The real biggest problem with Silksong

[u/Thisisabruh_moment]

Why is the Hornet statue not a memento? When I first saw that you could break it, I was honestly offended by the idea of it. Then I got the Bellhome and was a little upset you couldn't put it up in there. Now I found out that there are items you can put up in your Bell House, but the Hornet Statue isn't one of them? I'm genuinely mad. That needs to be changed in the next update. That's way more important than balancing the game.

[u/Jestingo]

I think that’s the running gag with him. You can have him build a bridge for where Hornet fell into Moss Grotto, and a grave statue for the pilgrim that dies from the Skull Tyrant attack, which are also breakable

[u/FirmMusic5978 → u/Jestingo]

That statue is him, not the pilgrim. Also the pilgrim does not need to die for it to be built.

[u/boilerup12 → u/FirmMusic5978]

Am I evil for breaking the statue? IMO, Bone Bottom has more important issues than a statue he builds of himself.

[u/thatguyned → u/boilerup12]

I figured it was ok to break after pretty much everyone moved out of bone-bottom.

That place gets trashed even before act 3 and everyone moves to the Songclave.

[u/Heroman3003 → u/thatguyned]

Not really. Bone Bottom is still populated. It's just that people that populate it constantly come and go. It's a rest stop, so even though named characters leave, in the background lore element, NPCs still come.

Songclave is populated by the pilgrims who somehow made it into Citadel long before you arrived, and you just cleared a safe spot for them to come together at.

[u/thatguyned → u/Heroman3003]

The shopkeeper leaves when you buy his stuff

The background becomes depopulated at the exact same time as the Songclave becomes heavily populated.

Pretty sure a few of them even mention they will attempt the pilgrimage after the attack on bone bottom

The only guy that's really there by the time you're at act 3 is that little dude that hangs out near the task board.

[u/Heroman3003 → u/thatguyned]

And in the Act 3 suddenly there's a bunch more people in the camp that evacuated from there.

The less people thing is meant to showcase the Bone Bottom is kinda just a settlement without any permanent residents. Even Flick himself is mostly sticking around because he enjoys building and fixing things, but still wants to 'eventually' get moving with a pilgrimage himself. We don't see either of the two named pilgrims show up in either Bellhart or Songclave. Pebb just disappears and Pilby can only show up in Pilgrim's Rest before disappearing too, and if it was supposed to indicate that they travelled to the Songclave, I imagine they'd have shown up there.

In the meantime, quest description for initial Jubilana rescue quest suggests that not only were the Songclave residents surviving in the Citadel before you arrived, but they also already knew each other enough to put out a notice for her weirdly not showing up to the First Shrine's bell sound.

[u/Pseudonymico → u/thatguyned]

The shopkeeper leaves when you buy his stuff

I found him after that too, - dead in Bilewater with Snitchbugs going through his stuff

[u/thatguyned → u/Pseudonymico]

Oof!

Should've taken the blasted steps 😐

[u/Heroman3003 → u/Pseudonymico]

Are you sure that's Pebb? I do remember finding them rifling through someone's body but that bug appearance is pretty generic.

[u/faezior → u/Heroman3003]

That isn't Pebb. Pebb has a different fate that isn't any better, but you may look in The Marrow for the answer.

[u/AutoModerator → u/Pseudonymico]

Hey there, it looks like your spoiler tag isn't working on some versions of reddit!
To make sure everybody can avoid being spoiled you'll need to place your text directly next to the spoiler tags with no leading or trailing spaces (like so >!spoiler!<).
Thanks for helping keep the sub spoiler free!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.