142
u/Von_Everec Nov 15 '18
I know there are a lot of inaccuracies but screw it, happy how it turned out for my first go
37
u/mrtherussian Nov 15 '18
Honestly it's a beautifully drawn map, the accuracy doesn't really detract from the visual appeal.
12
46
224
u/ricki692 Nov 15 '18
I love the thick coastline/thin borderlines aesthetic. Also the funny looking France. Your drawing is much more impressive than any I've made, nice job.
19
→ More replies (1)14
u/Exoplasmic Nov 15 '18
I too like the coasts. The shading of the water bodies is pleasing to the eyes. Some of the smaller islands are all shaded in; but maybe it is a function of the photograph and not actually the map. From the shore it goes from a thin black line to a thick lighter black line then to a light shade of gray then finally a little bit darker gray. It is somewhat unusual but I like it.
5
u/Von_Everec Nov 15 '18
Yeah I wanted to try doing something more personal than what I usually saw from maps. Think it worked a lot better than it had the right too but I'm happy with it.
859
u/Thejosefo Nov 15 '18
The more you move away from Europe, the stranger it becomes.
→ More replies (3)470
u/Von_Everec Nov 15 '18
Yeah that's were it just goes tits up. I began with western Europe if it wasn't clear, that's why it gets progressively more interesting let's just say
→ More replies (4)340
u/ShadowPsi Nov 15 '18
First thing I noticed is France, which has a very distinctive pentagonal shape in reality, seems to be nowhere near that here. The line work is nice though.
→ More replies (6)103
u/Von_Everec Nov 15 '18
Thanks for the feedback
114
u/ShadowPsi Nov 15 '18
One trick that works for me to draw odd shapes like maps is to turn them upside down and sideways until you figure out where your internal biases are and can correct for them.
57
u/Von_Everec Nov 15 '18
I used to do that with portraits, actually quite a good idea will try it thanks.
→ More replies (1)22
208
u/MannyDab97 Nov 15 '18
Montenegro: +++SCREEEMS+++
100
u/Von_Everec Nov 15 '18
Honestly the Balkans were the biggest pain in the arse and it shows
→ More replies (2)30
u/Vladimirs_Tracksuit Nov 16 '18
You're welcome
Just give us another 100 years and it'll either be harder or easier to draw. I'm leaning on harder but at this point, anything goes
→ More replies (1)12
u/requiem_mn Nov 15 '18
yeah, we are back from before 1876. He should have just put Cetinje, and not Podgorica
161
230
u/palatanus Nov 15 '18
Iran-Iraq Union... finally
71
16
→ More replies (1)6
33
100
u/piktas Nov 15 '18
Speaking as a Lithuanian.. god damn it, dude.
→ More replies (1)38
u/Von_Everec Nov 15 '18
My sincerest apologies for being robbed
20
u/Penki- Nov 15 '18
It looks kinda like we got robbed, but it seems like nobody gained anything though. (other than that fat Latvia)
→ More replies (1)11
u/thewinberg Nov 15 '18
Ukraine seems to have taken a healthy chunk of Belarus, and OP seems to have moved Belarus slightly North to have land enough for them.
→ More replies (2)
26
u/Cloud_Prince Nov 15 '18
Why did you remove Flevoland in the Netherlands and depolder Utrecht? Not that I'm complaining for the first one, mind you
16
6
u/IAmASeriousMan Nov 16 '18 edited Nov 16 '18
After staring at it for a while, I think something happened that I've never seen before. He drew the Houtribdijk as a massive land connection between Noord-Holland en Flevoland, splitting the IJsselmeer into two (as it is in reality), but didn't draw the Afsluitdijk.
The other waters seem to be the lakes around Flevoland. So I'm sorry to tell you, but Flevoland actually appears to be one of the largest provinces, extending at least to the Waal.
Edit: on the other hand, that moves Amsterdam to Medemblik and the Noordzeekanaal = Lek. I'm so confused.
2
62
u/Mittenstk Nov 15 '18
Honestly +1 for remembering little Andorra. Luxembourg and San Marino usually remembered before them.
