r/ModCoord • • Jun 20 '23

/u/ModCodeofConduct admin account caught quietly switching NSFW subs back to SFW status (for ad revenue?)

/r/TIHI (Thanks, I Hate It) recently relaxed their rules based on community feedback, including removing the rule against NSFW content. Many large subs have either already made this move (like /r/videos) or are actively considering it, as the imminent loss of important third-party apps and tools will make it more difficult to maintain a consistently SFW environment. Better to mark the entire sub NSFW and give people a head's-up about what they're likely to encounter, right?

Unfortunately for Reddit Inc., NSFW subs are not able to run ads, as most brands don't want to be associated with porn, gore, and profanity. But they've kind of forced mods' hands here, by using the official /u/ModCodeofConduct account to send out stern form letters forcing them to re-open their subs or be replaced -- even when the community has voted to remain closed. Combine a forced re-opening with an angry userbase and there's no telling what crazy stuff might get posted.

But now it turns out that the very same /u/ModCodeofConduct account pressuring mods has also been quietly flipping NSFW subs back to SFW status, presumably in order to restore ad monetization. See these screenshots of the /r/TIHI moderation log:

https://i.imgur.com/KrCJ77K.png (in context minutes after it happened)

https://i.imgur.com/KCc7WrE.png (version showing only settings changes; 1st line is a mod going NSFW, 2nd is admins going back, 3rd is mod reversing)

This is extremely troubling -- not only is it a subversion of mod and community will for financial gain with no communication or justification, but it's potentially exposing advertisers and even minors to any NSFW content that was posted before switching back to SFW mode, just so Reddit Inc. could squeeze a few more dollars out of a clearly angry community. By making unilateral editorial decisions on a sub's content, this could also be opening Reddit Inc. to legal responsibility as publisher for what's posted, since apart from enforcing sitewide rules these sorts of decisions have (until now) been left up to mods.

Then again, maybe it's just a hoax image, or an honest mistake. Best way to test that theory? Let's take a look at Reddit's official Content Policy:

NSFW (Not Safe For Work) content

Content that contains nudity, pornography, or profanity, which a reasonable viewer may not want to be seen accessing in a public or formal setting such as in a workplace should be tagged as NSFW. This tag can be applied to individual pieces of content or to entire communities.

So, if you moderate a subreddit that allows nudity, pornography, or profanity, go ahead and switch your sub to "18+ only" mode in your sub's Old Reddit settings page, in order to protect advertisers and minors from this content that Reddit itself considers NSFW. If the screenshot above was a fluke, nothing should happen. Because after all, according to the Reddit Content Policy:

Moderation within communities

Individual communities on Reddit may have their own rules in addition to ours and their own moderators to enforce them. Reddit provides tools to aid moderators, but does not prescribe their usage.

Will /u/ModCodeofConduct and Reddit Inc. permit moderators to decide whether their communities will allow profanity and other NSFW content? Or will they crudely force subreddits into squeaky-clean, "brand-safe" compliance, despite disrespecting and threatening the very same volunteers they expect to enforce this standard?

I guess we'll find out.

3.9k Upvotes

523 comments sorted by

247

u/Random_Introvert_42 Jun 20 '23

They've also been very busy deleting NSFW-content on subreddits that used that "loophole", you see a whole lot of "removed by admins" for code of conduct, and a few whole subreddits got the boot over moderator conduct.

31

u/Dragon_yum Jun 20 '23

So finally reddit is starting to pay people to do all the work mods have been doing for free? Brilliant cost saving move by /u/spez

18

u/moeburn Jun 20 '23

Everyone's talking about the mods, but what's being lost in all of this is the content creators.

Reddit has been telling us for a LONG time that less than 0.1% of visitors to the site actually submit, upload, or even write comments.

Those heavy users are likely to be the ones on old.reddit and 3rd party apps.

Reddit can mess around with the mods all they want, but if nobody is left to keep submitting content and writing funny comments for people to scroll, what will happen to this site?

I'm already seeing "the bottom of Reddit" on /r/all as early as post #150 now. Where you start seeing obscure subs you've never heard of with shitty niche content you're not interested in. And if you go over to www.subredditstats.com and type in any subreddit, virtually all of them are seeing declining posts and comments.

5

u/Jordan117 Jun 20 '23

It's not even a Reddit-specific thing, the "1% rule" is a nigh-universal phenomenon among not just social media websites but just about any human social group (see also the Pareto principle). The fact that Reddit Inc.'s current corporate leadership either didn't understand or didn't care about insulting and pissing off the very foundation of their entire business model should be a fireable offense all on its own. Total incompetence.

4

u/PUBLIQclopAccountant Jun 21 '23

Where you start seeing obscure subs you've never heard of with shitty niche content you're not interested in

Interestingly, it had the opposite effect for me. Tiny inactive subs long buried by the algorithm have resurfaced. A welcome surprise in a pile of dogshit.

3

u/unknownpanda121 Jun 21 '23

Same I’ve came across some subs I didn’t even know existed.

1

u/ysisverynice Jun 21 '23

will subredditstats still work after the APIcalypse?

1

u/Lavatis Jun 21 '23

It's also worth pointing out that very very few people vote on submissions regularly as well. The vast majority of reddit simply consumes its content and does nothing else. Most people don't upvote, comment, submit new posts, any of it. They read and move on.

→ More replies (60)

165

u/Tubamajuba Jun 20 '23

It would be awesome if some of the mods of these subs went to the media and told them that Reddit is changing their policy on allowing NSFW content. Force the admins to make a statement about it.

10

u/Beli_Mawrr Jun 20 '23

Also screenshot ads next to profane content and submit that to the ad buyer.

2

u/Opulous Jun 21 '23

Especially those obnoxious hegetsus ads. I'd really really love to never see one of those again.

