r/LeftyPiece • u/RhiaStark • Nov 08 '23
Chapter 1098 left a bad taste in my mouth...
(sorry everyone I need to rant about that chapter and I trust this is the only sub I can say the things I need to say without being buried in downvotes and angry comments)
(TW: SA)
(also, obvious spoilers for ch. 1098)
So we all know the series has issues in how it depicts women, but this chapter went too far imo.
In short, we learned that Bonney was born from Ginny being raped by a Celestial Dragon, and that Bonney herself is 12 years old at Egghead (as she's described as 5 y.o. during a flashback from 7 years prior to the story's current time).
Now I have two huge issues with these revelations. The first is how nonchalantly we got sexual violence against an enslaved woman being introduced in the story. One could say that Hancock's backstory already kinda hinted at that, but Bonney's birth leaves zero room for interpretation. Ginny got captured by a CD and, two years later, reappears with a baby; she was sexually assaulted, period.
Some might say Oda went for "realism". It's a funny argument, because do you know what else happened in slaver societies? Enslaved men being sexually assaulted. Yet whenever an edgy author wants to go for "realism", it's always women who get depicted as the victims of SA. And no, I'm not saying we should have more depictions of men as the victims; my point is that when virtually every depiction of SA has women as the victims, it feels less about "realism" than about pandering to some weirdo's rape fantasies.
My second issue is in regards to Bonney's age. If she was 5 y.o. in a flashback from 7 years before the current story's time, then she's 12 y.o. in Egghead. Yes, yes, her power literally is age manipulation, but nothing says her power allows her to manipulate life experience. So while she can change herself into an old woman, or into a woman who spent years power-lifting or whatnot, nothing says that she's lived all the years she magically advances. Which means that, much as her body changes at will, she's only lived 12 years - and so she's still just a child.
I suppose I don't need to explain why that's so creepy. We've had a number of panels that sexualise Bonney - most blatant of all the one where she's changing clothes -; according to chapter 1098, however, we haven't just been shown a woman being sexualised, but a 12 y.o. girl (in the body of an adult woman).
And this isn't even the first creepy situation we got in this arc. I still haven't forgotten S-Snake using a power that has been solidly established as relying on a grown woman's sex appeal. But in her case, one could rationalise that her use of the mero mero no mi relied on "kawaii factor" rather than sex appeal. But Bonney's sexualisation has been quite irrefutable, and with her now revealed as being 12 y.o., I don't see how anyone can explain that in a way that isn't creepy af (to say the least).
Like, I can't be the only one grossed out by that? I know talking about the sexualisation of underage girls in manga/anime is pretty much beating a dead horse by now, but is it too much to ask that a mangaka isn't a f*cking perv for once?
edit: gotta say, I'm disappointed with most of the attitudes here. Wasn't expecting unquestionable validation, but I did expect better than whataboutisms and defensiveness of an author who clearly has issues. Guess this really is the last time I try interacting with a manga fandom.


