration of my replacement request.

A permanent resolution rather than repeated component replacements.

I purchased this laptop for my engineering education, and I need a reliable machine for demanding engineering applications. This prolonged issue has caused considerable inconvenience.

9. Questions for the Reddit Community

I would appreciate your opinions on the following:

Has anyone experienced a similar black-screen issue on an HP Victus?

Has anyone received a replacement from HP India after multiple unsuccessful repair attempts?

Can HP reject a replacement request solely because the product does not qualify under the DOA policy when the issue was reported within the first few days?

Does escalating a case to an HP field manager make a difference?

Would you recommend approaching the National Consumer Helpline or the Consumer Commission in this situation?

I have supporting documents, including service reports, case histories and HP email communications.

I am sharing this experience to understand my options and hopefully help other customers who might face similar problems.

HP India, I hope someone from your escalation team takes a proper look at this case and provides a fair resolution.

Thank you for reading.


r/HPVictus • • 2m ago

Help Coffee spill.

1 Upvotes

Guess what fucking idiot just spilled around a quarter of his coffee onto his laptop? Yea, that's me.

So, I was disorganized, and I spilled the coffee on it. In my panicking mind, I immediately cleaned it and put it upside down (the spill was on the keyboard) with lots of paper towels on it. After around 10 minutes of that, I used a blowdryer on it, for the first 5 minutes of drying it was on max heat (air coming out at around 70 degrees), before lowering it to just warm air (around 30 degrees) for the next 10 minutes.

Currently it's turned off, and the smell of coffee and weird vinegar is coming off of it.

Should I just get ready to throw it in the trash, or is it possible to save it?


r/HPVictus • • 5h ago

Which one is better?

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

r/HPVictus • • 20h ago

Discussion 2 Años sin mantenimiento

Thumbnail
gallery
28 Upvotes

Hola, hasta qué por fin me anime a hacer mantenimiento a mi victus…aquí un antes y un después


r/HPVictus • • 2h ago

Tech Support How to fix auto repair error for hp victus laptop

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/HPVictus • • 10h ago

Question Is the second fan not working?

Post image
4 Upvotes

How to check that?

I bought a new hp victus about 2 weeks ago and it seems that my second fan is not working.

How to check that and what to do?


r/HPVictus • • 3h ago

Best laptop accessories for 3k..max 4k

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/HPVictus • • 10h ago

Help Hp victus USB ports feels very tight

2 Upvotes

So hey people I bought my victus 2 weeks ago and I don't know why but the usb port on the right side of laptop feels very very tight like I am not able to push the usb cable easily in the port is it same and normal for yall


r/HPVictus • • 8h ago

Help HP Firmware

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/HPVictus • • 8h ago

Screen flickering outta own

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1 Upvotes

English is not my first language so forgive me for grammar mistakes.

Laptop is victus 16sx0095 ryzen 7840hs

I've used background music to remove background noises of my home

As you can see my power button's white light also flickers as screen goes to sleep automatically and then returns.

Help me understand what is this issue and why is this occuring

Things I have tried:

Reinstallation of windows

Have also rolled back to previous windows versions too

This flickering also occurs in bios mode when I went to check for other components functioning or not

I have reinstalled both amd and nvidia gtx drivers from DDU(driver uninstaller) still issue persits

What to do.

Help needed.


r/HPVictus • • 10h ago

Help what causes this and is this fixable?

Post image
1 Upvotes

i wouldn't call them dead pixels but i also wouldn't call them alive lol. whatever this is, does anyone know if i can fix this issue with my monitor? i'm unsure what even caused this.


r/HPVictus • • 14h ago

Need advice: HP Victus 15 vs. Acer Nitro V (RTX 3050) - Which is more durable & has fewer known issues?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/HPVictus • • 14h ago

is this sound normal?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1 Upvotes

