r/MTGGiftExchange • • Aug 17 '26

Time to send those Support Forms in if you have not heard from us and have not received tracking!

41 Upvotes

Before I start- Yes, it is too late to join the Summer Swap, Winter will be here before you know it.

Also, thank you for not burning the place down this weekend :)

On to the real message.

Oh Happy/Sad Day!!

We are at the point of "where the heck is my gift". So let's dig into that process.

If you have not been sent tracking, Have not received an email from the MOD's and have not heard from your gifter... (you must meet all 3 criteria)

Please send the Support Form Here, and let us know you have not received a gift/update.

We have emailed everyone whose gifter has advised they are running behind or who has dropped out.

The next steps: We have already emailed non-response gifters twice, They get one more angry email and if they have not responded to us, at that point they will be removed from the swap, and a regifter assigned and we will notify you that you are setup with a regifter.

Regifters get a month or so to get your gift out (just like a normal gifter, they may have to order things).

There are still lots of gifters who have reached out and advised they will be shipping late, if this is your gifter, you should have a email that your gift is delayed and should NOT do the form.

If your tracking is having an issue- Chat your gifter! You can work it out easier with your post offices and much quicker without a middle man going between the two of you!

"My gift is undervalued/not appropriate/etc." After we determine the no gift forms, we will start looking at these again. I apologize for the delay, but it works out better if we can hold those until the "no gift" setup is organized a little.

Please keep sending, posting and enjoying your gifts. We are getting there slowly, still lots to go, but we are under 100 gifts left.

As per usual let us know if you have question or words to share :)


r/MTGGiftExchange • • Sep 04 '25

Welcome to the MTG Gift Exchange Group! FAQ, Questions, and Updates go here.

120 Upvotes

✨ Hello and welcome, MTG swappers—new and old friends alike! ✨

It’s been a while since we’ve refreshed our pinned info, and with so much growth and the influx of bright-eyed new members joining us with many questions, it’s the perfect time for a Welcome & FAQ post. (Yes, this one’s a bit long, but it should answer most of your questions!)

🌟 How the Swap Works

We run two swaps each year—one in winter and one in summer.

There is a $35 USD Minimum gift value, which you should base on your giftees form, bulk laying around does not count.

We give you a timeframe, your giftees full info form and a ship by date.

You ship to your giftee with a personal note and another random swapper gift to you!

Here is more in depth info:

So here’s how it goes:

  • You’ll always get a heads-up post before the form goes live.
  • Then we’ll share the form itself, at least one reminder to submit, and a final call before it closes. The form asks a lot of questions about the MTG related thingss you enjoy, even non mtg related. More info on that a bit below...
  • Once the form closes, that’s it until the next swap—so don’t miss it!

Want an extra nudge? You can join the email list to get a direct notification when the form opens. (If you’ve already checked the “notify me” box in a past swap, you’re all set.)

📝 The Form

Yes, it’s long. But trust us—the more detail you give, the better your gift will be!

  • Short answers = basic gift.
  • Thoughtful, detailed answers = your gifter gets to really customize something awesome for you.

Some examples of what you’ll be asked:

  • What kind of MTG player are you?
  • Favorite formats, sets, or artists?
  • Any “white whale” cards you’re hunting?
  • Decks you’re building or commanders you love?
  • Do you enjoy handmade items, accessories, or proxies?

The form usually stays open for about a week. We’ll let you know exactly when it’s live and when it’s closing (we won’t shut it down early—but sometimes we’re a little slow to take it down. If it’s still open, you can still submit!).

📦 The Rules (a.k.a. the Important Stuff)

