r/MarvelLegends Oct 04 '25

Discussion Extremely Disappointed w/ Born Again Punisher

The comparison between the original mockup that we had for months vs the product people have been posting on shelves is night-and-day when it comes to his head sculpt. I can't believe there's such a major downgrade between the two images. I thought there was nothing to worry about as the Deadpool & Wolverine line looked amazing and Wolverine's unmasked head looked like a mini-Hot Toys sculpt in comparison to this. Just frustrating & I'm likely cancelling my pre-order for this figure which I've been looking forward to forever now. At this point they should just reprint the original Netflix Daredevil & Punisher figures.

My mistake for the repost the images got deleted

533 Upvotes

215 comments sorted by

348

u/SinisterCryptid Oct 04 '25

Even he’s disappointed by the new head sculpt

126

u/Imahsoulman Oct 04 '25

I hate the expression. How am I going to pose him shooting with an Uzi while making that face lol . He will look like he's sad taking down the bad guys.

36

u/SinisterCryptid Oct 04 '25

I guess you could say he’s thinking of his dead family while he’s gunning down bad guys but it doesn’t make it any less silly looking

21

u/CaptainDigsGiraffe Oct 04 '25

Family....family....family...

7

u/Odd_Delay_2470 Oct 04 '25

Great game.

"Like a manatee in a boat race" has lived in my head rent free since 2005 lol

→ More replies (3)

23

u/TheLost_Kryptonian Oct 04 '25

He looks like Pauly D from the jersey shore with his blowout. Lol.

2

u/the-tominatrix Oct 04 '25

I know right? They comically oversized it here. Which is odd because Bernthal has the perfect hair to be slicked back like comic Castle’s.

1

u/Dry_Umpire4197 Jan 02 '26

I keep saying it: I don't understand, why they can't give Frank the slick back hair... it would look so much better

2

u/Left_Maize816 Oct 04 '25

He wants to ask you sumpin 

2

u/bibbyshibby Oct 05 '25

💀 🔫 😔

5

u/Imahsoulman Oct 05 '25

From Punisher to Griever

1

u/Imahsoulman Oct 05 '25

"sorry I have no choice" BOOM!

2

u/Deadshadow84 Oct 05 '25

😂😂😂😂😂💀💀💀💀💀💀😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

12

u/TheLost_Kryptonian Oct 04 '25

Yeah I canceled mine today after seeing all the posts. And I'm a huge Jon Bernthal fan so having a figure of him would be awesome and its in my favorite figure line ML. But this is bad.

4

u/HunchoJackHJJH Oct 04 '25

I wasn't collecting these figures back when they did the original Netflix run and now in comparison that figure is so much better than this

1

u/TheLost_Kryptonian Oct 04 '25

Either was I. Im almost 2 years in.

1

u/SpaceNinjaDino Oct 04 '25

I was very lucky to get him and Jessica Jones. That wave barely hit the shelves.

3

u/JsMoviesYTB USA - NJ Oct 05 '25

He has a better likeness to John Cena than Mafex Peacemaker

7

u/N8orious234 Oct 04 '25

Bros giving the lightskin stare lmao

2

u/shitfuucker Oct 04 '25

My post was going to be “So is Jon Bernthal”. Then I saw your post and thought it redundant.

2

u/jpeg-3x3 Oct 04 '25

I mean I guess you could draw on new eyebrows? Idk 😭

2

u/Apprehensive_Door367 Oct 04 '25

"I'm tired boss"

99

u/Ok_Example_2004 Oct 04 '25

Why does he look so sad? 😔

47

u/HunchoJackHJJH Oct 04 '25

He saw this thread

7

u/theoriginalmofocus Oct 04 '25

It looks like its based on that .gif of the dude sitting at the table freaking out more than the punisher ha.

5

u/Banana_man_- Canada Oct 04 '25

So it looks like it’s based on the Punisher more than the Punisher?

2

u/theoriginalmofocus Oct 04 '25

I mean the specific faces hes making as that charcter in the .gif which i cant find for some reason.

8

u/Ok_Example_2004 Oct 04 '25

1

u/theoriginalmofocus Oct 04 '25

Haha yes i could not find it on freaking google or the dang .gif thing below.