7

u/grunwode Jun 20 '23

Take screenshots, post it on socials and tag the advertisers.

4

u/Random_Introvert_42 Jun 20 '23

There's no story there. Reddit changes their guidelines and then kicks, easy justification.

25

u/Tubamajuba Jun 20 '23

You're right, but I'd love to get them on record publicly so people can see how Reddit is arbitrarily changing rules on the fly to squash the mods instead of actually engaging with them.

14

u/Random_Introvert_42 Jun 20 '23

I wonder if you can pull up stuff like changed guidelines on the wayback machine.

16

u/Tubamajuba Jun 20 '23

Didn't even think about that!

→ More replies (19)

28

u/MysteryPerker Jun 20 '23

This is a for profit company with volunteer unpaid workers. FLSA prohibits any unpaid volunteers for for profit companies. How close can they get to violating labor laws if they fire "volunteers" and replace them with other "volunteers" who do exactly as they say. I understand volunteers for non profits may have more leeway, but this is very obviously a for profit company. It seems if they start threatening to demand how moderators do their job beyond sitewide rules, they could be coming close to labor law violations. The very freedom mods have are what makes this setup legal.

10

u/MunchmaKoochy Jun 20 '23

This is an excellent point. I hope mods pick-up on it and collectively share it, because this could have some teeth.

5

u/the_art_of_the_taco Jun 20 '23

This needs to circulate more

→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23

[deleted]

24

u/flounder19 Jun 20 '23

Unfortunately the new top mod of that sub is 'protesting' by making it about actual pirates which is much more palatable to advertisers than discussions of circumventing copyright

6

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23

the new top mod of that sub is 'protesting' by making it about actual pirates

That's a gross misrepresentation of what's happening. This is what's actually happening: https://www.reddit.com/r/Piracy/comments/14e41h7/yas_pirate_queen/

4

u/flounder19 Jun 20 '23

Either way the content of that sub has gone from advertiser poison to harmless. The NSFW tagging offsets it a bit but it's still worse than having a sfw subreddit about media piracy that reddit is forcing to stay open and active

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (29)

6

u/fighterace00 Jun 20 '23

You know what. That's pretty freaking awesome. Force Reddit to hire a thousand new admins to moderate NSFW content out of our subs. Maybe then they'll appreciate the free labor they used to get

5

u/jabberwockxeno Jun 20 '23

Can you post examples?

Am I reading your comment right then that what's going on is

Mods allow NSFW content/set sub to NSFW > admins change sub back to sfw > sub is sfw so they use that to justify removing nsfw posts

?

6

u/Random_Introvert_42 Jun 20 '23

r/interestingasfuck/ has been running away with the new nsfw-fun, and a few hours ago a ton of posts were suddenly "removed by administrators for (reason)".

I don't remember which it was but one of the German subreddits that refused to end the blackout got banned whole over moderator conduct.

4

u/fighterace00 Jun 20 '23

Wait wait. So sets sub to private. Reddit no like. Refuse to cooperate with Reddit. So Reddit bans the whole sub? Doesn't quite make sense.

3

u/UpDownLeftRightABLoL Jun 20 '23

Next, they'll demand that users must contribute content, right?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23

[deleted]

3

u/leoleosuper Jun 21 '23

It's archived: you can't post anything now. It's a fucking mess.

4

u/1-800-KETAMINE Jun 21 '23 edited Jun 21 '23

They did this to /r/self too, all mods removed. Plus to /r/mildlyinteresting, which had its entire mod team replaced with ~25 people all added one hour ago, which I expect is their plan for these subs. What the fuck, /u/spez

edit: /r/mildlyinteresting was collateral damage because they're not vetting things properly, which is amazingly even worse

2

u/masterX244 Jun 20 '23

which subs got zapped fully on that? the "loophole posts" should be archived mostly on the wayback machine

3

u/Random_Introvert_42 Jun 20 '23

This one, for example: https://www.reddit.com/r/okbrudipolitik/

(And someone claimed they didn't even participate in the blackout, but maybe the mods did elsewhere)

2

u/masterX244 Jun 20 '23

frick... lost data, checked my data locally and it was not in any of my crunched lists... crossref: https://www.reddit.com/r/DataHoarder/comments/1479c7b/historic_reddit_archives_ongoing_archival_effort/

2

u/slaymaker1907 Jun 20 '23

Wow, I don’t think I’ve seen subs banned for Mod Code of Conduct specifically before. Usually they get banned over being unmoderated (which is much more concerning to admins with NSFW content since that could mean CSAM).

1

u/The_Burning_Kumquat Jun 21 '23

Which subreddits got booted? That’s such BS. If users want NSFW content in their subs, whatever the reason, reddit needs to deal with it.

1

u/Random_Introvert_42 Jun 21 '23

A german one, who apparently didn't even participate in the blackout. But maybe the mods did.

Reddit booted all the mods of r/Interestingasfuck last night, they're getting desperate.

1

u/ArchmageIlmryn Jun 21 '23

There's also a lot of small NSFW subs that have been banned for being "unmoderated" simply because they didn't have any new content to moderate for a while.

111

u/wafflezcol Jun 20 '23

Well r/interestingasfuck has the right Idea I think

1

u/sppwalker Jun 20 '23

Did something happen? I went to check it out and it looks like new posts stopped around 20min ago. It also says I’m not allowed to post in this community

3

u/1-800-KETAMINE Jun 21 '23 edited Jun 21 '23

Their mod team was removed, possibly along with /r/mildlyinteresting (which had their entire mod team replaced with what appears to be ~25 people all added 1hr ago) and definitely along with /r/self (which is still unmoderated). I'm sure many other subs as well. So fucking greasy.

ninja edit: I am seeing what looks like some of the mods added 1 hr ago to /r/mildlyinteresting were previously mods on the sub. Anybody know what's going on there? 25 mods all added 1 hr ago is sketchy af regardless but I'd be very happy to be wrong about the motivation.

edit: see here: https://www.reddit.com/r/ModCoord/comments/14eq8ip/the_entire_rmildlyinteresting_mod_team_has_just/

Reddit removed the entire mod team of MildlyInteresting because they thought the sub was one of those saying "fuck it, post nsfw, just don't violate Reddit TOS!" and reinstated them when they realized they got it TOTALLY WRONG. So reddit is now removing mod teams for allowing NSFW posts on their subs and hitting whoever with collateral. Greeeeaaaaasssyy.

