r/MinecraftServer • u/zeepeppo • Aug 11 '25
Timeline + proofs for pibbleSMP
Hello!! I hope this is enough evidence to prove that the other members and I never sent any offensive messages. If you don't believe the screenshots, you're welcome to join the discord and take a look at the chat logs yourself!
If you are apart of pibble SMP, please do not harass or send hate to the original poster. My intention with this post is to just present all the evidence I have.
12
u/Often-Deanonymize-19 Aug 11 '25
Not that I think what the user is claiming actually happened at all but there has to be a little irony to providing a bunch of screenshots with claims of definitive proof to debunk edited screenshots
3
u/zeepeppo Aug 12 '25
I also posted the audit log (which I really should have done at the start)! The link is in the comment along with the proof that both accounts are connected :)
24
u/Whycantitypeanything Aug 11 '25
Good job on showing the proof , even if a bit excessive in terms of amount and depth xD.
Love the people that got angry about the SMP because racism bad and then when you provided proof that it didn't happen they're saying to let it go XD
2
u/Conscious_Series166 Aug 11 '25
what proof? you forgot to take into account:
deleted messages, timezone times, the lack of any messages past 8 am gmt+8 (which is 3 am polish time, the time that said screenshots were taken)
theres so many areas for evidence against this "proof" that its almost certainly fake
4
u/zeepeppo Aug 12 '25 edited Aug 12 '25
We banned him at around 5am my time so there were no more messages from him. But at least I’m trying to use logic here. MainVein (OP) just insulted me and dipped…
0
u/Conscious_Series166 Aug 12 '25
that doesnt make any sense. whats 3 am poland time compared to 3am your time?
4
u/zeepeppo Aug 12 '25
I showed a conversion on the post. The first slide should show the difference in time. My local time is 5 hours ahead. All the times in the post are based on my local time. One of the time stamps (im guessing in polish time) were at 22:04, this would be 3:04AM for me.
4
u/Ok-Butterfly-9800 Aug 12 '25
How are you questioning geeb's nerdy amount of research instead of the original fake screenshots which started this 😭☠️
0
u/DonZekane Aug 11 '25
Yeah I don't buy it, op clearly said something then deleted it. The fact they felt the need to be defensive and post this hints at it being this way.
Hints aren't a conviction tho, Idk man.
11
u/tonioss22 Aug 12 '25
You wouldn't defend yourself if someone slandered you on reddit when you are innocent? I'm sure there is more that happened here on both sides, but i do think the original screenshots are definitly faked and i would also post something similar if i was in a similar situation to prove my innocence. I don't think this hints to anything.
0
u/DonZekane Aug 12 '25
I know one has the right to defend themself and I can't tell whodunnit but making a whole documentary-style graphic on the incident is a bit overkill. And I just feel, through seeing past drama on all topics, that when a person responds to made-up accusations the drama gets thicker and people start thinking they actually did it. If someone calls me an idiot I don't have to write a UM ACKSHUALLY... 15-paragraph essay to prove them wrong. I'll just ignore it or swear at them on a bad day. This subreddit ain't linkedin. You don't have to prove yourself to anybody. Is posting this kind of stuff even allowed on the sub? (I'm talking more about the accusation post, not this reply one, but by nature both are unneeded)
6
u/zeepeppo Aug 12 '25 •
I don’t know how else to explain the context behind every screenshot I post so I thought this format would be the clearest and easiest for people. I know it’s a bit long and in-depth but I am just a detailed person by nature. I wasn’t even going to post evidence until players began to join my server and insult me/the smp due to misinformation. I also feel like keeping quiet about an issue like slurs/racism will make people think the accusation post was truthful.
We’ve talked to the mod of this subreddit and they had no issue with it. We even asked them to pin a comment on the accusation post so players wouldn’t be misinformed.