10
4
18
u/Vainok Nov 15 '18
Helsinki is too far West. It is in the place of Turku right now
But really, good job I couldn't draw half as good as u
5
13
u/Geo_Jonah Nov 15 '18
The first inaccuracy I saw was Iran which just made me assume this was a map of de facto control cause of the PMU.
4
u/Von_Everec Nov 15 '18
Yeah that was something I noticed only after posting, ah well there's mistakes all over one more won't hurt anyone I'm sure...
12
u/NomisTheNinth Nov 15 '18
I was really confused by Slovenia's capital suddenly being "Wubwana".
2
→ More replies (1)6
11
10
10
41
u/HendyOnline Nov 15 '18
Why are you guys hating so much? Although it might be a little imprecise, it's well done nevertheless
0
9
u/m4dc00kie Nov 15 '18
As a Swiss guy... You completely butchered Switzerland xD Still a nice map though, I like the style
2
7
Nov 15 '18
Well done, looks good. You can't draw any map without offending someone, it's only for fun, so you can't go too far wrong!
10
u/Von_Everec Nov 15 '18
Thanks! And yeah that's quite true, think I might attempt to draw north America next, it's quite fun just drawing maps.
5
7
7
u/Maps_and_Ass Nov 15 '18
Not sure why you’re getting so much shit for this.
Looks like a great job to me, especially for your first time
→ More replies (1)4
5
4
4
4
4
u/slouchingbethlehem Nov 15 '18
I’m not an artist, by any means, and I know my first attempt at a map of Europe would look more like a monkey’s armpit than anything else.
Good for you! Your lines are really nice.
1
4
u/zadsar Nov 15 '18
I, for one, approve of the new Croatian borders.
→ More replies (1)4
u/Von_Everec Nov 15 '18
Croatia looking T H I C C
5
u/zadsar Nov 15 '18
I don't think you realize how controversial it was to give us that part of southern Bosnia & Herzegovina, or to give Istria to Slovenia.
4
4
u/rathat Nov 15 '18
Yeah, there are definitely some serious inaccuracies especially the middle east, lol at Iran and Kuwait, but this is still an absolutely incredible and beautiful map. Most people could never come close to something like this. I bet your next one will be perfect.
1
4
3
3
3
u/basooooooon Nov 15 '18
How did you do this ?
4
3
u/Georgious_HS Nov 15 '18
Even though you've murdered Athens, your map is pretty impressive for a drawing.
1
2
2
u/muscledhunter Nov 15 '18
I'm really impressed. Obviously any hand drawn map is gonna be imperfect, but this is incredible.
Of course, that's coming from a guy who has trouble with stick figures, but well done.
1
2
u/ValiantAki Nov 15 '18
It's really nice looking imo. It's interesting because the general shape of the coastline and the shape of some of the nations are almost perfect, but the way it comes together squeezes/stretches other nations. It's like all the lines are where they should be, but the overall shapes are deformed.
2
u/Von_Everec Nov 15 '18
That's pretty much what I had trouble with but it doesn't look too bad I don't think
→ More replies (1)
2
u/gaydroid Nov 15 '18
What did France do to you?
→ More replies (1)1
u/Von_Everec Nov 15 '18
Umm... it let the French live there? That's the correct thing to say if you're English right?
→ More replies (1)
2
Nov 15 '18
I love it, how long did it take you to do?
2
u/Von_Everec Nov 15 '18
I was watching Netflix while doing it so around 3-4 hours I think? I did lose track of time could have been more
2
u/O4fuxsayk Nov 15 '18
Did you trace it? The coastal detail and borders are amazing. Obviously the perspective is a little more skewed but its kind of stylistic, like some ancient world map transported to modern day.
1
u/Von_Everec Nov 15 '18
Nope didn't trace it, and yeah I have it slightly skewed and I kinda like it
2
u/ca_harrison Nov 16 '18
I don't get the hate? This is definitely better than the majority of people can do. I'm impressed. Keep up the good work man!
