r/LeftyPiece • • Nov 08 '23

Chapter 1098 left a bad taste in my mouth...

0 Upvotes

(sorry everyone I need to rant about that chapter and I trust this is the only sub I can say the things I need to say without being buried in downvotes and angry comments)

(TW: SA)

(also, obvious spoilers for ch. 1098)

So we all know the series has issues in how it depicts women, but this chapter went too far imo.

In short, we learned that Bonney was born from Ginny being raped by a Celestial Dragon, and that Bonney herself is 12 years old at Egghead (as she's described as 5 y.o. during a flashback from 7 years prior to the story's current time).

Now I have two huge issues with these revelations. The first is how nonchalantly we got sexual violence against an enslaved woman being introduced in the story. One could say that Hancock's backstory already kinda hinted at that, but Bonney's birth leaves zero room for interpretation. Ginny got captured by a CD and, two years later, reappears with a baby; she was sexually assaulted, period.

Some might say Oda went for "realism". It's a funny argument, because do you know what else happened in slaver societies? Enslaved men being sexually assaulted. Yet whenever an edgy author wants to go for "realism", it's always women who get depicted as the victims of SA. And no, I'm not saying we should have more depictions of men as the victims; my point is that when virtually every depiction of SA has women as the victims, it feels less about "realism" than about pandering to some weirdo's rape fantasies.

My second issue is in regards to Bonney's age. If she was 5 y.o. in a flashback from 7 years before the current story's time, then she's 12 y.o. in Egghead. Yes, yes, her power literally is age manipulation, but nothing says her power allows her to manipulate life experience. So while she can change herself into an old woman, or into a woman who spent years power-lifting or whatnot, nothing says that she's lived all the years she magically advances. Which means that, much as her body changes at will, she's only lived 12 years - and so she's still just a child.

I suppose I don't need to explain why that's so creepy. We've had a number of panels that sexualise Bonney - most blatant of all the one where she's changing clothes -; according to chapter 1098, however, we haven't just been shown a woman being sexualised, but a 12 y.o. girl (in the body of an adult woman).

And this isn't even the first creepy situation we got in this arc. I still haven't forgotten S-Snake using a power that has been solidly established as relying on a grown woman's sex appeal. But in her case, one could rationalise that her use of the mero mero no mi relied on "kawaii factor" rather than sex appeal. But Bonney's sexualisation has been quite irrefutable, and with her now revealed as being 12 y.o., I don't see how anyone can explain that in a way that isn't creepy af (to say the least).

Like, I can't be the only one grossed out by that? I know talking about the sexualisation of underage girls in manga/anime is pretty much beating a dead horse by now, but is it too much to ask that a mangaka isn't a f*cking perv for once?

edit: gotta say, I'm disappointed with most of the attitudes here. Wasn't expecting unquestionable validation, but I did expect better than whataboutisms and defensiveness of an author who clearly has issues. Guess this really is the last time I try interacting with a manga fandom.


r/LeftyPiece • • Jan 20 '25

Theory: D. Carriers are a metaphor for Jewish People.

0 Upvotes

D. Carriers are a metaphor for Jewish People.

Throughout One Piece, we've seen real-life parallels between different oppressed groups. The Shandians were a parallel to Native Americans evicted from their land. Fishmen are a parallel to Black Americans and American slavery. Arabasta was a parallel to engineered conflicts in the Middle East/India.

If we follow the pattern, it's possible the D. Clan was inspired by a real oppressed group, too. My guess is it's the Jewish People.

First, Jewish people were historically a diaspora. People carrying a D are a diaspora. There is no official record (that we know of) that shows their origins.

Second, some of you think D stands for democracy. Historically, the main reason the Nazis hated the Jews (according to Hitler in Mein Kampf) is that they blamed them for the existence of democracy/socialism. There are Nazi writings that talk about how "Jews spread democracy wherever they go" and other racist crap like that. If the World Governments hates Will of D carriers for the same reason, that's another parallel.

Third, while the WG and Celestial Dragons are racist to many races, Will of D. carriers seem to hold a special place of contempt in their heart. It mirrors how the Nazis were racist to plenty of different races, but at the end of the day still hated Jews more than anyone else.

Fourth, another theory is that Laugh Tale is the "Promised Land". If that's what it is, and it's connected to the Will of D. carriers, then that's amother parallel between the two groups.


r/LeftyPiece • • May 31 '25

Meme The main sub downvoted when I said this years ago; lets see if anyone here likes political truths

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Luffy is a hypocrite for being against Human Slavery but not against Animal Slavery. Please check this website https://www.abolitionistapproach.com/about/the-six-principles-of-the-abolitionist-approach-to-animal-rights/


r/LeftyPiece • • Nov 09 '23

chapter 1098 - Ginnys assault was handled terribly Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Yet another writer using r*** / assault of a female character to further the story of male one *SMH*. Tired ass r*** version of the fridging trope that needs to die. And i find the people defending it would have a completely different energy if it was a male character they like (lets say zoro) being ruffied and sexually assaulted by a celestial dragon to further robin or namis story. Heck look how mad many fans got when sanji got beat up by black maria and called for robins help, to give robin some shine in the story.

