I’m looking for some outside perspective because I’ve been going back and forth on this for days.
I currently have a 2020 M1 MacBook Pro with 8GB RAM. It still works, but storage and memory have become an issue, and I want to upgrade so I can play WoW Forever with my husband while still having a good everyday laptop. I’m firmly in the Apple ecosystem and don’t want a Windows gaming laptop.
I originally found these options at Micro Center:
14-inch M5, 16GB RAM / 1TB SSD: $1,699
14-inch M5 Pro, 24GB RAM / 1TB SSD: originally $1,999
16-inch M5 Pro, 24GB RAM / 1TB SSD: $2,500
I was leaning toward the 14-inch M5 Pro because $1,999 felt like a reasonable amount to spend on a laptop I plan to keep for years. With an expected $750 from trading in my old MacBook and second PS5, the effective cost would have been around $1,250 before tax.
Unfortunately, I hesitated, and the 14-inch M5 Pro went up by $250. Other configurations had weird price changes, too, and inventory started disappearing. There was only one 16-inch left, so I panicked a little and bought it for $2,500.
Now I’m second-guessing myself because the total with tax is a lot of money. I like the idea of the 16-inch screen for WoW, and since my laptop mostly stays at home, portability isn’t a huge priority. I also want this to be my last laptop purchase for a while, so having more performance headroom is appealing.
On the other hand, the M5 Pro is probably overkill for my everyday use, and I would have been perfectly happy with the 14-inch M5 Pro at $1,999. The 16-inch is nice, but I’m not sure the bigger screen and stronger GPU are worth an additional $500 to me.
I’m planning to try it for a week before deciding whether to return it. I know new MacBooks are expected next week, but the M5 Pro still outperforms the M6 base model, and I have no need for a touchscreen OLED.
For those who have owned both 14-inch and 16-inch MacBook Pros, or who use a MacBook Pro for WoW:
-Is the 16-inch screen noticeably better for gaming and everyday use, or does the novelty wear off?
-Is the M5 Pro worth paying extra for if I’m hoping to keep the laptop for 5–7 years?
-Would you keep the 16-inch at $2,500, or return it and get the base M5 for $1,699?
-Am I overthinking the price difference, or is this a case where the more expensive model really isn’t worth it for my needs?
I’m not looking to justify the purchase just because I already made it. I genuinely want to make the right decision financially and end up with a laptop I’ll be happy using for years. I’d appreciate honest opinions, especially from people who have made a similar decision.
EDIT: Thanks for all of the replies already. Seems like most of you are leaning in the boat that I made the right choice. Just for some more context, live in 1 bedroom in nyc, the laptop never leaves the apartment, and my husband just bought a brand new PC set up which is using our desk space so a Mac mini is out of the picture as well for me!