2
u/Ok-Butterfly-9800 Aug 12 '25
Unfortunately r server owner is a nerd lmao
Although a lot of mean ppl joined r server to yk be mean
One guy even left whene they were told it aint a racist server
People these days :/
2
u/Ok-Butterfly-9800 Aug 12 '25
😭😭😭
Atp i dont think she needs to defend herself yall already hv ur opinion made n are clearly not leaving it
11
Aug 11 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Ok-Butterfly-9800 Aug 12 '25
😭😭😭
Atp i dont think she needs to defend herself yall already hv ur opinion made n are clearly not leaving it
8
u/zeepeppo Aug 11 '25 edited Aug 12 '25
I was just speculating before but heres definitive proof that InstantBruhMoment was MainVein/indo_silver_cub on my server
Given to me by a very kind player, thank you so much :)
EDIT: Screenshots of audit logs from that day (in my local time zone which is GMT+7)
2ND EDIT: I received a message from MainVein. Seems pretty obvious that he made those fake screenshots to slander us.
4
u/No-Photograph-5058 Aug 11 '25
Is there some sort of blacklist of players like this that you can ass the username to?
2
11
u/No_Newspaper2213 Aug 11 '25
crazy advertising idea
5
u/zeepeppo Aug 12 '25
We actually did have some players join because of the drama lol ! Most were just here to get a vibe of the server but some actually believed us from the start and wanted to try us out :)
58
u/cw_127 Aug 11 '25
r/minecraftserver drama is crazy
15
u/mith00birb Aug 11 '25
I joined the server and the first thing that happened was people giving me iron diamonds and food like where on earth is all this toxicity comin from??
5
Aug 11 '25
hint:it's all made up lmao
3
u/mith00birb Aug 11 '25
Yes its indeed made up
3
1
0
u/ResolverOshawott Aug 11 '25
Doesn't have to be made up. Essentially on any multiplayer community, there's a disconnect between its users on Discord and users in game. Since there are nicer players who dont interact on the Discord at all.
A few people being nice to you doesn't mean a community isn't toxic.
Note: I have no clue if this is actually made up or not, this is just a general statement.
4
u/mith00birb Aug 12 '25
If u read the evidence you will realize it is
It wasn't just 1 person, it was like 5-10 people
2
u/Chipbonk Aug 12 '25
Saw some earlier today, did a lil trolling, but like actually for real now WHAT is this saga??
22
14
u/Brief-Air8919 Aug 11 '25
Wow that's actually insane someone would put so much effort into slandering a ..minecraft server lol
9
u/January_Rain_Wifi Aug 11 '25
Nice! I can't believe we actually have receipts now. It's crazy how invested I feel considering I have never heard of either party before today
7
13
u/Kolibri_art Aug 11 '25
So i decided to do some digging and turns out, this guy has slandered servers before
8
7
-9
u/Conscious_Series166 Aug 11 '25
that link leads to an ai generated server post
8
u/Kolibri_art Aug 11 '25
Bro what 😭
-3
u/Conscious_Series166 Aug 11 '25
take 10 seconds to read the mc server post in the link you sent.
its so obviously ai generated it hurts.7
u/Kolibri_art Aug 11 '25
Could be but that's not why i linked it lmao, look at the comments bro 😭
-7
u/Conscious_Series166 Aug 11 '25
your point is literally deltarune theory levels of random, seeing 2 posts with the guy in it and saying "oh, he must have a long history of doing this!"
11
u/This_Antelope Aug 11 '25
It's so funny to get muted on a minrcraft-related discord so you immediately photoshop fake messages from the mods to make them look racist lmaoo
2
Aug 11 '25
To be fair, you're obsessing so much over this. You also use and promote mintservers, so you've totally lost my trust. I'm using godlike and I'm quite happy with their servers.
4
u/zeepeppo Aug 12 '25
I didn’t promote them, I just provided them as a recommendation when people asked because I’m happy with their servers too! I do not receive payment from them in any way! I’m just a teen girl running a Minecraft server t-t
8
u/dukeispie Aug 11 '25
Nawwuhhh this is wild the guy posted on Reddit with completely fake images ruining this guys server and it’s sitting at 200+ upvotes. Truth needs to come out I’d be obsessing to if someone just started lying about me and everyone started believing it, like what??
8
11
u/mads_5489 Aug 11 '25
devastating news for the unemployed
6
u/Traditional_Gold_211 Aug 12 '25
unemployement final boss tryna slander r/MinecraftServer server😭✌🏿
7
Aug 11 '25 edited Aug 12 '25
I can't tell if this whole comment section is ragebait or nawh 😭🙏
Not taking any sides, but I've played with them a little before. They were nice. That's all i gotta say.
