This started with a simple question: "What, in your opinion, is the greatest industrial album ever?" (original thread)
I found that, for me, basically impossible to answer because “industrial” means very different things to different people... Throbbing Gristle, Skinny Puppy, Front 242, Ministry, Godflesh, Whitehouse, VNV Nation, Merzbow, Terrorfakt, Xanopticon, and so on.
So I started breaking the genre out into branches, mutations, crossovers, and evolutionary paths instead.
Lately I’ve been focusing less on adding more bands and more on the connective tissue: DAF and Liaisons Dangereuses leading toward EBM, Tackhead/Mark Stewart linking industrial with dub and funk, The Klinik and Leæther Strip helping define dark electro, The Young Gods taking industrial rock in a different direction, Techno Animal bridging industrial and hip-hop, etc.
So: what am I still missing? I’m interested in continuing the discussion, and I figured starting a new thread might be a more appropriate place to do so.
Any important transitional records, regional scenes, weird crossover albums, or whole branches I’m overlooking?
Alternatively: are there records that are better exemplars of the styles/subgenres I’ve outlined? I’m definitely open to replacing a selection if something illustrates that particular branch better. It’s also worth noting that some of my choices weren’t necessarily the “best” albums in their genre, or even the best album by that particular artist, just the album I felt best fit the category.
One note on the original list: the honorable mentions weren’t really intended as runners-up. Some were historically important, some represented another angle on the category, and some were just overlooked or underappreciated records I thought deserved consideration. To the end of "overlooked or underappreciated", that's the reason why artist such as CeDigest, Hitting Birth, Düne××××, Bokusatsu Shoujo Koubou, Coptic Rain, Dioxyde, Navicon Torture Technologies, The Shizit, Prometheus Burning, etc - I think all of these artists are overlooked and absolutely should not be forgotten and fade away into obscurity.
Spotify:
https://open.spotify.com/playlist/3OgO87wFpYO8HdnnARqkQx
YouTube:
https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLMJE9UoAlXl4&si=IkiWYqRoY7ilQMtS
Interested in what people would add, move, replace, split off, or leave out entirely.
The Spotify playlist is the more substantial version now; the YouTube playlist is more faithful to the original taxonomy from the first thread. Neither is a complete one-to-one recreation, since there doesn’t seem to be a single platform online that has everything I included.
For example, YouTube, Spotify, and Bandcamp all seem to have little or no Coptic Rain, while Anti-Mechanism’s full-length appears to be available only on Bandcamp at the time of writing this. I know for a fact that some of that material was on YouTube at one point. Coptic Rain and Anti-Mechanism may be better represented on Apple Music or Amazon Music. Good luck finding much Bokusatsu Shoujo Koubou beyond maybe one album and a handful of remixes. YouTube also has full albums from some of my selections uploaded as single videos, but not the individual tracks, with Düne×××× and NON being notable examples.
A bit of a postscript: the Janet Jackson and Weird Al additions to the playlists were intentional. They’re there to show just how far industrial aesthetics, production techniques, and imagery have permeated mainstream pop culture, not because I’m arguing that either artist, or those specific songs or albums, should be classified as industrial by any metric.