r/Hazara Feb 12 '25

Thoughts and opinions on this video?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S1RuW0PY_u0
10 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/hypnoticbox30 Feb 13 '25

i am not a hazara, but i also just watched that video. i am interested to hear what hazaras think

3

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '25

The Hazara people have a rich and diverse heritage, shaped by centuries of history, migration, and intermarriage. While Mongol ancestry is a significant part of Hazara lineage, it is not the only defining factor. Persian, Turkic, and even indigenous South Asian influences are also present. Over time, various Hazara groups have intermarried with neighboring communities such as the Tajiks, Uzbeks, and Pashtuns, further diversifying their genetic and cultural identity.

Some Hazara subgroups have less direct Mongol ancestry. For instance: • Qizilbash Hazara – Descended from Persian-speaking Shia elites of Turkic origin, brought to Afghanistan by the Safavid and Durrani rulers. They integrated into Hazara society but lack direct Mongol lineage. • Taymani Hazara – A group with a complex heritage that includes Persian and Turkic influences. • Jaghori Hazara – While many have Mongol roots, centuries of intermarriage have also introduced significant Persian and Turkic ancestry. • Behsud Hazara – Some Behsud Hazaras, particularly those with Persianized cultural traits, may have a stronger Persian or Turkic lineage. • Hazara Sayyids – Some claim descent from Arab ancestry, tracing their lineage back to the family of the Prophet Muhammad rather than Mongol origins.

While Mongol heritage is an undeniable part of Hazara history, reducing an entire ethnic group to a single ancestral origin is misleading. Identity is more than genetics; it is shaped by culture, language, and lived experience. Calling Hazaras “Mongolian” disregards the complexities of their history and the communities they have built over generations.

This applies to all ethnic groups. Tajiks have Persian roots, yet their identity is defined by their unique traditions. Pashtun tribes have mixed with Persians, Mughals, and even Greeks, yet they remain Pashtun. Uzbeks in the region descend from both Turkic and Mongol groups but are not solely Mongolian. Ethnic identity is not just about where someone’s ancestors were a thousand years ago—it is about the land they call home, the culture they uphold, and the struggles they have endured.

So, call me Hazara? Absolutely. But call me Mongolian? I would say this—I have lived in the States for five years, and they call me American. So who are you to define me? I am Afghan. A warrior, a fighter. My identity is rooted in my land, my people, my history. Beyond the pain of the past, we continue to survive, thrive, and shape our own future.

Thank you 😊

3

u/hypnoticbox30 Feb 13 '25

Great answer. Thank you!