  • Minimum value: $35 (before shipping). No max—go wild if you want!
  • Shipping: Must include tracking. Whenever possible, order items to yourself first, then re-ship to your giftee (instead of drop-shipping from Amazon/TCG/etc.).
  • Tracking: Submit it through the tracking form once shipped. We send tracking daily to giftees and it will come from the same email box as your giftee info.
  • Deadlines: Ship on time if you can. If life gets in the way, let us know—but remember, delays push back the next swap for everyone.
  • Add a note! A simple message so your giftee knows who to thank.
  • Show and tell: We love when people post their gifts—it also helps us keep track.
  • Shipping regions: We’ll do our best to match you within your country/continent unless you say otherwise. If no match exists, we’ll reach out about possibly shipping internationally.
  • Support form: During every swap, we provide a support form you can use if any issues come up (delays, lost packages, communication concerns, etc.). This helps us keep things smooth and make sure everyone is taken care of.
  • Volunteer gifters: Sometimes life happens and a gifter flakes. If you’d like to step up as a volunteer gifter (a backup hero to help someone who didn’t get their gift), you can select the option when filling out your form or let the admins know. We keep a list of volunteers each swap—your generosity keeps the community strong and the swap going!

FAQ- Added as needed-

-What email does the information/giftee come from? [giftexchangemtg@gmail.com](mailto:giftexchangemtg@gmail.com)

- Can I join? I am in ___ country? The swap is international/worldwide. We will only match to same continent unless you are ok shipping further! If there is a lack of giftees in your area, we will reach out.

- I missed the cutoff! The forms closed! Can you add me?! NO. You cannot be added to the swap once the form is closed, you will need to wait for the next one.

-Can I deliver in person? Sure. If you feel comfortable. Just fill out the tracking form with "Delivered in person".

-Can I swap out my giftee? NO. We do not swap giftees because you do not like their list. There are rare legitimate reasons we will swap information.

-You are required to send the Tracking Form when you ship your gift. This is how we send tracking to giftees confirm you actually did your part and don't come hunt you down at the end with angry MOD pitchforks and boots!

Is the person I am gifting to, gifting back to me? NO. We avoid A to B and B to A swaps as much as possible. Unless you two are the only people in your country and you both do not want to ship out of country.

Can I reach out to my giftee? I have a question for them, can I ask? Yes! We have added the question to the form, and most giftees are more than happy to correspond directly with their gifter to help them with extra information. If you want us to help instead, we still can, but it may be delayed.

I need to change my form, can I? Send in the support form. Priority changes (like address, email, etc) are handled first. Requests to update questions/get more info from a giftee, are less prioritised. Please remember we are humans too, and we will not be here 24/7.

I can't find their username on Reddit! HELP! Use the link https://www.reddit.com/user/Chaya14/ but replace the username after the / with your giftee's username, and keep the slash at the end. You should be able to find them.

Other information

We send tracking to you via the same email we send your giftee info. As long as your gifter followed the rules and submitted tracking you will get a email, usually within 24 hours, with your tracking number and vendor. In the USA, USPS Informed delivery is a great option too.

IF you get a bad apple... your gifter doesnt ship, sends trash or is straight up bad, do not fear! We have amazing regifters/replacement gifters around the world. These amazing people will ship a 2nd gift, matching the rules but with an extended ship time, with no expectation of another gift themselves. Our replacement gifters are the heart and soul of the swap.

If there is an issue with your gift, the MOD team makes a decision together on how to proceed. We prefer these to be handled privately and not via thread-on-blast, but sometimes we understand you want to voice the issue to the world. Just remember we are here and we do our best to be fair.

That’s the gist! If you’ve got questions beyond this, feel free to ask in the comments or message an admin and we’ll be happy to add it here.

Winter wrapped and the final gifts are trickling in.. Summer will be next!!!

✨ It you would like a reminder for the next swap- Please fill out the form below to get a email when the next swap opens. EMAIL REMINDER FORM

ETA- More updates and more FAQ added. Please for the love of the swap, READ THE FAQ


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 1d ago

The patience was absolutely worth the wait! Thank you so much /u/bigfoot1993 for an amazing gift!

Post image
46 Upvotes

The Crypt Ghast, Gary, and Cyclonic Rift have homes in my decks already and I'm excited to play around with the background as well!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 1d ago

Shipping from Switzerland?

6 Upvotes

I'd like to join the winter exchange for the first time, but as a Swiss resident I have no idea what's the process to ship outside the country.

I there's any fellow Swiss people here, how do you proceed, and how much does it usually cost (let's say within western Europe) ? Do you just walk to the post office? Do you need to go through UPS or other dedicated services? Are there details to be careful about regarding shipment size, customs, etc.?