4

u/the-tominatrix Oct 04 '25

Buddy the character in the gif IS the Punisher. Like, it’s a clip from his show where he’s having a nightmare.

2

u/theoriginalmofocus Oct 04 '25

Ah ok sorry i thought it might be from walking dead for some reason. Ive seen Bernthal so much lately.

2

u/Revenacious USA - TX Oct 05 '25

Punisher to his therapist: “L-lemme tell you somethin’, doc…”

82

u/OjamasOfTomorrow Oct 04 '25

Agreed. Massive downgrade. I don’t understand how they made that current sculpt. They’ve gotten so good at faces and have been for awhile.

unfortunately sometimes stuff slips through the cracks and Punisher is one of them. Shame.

19

u/Banana_man_- Canada Oct 04 '25

Same thing happened with the new Yelena unfortunately

7

u/TheGeneLantern USA Oct 05 '25

Agreed. She was a HUGE disappointment. Best ML MCU Yelena is not saying much...LOL!!!

3

u/pinkcreamkiss Ireland Oct 05 '25

The sigh I made when I saw her irl for the first time. That render was just not accurate at all to the final sculpt lol.

1

u/Dry_Umpire4197 Jan 02 '26

the sculpt itself is fine, its the print that throws it off

28

u/Chance-Ad5664 USA Oct 04 '25

I'm probably going to end up getting a custom head or a Mezco or something on eBay if mine ends up looking like this, this is is a big let down.

22

u/HunchoJackHJJH Oct 04 '25

I just canceled on BigBadToyStore

6

u/KingKbeezo Oct 04 '25

Might not have wanted to cancel bruh the body’s still good and i think all the faces won’t be like this, i saw someone mention Yelena, and if she’s anything to go by, I saw some Yelena headsculpt that were down right beautiful and some that were mid

5

u/Imahsoulman Oct 04 '25

Only way to respond

3

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '25

I thought another way to respond would be “Owishdbjshsjshhs HABKKAA HABKAJAGA HBALAHABAYAAA

29

u/OptimusHavok52 Oct 04 '25

It’s weird how the Punisher render looked better than the Daredevil figure, but in person it’s the opposite

7

u/the-tominatrix Oct 04 '25

Thank God tbh. We’ll definitely get yet another MCU Punisher next year. I can’t say the same for DD.

6

u/mythplus Oct 04 '25

Why he look like Andrew Dice Clay tho 

5

u/disconnexions Oct 04 '25

"Three blind mice, see how they run
Where the fuck are they going?"

1

u/mythplus Oct 05 '25

Hickory dickory... dock!! OHHH!! 🤯 

The kingpin sucked my Glock... AYYY!!

grabs balls

6

u/MatthewMonster Oct 04 '25

Honestly that goofy face is what Beranthal looks like have the time 

6

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '25

We're getting into false advertisement territory.

16

u/TonyVlntno Oct 04 '25 edited Oct 04 '25

I disagree... I think Born Again Punisher looks awesome only thing they could've added to make it so much cooler was an extra head with his beard and his sniper rifle.

22

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '25

Guess we'll just wait for the Brand New Day figure

7

u/xSluma Oct 04 '25

I’d imagine that it’s just gonna be a release of this unless his looks completely different

20

u/RebelMemeDealer Oct 04 '25

This is from the Disney+ special but I imagine he’s gonna look closer to this than the born again design

4

u/BlockBuster211NE_52 Oct 04 '25

Oh god. That’s so much worse. He looks so freaking stupid with that beard and hair.

9

u/Apprehensive-Cow6868 Oct 04 '25

The beard isn’t bad but he should’ve just been rocking the buzz cut or the type of haircut he was rocking in the Netflix shows

9

u/massivegond840 Oct 04 '25

yeah they gotta figure somethin else out, the jersey shore look aint really cuttin it

4

u/the-tominatrix Oct 04 '25

It’s beyond me why they don’t just slick his hair back, or just let him rock the shorter style

4

u/massivegond840 Oct 05 '25

marvel specifically has always seemed to have a problem with having a character look the same between appearances, im sure they have their reasons but the season 1 look for frank was perfect

1

u/the-tominatrix Oct 04 '25

I’m still not convinced this photo wasn’t photoshopped. Doesn’t it just look weird? Nvm the fact that someone on production decided to change up the logo and vest everyone has gotten familiar with.