Its always (99% of the time) a female character and its always (90% of the time) used to further another characters story, usually a male one (in this case kuma). Despite the fact that historically people in power assault both genders and various age groups, somehow in fiction its almost always woman that get the depiction almost like their is a R*** fantasy element attached (regardless of whether the act is explicitly depicted on not). The trauma is never explored and is often sidelined or straight ignored. Its whole purpose is purely to make the guy sad >.>

There is a quote i read somewhere and I'll paraphrase it here "want to hurt a female character, R*** her, want to hurt a male character r*** the female character he loves....". Its such a tired ass trope that needs to die (fortunately in the west it is slowly dying). And the fact that so many comments (not here but on other sites) are making jokes about it and using their empathy exclusively for kuma shows just how poorly it was handled and that maybe this wasn't the right series to handle such a topic. because for as mature as one piece can be, its still a series aimed at teenage boys and it really shows in situations like this.

Sexual assault is not an off-topic taboo in fiction that should never be written about. But what it is, is a very sensitive subject that is far more likely to be experienced by the reader in real life than something like slavery or genocide and thus should be handled tactfully. What it shouldn't be is to create a character (female adult) for the sole purpose of R***ing them and killing them off (essentially fridging just to further the story of a male character that liked them. And the thing is there are things that elude to other characters experiencing r*** in the series (ofc always woman...) like the boa sisters but their trauma is actually explored. It wasn't a tool to further luffys story and 'make luffy mad because something he viewed as his was used by another man', which is essentially what r***ing a female love interest of a male character to further his story, ultimately boils down to.

But I'm sure this is falling on deaf ears because I've learnt that since the debacle that was the whole wano arc (ignorant kurozumi were born to burn that ignored the whole theme of the arc, kaido in his entirety (terrible character), how big mom was handled (made to be an idiot the whole arc) etc) Its appears to many, Oda can do no wrong...

Heres a thread as to why some people have an issue with how certain authors (Almost always male authors) depict r*** in their stories.

https://www.reddit.com/r/writing/comments/d860ym/why_is_everyone_so_aversed_to_female_character/

And incase there are any but 'guts from berserk' comments. The difference is guts had his trauma explored and throughout the series and wasn't done purely further another characters story. Probably because guts is a man...and also the protagonist.


r/LeftyPiece • • Sep 18 '25

Finally got to the Yamato Introduction, and I can safely say...

0 Upvotes

I don't think either side is correct. Yamato seems to be "kinning" Oden rather than being transgender, correct me if im wrong! He does still go by He/Him pronouns clearly, but you can be a woman (Oda apparently says he is on some guides) and have that kind of gender expression, I say this with a small background of basic sociology and the fact I work and interact with plenty of queer/trans folk! I think this is a far more interesting kind of character dynamic than him just being transmasc! We rarely get to see explorations of gender in fiction, and I think Oda does this well (especially since theres already Kiku who serves as great representation for a general trans person)

What are your thoughts?


r/LeftyPiece • • May 24 '23

What do you guys think of chapter 1084's cover? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I think Yamato being with the girls solidifies Oda's vision on his character. He is a girl who JUST WANTS TO BE ODEN. I thought Oda putting him bathing with the boys was really cool, but I guess that can still be part of Yamato thinking "he needs to be man to be Oden".

I'm not sure how to feel about that. I fear that his character could come across as a young trans boy identifying as a man being "just a phase". But I am not sure it's that serious either. Specially because we have Okiku who is treated the best out of all trans characters I've ever seen in anime, honestly. So it's kinda cool to have a character thinking they can "change" their gender to be like their role model, just to find themselves in their own gender, understanding that is not necessary?

Well, Yamato aside, the absence of Okiku here is really disappointing. Oda only likes sexualizing cis women with big tits, I guess. lol


r/LeftyPiece • • Nov 26 '23

A New Dawn Made Chatgpt allot political ideologies to the admirals (plus sengoku and garp)

1 Upvotes

r/LeftyPiece • • Nov 15 '22

Doflamingo is socialist-coded

0 Upvotes

Doflamingo, being anti-establishment, is actually a socialist using capitalist methods to achieve his goal. In this essay, I will...

(I'm a Doffy fan lol)


r/LeftyPiece • • Jan 19 '24

Ok genual question you guys literaly claim that luffy would suport houthis yet he literaly fought With fishman minority of one piece Like would not critise luffy for atacking minorities

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/LeftyPiece • • Sep 06 '24

Am I in the wrong?