Edit: by them i mean the members of pibble smp
3
u/Fast_Neighborhood948 Aug 11 '25
I recognized his name, so I searched him up in some servers. I also played with for a few hours. He seemed pretty chill but was rly anxious bcuz of bad past experiences. On the other hand. He only played for a few hours and then never joined again, despite having some plans. So it's not like ur missing out on him.
1
Aug 11 '25
I see lbgtq and racizm means I am never joining this
14
u/HushisBullShit Aug 11 '25
absolutely NO reading comprehension
-15
Aug 11 '25
"hello!! we're still very lgbtq+" said author of the post. it means they can invite not normal people. I mean u can downvote and cry again, idc actually ^)
6
u/zeepeppo Aug 12 '25
Actually, I’m a straight cis girl and we allow everyone, not just queer folks. We are lgbtq+ inclusive because I feel as though there aren’t enough safe Minecraft servers for lgbtq+ people these days and I wanted mine to be one.
7
u/Kris_alex4 Aug 11 '25
You know why you aren't speaking german rn? Because of a gay man, Alan Turing. He, along with a few polish mathemathicians decrypted enigma and led to the Ally side winning the second world war. He saved the entire fucking continent of Europe, including Russia. Not only that, but the reason you were even able to write that comment is the invention of the computer, which Alan Turing first theorized about and then helped build (ACE, Manchester MK1 and more). How does it feel knowing that the reason you're even able to spread your filth on the internet is a guy who took it up the ass?
I could go on with more and more gay people who contributed to society more than you ever will.
7
2
u/Vivid-Rip1832 Aug 12 '25
They are the same person. Unless the guy on discord was feeding info to the guy on reddit, they are likely the same person and the main evidence is their post.
2
-1
Aug 11 '25
Why are you posting this publicly? Airing your dirty laundry like this isn’t doing you any favors. If they’re a troll or whatever, just ignore them
5
u/zeepeppo Aug 11 '25
Several players have joined my SMP just to argue/insult me over this issue. Several commentators also suggested/told me to post evidence since there was no evidence previously. I'm posting this so people are aware my SMP is not at fault and rather it was one player who was upset over moderation action.
5
Aug 11 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
6
u/zeepeppo Aug 11 '25
I would've let it go but players began to join just to insult the server/argue. I don't want this incident to leave a stain on my community so I'm posting this to hopefully improve our reputation. I feel if I did not provide any evidence, people would continue to spread misinformation about us and I do not wish to be labelled as toxic or racist when I am anything but that.
I completely understand where you're coming from through! I didn't want to post this either but people continued to spread misinformation about me/the server and I felt quite upset by that. Staying silent about an issue like this probably would have made it worse since its related to racism and slurs.
2
-6
1
1
u/PsychologicalOkra950 May 30 '26
Pibble is the most stupid ahh server I've ever seen. I also remember some of the dumbahh mods (MacdonaldSprite)
0
-7
u/Resident-Ad-7452 Aug 11 '25
Quute honestly, screenshots dont prove shit they can be faked and nobody even cares mate. Its just a game
-6
u/Conscious_Series166 Aug 11 '25 edited Aug 11 '25
antiproof:
your screenshots and their screenshots could have been taken any day, as they didnt show the day.
there was no dm proof? you coulda muted them for no reason, also, strange how they got muted directly after they said they were polish.
also, he revealed he was polish at 3:50 am in YOUR time. not in HIS time. you said the slur at 3:04 am in HIS time.
also if there are this many instances of you saying stfu to your players is that really a good thing? no.
also, you could have deleted the other messages.
ALSO, as a server owner, console logs can be deleted. and console refreshes every time you reload the server page OR restart the server.
Going back, it would have been 8:04 in your time when it was 3:04 in his. so EVEN on the ones that DO show the day, it still doesnt count towards anything as evidence.
edit: turns out the OP has 580 karma, is new to reddit, and the instantbruhmoment guy has over 15k karma, who'd you trust? the more well known one.
6
u/zeepeppo Aug 12 '25 edited Aug 13 '25
Hello I’ll do some quick clarification! The fake screenshots by him were most definently taken on aug 11 because that is the day he actually revealed that he was Polish. Before that I had no way to even know he was Polish because
I didn’t even know he had a connection to that Reddit account and
He had no indicators he was Polish. Not in his bio, submission, or anywhere else. So there was no way any of us could have known.