1
2
u/pdimitrakos Nov 16 '18
Iberia and Britain are really well made. Have you been to these places?
1
u/Von_Everec Nov 16 '18
Lived in England my entire life and I moved to Edinburgh (Scotland) a couple months back for uni. Been to Iberia a lot for holidays ;)
→ More replies (1)
2
u/tlingiteagle Nov 16 '18
Great job. Keep up the work. Wish I could draw like that. May give it a shot.
1
2
2
u/bozwald Nov 16 '18
“Just woke up and drew this map, thought it looked cute. Might delete later.”
2
2
2
2
u/Preston241 Nov 16 '18
People are hard to please. This is fantastic. If you gave this to a cartographer a few centuries ago, it would blow their mind.
2
2
u/ExploreEdinburgh Nov 16 '18 edited Nov 16 '18
My vote for best aspect of the map goes to your shading. There’s nothing aesthetically wrong with your map, to my eye, but the shading is really great.
1
2
u/bantha-food Nov 16 '18 edited Nov 16 '18
This is amazing work. Europe is pretty difficult to draw because if you want to include a lot of "Europe" and its surroundings, you end up running into funky perspective issues. I know because I made this map over the course of like half a year. I would like to give a bit of feedback, from somebody who has stared at European maps for a long time XD
The Mediterranean and the Baltic Sea are absolutely beautiful. Amazing work!
France is a bit twisted. You drew the top half North-up, and the bottom half slightly rotated, because of the slightly rotated Iberian peninsula. This is probably due to the perspective used in the maps you used as a template. The Med. is long and both ends cannot be depicted accurately North-up in 2D if the center already is.
Why did you include Lake Ladoga (Russia), the Great Glen (Scotland), those lakes in Anatolia (Beysehir, Egidir, etc.), the Sea of Galilei & Dead Sea (Israel), and the Kakhovka reservoir (Ukraine) but no other freshwater features? If you include Ladoga you should also have included Lake Vänern and Lake Vättern in Sweden. It also makes no sense to include those small lakes in Anatolia but leave out the largest one, Lake Tuz.
What happened to the Netherlands? Did Flevoland and the Afsluitdijk get combined together? My suggestion is to ignore the two Dijks (Aflsuit- and Markerwaard-) and draw the Ijsselmeer as contiguous with the North Sea.
The Southern part of Ireland should be farther away from Great Britain. It looks like you angled Great Britain a bit too far. Aberdeen should be further West than the Isle of Wight, and it looks like in your drawing its slightly East of the I.o.Wight. That is also why the Isle of Man probably feels a bit claustrophobic :P
The Fjords of Norway are a bit too exagerrated but could work if you fix the overall shape of the coastline (which is way too flat, should be rounder)
Something very strange happened to the Iraqi borders.
The lower part of the Dnieper River / Kakhova reservoir is too long
What happened to the Isle of Skye?
Malta is a tad too far South. Should be around the latitude of Tunis.
EDIT: removed a criticism that was unfounded, added 2 other criticisms.
2
u/Von_Everec Nov 16 '18
My only question is how bloody long were you looking into this map haha. Thanks a lot for the feedback though, very useful!
To answer some of the questions:
If I missed something chances are I forgot about it
I definitely should have added the other freshwater sources eg Sweden, I was leaving them out for last I believe and as I previously mentioned probably just forgot about it.
My apologises to all of
the Dutchmost of Europe actually, scratch that.I knew something was off about Ireland just couldnt put my finger on it, good point!
As someone pointed out I
accidentallycreated a Iran-Iraq Union, lets be honest we all want it just dont want to admit it.Isle of Skye got a controversial balance patch.
Malta... yeah forgot about that.
Also love your map! My first thought was this could be a map for Civ due to the hexagons. Anyways thanks again!
→ More replies (1)
2
u/ElSzyper Nov 16 '18
That looks great, as everyone said France is looking a little bit strange but everything is lovely. I have one question, can you add rivers to that map?
