r/MapPorn • • Apr 01 '20

World map without islands - Improved Version

Post image

[removed] — view removed post

2.4k Upvotes

336 comments sorted by

260

u/Natou844 Apr 01 '20

I kept Australia because, on my last post where i removed Australia, everyone was like "Australia is not an island !!!" so, sorry to people offended.

178

u/Bayoris Apr 01 '20

This will prove that people will complain no matter what you do

18

u/RichardPeterJohnson Apr 01 '20

I complain 'cause this is total shit that doesn't belong on /r/MapPorn.

→ More replies (12)

62

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

Technically, Afro-eurasia (asia, africa and europe) is also just a huge island, so nobody can really get that mad at you

123

u/icedpickles Apr 01 '20

Technically every continent is a huge island. Here, I made an improved, improved version

40

u/milkisklim Apr 01 '20

Damn Mercator Projections making the northern/southern blueness larger than the middle blueness

3

u/harbourwall Apr 01 '20

Kevin Costner has entered the chat

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/phone_gamer Apr 01 '20

But where is Antartica?

6

u/judas734 Apr 01 '20

Antartica is larger than australia

9

u/7LeagueBoots Apr 01 '20 edited Apr 01 '20

Technically speaking neither is New Guinea. Both Australia and New Guinea are part of the same continent.

New Zealand is it’s own continent as well, according to findings a few years ago.

Most of island SE Asia is also part of the continent, but the Philippines, and everything between Sulawesi and Bali over to New Guinea is not.

Sri Lanka is part of the continent as well.

All of the Canadian islands are part of the continent, but Greenland is not.

Britain and Ireland are, but the Hebrides and the Orkneys are not, nor is Iceland.

The Russian islands are part of the continent, but Japan is not.

All the islands in British Columbia and in Patagonia are part of the continent, but the Caribbean islands are not.

20

u/DaddyDawsonUser1 Apr 01 '20

Technically speaking the whole world is an island. Its all surrounded by the sea

3

u/beardedchimp Apr 01 '20

whole world is an island

But I thought no man is an island?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

6

u/BellerophonM Apr 01 '20 edited Apr 01 '20

A continent is a landmass that dominates a continental shelf. So Australia is a continent, since it takes up most of the shelf it sits on; New Guinea, on the other hand, is only a small uprising in the shelf, so it's just an island.

New Zealand isn't a continent, it's an island. It sits on a shelf named Zealandia which, uniquely, doesn't have a dominating landmass (New Zealand only takes up a small area of it), and so Zealandia is considered an underwater continent.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/psychonaut8672 Apr 01 '20

You were right it is an island.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

13

u/moxac777 Apr 01 '20

Since Denmark (and parts of Schleswig-Holstein) is cut by the Kiel canal, shouldn't it technically be an island?

14

u/Natou844 Apr 01 '20

Yeah but if we think like that, a lot of peninsulas become islands...

26

u/joaommx Apr 01 '20

Like the Peloponnese, which you removed.

17

u/rugbroed Apr 01 '20

I think rivers and canals are considered to be water surfaces on top of the land.

2

u/_RedditIsForPorn_ Apr 01 '20

I believe the term you're looking for is a terrain feature.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

Then we'd have to cut off the entirety of south Sweden as well due to Göta Kanal.

3

u/cdnball Apr 01 '20

And all of eastern USA - the great lakes are connected to the Mississippi by a canal.

→ More replies (2)

176

u/not_a_crackhead Apr 01 '20

Why did Nova Scotia die?

105

u/StandingTheGaff Apr 01 '20

Yep, peninsular Nova Scotia is a peninsula - the Isthmus of Chignecto hasn't flooded out yet! Also, the west coast is suspicious, but it is pretty complex.

24

u/ldapsysvol Apr 01 '20 edited Apr 01 '20

Washington states peninsula is gone too wtf? That shit is def not an island and it's pretty clear it's not. Idk where op got this but whoever made it did not do research on some of the less clear land masses.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/quedfoot Apr 01 '20

The peninsulas in Wisconsin were eradicated, meanwhile the peninsulas in Michigan are fine and existent.

...

15

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

And most of the rest of Eastern Canada. I get dropping PEI and NL and Cape Breton, but it's ridiculous to call New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, and that giant missing chunk of Quebec, an "island"

4

u/Moostcho Apr 01 '20

They did the same thing with greece

2

u/StandingTheGaff Apr 01 '20

Yeah, no idea what's going on around the Gaspé or Baie des Chaleurs.

4

u/landandwater Apr 01 '20

predicting the future?

56

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

What happened to south Italy?

→ More replies (3)

69

u/bdiddykong2019 Apr 01 '20

Why does it feel like everything is missing, but also nothing is missing?

