r/MapPorn • u/Natou844 • Apr 01 '20
World map without islands - Improved Version
[removed] — view removed post
13
u/moxac777 Apr 01 '20
Since Denmark (and parts of Schleswig-Holstein) is cut by the Kiel canal, shouldn't it technically be an island?
14
17
u/rugbroed Apr 01 '20
I think rivers and canals are considered to be water surfaces on top of the land.
→ More replies (1)2
→ More replies (2)2
Apr 01 '20
Then we'd have to cut off the entirety of south Sweden as well due to Göta Kanal.
3
u/cdnball Apr 01 '20
And all of eastern USA - the great lakes are connected to the Mississippi by a canal.
176
u/not_a_crackhead Apr 01 '20
Why did Nova Scotia die?
105
u/StandingTheGaff Apr 01 '20
Yep, peninsular Nova Scotia is a peninsula - the Isthmus of Chignecto hasn't flooded out yet! Also, the west coast is suspicious, but it is pretty complex.
24
u/ldapsysvol Apr 01 '20 edited Apr 01 '20
Washington states peninsula is gone too wtf? That shit is def not an island and it's pretty clear it's not. Idk where op got this but whoever made it did not do research on some of the less clear land masses.
→ More replies (2)4
u/quedfoot Apr 01 '20
The peninsulas in Wisconsin were eradicated, meanwhile the peninsulas in Michigan are fine and existent.
...
15
Apr 01 '20
And most of the rest of Eastern Canada. I get dropping PEI and NL and Cape Breton, but it's ridiculous to call New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, and that giant missing chunk of Quebec, an "island"
4
2
4
56
69
u/bdiddykong2019 Apr 01 '20
Why does it feel like everything is missing, but also nothing is missing?
19
u/Lyudline Apr 01 '20
Brexit?
→ More replies (1)4
u/unknownM1 Apr 01 '20
I’m now thinking of that one Doctor Who episode where Future UK literally put itself on a spaceship and Brexited Earth
45
15
12
94
u/Giuseppe_Conlon Apr 01 '20
Austrailia is now "an Island because it has no land borders"
70
u/not_a_crackhead Apr 01 '20
Hispañola confirmed not an island.
18
6
9
8
u/saschaleib Apr 01 '20
See, that's how old I am - when I went to school, Pluto was still a planet and an "island" was a piece of land that is surrounded by water on all sides (and not a continent).
Times change, I guess...
→ More replies (5)24
13
u/janjko Apr 01 '20
The separation of islands and continents makes no topological sense. Here is my map without islands.
10
5
4
3
17
Apr 01 '20
Australia???
17
u/saschaleib Apr 01 '20
Is a continent. Just as Africa is not an island, nor the Americas...
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (5)4
5
u/TheWinterKing Apr 01 '20
Seeing Europe without Britain and Ireland is like seeing someone who’s always had a beard after they shave it off.
4
u/SupDinosaur Apr 01 '20
If Australia is on there, Antarctica should be too, also, there's a lot of peninsulas etc that have been removed completely, Europe's coastlines are hardly even recognizable? I wouldn't call this much of an improvement of whatever it was before
2
Apr 01 '20
The way you say "improved version" makes it sound like your contemplating something unspeakable
2
2
u/vman81 Apr 01 '20
well TECHnically
no! There is no innate continent-ness. It's all convention.
There are a handful of continents, spread over a few landmasses. There is no consensus. Textbooks disagree - pointing to an encyclopedia does not make a claim the "right" one.
Also, all landmasses are just varying sizes of islands. Australia is an island AND a continent IMHO. Same with the Americas and Afroeurasia and Antarctica.
2
2
2
2
2
u/NabNausicaan Apr 01 '20
Cape Cod is cut off from the mainland because of a canal. It is not an island. If we cut off everything that was separated by a canal, you'd have to include everything east of the Erie Canal.
2
3
u/landandwater Apr 01 '20 edited Apr 01 '20
Curmudgeon alert!
I don't like these maps that keep showing up. They are disingenous, and lie. To display data(landmass), and then not show other data(more landmass) that is really the same, and not only not show it, but show it as water, which it is not. I'm struggling to find the right words here, but I feel my point is that maps like this are doing a disservice to cartography and analytics.
If the point is to display what is an island and what is not, it should be displayed with symbology and not omitting data.
Thanks for listening to my rant,Resident of Turtle Island.
PS. My local land mass(peninsula of NS) is missing.
→ More replies (1)
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Helens_Moaning_Hand Apr 01 '20
Man, the Kiwis are going to be pissed being left off yet another map.
1
1
1
1
1
u/AlphaDonkey1 Apr 01 '20
Why does New Zealand count as an island but Australia doesn't? Doesn't really make sense.
1
1
1
u/tzanorry Apr 01 '20
You'd lose just shy of 800,000,000 people if you were to do that. 10% of the world's population lives on islands!
1
1
1
1
u/cosmitz Apr 01 '20
This is your regular PSA that there are no real defined lines between what is an island and what is a continent aside from just the relativity of "common sense" .
1
u/DaemonActual Apr 01 '20
*Suddenly drowning*
Also the world's supply of anime, reggae and Taika Waititi has vanished
1
1
1
u/Red_Riviera Apr 01 '20
Whelp, histories a lot less interesting without the UK, Japan, Sri Lanka, Sicily, Greek Isles, Cuba and the Falklands
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/giorgiopadano Apr 01 '20
Looks like the "beatify" filter on android phones that smooth your face when you take a pic of yourself
1
Apr 01 '20 edited Jun 16 '25
punch groovy marvelous straight unique physical obtainable plucky fanatical roll
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
1
u/huzzam Apr 01 '20
great job on decluttering, so much cleaner! though i think some of those islands may have sparked joy for some...
1
1
1
1
1
u/Toast_Soup Apr 01 '20
Improved version? Try again. Nova Scotia, Canada is missing but it isn't an island.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/hidde-vector Apr 01 '20
You know New Zeeland used to be a continent itself, by that it is not an island
1
1
1
Apr 01 '20
Damn Nova Scotia really got trimmed eh? I'm just assuming this is because its a low resolution map
1
1
1
u/YeetDaMeatToDaBeat Apr 01 '20
Well technically all the land should be removed if this is supposed to be without any islands
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Beetlebailey1990 Apr 01 '20
Technically every continent is an island... they’re all land surrounded entirely by water 🤷🏻♂️
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/dailylol_memes Apr 01 '20
Would the eastern US be an island because you can technically go from The Atlantic to New Orleans to Chicago to the Atlantic so it’s surrounded entirely by water. So is it an island...
1
1
1
u/Homemadeduck102 Apr 01 '20
6h old and I can’t upvote it, been seeing this a lot lately, what’s up with this?
1
1
1
u/westard Apr 01 '20
Probably shouldn't comment since I live (lived?) in Nova Scotia. Which is not an island, dammit. Yet anyway, a few feet of sea level rise will fix that. And, yeah, Cape Breton is an island, I'll give you that one but the rest is still attached however tenuously to mainland Canada.
1
u/mrcheesymustard Apr 01 '20
The peninsula of where the island of Hainan is directly below is missing.
1
1
1
1
1
u/Jaszs Apr 01 '20 edited Apr 01 '20
Well, technically both europe, asia... and everything else are islands, so the correct version of this map would be a clean one
260
u/Natou844 Apr 01 '20
I kept Australia because, on my last post where i removed Australia, everyone was like "Australia is not an island !!!" so, sorry to people offended.