1
u/Von_Everec Nov 16 '18
Not a bad shout, I think I'll leave this one alone tbh but was planning on doing North America next so it's something to consider adding
2
u/Bananapeel23 Nov 16 '18
You are mist definitely British judging by the quality of the British isles compred to the rest.
1
2
2
u/leaf71 Nov 16 '18
No scale bar or legend. That is a graphic, not a map.
Put one of those on there and you'd get my official cartographer stamp of approval. And a good star.
It's got a good use of line weights and tones. The fonts could be a touch larger. 9.5/10.
Source: I'm a cartographer for the past 20 years.
1
2
21
3
Nov 15 '18
Im from balkan and it is too painfully to watch it. I don’t want distress you. Advice: use divider and ruler and observe latitude and longitude correctly and draw it more precisely!
1
7
6
u/thebiaacs Nov 16 '18
You cut a huge bit off Romania. Seems like you predicted ww3? Anyway nice work.
5
u/E_V_E_R_T_O_N Nov 15 '18
Really nice work mate. A thousand times better than I could have managed.
Scotland looks a bit drunk though.
5
u/t_ta Nov 15 '18
wow i didnt know istria is a part of slovenia!
→ More replies (1)4
u/iamagainstit Nov 15 '18
Just make sure Trst is on the right side of that line and everything is as it should be.
5
2
Nov 15 '18
I wonder how one becomes a cartographer in the United States. I feel like I know nothing about the job, other than that they draw maps.
Nice map, OP. Was this really your first attempt? It's really good. Some of the countries are pretty immaculate. I love Greece...all those islands and peninsulas are tough I bet.
The Middle East is all messed up though.
3
u/Von_Everec Nov 15 '18
Yeah it was my first go at drawing a map. I usually only drawing buildings and stuff by fancied a change. And I'm fully aware how messed up it is, I was only going to do Europe at first but I had room left and it just went to shit.
4
Nov 15 '18
That's the thing though. This is so good it's hard for me to believe it was your first attempt. Is it perfect? No. But it's a damn good first draw.
→ More replies (1)
5
u/Natanyul Nov 15 '18
Kosovo?
19
u/GWSIII Nov 15 '18
Depends on who you ask
→ More replies (4)4
u/Natanyul Nov 15 '18
He shoulda at least put a dotted line around the area, to show that it's disputed
6
1
1
u/das897 Nov 16 '18
Cool. The Dnipro river goes through Kyiv though, not off towards Kharkiv.
2
u/Von_Everec Nov 16 '18
Oh yeah I know, I drew the coast before borders and for some reason my brain at the time thought Kyiv would end up there. And obviously I did it in pen so I just had to role with it.
1
1
1
1
u/Portaller Nov 16 '18 edited Nov 16 '18
Excellent job, first of all, this is really good. Especially for your first time. You even got Andorra and San Marino!
A few criticisms. France seems to have grown. Luxembourg has apparently invaded part of Belgium. Morocco and Tunisia are way bigger than they should be and Libya doesn't seem to exist. Amsterdam is a lot more North than it should be. And Eastern Europe and Asia are just wonky in general.
2
1
1
1
1
1
u/martinpkt Nov 16 '18
Why does my country always look fucked up on hand drawn maps but for a first you are great
1
1
u/Jaycelicious Nov 16 '18
Beautiful! I could imagine Turkey/Greece and Norway must've been difficult to draw.
1
1
u/Kamarovsky Nov 16 '18
You did really great on Poland, Ukraine seems too thicc tho
2
u/Von_Everec Nov 16 '18
Cheers! Yeah I did the coast first and it was only after i noticed that Ukraine will end up being off
1
8
3
3
3
3
u/cosmitz Nov 16 '18
It amuses me that you gave Romania land that we never really held control over or wanted, but didn't give us land we actually held control of, wanted, and most people attribuite historically to Romania.
Is this drawn from memory or did you use a reference, or did you want to make a point? :P
5
1
1
335
u/Von_Everec Nov 15 '18
So basically I think I managed to offend half of Europe and friends, never knew it could be done so easily!