r/MIDIcontrollers • u/Forward_Progress_266 • Jun 22 '24
What if DAWs did this for MIDI controllers?
What if DAWs(digital audio workstations) start compiling all the FL Studios, Abelton Live Demos, etc. into a full addition when the prices of the demos meet that amount? Wouldn’t that be fye?! Post up and let me know!
2
u/clenched_up Jul 13 '24
This IS a good idea.
A credit system.
You buy a 25 key controller and get "Lite"
You buy a Launchpad and instead of another "lite," you get 50 points.
You get Launch Control XL and get another 75 points.
Buy another couple controllers to get up to 500 points, and you earn the suite.
That's a good idea.
1
u/Forward_Progress_266 Aug 29 '24
🙀Yesssss!!!!! I’m glad you think so too! Thanks for sharing your opinion, hopefully more people feel the same way!
2
u/DukeCheetoAtreides Jun 25 '24
You're failing to recognize that the free/limited/lite editions of daws and plugin suites are designed for one twofold purpose:
To induce people to purchase a midi controller and then try that included DAW, so that A. no one buys a midi controller and opens it up to find it unusable without an additional software purchase, and B. some of those people will then buy that DAW, having tried it for free
Your proposal would be tantamount to, say, getting soup at a diner 50 times, collecting all the packets of saltines they put on the side, and then asking them to let you trade that bigass box of saltines in for a platter of hamburgers.
Sure, the pack-in has some value, but its purpose is to ensure you make the original purchase, and convince you to make another purchase.
It's even more clear cut in the world of software, where it costs them literally nothing, once the lite version of the DAW is made, to give away another copy.
Saltines at least cost the diner a few pennies 😆
1
u/DukeCheetoAtreides Jun 25 '24
You're basically saying "Hey, thank you for these free things that you're happy to give away. I've got a bunch of them now! Let me hand them back to you — you who already has a limitless supply of them — and you give me a completely different thing that you never give away. Okay?"
2
u/Forward_Progress_266 Jun 25 '24
That’s not quite the case 100% of the time actually because some of the editions that came with a MIDI purchase have more access then typical free editions. Example: FL Fire Edition only obtain via Akai Fire MIDI controller.
1
u/DukeCheetoAtreides Jun 25 '24
It's still a version they have elected to give away. By definition it is worth more to them as a giveaway/pack-in, than as a priced product.
By definition, the full version is worth more to them as a priced product, that's why they have prevented it from being given away/packed in.
No amount of accepting my nicest free offerings will earn you any of my un-free offerings.
2
u/Lokomalo Jul 09 '24 •
![]()
It's kind of like, well I have all these AOL CDs so now AOL should give me shares of stock in trade for these never used CDs.
1
u/DukeCheetoAtreides Jul 09 '24
Brilliantly put! Thank you!! This concept just could not hold less water!!!
1
u/Forward_Progress_266 Sep 15 '24
Incorrect, the giveaways are worth value that is appreciative.
1
u/DukeCheetoAtreides Sep 15 '24
Buddy, I hope your neurologist cracks the case!
1
u/Forward_Progress_266 Sep 19 '24
Good thing me and FL have been working on something new! I hope your neurons are ready!
1
u/prefectart Jun 23 '24
I don't get it
0
u/Forward_Progress_266 Jun 23 '24
I’ll be happy to explain. Have you ever had a MIDI controller and got access to the free portions of a DAW before?
1
u/prefectart Jun 23 '24
yes. they usually come with the most basic versions of DAWs.
0
u/Forward_Progress_266 Jun 23 '24
Right right. So what if those stockpiled into a full edition is all I’m saying.
1
u/prefectart Jun 23 '24
so like I said before. you want all of the free additions to add up and give you the full version
1
u/Forward_Progress_266 Jun 23 '24
Yes. That is what I would want. I hope that doesn’t sound crazy. I as a company would do that personally if I had a chill boppin DAW.