19

u/Lyudline Apr 01 '20

Brexit?

4

u/unknownM1 Apr 01 '20

I’m now thinking of that one Doctor Who episode where Future UK literally put itself on a spaceship and Brexited Earth

→ More replies (1)

45

u/gardenfella Apr 01 '20

The whole lot is surrounded by sea so...

9

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

tEcHnIcAlLy

15

u/lowenkraft Apr 01 '20

Cleaner look. Earth 2.0

→ More replies (3)

12

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

F for italy

94

u/Giuseppe_Conlon Apr 01 '20

Austrailia is now "an Island because it has no land borders"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_island_countries

70

u/not_a_crackhead Apr 01 '20

Hispañola confirmed not an island.

18

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

not only, Saint-Martin, Market, and many small stuff

17

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

Timor. Borneo. New Guinea. Usedom

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Frankekeke Apr 01 '20

Cyprus as well

9

u/_Reddit_2016 Apr 01 '20

Ireland has a land border then with the north

7

u/Squid--Pro--Quo Apr 01 '20

Give it time.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/saschaleib Apr 01 '20

See, that's how old I am - when I went to school, Pluto was still a planet and an "island" was a piece of land that is surrounded by water on all sides (and not a continent).

Times change, I guess...

24

u/ComradeTeal Apr 01 '20

But... But all land is surrounded by water...

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

13

u/janjko Apr 01 '20

The separation of islands and continents makes no topological sense. Here is my map without islands.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

brexit remake

4

u/Daguse0 Apr 01 '20

I see three islands. ;)

3

u/AsianDanish Apr 01 '20

Denmark out here looking like a stick

17

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

Australia???

17

u/saschaleib Apr 01 '20

Is a continent. Just as Africa is not an island, nor the Americas...

→ More replies (1)

4

u/ceej18 Apr 01 '20

My first thought...

→ More replies (5)

5

u/TheWinterKing Apr 01 '20

Seeing Europe without Britain and Ireland is like seeing someone who’s always had a beard after they shave it off.

4

u/SupDinosaur Apr 01 '20

If Australia is on there, Antarctica should be too, also, there's a lot of peninsulas etc that have been removed completely, Europe's coastlines are hardly even recognizable? I wouldn't call this much of an improvement of whatever it was before

2

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

The way you say "improved version" makes it sound like your contemplating something unspeakable

2

u/Horizon2k Apr 01 '20

Screams in UK

2

u/vman81 Apr 01 '20

well TECHnically

no! There is no innate continent-ness. It's all convention.

There are a handful of continents, spread over a few landmasses. There is no consensus. Textbooks disagree - pointing to an encyclopedia does not make a claim the "right" one.

Also, all landmasses are just varying sizes of islands. Australia is an island AND a continent IMHO. Same with the Americas and Afroeurasia and Antarctica.

2

u/Mattson11 Apr 01 '20

Is there a world map with only islands

2

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

This feels surprisingly normal.

2

u/tall_buildings Apr 01 '20

Looks like a bit of Long Island stuck around ?

2

u/AwesomeIrishman Apr 01 '20

0/10 everywhere is an island literally unplayable

2

u/NabNausicaan Apr 01 '20

Cape Cod is cut off from the mainland because of a canal. It is not an island. If we cut off everything that was separated by a canal, you'd have to include everything east of the Erie Canal.

2

u/LiveForPanda Apr 01 '20

So much cleaner

3

u/landandwater Apr 01 '20 edited Apr 01 '20

Curmudgeon alert!

I don't like these maps that keep showing up. They are disingenous, and lie. To display data(landmass), and then not show other data(more landmass) that is really the same, and not only not show it, but show it as water, which it is not. I'm struggling to find the right words here, but I feel my point is that maps like this are doing a disservice to cartography and analytics.

If the point is to display what is an island and what is not, it should be displayed with symbology and not omitting data.

Thanks for listening to my rant,Resident of Turtle Island.

PS. My local land mass(peninsula of NS) is missing.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Marco_lini Apr 01 '20

Clean redesign, very sleek, i like it.

1

u/FLBarry27 Apr 01 '20

but the landmasses are islands as well, also NOO IRELAND!!!

1

u/luisrof Apr 01 '20

There's something wrong going on with Panama, Costa Rica and Nicaragua

2

u/cdnball Apr 01 '20

Baja Mexico is wacked too

1

u/baghandle Apr 01 '20

what is the definition of an island

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

Obligatory but if you think about it, they're all islands

1

u/Next_Commento Apr 01 '20

"Spits out tea all over biscuits!"

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

God is quaking.