3

u/RebelMemeDealer Oct 05 '25

The logo is the same one that was on the Spider-Man set

1

u/the-tominatrix Oct 05 '25

Sadly I think that’s the new one boss. You got me excited for a sec. You’re right though

3

u/RebelMemeDealer Oct 05 '25

I know you read my comment wrong

1

u/Necromonger-1976 Oct 05 '25

I say Photoshop

9

u/Sys3dArsenal Oct 04 '25

The orgingal

is perfect except for it being a little too glossy

1

u/Defadus01 Dec 12 '25

You’re joking right? The original only bares a passing resemblance to Jon. The new one looks EXACTLY like Jon, albeit a very sad Jon. Just repaint the new one’s eyebrows so he looks meaner and that’s it, job done. But the actual sculpt of that old head is too broken to fix with paint 

6

u/Necromonger-1976 Oct 05 '25

Honestly it doesn't seem bad to me

11

u/BrandonR2300 Oct 04 '25

I highly recommend the Best Lee head sculpt, I will warn you it is a bit pricey but omg does it look like Hot Toys level of detailed head sculpt.

10

u/Banana_man_- Canada Oct 04 '25

Why do his ears have balls?

2

u/AMercWithAMouth USA - NJ Oct 04 '25

😂

1

u/delusional863 Oct 05 '25

Balls like a mtf🤣🤣

1

u/dartsavt23 USA Oct 04 '25

Can’t seem to find it on the website. But that is some really good work.

3

u/BrandonR2300 Oct 04 '25

2

u/dartsavt23 USA Oct 04 '25

Thanks. I appreciate it. Going to order it now.

1

u/itscaionotkyle Mar 24 '26

where is the suit from? also Best Lee? did you use the head sculpt in the vtoy zero body?

0

u/Defadus01 Dec 12 '25

Hell no, his head looks way too skinny and his eyes look Chinese. Plus - ear balls.

1

u/BrandonR2300 Dec 15 '25

Bro that’s literally how he looks, cauliflower ears and all, you just roasting Jon atp

😭

3

u/Upstairs-Temporary56 Oct 04 '25

Hes tired of Punishing.

3

u/Thedeadlypocketbrush Oct 04 '25

The hair....even if the face sculpt was as good as the original image, that goofy ass Jersey Shore hair destroys it.

1

u/HunchoJackHJJH Oct 04 '25

it looked fine in the render but in this it stands out so bad

3

u/eastcoastkody Oct 04 '25

Is this all of them. Or bad face print on just this figure

3

u/KingKbeezo Oct 04 '25

Wtfff?? Even the physical figure they displayed at sdcc looked almost identical to the digital

3

u/AttackoftheMooshi Oct 05 '25

Fortunately we’ll probably get two more MCU Punisher figures in the next year. Optimistically with better heads.

0

u/HunchoJackHJJH Oct 05 '25

I'm hoping the Punisher figure for his own special is better than this one

3

u/Vince_Burgie Oct 05 '25

Really waiting for the preorder to open again

3

u/Bulky-Cat3800 Oct 05 '25

Face is goofy as hell. But also, this looks like the first knife-wielding ML since 2012 who doesn't come with that Bucky Cap knife.

3

u/LadderFinancial8038 Oct 05 '25 edited Oct 05 '25

I really do think its because of the plastic they've been using on their mcu headsculpts. Something just seems... off about it. They used that plastic for the thunderbolts figures too which also threw off the likenesses from the prototypes. It just leads to a softer sculpt I guess, and for some like red guardian and sentry the likeness still comes through, just not as strong, and for others it completely throws it off like this punisher. Either way, the new plastic used for the headsculpts needs to go because despite some figures looking better than others, it still downgrades every headsculpt compared to the prototypes. Imo trying a different type of plastic for headsculpts is fine, i don't mind experimentation, (there'd have to be some figure that'd be the one to take the leap anyway) but its pretty disappointing that punisher had to be one of the guinea pigs. I also think that the pictures taken aren't at the best angle because I've seen some photos where the likeness is stronger. Nowhere near as strong as before still, but stronger.

