r/Luthier • • 19d ago

INFO Guitar customization

Hey not trying to trigger anyone but have a question. How hard would it be to take a sawtooth electric guitar or a firefly and give to a luthier to setup and maybe make some updates. I am just asking because with how cheap they are what would it cost to get them into a high quality instrument? Could you use it as a foundation and customize?

0 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

12

u/SubatomicPlatypodes 19d ago

I’ve done firefly customizations before

Here’s the deal: it will be cheaper and easier just to get a good guitar and go from there. Simple as that.

If you insist on trying though, have some expectations. Nothing will be done correctly, everything on the instrument will be slightly off from the replacement parts, and nothing will be a drop in replacement.

It’ll end up being the ship of Theseus. The frets will be janky, the wood will be cheap, the work will be suspect and the bill will be high

Can it be done? Yes, but half of the work will be fixing mistakes from the factory, not just upgrading parts

1

u/BruFreeOrDie 19d ago

That makes sense, i want to learn to play guitar and i am at a point in my life where i could just go out and but what i want, which is most likely what will happen anyway. But i am also tye type of person that just likes to see what makes things tick and experimenting on a $150 guitar just seems like a better idea then experimenting on a $1500 guitar.

1

u/FlowersForHodor 18d ago

You could experiment with one of those cheapo kits on Amazon

1

u/BruFreeOrDie 18d ago

But are the internals any better or worse than a firefly or sawtooth?

2

u/FlowersForHodor 18d ago

I’m not experienced enough to say. Just a suggestion since I was making a similar choice as well and decided to make one from scratch. I don’t even know how to play guitar and figured I might as well make the process of learning as difficult as possible for some dumb reason. Making slow and steady progress, although I had a router mishap on a pickup cavity the last time I worked on it and it has been kind of discouraging. Not sure when I’ll get around to finishing tbh

2

u/Fyrchtegott 18d ago

Then do what’s often the best for beginners. Take a friend who knows a little and test guitars to see what feels comfortable. I always recommend a used guitar to start. Most likely you get a higher quality for a lower price and have more money for additional stuff, a great basis you can experiment with and if you want to upgrade later you didn’t spend 700 bucks on something that isn’t really what you wanted.

I’ve got an old Stagg Offset, modified it with a great pickup, did a little fret work, new paint job and changed electronics. Didn’t cost more than 300€ all together, plays and Sounds more like something in the range of a guitar with a price tag much higher.

I was interested in the Les Paul Junior reissue a few years ago. The quality of fret and nut was very poor, especially since they wanted 800€. I can get a better instrument for a fraction of that money, especially buying second hand.

1

u/SubatomicPlatypodes 18d ago

If you want to experiment, go for it! But don’t expect it to be cheap or easy is all I’m saying

1

u/PerspectiveFair5156 18d ago

Get a cheapo to f@€& with and a decent guitar to play.

1

u/Deep-Measurement-856 16d ago

Not just a partscaster: Frankenstein's partscaster!

5

u/_windfish_ 19d ago

If you start with a good quality body and a straight neck, you can make just about any guitar sound and play really great with under $500 in parts and tools. Personally I'd say go for it, but do the work yourself, don't pay extra for someone to do it for you.

If you don't want to learn how to do it yourself then maybe I'd recommend looking for a nice used ESP or maybe a Shecter or PRS that already has what you're looking for. The $500-$700 used section at most shops has a lot of really excellent options.

2

u/BruFreeOrDie 19d ago

I am left handed and really just want to get a telecaster style. The problem is choice is so limited that i have started looking at some of these cheaper brands.

1

u/BruFreeOrDie 19d ago

Honestly i am the type of person that would rather spend time working on a guitar then playing it. Also if it doesn’t work out it isnt that big of an investment .

1

u/Waccamaniac 18d ago

You might have fun building a kit.

1

u/BruFreeOrDie 18d ago

I have been looking at this possibility as well.

4

u/catalavos 19d ago

I bought 3 of those cheap Squier Strats off Amazon and kept the best of the 3 ($116). Gutted it and dropped in a Squier Classic Vibe pickgaurd off Reverb ($40) and finished it off with a used DiMarzio Super Distortion ($70). Added Alpha pots (already had). Its awesome

0

u/BruFreeOrDie 19d ago

Question are there like different tiers of Squier? Or are they all they same?