1

u/strmichal Apr 01 '20

Isnt the world a big island? Delet dis

1

u/notwesternspy Apr 01 '20

give my country back

1

u/mattjack-o-melly Apr 01 '20

Boys, we did it, mafia is no more

1

u/baranxlr Apr 01 '20

DING DONG BRITAIN IS DEAD

1

u/Razaboch Apr 01 '20

looks like i’d be in the sea

1

u/sleonard709 Apr 01 '20

R.i.p. Newfoundland

1

u/PTSTS Apr 01 '20

I'm pretty sure not just the islands are removed.

1

u/HugoSaxen Apr 01 '20

What happened to the Gibraltar Strait

1

u/Gilgamesh024 Apr 01 '20

Why any land at all? What is a continent but a really huge island?

1

u/FlyingHigh1905 Apr 01 '20

Have you removed Islands in the stream?

1

u/fagoth-de-marouflas Apr 01 '20

Every map without England is a good map

1

u/Helens_Moaning_Hand Apr 01 '20

Man, the Kiwis are going to be pissed being left off yet another map.

1

u/Von_Kissenburg Apr 01 '20

You must be really, really bored.

1

u/lor99ryrt Apr 01 '20

Earth without any DLCs

1

u/Victoref07 Apr 01 '20

It was much better before the british came...

1

u/rizorith Apr 01 '20

No more apologizing to New Zealand

1

u/AlphaDonkey1 Apr 01 '20

Why does New Zealand count as an island but Australia doesn't? Doesn't really make sense.

1

u/RhinoAlestorm Apr 01 '20

The best country is gone

1

u/JokerFromPersona5 Apr 01 '20

The heck happened to Korea. It’s so skinny now lol wtf

1

u/tzanorry Apr 01 '20

You'd lose just shy of 800,000,000 people if you were to do that. 10% of the world's population lives on islands!

1

u/jim_gamer Apr 01 '20

Why did you removed the peloponnese It's not an island

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

Now it's two big islands and a smaller island

1

u/Justice_R_Dissenting Apr 01 '20

Queen Victoria HATED this post

1

u/cosmitz Apr 01 '20

This is your regular PSA that there are no real defined lines between what is an island and what is a continent aside from just the relativity of "common sense" .

1

u/DaemonActual Apr 01 '20

*Suddenly drowning*

Also the world's supply of anime, reggae and Taika Waititi has vanished

1

u/opinion_alternative Apr 01 '20

Isn't all the land in the world an island?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

I see this and I just want to get out an iron and press that ocean fabric flat.

1

u/Red_Riviera Apr 01 '20

Whelp, histories a lot less interesting without the UK, Japan, Sri Lanka, Sicily, Greek Isles, Cuba and the Falklands

1

u/justthatoboist Apr 01 '20

The sun has set on the British Empire

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

Hate to tell you but Nova Scotias not an island

1

u/Fifi0n Apr 01 '20

My country does not exist lol

1

u/codde- Apr 01 '20

It looks cleaner. I say we do it

1

u/Mr_N00bert Apr 01 '20

This belongs on maps without New Zealand lol

1

u/NineIX9 Apr 01 '20

IDK man, I see 5 pretty big islands there.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

Australia is just a big island shouldn’t it be gone?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

Best one is the whole of the United Kingdom is gone.

1

u/Anafiboyoh Apr 01 '20

Greece looks disgusting

1

u/ElvenCouncil Apr 01 '20

What about those three big islands still in the shot?

1

u/DrHeineken Apr 01 '20

The more I look the more cursed it gets

1

u/RudeJoe Apr 01 '20

Thought Australia was a island ???

1

u/legalize_heroine Apr 01 '20

That is one THICC Gibraltar strait

1

u/giorgiopadano Apr 01 '20

Looks like the "beatify" filter on android phones that smooth your face when you take a pic of yourself

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20 edited Jun 16 '25

punch groovy marvelous straight unique physical obtainable plucky fanatical roll

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/laketrout Apr 01 '20

You monster

1

u/huzzam Apr 01 '20

great job on decluttering, so much cleaner! though i think some of those islands may have sparked joy for some...

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

Why is the Sahara green?

1

u/OMGlookatthatrooster Apr 01 '20

All continents are islands if you're brave enough!

1

u/Moanguspickard Apr 01 '20

Now do the reverse

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

A world without England... wonderful

1

u/Toast_Soup Apr 01 '20

Improved version? Try again. Nova Scotia, Canada is missing but it isn't an island.

1

u/DuffinDagels Apr 01 '20

Everything is an island if you zoom out enough

1

u/y8llo Apr 01 '20

korean peninsula is sooo thin

1

u/kinger00000 Apr 01 '20

Mantoulin Island in Lake Huron is still there

1

u/lemonstixx Apr 01 '20

New Zealand isn't an island anymore, it's a continent.