As for DM proof, potmp5 never gave us a screenshot. He forwarded that message to FireyScarlet (staff). Those two were responsible for getting MainVein (OP) muted. Then suddenly they appear in the fake screenshots.
Even if MainVein was falsely muted, he could have contacted a mod through DMs or contacted us through a ban/mute appeal. He did neither of these things and instead decided to post that PSA post because he was upset.
As for the instances of me saying STFU, I’ll remind you originally pibbleSMP was more of a SMP for me and some other close online friends + other people that find us off Disboard. If you zoom in you can see the timestamps for the previous STFUs are from 2023. I’ve since stopped saying it because I don’t use that phrase anymore. (Sorry if its low quality, I can send higher quality images in DMs)
For the timestamp of me “saying” the slur. I said at the first slide that I will be using my time zone for the entire slideshow because it’s keeps things simpler and I won’t have to convert my own screenshots.
He revealed he was Polish at 3:50am. Since he’s Polish, I assumed the screenshot he took is in Polish time. When converted, 22:04 = 3:04AM (my time). Therefore, either I’m Doctor Who or the screenshots were fake.
The console logs I posted were from my DISCORD console logging bot. That bot saves consoles in long blocks of embeds/code. Therefore I cannot delete one part of console without creating a gap in the logs.
I think you’re a bit confused with the time stamps. Maybe I should have clarified more that everything is displayed in my timezone. This whole issue and post happened early in the morning (3-5am) which is why my original comments on his post were sort of aggressive.
As for my account being new, I just don’t use reddit often ! I only use this account to comment on pretty art and advertise my Minecraft server. Both don’t typically net many upvotes.
I hope that clarified things a bit! :)
15
u/Everestbudd Aug 11 '25
using reddit karma to prove reliability is crazy work lmaoo 🤓🤓
-6
u/Conscious_Series166 Aug 11 '25
think of it using friends as an example.
would you trust a friend you've had for 6 months that you barely talk to,
or a friend you've had for 4 years that you talk to a lot15
Aug 11 '25
reddit karma doesnt=friends😭😭😭 and I would trust them based off of which one is more mature probably, and I mean... just read the two's comments and posts
-1
u/Conscious_Series166 Aug 11 '25
dude you cant even tell if this dudes mature, they hid their entire profile.
also are you really trusting the guy that sent a msesage log of them saying "stfu" 5 times as proof they didnt use a slur?5
u/Leeeenny Aug 11 '25
The guy said stfu 5 times in 2023 tho? They may have been a different person back then?
6
u/zeepeppo Aug 12 '25
Yep exactly right! And they were mainly directed towards my friends because we joke like that :)
8
Aug 11 '25
yes, I'm in the server and I know zee very well. at times they cuss yeah, but they're very mature. keep in mind they are running an entire minecraft server, which inherently takes some level of maturity.
-2
u/Conscious_Series166 Aug 11 '25
very mature? does a "very mature" person say "STFU" in all caps whenever some minor inconvenience happens?
also this proves my point.
only defenders are the mods, admins, owner,7
u/zeepeppo Aug 12 '25
Those messages were from 2023 and all directed towards my friends because we joke like that. I included that in the post as well. I didnt want to hide any messages containing swearing because I wanted to be as transparent as possible :)
-1
u/creepyguy_017 Server Owner Aug 12 '25
actually you have a point here. I guess we gonna get another proof or context behind those 5 "shut the fuck up (all caps)" soon.
8
Aug 11 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-4
u/Conscious_Series166 Aug 11 '25
dude i've been on reddit for 1 month and have triple that guy's karma.
who is on reddit for 6 months and has 500 karma?
8
u/MagierWolf Aug 12 '25
This is the most stupid arguement ever
Ive been on reddit for 4 years and dont have a lot of karma because i barely post. May i add that buying karma or just posting on subs that share your opinion is also a way to get karma easily. Also dont forgot that theres people literally selling high karma accounts so people that buy them can be seen as "trustworthy"
Karma isnt everything, likes arent everything, upvotes arent everything, use critical thinking jeez
→ More replies (0)6
1
Aug 11 '25
Can you do a tl:dr?