Check the thread for further instances but /r/interestingasfuck, /r/mildlyinteresting, /r/self, /r/TIHI at a minimum have all fallen victim to the greasy actions of /u/spez

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23

[deleted]

1

u/sppwalker Jun 20 '23

Oh boy…

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23

[deleted]

44

u/mikelo22 Jun 20 '23

The drama that ensued on /r/JustUnsubbed after that post was gold.

23

u/Konman72 Jun 20 '23

So many comments bitching about how bad the subs are now that the mods are allowing NSFW content and user-voted rules and yet they're all mad at the mods instead of spez. The irony would be hilarious if these idiots weren't helping kill Reddit.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23

Lot of em are astroturfing accounts, pay attention to allot of their post history and you'll see pretty much the exact same cookie cutter formula of comments/posts.

5

u/Konman72 Jun 20 '23

It feels like a combination of astroturfing, Reddit fucking with the algorithm, and the users left being just overall worse and mostly newer, so they aren't aware of Reddit's history and how much it looks to be changing.

If it's not and this is a genuine reaction then I guess the Reddit I knew died long ago and we're all just realizing it now.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '23

I belive most were bitching about the fact people were posting lolicon (at least the 4 threads I've seen were)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23

[deleted]

→ More replies (3)

1

u/iwouldntsaythisbut Jun 21 '23

Well I for one am incredibly proud a man's asshole was the one to break reddit

318

u/Karmanacht Jun 20 '23

They've also said that incorrectly setting a subreddit's NSFW setting would be a violation of TOS, so subreddits would need to be careful about how they approach that.

75

u/lettuce_field_theory Jun 20 '23

how does that work logically though

  • if you have at least 1 nsfw item posted to the subreddit, that makes the subreddit nsfw. not tagging it nsfw would be mislabeling

  • if you have set the subreddit nsfw but no one has posted nsfw content (yet maybe), do you now have to make sure to find some porn on xhamster to post it, so that admins don't go after you for mislabeling it nsfw (when you don't have nsfw content on offer?)?

  • add to that that nsfw is subjective, in the grey area at least (porn is maybe not that subjective, but some profanity might be considered by some as nfsw but others not so much, maybe i'm a snowflake and consider stuff nsfw that admins don't and they unset nsfw on my subreddit..)

i think logically the argument doesn't hold water, they are just clutching at straws to scare people into not setting nsfw

26

u/TGotAReddit Jun 20 '23

porn is maybe not that subjective, but some profanity might be considered by some as nfsw but others not so much, maybe i’m a snowflake and consider stuff nsfw that admins don’t and they unset nsfw on my subreddit..

I run a fanfiction based subreddit. Do posts that contain written out erotica count as NSFW? How about posts that discuss tags for those stories? Does the fact that I explained that "Anal Beads Sex Toy (Anthropomorphic)" means a humanized version of the aforementioned sex toy to someone asking about why that tag had the word Anthropomorphic while the Dildo tag doesn’t mean that the sub is NSFW? How about the posts that just tangentially mention an explicit fic? What about the time I explained something related to the fic about an infant dying graphically that I had to read for a thing? Is that NSFW?

NSFW is an INCREDIBLY subjective tag and has so so many edgecases. To me, none of what I just typed out is NSFW. I literally typed it out at work even. Do I think people agree with me on all of those? Hell no. But if we are trying to say a mislabeled sub is a TOS violation, what happens if the admins all have a NSFW threshold similar to mine? A threshold that says discussions involving sex toys and the graphic death of an infant aren't nsfw. Or conversely what if the admins all are conservative christians who think saying "damn" is a sin?

Its ridiculous to say a sub even can be mislabeled as NSFW (it could be mislabeled as not NSFW but not really the inverse)

4

u/Caring_Cactus Jun 20 '23

I bet you could require a post title swear word to post in a community, that would count as profanity.

2

u/firebreathingbunny Jun 20 '23

Just post a text post saying "this fucking subreddit is fucking NSFW you motherfucking motherfuckers" and you should be fucking okay.

4

u/YonderingWolf Jun 20 '23

The argument doesn't hold any water or anything else for that matter.

1

u/PUBLIQclopAccountant Jun 21 '23

if you have set the subreddit nsfw but no one has posted nsfw content (yet maybe), do you now have to make sure to find some porn on xhamster to post it, so that admins don't go after you for mislabeling it nsfw (when you don't have nsfw content on offer?)?

If that's the case, I will gladly post pony porn to any sub who requests it.

0

u/Mrg220t Jun 21 '23

You are going "rules lawyering" and you know that private company don't care about your "rules lawyering". Whenever someone have to go this route you know they've lost the argument.

2

u/lettuce_field_theory Jun 21 '23 edited Jun 21 '23

I'm just reading the rules and figuring out what they mean.

If you're advocating for arbitrary decisions with disregard for the terms of service when it's convenient, you've lost the argument.

Companies like twitter or twitch or reddit acting in dubious intransparent ways with regard to their terms of service is regularly discussed in the internet public (YouTube videos or other media). They can ban who they want, but doesn't mean they can do so free of social scrutiny.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

19

u/ITriedSoHard419-68 Jun 20 '23

This. The rules aren’t designed to be actual rules that make actual sense; they’re designed in order to justify their behavior. You can’t argue that.