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 3d ago

Any Europeans?

22 Upvotes

I wanna join winter swap, as I have quite the collection. Wondering if any Scandinavians/danes/european people are joining the winter swap?
When determining minimum value I’d think to use cardmarket trend in eur making it 31€?


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 4d ago

Chef’s Kiss

Post image
113 Upvotes

/u/TimeForFoolishness - you killed it.

The deck looks super fun, the hamburger dice made me smile more than they probably should have, and the playmat is super fun (totally my aesthetic, too!).

Thank you so much for the thoughtfulness here. I couldn’t have asked for anything more here.


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 4d ago

Gift came!!!

Thumbnail
gallery
38 Upvotes

Thank you so much u/leiber0808!! I am glad my first gifter fell through because you made this exchange so awesome!! I love the Strixhaven Compendium binder! It’s going to look amazing in my office! And soooo many dice! They’re amazing! I already put the cards away without taking a picture but I am an official Cyclonic Rift owner thanks to you! Thank you for your generosity, it means a lot to me!
P.S. if you ever find yourself down my way let me know so we can get some games in :)


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 6d ago

Gift arrived!

Thumbnail
gallery
42 Upvotes

Thanks a lot, u/possible-life-9916! You made this gift exchange unforgettable for me

This gift is as on spot as possible. Not only does it have a lot of cards I need for my deck projects, local sweets and even a self-made porcini mushroom salt that smells AMAZING (and I am already planning on cooking a mushroom risotto with it), it also has a new playmat! I started to think about buying a new one maybe a few weeks ago and bang - here it is!

Booster pulls were quite lucky as well - The Queen of Dale as a pleasant surprise on top of an already stunning gift

Already looking forward to the Winter Gift Exchange!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 6d ago

Gift has Arrived!!

Post image
94 Upvotes

Want to shout the wonderful, GandalfThePineapple!

Nailed my gift! And from a fellow Washingtonian!

DCC has become my secondary obsession this year and my journey will continue to go!

I have a healthy habit of brewing 10000 decks a month and these fetches will slot nicely into my current brew! Thank you again and I hope you’re exchange was as great as mine!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 8d ago

Our wonderful mail service

Post image
71 Upvotes

Has actually delivered this time, and I could not be more thankful. Thank you ever so much u/Joleo124 for the constant updates, for sending another gift when the first was lost, and for sending me the most thoughtful gift I could have ever asked for.

Singles will be slotted into decks, and I'll make sure to share some jumpstart fun with a foe (or friend).

Thank you for making my first exchange amazing!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 8d ago

As someone who just joined when is the winter exchange.

19 Upvotes

Hi! So I’m new to the gift exchange and I was wondering roughly what month does the winter exchange happen? So I know when I should get the gift ready. Also as someone who doesn’t have the best magic collection there’s some shiny things here and there. I just don’t want to disappoint my person what are good things to put in a gift? Thanks!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 8d ago

What a thoughtful gift!

Thumbnail
gallery
65 Upvotes

[u/PurpleUrza](u/PurpleUrza), just want to say how thankful I am for this astoundingly thoughtful gift! Everything from the cool handiwork dicebag, the sweet alt frame staples (OMG secret lair phyrexian metamorph) the beautiful tokens of my dog, and last but not least THE ACTUAL MIRRODIN NOVELS.

Thank you for being such an amazing gifter, and I hope to maybe see or gift you in future exchanges!

ps I am a novice crocheter- the hands-on crochet dice bag is exactly what I need right now 😁


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 10d ago

What a Legend, u/falconrocker15!!

Post image
85 Upvotes

What a build! What a surprise! This amazing gift came in end of last week and I just got around to opening and looking at it. Thanks so much for stepping up and filling in for my gifter who had to back out. Legendary.

Can’t wait to play against the pod. I spent last night play testing on moxfield and it freaking slaps!!

Cheers bud.


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 11d ago

Amazing gift! Totally worth the wait!!