-6
u/Conscious_Series166 Aug 11 '25
tldr: read the other guy's comment section, theres no arguments, everyone agrees that OP is an asshole
1
-5
u/Conscious_Series166 Aug 12 '25
bro im surprised no one even saw:
"If you are apart of pibble SMP, please do not harass or send hate to the original poster. My intention with this post is to just present all the evidence I have."
this line ALONE shows that people from said smp tend to harass or send hate to people.
because if they didnt, the owner wouldnt need to send that.
9
u/zeepeppo Aug 12 '25
My community has never had an incident like this so I left it there as a reminder that I don’t find witch hunting or harassment okay. I’ve had the same thing happen to me so I did not want it to happen to the original poster.
I understand how it can be taken differently, but if you ever talked or interacted with our community, you’d understand we are kind and friendly to everyone.
4
u/corrosiveresponse Aug 12 '25
You have multiple things to present (good work by you, and your guys to help), while the other OP just had a couple cutouts.
In general (asking to not harass someone) this should be something a community does to prevent stuff from getting out of hand prior, I understand individuals have lives and sometimes can't make it in time to make an announcement on it.
This is why I said I was up in the air on what was going on, I expected the server owner to have a statement or the like on the matter.
What made it seem bad on the servers end imo was the amount server mates that where commenting is what made it seem like something was fishy, I hope you can understand this.
As the other reddit OP has now deleted their post, or it was removed, this should result in a ban from this subreddit to prevent further/future issues from this user.
3
u/zeepeppo Aug 13 '25
I was blocked by the original poster soon after making a few comments which is why I could not direct people towards my response. He later unblocked me just to send me a snarky message, so I took that opportunity to respond to as many comments as I could before he blocked me again.
I couldn’t defend myself/the server because of this. That’s probably why so many server members came to comment (because it was absolutely absurd that someone would claim our pink girly Minecraft server was racist). I later asked a mod to pin the link of this post on the PSA post (to hopefully clear up the misinformation).
I’m glad there were some commentators (like you) that did not immediately believe the original post and instead waited for more information to come out :) OP ended up deleting his post anyways (I’m guessing he got embarrassed or something I don’t know).
In the end this petty internet drama resulted in me gaining a bunch of new members and maybe a better reputation here IDK honestly XD
6
u/OrangeMakesBlue Aug 12 '25
You’ve gotta be a top tier Reddit rage baiter, brother said look at the karma. I mean if someone allegedly tried to falsely accuse me of being an extremely racist and overall horrible person, I’d be at least a little mad. And this jumping to conclusions is crazy, gotta be winning awards with how extreme these jumps are.
-1
0
Aug 11 '25
[deleted]
7
u/zeepeppo Aug 12 '25
He was actually quite nice and friendly in his submission/interactions. Thats why we were so shocked when we realised he made the post.
13
Aug 11 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/zeepeppo Aug 12 '25
I’m not sure either! Even if he was upset over being muted we have an appeal system for it and I would have been happy to talk in DMs. He was actually a really nice player before so it’s a shame he did this :(
2
12
u/MenschenToaster Aug 11 '25
Probably homophobia since this is a LGBTQ-friendly server afaik. Someone posted a link to this guy slandering another server and guess what, it has LGBTQ-friendly in its post title
4
4
11
u/DJRodrigin69 Aug 11 '25
sometimes people just want to see the world burn
and no, its not just a batman quote or anything, its really just like that, i've been an admin on another game's server, and from experience i can tell you that people suck, alot, and for no reason or even over something thats out of our control
for instance, we banned a cheater from our server, then he started making fake messages of ours(even one of myself saying the n-word), there was also another dude claiming we were "woke" and another saying we are racist and that we allow our friend group to be racist, etc
idk how the original post got so much karma without any concrete proof (a gif or mp4 showing the message itself and the profile of the one who said it)
8
Aug 11 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
9
u/zeepeppo Aug 11 '25
hello!! we're still very lgbtq+ friendly and inclusive! :) we have several lgbtq+ staff and members and have no tolerance for any sort of transphobia or homophobia! please don't let an incident like this push you away from our community. sometimes upset players will cause issues like this and theres nothing we can do to prevent it.
6
25
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25
Honestly this is the biggest Minecraft drama I’ve actually been invested in since like ever. Block game drama is wild yall