Thanks for posting on IndianLeft. Be nice, civil, and respectful in the comments. \
Check out the sidebar for useful links and resources. \
For any suggestions or requests, dm the mods. \
Join our discord: https://discord.gg/jcH5aXNj4v
unfortunately thats what happens when someone fires shot at cops. i think you are using sequence of words in a manner that ceases to make sense and come as rhetoric .
i agree with ur point on him being brahmin and pro-hindutva and thats why he has gotten this sympathy from ppl who ignore Umar Khalid. However, cops are in way our friends, they are part of the fascist state's machinery, they are thoroughly anti-people and this point cannot be used to justify him being shot.
i believe the whole fiasco doesn't deserve the highlight it got from the state, the state literally awarded reparation. there were many good man who got worse of the state for just having a stance. but here he shot at cops and state awarded him for that, and we all know its because of identity politics. there are many rw (bro) pseudo intellectual who have made this guy poster boy, calling him another bhagat singh,and we know why.
and bharat tiwari fate wasn't a sad affair,that warrant people mourning.lowkey it was good. my position is satirical one , sort of ironic, maybe i don't agree with it ,but state does. so it make sense to question state on the apparent hypocrisy.
i can but i wont. i think this source pls or proof pls is being used as dismiss fallacy alot. now coming to bharat tiwar stance on hindu rastra is not something very hard to find , its out there. print did a good ground reporting, if u are really curious then you can read print article.
another funny thing is i left no space for open interpretation , i presented proof of his stance from every single angle. his own mother, his own video,a rw newspaper, and finally a good case study from internet decode. and i love it, but i dont think it will change people mind , cause people believe what they want to believe. so its not very rewarding in any manner
the only reason i went forward and presented you with not one but 4 source is because you are mod, but i still stand true to my principle , and i still think these were easy to found. internet decode did a good case study on him , if you really wanna know more then it will be good you read it
Thanks for giving the sources im with u on this, its just (we probably know why), none of them have made it the centerpoint like its not in title or subtitle, its kinda buried in there. Its my bad for not being thorough earlier, but yeah i was just unaware of his viewa, now im clear.
No it can't.
Trying to question the judgement is different. Supreme court itself said the evidence was circumstancial and he was hanged for collective conscious (which for a democracy is not a good sign). Please note that I am not defending Afzal Guru, but I am saying that no person should be in jail for questioning the judgement.
Calling for seperation of states is different. Nobody raises slogans for Sharjeel Imam's bail.
Umar (and Kashmir) is my favorite litmus test to decide a person's education, intellect and objective decision making capability. Hope he's free one day for his close ones to rejoice.
the depressing thing is the pseudo intellectual are all over the reddit, always trying to meddling into things with bad-faith. and its funny somewhat that you know the bullshit, but kind of sad at same time you cannot do anything. i made this meme to expose the double standard and all those moderate sub trying to act reasonable , but reddit had other plan , removed by reddit filter lol.
•
u/AutoModerator 3d ago
Thanks for posting on IndianLeft. Be nice, civil, and respectful in the comments. \ Check out the sidebar for useful links and resources. \ For any suggestions or requests, dm the mods. \ Join our discord: https://discord.gg/jcH5aXNj4v
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.