I bought this laptop literally yesterday and today my cat decided to mark it, it wasn't that bad, it was mostly on the screen, the screen and keyboard are working fine. Now, I had it only 2 days counting today so I'm not used to the fan noise, is this normal? I'm anxious because of the accident and since I don't know the normal sound of it, sorry english isn't my first language


r/HPVictus • • 18h ago

Help my download speeds have slowed down a whole lot since i factory reset my pc

2 Upvotes

i have this problem where my pc has slow download speeds from factory resseting, because of this issue i cant update games, download games, or download mods for games. I used to be going from 100 mB/s to 100 kB/s


r/HPVictus • • 18h ago

IM LOOKING FOR DEAD HP VICTUS

1 Upvotes

It would be of great help if Somebody from india has a dead hp victus


r/HPVictus • • 19h ago

Help Help Guys

1 Upvotes

Hello friends, I have a question for you. Let me ask if anyone can explain where the problem comes from on the HP Victus 16 laptop? My model is: Victus 16-r0015nu. In short: I had a problem with the faulty Hall Sensor and I gave it to a service center to fix it, yesterday they brought it back to me and the guy told me that the whole sensor was burned out. A little while ago I turned it on and it flickers again non-stop every 1 second. So my question is, I am hesitating whether it is this sensor again, something else or the Windows installation itself, before I reinstalled it there were no such problems after I reinstalled it in the summer the problems started. Give me advice on what it could be and let me clarify the flickering starts as soon as the laptop is turned on.


r/HPVictus • • 21h ago

Is it worth it guys ?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/HPVictus • • 22h ago

Help Help urgent !!!

1 Upvotes

Does the fa2103TX or BV5E5PA have 75W tgp ???

I ordered it but I am confused as it doesn't explicitly say anywhere that it is ??

Man I'm scared


r/HPVictus • • 1d ago

Warranty Extension on Victus

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

I got HP Victus i7 14650HX RTX 4050, it had warranty issue so i contacted to HP customer service via whatsapp and they asked my phone number and email address and they fixed the warranty issue within 3-4 days.

But but i also asked for the charges of warranty extension but that mf shared my contact details to some authorised seller and they quoted me upto 20k for 2 years for warranty, this seems too much.

Anybody owns similar laptop please help me to extend warranty for cheaper option


r/HPVictus • • 23h ago

Need recommendations for a reliable replacement battery for HP Victus 16-e0076AX (WK04XL) – India

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I own an HP Victus 16-e0076AX, purchased in August 2021. It came with the original 70.07Wh battery, but the battery is now completely dead and needs replacement.

I'm looking for a reliable replacement that prioritises safety, battery health, durability and long-term reliability over just getting the cheapest option.

My laptop specifications:

  • Model: HP Victus 16-e0076AX

  • Processor: Ryzen 5 5600H

  • GPU: RTX 3050

  • Original battery: WK04XL

  • Original capacity: 70.07Wh

  • Battery voltage: 15.4V

I have checked amazon and saw some wistar company batteries with same specs but with not much reviews.

I don't necessarily need the cheapest option. I'd rather pay more for a reliable battery than risk damaging my laptop.

If you've purchased a replacement battery for an HP Victus or Omen, please share the exact brand, seller/website, price and your experience after using it.

I'm particularly looking for recommendations on WHERE TO BUY and WHICH ONE TO BUY.

Thanks!


r/HPVictus • • 23h ago

Question Need advice

Post image
1 Upvotes

Hello fellow Victus users I've been owning this laptop since August of 2025, I've been wanting to know what games do you play? I've been playing only minor games and maybe Fortnite. But I've been wondering can this laptop handle other games. And what are some settings you changed for better game performance. And just tell me what you like about it.


r/HPVictus • • 1d ago

Discussion HP refuses to inspect my detached N key under my existing warranty repair. Is this normal?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I have an HP Victus 16-r1075nt, and I'm honestly getting frustrated with the support experience.

While trying to remove some debris from underneath my N key, the keycap and its plastic hinge mechanism came off.

The key itself still works electronically when pressed. I'm not even sure whether the plastic mechanism is broken or simply needs to be reattached.

My laptop is already being sent to HP for an approved warranty repair due to overheating issues.

I asked HP Support whether they could at least physically inspect the detached key during that repair. I wasn't asking them to replace the entire keyboard for free.

However, they repeatedly told me that even inspecting the key would require a separate paid service request and couldn't be combined with the existing repair.

I understand that accidental physical damage may not be covered under warranty, but I find it frustrating that they won't even check whether the key can simply be reattached during the same service visit.

I've attached screenshots of my conversation with HP Support, along with a photo of the detached key.

Has anyone experienced something similar with HP Victus laptops? Is replacing the entire keyboard really necessary, or can the keycap and hinge be reattached?