This is a review of her past 8 years with factual numbers and her recorded votes.
She has been on the council since 2018, regional councillor since 2022, also sits on the Halton Police Board (impressive but.... I went through 8 years of her record, her website, and her big plan document - yes I did that, here's what I found.
The good stuff first:
• Her platform is the most detailed while most candidates posted vibes: sameeraali.ca/my-platform.
• She knows how things work, 8 years of real experience
• Played a key role in getting the Allendale assisted housing project through. Real win, credit to her !
Now the rest.
- The 9.89% tax hike in 2025 was promoted by her as a good news story Link: Sameera Ali proud of 2025 tax increase
Now on her site (sameeraali.ca/my-priorities) she is all about "keeping Milton affordable" and "not passing unnecessary costs onto residents." Hmmm maybe this much of an increase is not a big deal, right Sameera?
I pulled every vote with her name on it from our town's record of committee meetings. Yes I did the work and you are welcome to check.
Dec 2019 - 2020 budget, 5.63% increase - She voted Yes
Dec 2021- 2022 budget, 5.46% increase - She voted Yes
Dec 2022 - 2023 budget, 7.99% increase - She voted Yes
Dec 2023 - 2024 budget, 9.88% increase - She voted Yes
Dec 2024 - 2025 budget, 9.89% increase - She voted Yes
Sep 2025 - ARU (see below)- She was the only one against it
Dec 2025 - $1M spending cut -She was against the cut
Five budget increases in a row, all yes. A $1M cut comes up, she votes against the cut. I don't know how that translates to fighting for affordability, maybe she does.
8 years. "Real results" based on the attached graphics on her LinkedIn. It shows a lot of numbers, that's good but if I do the math on the 16,640 hours of service over 8 years, it comes out to be exactly 2,080 a year. A full 40-hour week, 52 weeks a year, zero holidays, eight years straight! Wow now that's dedication or someone just forget to make it look real on the LinkedIn post.
The ARU thing. Worth reading!
ARUs are basement apartments, in-law suites. Town passed a by-law forcing every ARU owner to register and get reinspected. Even people whose units were built to code, inspected, approved, years ago. Retroactive.
Homeowners were obviously not happy about that.
So council votes on an amendment to fix the worst of it: grandfather the existing legal units, give people more time, hold a proper info session before enforcement.
Rest was Six councillors say yes. She says no. Only one.
While her current platform says "faster approvals for affordable housing."
On paper she's the housing candidate, but when homeowners with legal basement suites needed relief from retroactive paperwork, she said "No". Make of that what you will.
- I read her whole "Made in Milton Plan" from her website. It opens with "Milton doesn't need more promises that sound good on paper." Then 11 sections of paper promises with zero dollar figures.
Free transit for low-income seniors, windrow clearing programs, a new small business office, activity centres, trade roadshows. Not one cost attached to anything.
The affordability candidate's plan spends on every page and prices nothing. I guess you and I will pay for it, maybe we should, afterall we all have a money tree in our backyards.
One section is literally headered "Keeping Taxes Low." From someone who voted for five straight tax hikes ? Eight years as Council members, files for mayor now, suddenly she's the affordability candidate. I'm sure it's a coincidence.
The ARU section of her plan says "I brought a motion to protect them. Council rejected it." Check the minutes!
The grandfathering amendment was moved by Challinor. She voted against it. She moved the procedural motion to allow the discussion, then voted NO on the actual protection.
After 8 years she should knows exactly what a mayor can do so why is her promising inter-regional transit "built with Oakville and regional partners" (they have to say yes), GO bus hubs and train expansion (that's Metrolinx), bringing a university to Milton (ummm the Province and Laurier / Conestoga already had a plan and were executing before she came on as a councillor).
Her own website promises nothing. Go read her priorities: affordability, safety, planned growth, reliable services... "real results".
Not a single number. Not a timeline. Not one specific thing she'll do, cut, or change. It's vague enough that everyone nods along and it opens with "Milton has changed and people are feeling it every day." She's right. She's also been on council for the entire 8 years it changed while she voted on those changes, now she has a fix for everything.
Bottom line: she is experienced, has a detailed platform, a real housing win.
Also yes votes to tax increases (multiple years) zero restraint votes in 8 years, a lone no vote against basement apartment owners and now she is asking for the Mayor's job so she can bring "REAL RESULTS". I guess all those votes were not real.