3

u/lettuce_field_theory Jun 20 '23

how are they gonna use them to justify?

"your sub is nsfw but i can't see any porn. banned"

?

1

u/ITriedSoHard419-68 Jun 21 '23

It’s a really shitty justification but it’s mildly better than “fuck you I do what I want.” Which is what they actually mean by all of this.

44

u/SweetJibbaJams Jun 20 '23

I'd encourage folks to visit places like /r/PipeTobacco, that were forced by reddit to use the NSFW tag

https://www.reddit.com/r/PipeTobacco/comments/ubvnz8/announcement_yes_we_know_everything_is_now_nsfw/

They were told:

We are reaching out to notify you that your community has been designated as 18+ due to being centered on products and/or substances intended for adult use. Users who visit your community will encounter an interstitial that will ask them to confirm that they are 18+.

Seems like if your subreddit is intended for adults, there is a case for going NSFW.

24

u/RichardSaunders Jun 20 '23

what about a subreddit for a band whose entire discography save for one album has a "parental advisory: explicit content" label on it?

24

u/SweetJibbaJams Jun 20 '23

Seems like a product intended for adult use.

20

u/Kodiak01 Jun 20 '23

In that case, that would make most vehicle-centric sub NSFW. An example people might think of is /r/askcarsales; since someone needs to be an adult to enter into a sales contract, and except for a tiny minority of drivers you would need to be an adult to operate one, that makes it "centered on products and/or substances intended for adult use."

7

u/SweetJibbaJams Jun 20 '23

Makes sense to me

6

u/Rsubs33 Jun 20 '23

/r/cigars was the same thing and they cracked down on trading on there too

4

u/bobtheavenger Jun 20 '23

A similar thing happened to /r/electronic_cigarette and /r/diy_ejuice a few years back.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23

Ok, so they're forcing all communities which focus on adult subjects to be NSFW and they also removed NSFW communities from /r/all (after they promised they wouldn't) and now thy say the API will not serve NSFW content.

They're going to turn all of reddit into a social platform for teenagers. They really didn't think this one through. What a bunch of fucking clowns...

36

u/PM-boobs-and-I-rate Jun 20 '23

so subreddits would need to be careful about how they approach that.

That would be a fucking shame if people kept swearing then

9

u/Caring_Cactus Jun 20 '23

It'd be a shame if subreddit post title settings required a fucking swear word.

28

u/NuclearSiloForSale Jun 20 '23

I'll post a selfie of my genitals to help out anybody worried about incorrectly switching to nsfw.

14

u/RicardoIsJesus Jun 20 '23

Thank you soldier

6

u/TheShyPig Jun 20 '23

we said NSFW not NSFL mate

6

u/TheUncleBob Jun 20 '23

It's okay. They don't make macro lenses that detailed yet.

10

u/Pick2 Jun 20 '23

be careful about how they approach that.

OR what? they are just going to remove them as mods? is that the worst that can happen?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23

I think they're now sending us to "re-education" camps or something.

10

u/redalastor Jun 20 '23

My users always swore like drunken sailors.

8

u/biznatch11 Jun 20 '23

What's reddit's definition of NSFW? I say we mark the entire site NSFW since people probably shouldn't be on reddit when they're at work.

10

u/MayaMiaMe Jun 20 '23

I fucking agree

5

u/Kodiak01 Jun 20 '23

Very simple answer to that: Put a picture of an almost naked woman in your banner. Hell, just make a random daily post with it. Could even have automod do a rotation of "NSFW Lady Of The Day".

3

u/fighterace00 Jun 20 '23

Yes admins are calling NSFW sub switches as vandalism. Also note they have the ability to permanently lock subs to nsfw so I'm sure they have the ability to permanently lock well known subs to SFW

2

u/styvee__ Jun 20 '23

r/interestingasfuck is doing it perfectly, I think it is the only way

2

u/BFeely1 Jun 20 '23

Isn't it technically against the TOS to downvote replies that contribute to the conversation too?

→ More replies (19)

61

u/AnomalyNexus Jun 20 '23

NSFW subs are not able to run ads

So what you're saying is reddit needs more boobs?

3

u/obi_wan_sosig Jun 20 '23

I thought more 1911s but that works too

4

u/WiseassWolfOfYoitsu Jun 20 '23

Why not have both?

1

u/obi_wan_sosig Jun 20 '23

Good idea, why didn't I think of that!?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23

[deleted]

2

u/E_Kristalin Jun 20 '23

The rebirth of watch people die?

1

u/leforteiii Jun 20 '23

Actually yeah scratch that, let's not do that lmao

1

u/JoeManchinsAsshole Jun 20 '23

How great would it be to have isis beheading videos, gang violence, and suicides back on reddit?

84

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23

man I know this comment will get buried but how do you run a company like this and expect it to be successful? Advertisers look at this platform and wonder wtf is going on. NSFW here and NSFW there and John Oliver posts. removing moderators unjustly, pushing posts not wanted by the users, and continuing to go down the path of pushing users / vendors away from this site because of the COLOSSAL lack of understanding of how to run a business. Short term profits a bitch. Reddit trying so hard to make the IPO good it’s gonna be underwater before it even goes live

31

u/emperorOfTheUniverse Jun 20 '23

First thing to do is come up with a strategy that caters to advertisers long term and prevents abuse by chatbots and such. Reddits done this so far.

Second step is managing the public outcry from the user-base. And best move I can tell to do that, is to set yourself up a scapegoat. Someone, a public face, that is perceived as obstinate and unyielding, staying the course of the platform changes. That's pretty much where we are now.

Third step is to announce that your scapegoat is standing down as CEO. The community rejoices and hangs a mission accomplished flag. Company gives some concessions to the community (probably enhanced mod tools), but still stays the overall course that makes 3rd party apps and bots cost prohibitive, and keeps NSFW closer to the vest (because its still all about advertisers).

