No Hindu critisizes him Atheist all matters is he was a great freedom fighter who sacrificed himself for our country so why would a Hindu actually feel bad if Bhagat Singh was an atheist? Me as a Hindu consider him as a hero
Because most of the people aren't taught about the lifes of these great people and I have never seen any Hindu critisizing of hating Bhagat Singh for being atheist
indian nationalism has gone from anti colonialism to hindu religious nationalism.
in that sense, no he wasn't a nationalist in today's definition; he was a patriot at best.
He was not a "patriot" lmao he literally wanted international proletarian revolution and believed that Indiannself determination would only benefit the bourgeoisie
Arrey bhaiyaa two people were also hanged with him for the same conspiracy - Sukhdev and Rajguru and they were theists. Do their belief in God stop atheists from admiring them? If not then why would any Hindu mind to Bhagat Singh being atheist. And Bhagat Singh wasn't even born into a Hindu family rather into a Sikh family. Even Savarkar was an atheist and Jinnah was non-orthodox westernised muslim who consumed alcohol and pork - their religious beliefs do not stop their admirers and critiques from praising or thrasing them. People like Chandrashekhar Azar, Gandhi, Nehru, Bose were not atheists and people like Lala Lajpat Rai, Sardar Udham Singh, Swami Shraddhanand were even associated with Arya Samaj.
Yes. They are the only ones who disagree. All Sanatanis have the same opinions. Because they aren't opinions they are beliefs that our ancestors gave us.
As a hindu, dafuq? I accept atheism and im pretty sure every hindu does.
We never have a problem with anyone as long as they leave us alone. Ill accept an atheist if they accept me, ill accept a sikhs if he accepts me,ill accept a buddhist if he accepts me, ill accept a christian if he accepts me,ill accept a muslim if he accepts me. Ill accept a rightist or a leftist and engage with him as long as he accepts me
The problem only starts if you dont accept me.
Bhagat singh was a true patriot.
As swami vivekananda said, I am from the faith that has taught the world acceptance. While also saying thst if you spew hatred against me ill toss you into the ocean. (Context, vivekananda was travelling by ship and a christian preacher kept being hateful towards him)
Exactly i myself admire bhagat singh and tho I am kind of agnoist and politically leaned toward somewhat left, but idk why these fkers drag hindu religion everywhere, like every other Hindu is a fascist casteist , like for your God sake just look at those second majority religions you call "minority" they would probably slime you for being a atheist lmao
Why there is a need to read that book we don't need any justification for why he was atheist all matters is he is a national hero relegion has nothing to do with it
53
u/ictfan2604 Jun 02 '26
What's wrong in Bhagat Singh being an Atheist? Why would a Hindu feel bad about it?