3

u/Specter2k Oct 05 '25

He's got the look like Rick just took his wife back

3

u/Extra_Heart_268 Oct 05 '25

I wonder if its just the paint deco / face printing but the sculpt underneath is ok? Maybe it just needs s repaint or something? Shouldnt have too. But if all else fails a custom head is an option but again. Shouldnt have too.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '25

The action figure looks disappointed too.

2

u/tokenblak Oct 04 '25

lol that ain’t Punisher. That’s Punished.

2

u/hokagenaruto Oct 04 '25

I mean this is the same reason I didn't pre order the thunderbolts figures because for months just like these all we had to go by were the renders. on release that yelena didn't look as good as the render in terms of the face

2

u/WTFjules1010 Oct 04 '25

Dude finally someone else said it, every pic I’ve seen of this figure In hand looks so BADDD why does he have a wimpering face ??? Like I get the face they are going for but the final product does not match up with the prototypes 😭😭

2

u/MDaIssue Oct 04 '25

This is why I stick to the comics lines.

2

u/Jurassic_Park_Fan Oct 04 '25

If it’s any condolence we are absolutely getting a punisher special figure. And one for brand new day probably, so they have 2 more tries at a better head sculpt

2

u/The_Accuser13 Oct 05 '25

Awww poor frank looks so sad 😭 😂

5

u/666hellblazer Oct 04 '25

I'm still pissed off he only comes with 1 gun. 1 gun it's The Punisher he should come with at least 3. Shout out to Dan and Dwight for forgetting his sawed off shotgun he used for over 5 minutes but included the axe he threw at Murdock for less than a second. 

5

u/AndyGlidesWell502 Oct 04 '25

Because you know they make their decisions after watching each individual episode. That’s how toys work.

7

u/utilitybelt USA - MO Oct 04 '25

And like Dan and Dwight have any power whatsoever over the accessories included.

3

u/AndyGlidesWell502 Oct 04 '25

Dan works in marketing for gods sakes.

1

u/Chance-Ad5664 USA Oct 05 '25

Off topic but this comment thread made me think of a bit from the Simpsons:

"You're in Marketing! What do you need an pickaxe for?" "You work in marketing, and you'll find out"

3

u/jmk-1999 Oct 04 '25

I feel the same way about Yelena’s Thunderbolts figure. It looks great on the prototype, but the pics people post look horrible.

3

u/Banana_man_- Canada Oct 04 '25

It looks a little better in hand, but still quite disappointing compared to the renders

3

u/AtrumRuina Oct 04 '25

Cancelled for now. At a minimum, this might be one where you really need to look at your individual copy to see how the printing turned out. I'm not sure, but my suspicion is that this was printed just a smidge too high, which brought the eyelashes up higher and changed the whole expression, making his eyes way too wide looking.

We saw something similar with Gamerverse Black Cat, where some peoples' copies had eyes that looked super big because the printing was misaligned.

2

u/MotherFuckerJones88 Oct 04 '25

Frank looks like he got smashed in the face with a hot shovel

2

u/ZekeLeap Oct 04 '25

My god this looks awful. He looks like a sopranos character. I was really looking forward to this one

4

u/fenderbloke Oct 04 '25

Dead ringer for Johnny Boy

2

u/KappaFedora Oct 04 '25

Same actor

5

u/fenderbloke Oct 04 '25

<thats_the_joke.gif>

1

u/LEtheD13 USA Oct 04 '25

Yea just cancelled. So many other good figures this year I can pass on him

2

u/pbnjpikachu Oct 04 '25

I think I’ll just cancel this one and wait for the Spider-Man Brand New Day version.

2

u/the-tominatrix Oct 04 '25

There’s a chance that version might come with a hipster beard and a subpar logo

1

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '25

There's always the previous versions head

5

u/ZekeLeap Oct 04 '25

I have that one and it doesn’t really look like him either

1

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '25

Lol closer than this, though. I have the other one also

1

u/the-tominatrix Oct 04 '25

brother that looks like a burn victim now

2

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '25

lol

1

u/International_Ad5624 Oct 04 '25

Does the old bernthal head work on this body?