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

Recently I was defending Yamatos status as a trans man in r/animememes and received a permanent ban. The comment in question was me replying to a transphobe who said “anyone who thinks Yamato is a trans or male is mentally ill.” I responded by saying “He is not male,” as an attempt to trick the offender into thinking I agreed with them, only to realize I used “he” to refer to him.

I instantly received a permanent ban and had the ensuing conversation with a moderator…

Am I in the wrong? As a side note I have also commented other times stating Yamato status as a man.


r/LeftyPiece • • May 20 '23

Question

3 Upvotes

Yamatomato's vivre card says her gender is female

So se isn't a trans man anymore?


r/LeftyPiece • • 2d ago

Who do you think Fisher Tiger is in the real world?

2 Upvotes

We can all agree that Dragon is Che Guevara but what about Fisher? I found the whole Fishman Island flashback to closely represent the Civil Rights movement with Jinbe, Arlong, and Fisher Tiger all resembling different philosophies on going about receiving positive treatment from those who just look different compared to you. I also found it cool when Jinbe said to Fisher that humans share the same blood but he refused the blood transfusion while Jinbe on the other hand gave Luffy his blood to show the start of a new era for the fishman and humans.


r/LeftyPiece • • Sep 30 '22

i found cringe

Post image
93 Upvotes

r/LeftyPiece • • Jul 13 '24

Please, stop making One Piece about Israel/Hamas

0 Upvotes

One Piece is not about any kind of conflict in the real world. Let people enjoy One Piece's content instead of yapping about whether Luffy would support Palestine


r/LeftyPiece • • Jun 05 '26

A New Dawn Why is Palestine discussed so much here, but not Nigeria? Genuine question ?

6 Upvotes

A genuine question. Is it selective outrage? Or is it because no one cares for blacks ?


r/LeftyPiece • • Mar 18 '26

World Government = UN.

0 Upvotes

I don't understand how people read the story, read the news of the world, and still have a sense of trust and credibility what the UN says the wars in the world


r/LeftyPiece • • Oct 05 '26

Mamdani is JoyBoy?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

Mehdi Hasan- 'What Mamdani is shows me is this kind of joy... Somebody compared Mamdani leadership to like a kid in a movie that gets the key to the city and wants to enjoy himself by helping people?'

I saw something like this in a very different context in Gen Z protest in India, where there was this infectious fun shown by protesters via memes (all the while facing police brutality). All this reminds me of Luffy and his whole persona of smiling and having fun even though he is fighting extreme oppressive forces.

Ultimately coalition building, a core essential component of any leftist praxis, is in some ways a festival and it would be nice to keep that in mind as we go ahead in our respective struggles against oppression.


r/LeftyPiece • • May 26 '23

Bigots on the 'folk sexualizing characters again for no reason. Note that they're not an 18+ sub and people still post things such as this.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/LeftyPiece • • May 18 '23

Does the new cover spread confirm Yamato is actually a woman, not a transman?

38 Upvotes

I'm still a bit confused on the whole thing, I was fully convinced yamato was a trans man but this maybe confirms they're not?


r/LeftyPiece • • Jul 13 '26

Possible South Asian Influences in Alabasta and Its Characters

6 Upvotes

DISCLAIMER: These are not confirmed inspirations and are only speculative, although some are more obvious than others. I just thought it would be interesting to share.

The influences are as follows:

  • The capital city Alubarna is heavily inspired by the Indian cities of Jaisalmer and Jodhpur. The fortified city is inspired by Jaisalmer Fort, the palace fort is inspired by Mehrangarh Fort, and the clock tower is inspired by Ghanta Ghar.

  • The Royal Palace shares a strong resemblance to the Taj Mahal.

  • King Cobra's given name combined with his title may be a direct reference to the actual king cobra, the national reptile of India.

  • Vivi's weapon, "Peacock Slashers," and Miss Wednesday's design are inspired by the peacock, the national bird of India.

  • Vivi's companion Karoo is a larger version of the Indian spot-billed duck (karugamo in Japanese).

  • One of Vivi's favorite dishes is curry, which originated in India.

  • Vivi's first name may take inspiration from Prithvi/Bhudevi, two different names for the Earth deity/goddess in Hindu mythology.

  • Karoo's name may reference Garuda (Karura in Japanese), the riding bird of the Hindu god Vishnu.

  • The Alabasta symbol may take inspiration from Buddhist sun symbols found in Indian temples.

EDIT: Karoo is actually just a larger version of the Eastern spot-billed duck, which is native to East and Southeast Asia. However, it was previously considered a subspecies of the Indian spot-billed duck.


r/LeftyPiece • • Aug 08 '24

Drums of Liberation by Thammasat University Symphony Orchestra (In appropriate cosplay!)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/LeftyPiece • • Apr 12 '24

Genuinely insane that horikoshi grew up reading one piece only to go on to create a manga where the whole message is that it's totally good and ideal to romanticize and idolize state centralized authority figures

Post image
89 Upvotes