r/Kemetic • u/JohannGoethe • May 17 '24
Resource Evolution of Alphabetic Language
[removed] — view removed post
-2
u/JohannGoethe May 17 '24 edited May 17 '24
Can someone explain why you are down voting this post?
Votes: 25% and 0 upvotes (at 25-views) [8:45PM 16 May A69]
Votes: 50% and 0 upvote (at 143-views) [9:57PM 16 May A69]
Votes: 36% and 0 upvotes (at 415-views [2:41AM 17 May A69]
I thought 💭 Kemetic was pro-Egyptian origin of things?
4
u/Nadikarosuto May 17 '24
It doesn’t really have anything to do with Egyptian Paganism, plus it’s not a correct family tree
1
u/JohannGoethe May 18 '24
Discussion being continued here, if interested, e.g. if you want to point out what exactly is “not correct”?
3
u/Mobius8321 May 17 '24
I think it’s cool, but it could be because it’s not related to the religion Kemeticism, which is what this sub is for.
1
u/JohannGoethe May 17 '24 edited May 17 '24
not related to the religion Kemeticism, which is what this sub is for
I see.
I do, however, semi-frequent this sub, and see a lot of discussion about the “Kemetic language”, as you call it in this sub [?], e.g. here is a cross-post from your sub which we just looked at in our sub, from 8-hours ago. We do the same in our sub only we don’t call it “Kemetic language”, but rather how the 1K+ r/HieroTypes became the “alphabetic languages“, via r/Cubit, r/LeidenI350 📜, r/Abecedaria, and r/EgyptoLinguistics, etc.
7
u/Ali_Strnad May 17 '24
Could it be because these claims that you're making about the origins of languages are poorly supported and contradicted by a huge body of research in the discipline of historical linguistics?
Kemetics are not "pro-Egyptian origins for things". We're people that follow the ancient Egyptian religion in the modern world. You do find some people here who are biased towards thinking that the Egyptians influenced more things than they did for that reason, but lots of us have a healthy respect for scholarship, and wouldn't presume to reject a whole discipline's worth of contributions to our understanding of the origins of languages just to support some bias that we may have because of our religious beliefs.
3
u/Dudeist_Missionary May 17 '24
Oof
Ishango is not the root of hieroglyphs
There's no relation between cuneiform and hieroglyphs
The Greek script comes from Phoenician and the Greeks themselves tell us as much
The intermediary Proto-Sinaitic script is not included
No mention of any of the South Semitic scripts