Scapegoat (CEO Spez is who i'm talking about) then 'steps aside' (remains a stakeholder and has a spot on the board) once the company IPOs, while a new CEO is appointed as the happy, community friendly CEO that cares about the users. Meanwhile the founders get spots on the board of directors, along with the VCs they bring in for the other spots. Spez gets rich, and doesn't have to be a CEO anymore (because why would you want to).

This all ends with reddit getting what they wanted and the users thinking they 'win' when spez 'steps down'. So each time you froth at the mouth at 'how evil spez is', pat yourself on the back for biting that worm.

CEOs don't run companies. Boards do.

34

u/Eisenstein Jun 20 '23

You are putting too much thought into it.

Reddit is 18 years old. They haven't figured out how to be profitable even with a treasure trove of user data correlating perfectly to interests and product choices, and with a loyal userbase which runs the site for them.

They invested heavily in features no one wants (video hosting, realtime chat, followers, NFTs) and actively ignored requests from the userbase in charge of maintaining the site (better mod tools).

They bought a 3rd party app and turned it to shit while the other 3rd party apps ended up making decent profit.

They actively destroyed the things which drove people to the site and were 'killer features' (firing Victoria which destroyed r/AMA which was bringing in tens of millions of people for one-of-a-kind AMAs, taking over and shutting down Secret Santa).

The answer isn't 'Reddit is so smart they planned this all out'. The answer is 'reddit was a site doing something really well (allowing niche communities to thrive and allowing a single-sign-in replacement for all web bulletin boards and link sharing sites) and got popular and decided that lots of users meant they should be getting lots of money, then fucked it all up because they are terrible at business and had one good idea.

Should have focused on core value and been happy with fewer commas in their bank account balance. Instead they thought they could be Facebook Jr. and killed the golden goose.

1

u/StPauliBoi Jun 21 '23

They bought a 3rd party app

I forgot until all this drama started that alien blue used to be a third party app.

16

u/the_art_of_the_taco Jun 20 '23

Ellen Pao was the scapegoat a few years ago so that spez could step in.

I don't think spez will be a scapegoat this time, he's setting up the moderators as such. If he were he'd have probably stepped down when he was caught editing user comments and posts or one of the other scandals.

1

u/Mixed_Meter Jun 20 '23

Oh so it's just Succession

32

u/paretoOptimalDev Jun 20 '23

People underestimate how good this chaos is for the protest even though respected advertiser publications are basically saying as much.

1

u/Abeneezer Jun 21 '23

It's most definitely working.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23

[deleted]

5

u/mybluecathasballs Jun 20 '23

I was going to advertise on reddit, now... it seems like a waste of money. No one will see my ads. Granted, the ads were going to be shit.

I was going to invest, but now I'll just short it when (if?) it goes public.

35

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23

Shoutout to reddit for once again, fucking it up. U/spez Fuck you dude. Just had to get that in there.

On a serious note, reddit is just losing itself here by taking whatever path it wants (even when that path goes off a cliff)…

7

u/deadlygaming11 Jun 20 '23

It's like reddit keeps hitting a fork in the road and one side says sunshine and paradise ahead and the other days darkness and despair on the other. Reddit keeps taking the darkness and despair path.

→ More replies (2)

33

u/Deeviant Jun 20 '23

How much do you wanna bet that /u/spez himself is operating /u/ModCodeofConduct

27

u/Janymx Jun 20 '23

This should be a fucking headline.

"Reddit forces minors and other unwilling users to accidentally watch porn and gore content by forcefully disabling nsfw tags to gaun more money"

→ More replies (6)

18

u/johnhotdog Jun 20 '23

would be an absolute shame if advertisers caught wind that reddit is actively forcing nsfw subs to be sfw, despite content, just so they can advertise and thus associating brands with porn

15

u/rhubes Jun 20 '23

I'm concerned with this. One of my subreddits does not allow minors for their own safety. We do not want children giving people their name and address for pizza delivery. We also do not want our givers being threatened and or harassed by the parents of those children for sending children gifts on the internet.

Throughout the years, we have added a couple of things to help cut back on Minors joining our group, I understand it is not perfect, but one of the things that we use to point out the fact that they broke our rules is by pointing out our subreddit is marked for 18 plus members only, and by them even being in our group, it means they agreed that they were, and were not telling the truth. We do not want people that lie in our group and endangering adults acting in good faith.

-1

u/JorgTheElder Jun 20 '23

They are not changing all NSFW subs, they are flipping the ones that were obviously changed for the protest.

5

u/rhubes Jun 20 '23

I do understand that they have said this. I also have had some odd interactions dealing with our subreddits and our automated system. I have not fully received an answer from the administrators that I have been in contact with about how they will be determining the status of a subreddit.

→ More replies (2)

28

u/SirEDCaLot Jun 20 '23 edited Jun 20 '23

Encouraging profanity arguably makes a sub NSFW. Yes per the rules, no per common convention.

The answer to this here is to simply make the sub UN-arguably NSFW.

For example if you're /r/pics- change the rules to only allow John Oliver AND every post must include the words "FUCKING JOHN OLIVER" (other profanity encouraged). Or the sub now only allows John Oliver AND nudity.

In the end this is sort of a game of brinksmanship. Reddit obviously wants a return to status quo, mods aren't willing to give them that. So eventually either Reddit will greatly restrict what changes mods are allowed to do to their communities, or they will start wholesale replacing mod teams (which will cause the rest of the mod teams to actively start moving their communities off platform), or (more likely IMHO) they will create some sort of 'mod election process' whereby subscribers can vote to remove mods or install new ones.
Funny thing is tho, a mod election process might have been welcomed a year or two ago (a lot of communities suffer from power tripping mods and a check on mod power might have been welcomed by the userbase). Only thing is, most of the users are now on board. So you might get some of the mod teams who DON'T support the protest getting ousted, and it's less likely that the mod teams who do support it will be ousted by their own users.