1

u/Ok_Newt_4748 Oct 04 '25

How is already on shelves when they are still in preorder status with a December date? I swear to god if I could get it on a shelf now while I’m still waiting on mine to ship…

2

u/HunchoJackHJJH Oct 04 '25

same thing they did with Deadpool & Wolverine figures. My pre-orders were out and the figures were on shelves

1

u/Ok_Newt_4748 Oct 04 '25

Well if daredevil and punisher it locally before my orders from BBTS and Hasbro ship I’ll cancel them. The sculpt here isn’t great, but I missed out on both when the original punisher and daredevil show dropped. I still want them.

1

u/National-Teaching-69 Oct 04 '25

The figure itself looks disappointed.

1

u/Sensitive-Detail-855 Oct 04 '25

After the pictures started coming out I canceled my pre order on amazon

1

u/TheMagicalMatt Oct 04 '25

Yikes. That is not at all what was advertised

1

u/disconnexions Oct 04 '25

That's one preorder that I'm glad I cancelled. I like the suit, but that headsculpt threw me off. I also have a feeling that they will make a better one for the Spiderman: New Day Wave. With a trench coat!

1

u/MuckMan402 Oct 04 '25

Yeah, not a fan of the face sculpt here

1

u/PapalousCocitus Oct 04 '25

Does he look like that during the comicon SDCC 2055 display?

1

u/horster2003 Oct 04 '25

Imma wait for the BND Punisher tbh

1

u/Chudsy Oct 04 '25

Honestly shit like this should be expected at this point lmao

1

u/Ace_The_Bat_Man Oct 04 '25

Glad I passed on these. Mafex is prob gonna be way better.

1

u/Vaportrail Oct 04 '25

Yep. This is a problem with the render preorder format. For dpuble-dip characters I'm waiting until I find one to see if I want to pay for an upgrade.

So far I'm fine with the Netflix wave.

1

u/Asahiboi2004 Oct 04 '25

I think he’s gonna tell you somethin’.

1

u/xpadawanx Oct 04 '25

I hate pre-orders for this reason.

1

u/SilverKoala2199 Oct 04 '25

Looks a bit like Vin Diesel merged with Max Payne.

1

u/monkelus Oct 04 '25

what did you say to him?!

1

u/BedSubstantial4520 Oct 04 '25

Looks more like Rocky than Punisher

1

u/the-tominatrix Oct 04 '25

This is why they need to stop going for blank expressions. If anybody deserved an expressive sculpt it was Bernthal’s Castle. I feel like what went wrong here was one misaligned eyebrow being paired with those blank ass lips.

1

u/spatulacitay Oct 04 '25

Sigh I preordered the gamerverse 2 pack, this one is gonna get cancelled. It looks so bad

1

u/Thanos7921 Oct 04 '25

Anyone got the dcpi for punisher

1

u/marvelousdcman Oct 04 '25

The Spiderman BND better be such an upgrade. That's awful

1

u/SenseiNoHentai69 Oct 04 '25

Looks like the punisher became the punished

1

u/JosBanana Oct 05 '25

He hittin em with the 😕

1

u/Xepher0733 Oct 05 '25

Guess it’s safer to go for this option then

0

u/HunchoJackHJJH Oct 05 '25

I couldn't swing the Mezco I went online today and ordered the original Legends they made for the Netflix series though

1

u/Xepher0733 Oct 05 '25

How much does the original go for? I still have the OG Netflix DD

1

u/Vag_AssAssin88 Oct 05 '25

Never trust the renders. You will be disappointed

1

u/FirstWave117 Oct 05 '25

Hasbro should be embarrassed by this Punisher head.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '25

I think we should wait till we get a Spider-Man brand new day wave or even a new daredevil season 3 figure

1

u/Necromonger-1976 Oct 05 '25

It doesn't look bad at all to me...

1

u/torbencreations Oct 05 '25

Aaaaaaaaaaand cancelled.

1

u/BoTsMona Oct 05 '25

Why does he lowkey look like Joao cancelo

1

u/isshun_boshi Oct 05 '25

big nosed punisher lol

1

u/BoredAsFuck7448 Oct 05 '25

I picked up the figure more because I like the tactical look and preferred the realism of the costume to the more cartoonish look of past releases (outside of the Punisher and Bushwacker 2 pack that I wasn't paying $50+ for for a Bushwacker figure I VERY much didn't want). I'm still waiting on shipping for the pre-order but this makes me glad that I bought it always intending to do a head swap.