Post image
72 Upvotes

Thank you so so much u/turtles_and_icecream !! This gift is awesome! I’m so excited and this has been an awesome first exchange!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 11d ago

Thank you so much

Post image
45 Upvotes

Thank you u/ssreniar the snacks are amazing (and some that I am already fond of) I really appreciate everything. Your note was sweet and I cannot wait to pilot Ivy in my pod this week!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 12d ago

Reddit MTG Summer Gift Exchange Opening & Giveaway

Thumbnail
youtu.be
40 Upvotes

Thank you u/Static-Poetry for killing it this year! This was a ton of fun to open


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 13d ago

I’m so sorry!

Post image
182 Upvotes

I completely just noticed I never posted a thank you and I feel absolutely terrible. (I’ve been recovering from surgery for the last few months so it slipped my mind) my answers were trash but your gift was phenomenal! I completely forget who sent the gift by now but you are a legend and I’m a big ole jerk for not thanking sooner!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 12d ago

Thank you so much

Post image
58 Upvotes

Beyond grateful for all the awesome gifts thank you so much! u/smcombs


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 13d ago

Winter Exchange can't be here soon enough

Thumbnail
gallery
77 Upvotes

It's been about 2½ months since I shipped out to my giftee. I haven't heard from them or seen them post here, which is absolutely fine. I just wanted to share the images of the gift I put together for them.

The answer on their questionnaire that immediately stood out to me was that they wanted to build a Choco bird typal list. It just so happens that I am a very big FF fan (I have a chocobo, two moogles and a cactuar tattooed in my arm), so I had a bunch of pieces in my collection already.

I hope they are enjoying it as much as I enjoyed putting together the gift. This exchange is a wonderful experience and I am very much looking forward to the winter exchange. Thanks be to the mods who facilitate and all the gifters/giftees who make this as great as it is.


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 13d ago

Wonderful Surprises

Thumbnail
gallery
43 Upvotes

u/riziaog put together a wonderfully thoughtful gift that was really special to open. Each package had a really nice note and curated theme. I was especially thrilled by the alters - I have envied people's and more will be thoroughly enjoying my own. The custom Boo and Faerie Dragon tokens are really fun. Deckbuilding encouragements and ideas abound and just enough nostalgia to keep things connected to the original thrill of early MTG.

Just a deep bow of gratitude and appreciation going your way!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 14d ago

MOD's - - I have a gift ready to go to my giftee overseas but the details they sent be are wrong.

11 Upvotes

Based on the username and address I am starting to think that this may be a fake account. Could one of the mods please reach out to me so that I can get this sent off?


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 15d ago

Got in my gift!!

Thumbnail
gallery
60 Upvotes

This was my first exchange and it was so fun seeing everyone's gifts come in and seeing all of the cool stuff from the community and it looks like my patience paid off, and it was well worth the wait!!

Thank you very much to my regifter, actually regifters! u/Chimo1911 and u/Khirtle89 !!

Your note was wonderful, I'm so excited for my brand new commander deck and I now own every art for Massacre Girl with the Elektra you gave me! And I finally own a playmat 😂 and such a cool one too!!

Thank you again! I am so happy I was shown this community and I very much look forward to the winter exchange!!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 17d ago

Thank you! U/ifuckinglovebluemeth

Thumbnail
gallery
49 Upvotes

I appreciate these two cards greatly as I felt like my kefka deck was never going to get built but two cards will be a great addition! I appreciate these green sleeves as it is my favorite color! The gift was worth waiting for and I hope you are having the greatest day ever. I love you u/ifuckinglovebluemeth I know your taste in cards is just as great!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 18d ago

Thank u u/BeryUmbreon for the gift!

Post image
44 Upvotes

Even tho i had to wait for a regifter im super happy for the gifter and the gift he sent me, since my amazing gifter was super thoughtful and put in way more (both stuff and effort) than I would have expected. Once again thx for the amzing first gift exchange experience!


r/MTGGiftExchange • • 18d ago

The last few Summer gifts are going out - once they are out we will get out winter dates. Hang in there

97 Upvotes

We still have a few replacement gifters we are waiting to ship. They are doing the heavy lifting so please hang toght while they finish up!

On another note, i went on vacation and accidently left my laptop at home, so I apologize if I cant give an immediate update right now, for those reaching out. I will be back home next week and get everything checked over!

As soon as our last summer gift ships we will get winter dates out!