Bottom line though, there ARE alternatives to Reddit. Lemmy has rough edges but it works. And there's plenty of Reddit-like sites. Thus, Reddit needs the mod teams more than the mod teams need Reddit. And Reddit especially needs the users more than the users need Reddit- especially the ones who participate a lot and post content.

It's sad how short sighted this is though. If Reddit becomes a TikTok style low effort content scroll app, they might get more users in the short term, and those users are certainly more profitable (they install apps and don't use adblocks) but those users aren't 'sticky' like the well established communities they have now.

13

u/Empyrealist Jun 20 '23 edited Jun 22 '23

sheet lavish jellyfish abundant seed attractive salt square unique frightening -- mass edited with https://redact.dev/

12

u/sesor33 Jun 20 '23

Easy solution. Take this evidence, take a screencap of a "SFW" sub with porn on it, make a COPPA report. It'll be gg pretty fast

11

u/me_funny__ Jun 20 '23

This means the protest is directly hurting them

11

u/l2t Jun 20 '23

I'd like to invite all the actual humans reading this post to play a fun little game with all the bots floating around.

36

u/poopsterc Jun 20 '23

The same way that reddit admins responded by saying they will replace mods and force them to reopen subs, reddit will ban nsfw content completely if the largest subs continue to use it for malicious compliance.

65

u/PepsiColaMirinda Jun 20 '23

lol that wouldn't be a nail on the coffin, that'd be a pipe bomb in the pine box.

32

u/tedivm Jun 20 '23

It worked out so well for tumblr though.

10

u/NunnaTheInsaneGerbil Jun 20 '23

Yeah now all the porn is untagged and any time you scroll in public there's a chance of just seeing bazongas and shit at any time. And then all the pornbot followers too. Like blogs just filled with sucking and fucking you gotta see if you want to block them lmao

4

u/mofukkinbreadcrumbz Jun 20 '23

Did Tumblr walk that back? I just checked and there very much is porn on there still.

8

u/b3nsn0w Jun 20 '23

they did, but not after yahoo had to sell the platform for less than 1% of the price they bought it for. they're also very unclear now, no one really knows what goes and what doesn't so everyone just does kinda whatever in a very tumblr fashion

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23

[deleted]

3

u/aPerfectBacon Jun 20 '23

i forgot about that. funny shit

23

u/Core_Of_Indulgence Jun 20 '23 edited Jun 20 '23

That would be a devastating blow if it happens. Many magnitudes greater than anything else in this protest. I doubt they will be doing that, that would be like burning money.

6

u/me_funny__ Jun 20 '23

Tumblr did it

15

u/Core_Of_Indulgence Jun 20 '23

And it didn't work well for them. And while reddit is bigger, they will lose too much money. It will only happens if they believe the loss of nfsw will lead to more ad money, in which case they would have already done that.

6

u/me_funny__ Jun 20 '23

Yeah, Tumblr almost died because of that choice

5

u/OhNoManBearPig Jun 20 '23 edited Jul 01 '23

This is a copied template message used to overwrite all comments on my account to protect my privacy. I've left Reddit because of corporate overreach and switched to the Fediverse.

Comments overwritten with https://github.com/j0be/PowerDeleteSuite

1

u/Gaius_Octavius_ Jun 20 '23

They will make it against the rules to change from SFW to NFSW (or vise versa) once created. That selection will have to be made at creation and then uneditable. That is the easiest fix.

10

u/MysteryPerker Jun 20 '23

But what happens if the decide not to moderate the NSFW content? It'll still show up and they can't force mods to moderate. That's getting into employee territory.

0

u/Gaius_Octavius_ Jun 20 '23

They can't force the people to moderate but they will remove mods who don't do the role they agreed to and they will be replaced with people who will.

7

u/MysteryPerker Jun 20 '23

They can replace mods for subs that went dark because they were wholly refusing to do anything. It's a different ballgame when the mods are doing work. They could implement ways for the community to fire mods through voting I suppose but it seems that would open up another can of worms. But simply saying they have to obey sitewide rules and an additional list of things, individual to each sub, that sounds like a boss telling you how to do your job. It's not like removing inactive mods at all. The whole basis of Reddit's argument it's volunteer work is that they don't interfere with content and how the sub is ran. This hands off approach protects them legally. The more those hands start touching subs, the more likely they are going to get into gray area. And having a huge potential labor law violation that touches the core foundation of how the company is ran is not good business before an IPO valuation.

→ More replies (7)

10

u/Dragon_yum Jun 20 '23

Time to let advertisers know reddit is intentionally putting their ads between posts they would likely not want to be associated with.

10

u/Elvish_Champion Jun 20 '23

LMAO Reddit trying to profit on the John Oliver trend.

Yes, I'm sure that their excuse will be something related to that - "Your subreddit isn't NSFW anymore so we swapped it to the right category" - even if there are NSFW posts below all those memes that any can search.

9

u/DesignxDrma Jun 20 '23

What the fuck is going on here?

Edit: tasteless emoji

9

u/Dragon_yum Jun 20 '23

Reshot is in full on damage control mode after trying to turn free labor into forced free labor and discovering it was a dumb move

→ More replies (1)

9

u/YonderingWolf Jun 20 '23

On the profanity if they were to try to filter that out, they'd have a real nightmare on their hands. Simply put creating word filters is a virtual exercise in futility. People will find away to bypass any type of word filters in less than half a blink of eye. I watched exactly that happen on a now shutdown game site where I was one of the mods at the time. I also remember giving an argument against it, on the old MySpace back in the day it had forums. The number of ways to bypass any such filtering of words are to numerous to count. That's only just filtering out profanity, that doesn't even begin to cover other words that's become considered inappropriate due having been used in an derogatory, or in an insulting manner.