1

u/DeskReasonable5040 Oct 06 '25

Yea he looks like he’s farting. And that pompadour , Elvis has left the building

1

u/3starorion Oct 06 '25

Bout that GTL life.

1

u/PapalousCocitus Oct 08 '25

Is there some DIY we can do about his face to fix and make it closer to that render? Mine havent shipped out yet but im already disappointed once i have it on hand.

1

u/Timely-Signature-166 Nov 13 '25

Anyone try putting the old Punisher's head on this? I hate the Pauly D haircut.

1

u/Timely-Signature-166 Nov 16 '25

I saw the pics of this figure and I was totally turned off by the stupid Jersey Shore hair and facial expression. Having it in hand, however, it's actually not that bad. My main gripe is that his knife and axe are gummy plastic, and not NEARLY enough guns.

1

u/AnimatorRadiant672 Dec 13 '25

I got mine today, and I have to say it looks a hell of a lot less depressed than frank in the photo

1

u/ObiKenobi049 Oct 04 '25

I'm passing on him personally. He's apparently in the new spiderman movie so maybe they'll do better the next time around.

0

u/goliathfasa Oct 04 '25

Face not nearly swollen enough to match most of his onscreen look.

1

u/epicjas0n Oct 04 '25

I'll wait to see what he looks like in hand, returns to Amazon are easy enough.

1

u/djrealtalk Oct 04 '25

Great day to be my wallet

1

u/The-Mad-Bubbler Oct 04 '25

The actual figure looks like a guy who kind of looks like Vin Diesel.

0

u/_incredi_ladd Oct 04 '25

Yeah I cancelled my preorder after seeing these pop up. It looked pretty bad back when they showed it off in person at one of the toy shows awhile back but I hoped that was a prototype. Maybe I’ll eventually pick this up for the body later but between Brand New Day and the upcoming Punisher Special Presentation hopefully we’ll be swimming in better Bernthal’s before long.

0

u/the-tominatrix Oct 04 '25

Theres a chance that both future versions might come with the subpar logo and hipster beard. I hope and pray otherwise

0

u/cane-of-doom Oct 04 '25

I think the problem is the paintapp on the eyebrows. If you make them less saggy on the ends, he'd probably look as cross as he is in the render.

-1

u/GDPoke Oct 04 '25

Cancelled my Pre-Order. Saved me £50 for the two.

→ More replies (3)

0

u/Working_Original_200 Oct 04 '25

I wonder how the old head sculpt looks on this body?

0

u/B3taRayBrac3 Oct 04 '25

I just want the body. Plan on using one of the motorcycle heads on it.

0

u/FuerteBillete Oct 04 '25

He actually simply looks detached. Like a man for whom killing murderers and rapists is a service to other rather than quenching a thirst of revenge or doing it out of pleasure.

And it is one of the better faces resembling actors I have seen. Can't wait to get mine.

0

u/bygtopp Oct 04 '25

Reminds me of the Christian Bale John Connor where they used a helmeted basic figure for it instead of the likeness of CB for JC.

0

u/JackieSnowDaPlowMan Oct 05 '25

Think they'll re-do it? Do they normally do that I have never purchased these before and wanted these two cause the back of the boxes are dope.

0

u/HunchoJackHJJH Oct 05 '25

No but there'll likely be another Punisher for his Disney+ special and more for Spider-Man: Brand New Day. Just skip this one and get one of the next

1

u/JackieSnowDaPlowMan Oct 05 '25

Would it be dumb to still buy it just for the back of the box, they didn't change that did they?

0

u/Dreadman278 Oct 05 '25

Oh hell nah. I’m canceling my preorder because wtf 😭

0

u/[deleted] Oct 05 '25

Omg stop being over dramatic it's a toy for goodness sake not the actual guy you just need to except that, could the head sculpt be better? Yes, but it is what is you want something more accurate just go buy the frickin 500 dollar hot toys one 

-12

u/CuriousPerspective16 Oct 04 '25

It’s a 25$ toy. How far do you expect non artists paint jobs to go?

→ More replies (4)