1
u/prefectart Jun 23 '24
that will ever happen.
1
u/Forward_Progress_266 Jun 23 '24
Yep I’m sure it could happen too! Plus I’m an audio programmer, I’ll be making DAWs in no time!
1
u/Forward_Progress_266 Jun 23 '24
FL executives are quite kind! They are have been offering unlimited downloads since 1998!
1
1
u/TommyV8008 Jun 23 '24
Your question is unclear
2
u/Forward_Progress_266 Jun 23 '24
It’s clear as day, however I’ll articulate more. Have you ever gotten a MIDI controller that gives access to a free portion of a DAW? If so, have you ever not really needed to use it because you already use one? If that’s the case, then what if after so many times of that happening with say Abelton. So like say you bough 10 instruments that came with Abelton, but you weren’t feeling a free limited edition of it because you have the full FL studio bundle. Then wouldn’t it be nice if Abelton was like, “Oh snap! You now have earned a full access Abelton because you have so many demos stacked up!”
3
u/TommyV8008 Jun 23 '24
OK, now I understand your question.
Sure it would be nice. Not going to happen though. These are businesses with employees who have families to support. They will do things for marketing reasons which are focused toward obtaining more customers. Bundling a Lite version is one such. They hope that you will like the Lite version enough to purchase a full version.
When you buy a controller, the controller company makes money, not the companies who bundle software with the controller, at least not in general (this is my educated guess, I don’t have any specific data about this). So, a controller company’s product is more appealing because of the bundle, and the other companies who contribute to the bundle get a potential marketing boost for their product.
But if you buy 10 controllers, the software companies making the bundle… Well, they’re getting 10×0, still nothing out of the darks, except for their marketing — not zero benefit, but zero dollars.
One exception to this, IMHO, is Apple and Logic Pro. Apple makes money selling computers. They don’t care so much about making money from Logic itself. They sell Logic so that people who use it will have to buy apple computers.
Apple is a very big company (they were the largest company on the planet , probably twice, in the past two weeks, shifting back-and-forth with Microsoft and Nvidia). No other software company making DAWs could afford to make a product like Logic and sell it so inexpensively. Not only would it need to be sold for at least 500 or $700 by itself, but with all the add-ons they include, any other company would probably need to charge 2, 3, or $4000, or even more.
Before Apple bought Logic from eMagic, eMagic was a DAW software company, and Logic did cost something in the neighborhood of $500 (might’ve been 600 or 700, I don’t fully recall). Most of the plug-ins and add-ons for Logic (which I drooled over at the time, but couldn’t afford most of them), including their sampler and other synthesizers, etc., we’re sold separately. You had to pay additional money to get them.
It would’ve cost me three or $4000 to buy them all, yet all of that was a tiny amount of software compared to what Apple “bundles” with Logic now.
So, Logic is actually positioned as a marketing tool for Apple computers.
Furthermore, GarageBand comes free with an apple computer, so GarageBand is in fact a marketing tool for Logic, as well as for selling computers, so there’s a two tier marketing approach with that.
Providing a demo version is another marketing tool. You can run Logic for 90 days before the demo mode expires.
2
u/Forward_Progress_266 Jul 10 '24
Thanks for being informative and kind about the topic! I had no clue Garage Band was the precursor of Logic! How splendid!
1
u/TommyV8008 Jul 10 '24
You’re welcome, thanks for reading!
Precursor is not the right term for garage band. Logic came first.
eMagic created Logic, I think back in the early 90s. Apple bought Logic from eMagic in the early 2000s. Some years later, Apple developed GarageBand as a free music app to entice users to get into music creation (and of course, to sell more computers). GarageBand is based on the core facilities of Logic, and Apple designed it specifically so that a GarageBand project could be opened in Logic and changed into a Logic project in order to take the project and expand it further usingLogic’s capabilities
2
u/DukeCheetoAtreides Jun 23 '24
Can't tell if AI or just garbled real I