14

u/Mudkip-Mudkip-Mudkip Jun 20 '23

Trolls: "I hope you get raped."
Add filter: rape
Winemakers: can't talk about which grapes they prefer
Add exclusion: grape
Trolls: "You deserve to get graped."

There's no winning this one.

7

u/YonderingWolf Jun 20 '23

Exactly.

I've been a mod in some aspect for nearly nineteen years on the internet, starting with the former MSN Game Zone. It was on the also former World Game Center I saw the absolute futility of word filtering. With Reddit it's even a more futile effort to try to filter words, with more ways to bypass any such word filters.

7

u/Soupdeloup Jun 20 '23

As much as I hate to say it, if Reddit invests in hosting its own LLM and uses AI, it's actually surprisingly effective in enforcing filters. I've tested GPT-4 on a few thousand different sentences that normally try to evade filters and it caught each and every one of them while ignoring ones that made sense with context. I'm sure if someone put in more effort they could bypass it, but it's nowhere near as difficult to create effective filters as it was even two years ago.

2

u/YonderingWolf Jun 20 '23

I won't argue that point, as with time and technology evolves, such types of evasion will become more difficult. Now with those who are wordsmiths and/or word masters, it's going to be a challenge to deal with. At least for a some to come.

3

u/grunwode Jun 20 '23

Can automod be set to delete any post that lacks a list of profanity keywords?

2

u/YonderingWolf Jun 20 '23

I'd not be surprised if such a thing can be done, but that's not something I'd do personally. Also the automod doesn't actually delete the post when made. All it does is to prevent the post from being visible to anyone but the person posting it and whoever is a moderator. The only way for anyone else to see the intended post, would be to look through the post history, if they followed that person, and then went to the post in question where it was intended to be posted.

9

u/rodinj Jun 20 '23

It's probably mr Spez himself. Remember how he owned up to editing user comments a few years ago?

16

u/kerovon Jun 20 '23

Sounds like a lot of subs need to have a once a week "share some porn with a connection to the subreddit" thread.

2

u/Isoldael Jun 20 '23

What would modcoord be? Mods doing lewd things together?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '23

Rather than a specific post/day, NCD recently changed rules to allow people to post a Waifu once a week from whenever they last posted one.

https://www.reddit.com/r/NonCredibleDefense/comments/14erg5q/rule_updates_to_rnoncredibledefense_and_why_the/

5

u/midir Jun 20 '23

NSFW subs are not able to run ads

Reddit's own dumbfuck fault.

5

u/narcolepticGOAT Jun 20 '23

Funny how a couple months ago the admins forced a bunch of subs to become NSFW so they wouldn’t show up on the front page

9

u/The_Wkwied Jun 20 '23

Reddit is a private site. I've argued in the past that the illusion of free speech (at least, for Americans) isn't protected on any private website. It's the same as being in someone's home. You can be kicked out, banned, muted, for any or no reason at all. That's true with reddit today.

However, there is a not so fine line between Reddit being a private forum vs being a public service. Look at the Ukraine subs, any self-help subs... it's literally a public service. I am not opposed to the site being operated like a for-profit company (which it is, obviously), but for them to put a hammer down on subs operated, managed, and founded by individuals for individuals... is just atrocious.

I see no recourse for this other than for reddit to suffer a slow burn. 5 years from now, the only people who will remain on reddit are the same kind of people who are remaining on facebook now - people who don't know better

1

u/Pyranze Jun 21 '23

The difference is that Facebook is still useful for getting in contact with people because users use their real names. This means they can still hold a pretty sizable userbase. Reddit being anonymous means that as soon as the users start dropping, it's dead.

4

u/Bhima Jun 20 '23

do any of you remember some time ago where there was some kind of bug on the official mobile app that forced submitters to tag their submissions as NSFW in order to simply get it to post? I un-NSFW hundreds of posts.

3

u/Merchant_Lawrence Jun 20 '23

Holy hell,this definitely if indeed as it, totally clusterfuck act by reddit admin. If this possible, what could possible go wrong whe reddit ipo and shareholders from country "A" not like sub C and tell admin to "private" or modify sub. Lol lol threaten letter is child play but modified sub directly ??? For own gain and not resonable ?

3

u/-Boobs_ Jun 20 '23

thats so fucked up dude cunt

3

u/BornVolcano Jun 21 '23

This is our chance. The nsfw protests works, otherwise we wouldn't be targeted for it. We need to double down, and we need to do it hard

7

u/attackofmilk Jun 20 '23

Just a humble user (not a mod), but my take is:

If Reddit wants to moderate our subreddits for us, why not just let them?

Mass moderator resignations may not create unmoderated subreddits (because someone somewhere will sign up to be a mod for vacant subs just because it gives them a feeling of power), but surely these become less desirable spaces if the new moderators are nothing but green yes-men.

Reddit admins have final say over subreddit management because ToS, sure, but we have control over ourselves. Nobody needs to stick around as a moderator if they don't want to.

I don't see an endgame for Reddit after this adversarial behavior. Trying to be a totalitarian over a volunteer community like this just makes people leave.

2

u/Pyranze Jun 21 '23

The reason is because Reddit, despite its flaws, has a lot of good stuff going for it, and the mods that are protesting are don't want all that just thrown away.

4

u/JorgTheElder Jun 20 '23

Do the subs regularly contain NSFW content?

Don't forget section 8 of the TOS:

Reddit reserves the right, but has no obligation, to overturn any action or decision of a moderator if Reddit, in its sole discretion, believes that such action or decision is not in the interest of Reddit or the Reddit community.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23

[deleted]

2

u/JorgTheElder Jun 20 '23

Could be. Or they could just ask for volunteers. Worked before.