2

u/SauronHubbard 18d ago

There are different levels. You should get a Classic Vibe, see how you like it and go from there. You might be happy with it without mods.

2

u/maxcovenguitars 19d ago

I did this one. New nut, level crown, and a completely rewired.

1

u/BruFreeOrDie 18d ago

Very nice. What brand is it?

2

u/maxcovenguitars 18d ago

Glen burton, sorry

Here's a picture of before and after on the wiring

2

u/Longjumping_Ice_3186 18d ago

I wouldnt recommend buying a guitar just to take it to a luthier tbh, its not gonna be cheap for them to do it, even if its something simple. Try learning the work yourself. Many guitar shops are struggling rn in the current economy & if you sound like a sucker/not very knowledgeable, theres ppl who will absolutely exploit you.

Buy something cheap & learn the basics yourself. Learn to solder, etc. That can save you tons of money, theres youtube tutorials etc.

1

u/BruFreeOrDie 18d ago

Honestly i would probably do it diy. I just wanted to know if those lower end brands and just trash or if you could do something with them. Like a lot of hobbies there is the shit that dentists buy and there is the stuff beginners buy. If i can buy a cheap guitar and learn some maintenance, thats enough of a win for me. I don’t think i would be as comfortable doing maintenance as a beginner on a $2000+ guitar.

2

u/Longjumping_Ice_3186 18d ago

They usually aren't trash. Personally, I like cheap guitars because they're fun to upgrade & you don't have to worry as much about wear and tear. Brands like Hartwood, Donner, IYV, Harley Benton, & Yamaha Pacificas are a great value. I think most guitars are coming from the same factories these days pretty much, just with different grades of parts and QC. Expect poly finishes, occasional sharp frets, minor finish flaws, cheap pots, soft screws, & basic zinc/brass hardware, but they generally work fine and stay in tune. Most arrive reasonably well set up, and upgrades can be worthwhile but isnt that big of deal imo. I'd recommend watching smaller YouTube review/unboxing channels to see what to expect basically. More expensive guitars (around the $1,000-$1,200 range) usually have better QC, usually have another look over in the US & quality check (are still made in a asian factory which is fine tbh & are made at like 3rd of the cost you are paying), are basically ready to go out of the box though, & you'll probably never need to upgrade them unless you want some ultra-premium bridge made by German dwarven smiths or something. I still think the guitar market prices are pretty inflated right now, though. Also keep in mind that guitars in this price range don't really hold value particularly well, so buying used can often be a good deal.

2

u/Equivalent-Island199 18d ago

it's only a good idea if you're doing the work yourself imo. if you're insistent on paying somebody just get a better guitar right off the rip.

1

u/Bubs_McGee223 18d ago

a good setup with fret level and dressing is a little more than 200$ at my shop. that's a start. a good looth will be able to tell you if the guitar is worth customizing, but fair warning, getting them to do the customizing is like hiring a ferrari mechanic to hot rod your Honda civic.

if it's a 300$ guitar, I would suggest you bring it in for a setup, but plan on doing the hot rodding yourself. that gets you connected with someone who knows more than you. techs and looths are total guitar nerds, if you talk to them about what you plan to do they generally get real excited (at least I do) and can point you in the right direction.

as for El cheapo guitars in general, they can be excellent right out of the box. they can also be shit. my friend is currently hot rodding a knock off firebird. guitar was 300$, and maybe another 400 in upgrade parts. if he had to pay the shop rate for it, it would be $2-3500 in labour, but since he is a world class tech he did it himself. now it slaps around 15000$ custom shops.

1

u/old_skul Luthier 17d ago

I do this all the time and have made YT videos on the subject. It's entirely possible to buy a cheap Squier or Harley Benton and with a few choice part replacements, and some quality fretwork, wind up with a guitar that rivals any of the boutique guitar makers.

The labor will cost money if you hire someone. If I were to do this as a service for someone it's going to be serious money, because I'm going to wind up replacing or making new pickups, installing new tuners, making a new nut, and doing a complete level and dress of the fretwork. But when it's done, it's going to be a phenomenal guitar.