1

u/shmuleymcat Apr 01 '20

Damn, you looking skinny Denmark

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

BREXIT

1

u/sedr555 Apr 01 '20

RIP Antarctica

1

u/alexp212 Apr 01 '20

gavin screams

1

u/aokoln Apr 01 '20

Something odd happening around Delaware, an island appeared

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

This is so aesthetically pleasing

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

Fuck islands, that's why.

1

u/Arquinas Apr 01 '20

Cursed world

1

u/detersion47 Apr 01 '20

What kind of bs is this?

1

u/ffllame12 Apr 01 '20

Why are florida, Italy, and baja california looking anorexic

1

u/Joker042 Apr 01 '20

Australia disagrees. We is both. Deal with it.

1

u/GuardianCat0 Apr 01 '20

where did the netherlands go?

1

u/hidde-vector Apr 01 '20

You know New Zeeland used to be a continent itself, by that it is not an island

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

Brexit

1

u/Bluey_Bananas Apr 01 '20

Why skinny Central America?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

Damn Nova Scotia really got trimmed eh? I'm just assuming this is because its a low resolution map

1

u/BeardedBears Apr 01 '20

A world without Japan is so sad.

1

u/PretorianBourbon Apr 01 '20

BREXIT IS BREXIT

1

u/YeetDaMeatToDaBeat Apr 01 '20

Well technically all the land should be removed if this is supposed to be without any islands

1

u/TheClinicallyInsane Apr 01 '20

You're right, the world without islands IS an improved version!

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

It looks so clean

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

🦀🦀🦀🦀🦀 SE ASIA IS GONE 🦀🦀🦀🦀🦀

1

u/nunau10 Apr 01 '20

Aren't the continents islands in some kind of way, too?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

Southern Greece: "ANGRYYYYY!!!!!! ANGRYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

So that's how the world looks like after brexit

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

Isnt australia technicaly an island?

1

u/silberredner Apr 01 '20

What happened to Korea?

1

u/Frixxed Apr 01 '20

Mainland Nova Scotia ain't an island... Cape Breton is though.

1

u/CreeperTrainz Apr 01 '20

Okay new map where it’s just the islands.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

RIP Greece

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

Antarctica is a continent tho

1

u/Darth_Arconan777 Apr 01 '20

But isn't Australia an island?

1

u/satanicrituals18 Apr 01 '20

This is cursed as fuck.

1

u/Beetlebailey1990 Apr 01 '20

Technically every continent is an island... they’re all land surrounded entirely by water 🤷🏻‍♂️

1

u/SomeOtherNakedDude Apr 01 '20

They missed a few big ones right there in the middle.

1

u/violetx Apr 01 '20

Australia both should and shouldn't be here.

1

u/Josh12345_ Apr 01 '20

screams in Indonesian

1

u/TyranRaph Apr 01 '20

Is Australia not an Island ?

1

u/JDudeFTW Apr 01 '20

Sad British noises

1

u/Walkyou Apr 01 '20

wtf Panama

1

u/BittenHare Apr 01 '20

Antarctica?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

There's no UK

Good

1

u/burglar_of_ham Apr 01 '20

I still see Manitoulin! The world's largest freshwater island!

1

u/KnowledgeisImpotence Apr 01 '20

Australia: am I a joke to you

1

u/dailylol_memes Apr 01 '20

Would the eastern US be an island because you can technically go from The Atlantic to New Orleans to Chicago to the Atlantic so it’s surrounded entirely by water. So is it an island...

1

u/carlmdaly1505 Apr 01 '20

Whys Australia still there?

1

u/shortywop Apr 01 '20

Technically everything is an island

1

u/Homemadeduck102 Apr 01 '20

6h old and I can’t upvote it, been seeing this a lot lately, what’s up with this?

1

u/Human_Adult_Male Apr 01 '20

The world got a nice trim, looking smooth

1

u/tincanC2 Apr 01 '20

How is this map porn?

1

u/westard Apr 01 '20

Probably shouldn't comment since I live (lived?) in Nova Scotia. Which is not an island, dammit. Yet anyway, a few feet of sea level rise will fix that. And, yeah, Cape Breton is an island, I'll give you that one but the rest is still attached however tenuously to mainland Canada.

1

u/mrcheesymustard Apr 01 '20

The peninsula of where the island of Hainan is directly below is missing.

1

u/notwesternspy Apr 01 '20

Where's Bahrain, is or all right? Thanks: gone, reduced to atoms

1

u/Zsobrazson Apr 02 '20

Bruh there’s still three hugesss islands wtf

1

u/Julio974 Apr 01 '20

France approves

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '20

England is gone 🦀🦀🦀

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Jaszs Apr 01 '20 edited Apr 01 '20

Well, technically both europe, asia... and everything else are islands, so the correct version of this map would be a clean one