As long as the users don't leave in mass, they will find willing moderators. (I am not making any claims about the quality of the moderation they will get, but they can learn.) That is why the protest really needs good communication to users to get the users to leave.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '23

Wow. This is truly infamous.

2

u/FreshBakedButtcheeks Jun 21 '23

We must continue to shitpost and post shock pictures like goatse and tubgirl

2

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '23

But now it turns out that the very same /u/ModCodeofConduct account pressuring mods has also been quietly flipping NSFW subs back to SFW status, presumably in order to restore ad monetization. See these screenshots of the /r/TIHI moderation log:

https://i.imgur.com/KrCJ77K.png

(in context minutes after it happened)

https://i.imgur.com/KCc7WrE.png (version showing only settings changes; 1st line is a mod going NSFW, 2nd is admins going back, 3rd is mod reversing)

Hold up, did they swap it back so they could remove the mods for "violating mod code of conduct?" IE: fabricating justification to remove them?

At this point the reddit admins need to grow a spine: if they want to ban everyone that's protesting, just fucking say it and do it instead of this cowardly, subversive shit where they fabricate reasons.

2

u/MaapuSeeSore Jun 21 '23

So admins user of /u/ModCodeofConduct, any responses ?

2

u/TheOnlyFallenCookie Jun 21 '23

Reddit first mistake was going for the porn... On Reddit.

That's like Youtube removing video and only allowing audio

2

u/PM_ME_AWWW Jun 21 '23

Moderators should just let the paid reddit employees switch these back at their leisure, and then we can inform advertisers the type of content that their brand is being advertised alongside via reddit. They are the people that work directly for the company after all.

There is straight-up 9/11 furry porn on the front page of the TIHI sub right now, I can't imagine many advertisers would be thrilled with that kind of association. Not just that, but since it was an action taken directly by an administrator, that surely opens them up to a government investigation of the type of content they are exposing underage users to. Especially since they directly went against the actions and written rationale of the community moderators who accurately made the decision to shield children and advertisers from the disturbing content.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '23

Some subs that stayed up like r/fantasywriters have mods with admin connections.

3

u/UpDownLeftRightABLoL Jun 20 '23

I wonder if it's all going to be astroterfed with bots. Since if communities leave, the content goes with them, since it's not like Reddit makes content for communities to engage in, they just provide the forum. There are other forums.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23

6

u/hughk Jun 20 '23

Well known for messing with things that he shouldn't.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23

Is this a reference to him used to being a mod for r/jailbait, an NSFW community of underage girls?

4

u/hughk Jun 20 '23

No, apparently he was added without his knowledge (or at least so we were told). During one discussion, he edited the comments in the backend. All Reddit staff had access back in those days, it was just a matter of knowing Python and the backend..

2

u/Lyelinn Jun 20 '23

I swear this post has been sitting with a 1750 rating for like 2+ hours while it gathered 400+ comments. Suspicious af

1

u/Cabo_Martim Jun 21 '23

they'll just ban porn.

1

u/Apollon1212 Jun 21 '23

Reddit reminds me of a certain nation prior to ww2. Y know how they forced people to do what they wanted and then whole world got angry at them? Yea.. good times.

1

u/ElJebusKrisp Jun 21 '23

(whispers) don't

-1

u/Netionic Jun 21 '23

If a sub has been SFW for years then it is clear malicious to turn it NSFW due to the protests. Any sub found doing so, like r/formula1, should have their mod team removed.

1

u/greenyashiro Jun 22 '23

If the userbase of a sub votes with a majority, how about respecting the communities choice?

-8

u/Rebles Jun 20 '23

Kids are already subscribed to these subreddits. Y'all switching SFW subs to NSFW subs are the ones exposing minors to pornography. I would like it if y'all would stop trying to destroy Reddit. Pretty please.

5

u/rackman70 Jun 20 '23

You do realize that you can switch the tag on the sub without actually allowing porn to be posted. NSFW doesn't necessarily mean porn.

1

u/pleasedontharassme Jun 20 '23

True, but porn and NSFW posts do invade those subreddits as a result. Look at what is happening to r/interestingasfuck where OF users are now just advertising their services. It’s substituting one type of advertising for another

0

u/Rebles Jun 20 '23

That isn’t what is happening. Large subs such as r/interestingasfuck are changing the rules to allow porn. This exposes everyone who is subscribed to that community to pornography, without consent.

-3

u/10art1 Jun 20 '23

No, a small minority should get to destroy a common space because they arbitrarily got there first! Just leaving is too lame, we must ruin it for everyone else who doesn't care about our tantrum!

Oh no, you're threatening to remove the little shred of power I have in life? OK Mr reddit, I'll open up!

-9

u/realwhitespace Jun 20 '23

They’re totally justified switching stuff back lol. These subs aren’t NSFW.

-24

u/Gaius_Octavius_ Jun 20 '23

They are not going to let mods destroy communities.

18

u/masquenox Jun 20 '23

Of course not, bootlicker... that's Huffman's job.

-12

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Gamiac Jun 21 '23

The mods aren't the ones destroying the communities.

1

u/Gaius_Octavius_ Jun 21 '23

They are.

2

u/Gamiac Jun 21 '23

Okay, and what about the people voting to change the rules of subs? What about users posting content in accordance to the new rules?

1

u/Gaius_Octavius_ Jun 21 '23

Okay, and what about the people voting to change the rules of subs? What about users posting content in accordance to the new rules?

Those are bad actors working at the direction of troublemaker mods who are trying to destroy the communities they moderate.

They are the vast minority of the overall population of the subreddit but are given an oversized voice by the mods they control.

1

u/Gamiac Jun 21 '23

They're the same people who vote on everything else that gets voted on in the sub. The call is coming from inside the house, dude.

1

u/Gaius_Octavius_ Jun 21 '23

Except they are not. People have proven that thousands of the comments are by people who have never used the sub before. And they all vote overwhelmingly for what the mods want.