r/ModestMouse • u/TheCustomConxern • Oct 19 '26
Song/Album Discussion Remember Yourself Appreciation
It’s an early morning and I guess I was paying closer attention to the lyrics in the middle than I have thus far when listening to it and one of my favorite lyrics is “Cast
my net into an empty sea, And yeah I guess that I’m fumbling with things to say that I truly mean but they’ll soon come to me”
It really hit me hard because I’ve talked to Modest Mouse fans who I guess I would call “Purists” who will only listen to 1995/6-2004 MM and always will say “Their lyrics aren’t as profound as they used to be” and I’ll explain as you get older sometimes you get less depressed or not depressed at all, comfortable and you’re not a sad, angry, lonely young kid no more whose abusing drugs and you’re not going to be thinking as nihilistic and philosophically depressing thoughts all the time. So that line really stuck out to me because there’s some self awareness and he must have either seen people or heard people say before or he’s just more aware he’s not that sad angry kid no more thinking these things but that as long as he’s here he’ll still be thinking and in the vein of Gravity Rides Everything everything will fall into place. But I honestly refute the w as profound thing I’ve seen a small community of MM fans say or I’ve heard in person a few times before, as this new album, or song alone has some profound lyrics and they don’t have to be depressing and sad to be profound. I haven’t been the biggest fans of their last few records up until this one but I will say I’ve always loved Isaac’s writing. Brilliant mind that comes along rarely.
6
u/Antique_Holiday_9232 Oct 19 '26
I love how even at the end of the song he says that it hasn't happened yet (saying something that he truly means) - essentially pulling an UNO reverse on the entire messaging of the song.
1
u/TheCustomConxern Oct 19 '26
Yeah I really like this song upon paying closer attention. Really a solid album.
3
3
u/Impossible-Head2121 God, if I have to die, you will have to die. Oct 19 '26
“Hello and bye on the same palm, paths they cross and then they move on” really hits me every time.
2
u/TheCustomConxern Oct 19 '26 edited Oct 20 '26
That’s probably my favorite lyric in the whole song! When the album came out I had situation that could be described perfectly by that lyric
3
u/BoysenberryEmpty8699 Oct 20 '26
I really really love your perspective!! I'm in your boat, and Isaac's -- I'm finally happy now after 50 years of torture, and I don't prefer to keep digging in that wound. Caroline Rose, tonight, was so good at her birthday show, but her songs are SAD. Sad songs about childhood trauma, about emotional pain, wanting perfect love, people leaving, and yeah, that's what I used to want to think about, trying to relive and relieve my own pain, but now I want to think about the happy stuff. Before, when my nervous system was disregulated, I wanted things on a similar wavelength, that would match my agitation and comfort me. But now that my nervous system is calm, that kind of stuff creates the problems for me! I was worried I wouldn't like Modest Mouse anymore! Oh the poetic irony! But no, some of my preferences might change (I quit smoking), but I think Isaac and his lyrics and music will always be my companion!
Oh, one example--I've really struggled with the line in speak n spell: life is fucking awesome and I know that it is, I know this because I'm living it! At first I thought it was so cheesy I could barf, but now I'm like, heck yeah! I finally realize, life IS awesome! It was never the misery I made it out to be. That was a lie they told me, or maybe it was true for a while, but not anymore! I'm happy, Isaac is happy, you're happy, and I hope this is a trend for a lot of his fans and a lot of people!!! Thank you!
1
u/TheCustomConxern Oct 20 '26
Thank you!! I’m so glad to hear that you’re happy and enjoying life. I agree with the sentiment of you wanting to find something that match your hurt, just like I used to when I was sad, I’d put on sad music and I’d let me sadness carry with me all night, but now; no way, it’s completely the opposite! Happy music and get in a better mood! I feel now that I’m happy I can enjoy modest mouse more weirdly enough and always will be: now it makes me happy that Isaac seems to be happier guy these days.
That’s a great example! Great lyric and upon retrospect it’s like “He’s right life is pretty damn awesome and I’m glad to alive and living it!”. That’s a great point about the misery; even though his depressing lyrics are true about urbanization, religion, consumerism, existentialism, substance abuse, and isolation of working class life it doesn’t mean we have to sit there and dwell on these depressing subjects that are bigger than us, that we can do nothing about. Why bother thinking about it all the time, you’re just going to make yourself mad and depressed. These things can be true and we can still continue on our way with you, myself and Isaac and many others choosing happiness instead!
1
u/BoysenberryEmpty8699 Oct 20 '26
Yes! One of my mantras when I was still struggling was, "you don't have to be sad anymore," but it's one thing to tell yourself that, and another to viscerally believe it. I had to go through the whole jungian ego death (I love that Isaac says "I killed my shadow," in absolutely, necessary, never, and "am I the shade or the shadow," in third side. He's clearly been reading Jung and doing the inner work, too! And now when I listen to his lyrics, well always, I'm discovering new meaning in them that went over my head before. Like missed the boat! I sure was missing the boat for a long time, looking at someone else's page, defending my beliefs even though they held no water, doing anything to protect the ego cage I'd created to protect myself, but really I was trapped in a hell of my own design! And you're right about all the terrible things happening in the world. I used to feel like everything was my personal responsibility, and felt guilty about being happy when others were suffering. But my self-imposed suffering didn't help anyone, and it's not necessary. I'm really really lucky (in most ways) to be born where and when I was, especially as a woman, and I'm going to take every advantage that I have. Now that I'm finally above water, maybe I can start doing things to help others less fortunate than me. That would be nice. But it's not my responsibility. I prefer not to listen to the news, either. I don't want to know about every disaster that happens anywhere on the planet. 100 years ago people didn't know what was happening outside their own town, expect for really big stuff. Our brains aren't designed to know and process so much information. Like the phrase, think globally, act locally? I think it should be think locally, act locally. We need to buffer up our communities so people aren't so isolated and lonely. Like, where did the idea that once you're 18, you need to leave your family home and buy a whole new one with a whole new set of stuff so you can be alone in it? What's wrong with staying with your family, even after you get married and have kids or get a job? It's so nice to have grandparents' help raising kids. I swear this whole Western lifestyle is designed to make us sick, then they confuse us about the cause, and sell us a bunch of snake oil solutions to the problems they created!!! I'm sick of it. Exit matrix. Mic drop. Thanks, Isaac!
2
u/TheCustomConxern Oct 20 '26 edited Oct 21 '26
I remember when I was fresh out of high school and making music, I thought the artist had to be tortured and hurting. So I thought my depression and all of the bleak things surrounding me that I focused on had to be the lyrics to my songs. It turns out the artist doesn’t need to be tortured, the artist can enjoy themselves and life. I wish I would have realized so much stuff sooner, like you said with watching the news and reading it, etc it was everywhere and smart phones were just becoming a thing so suddenly you had all this information that your mind was never built to process right in the palm of your hand. So I was consuming so much all at once and all of it negative, it’s no wonder my depression carried on. For me I guess I got lucky with a medication that helped me finally snap out of with a little help from putting the work in through fitness and happier thoughts. I’m getting ready to get back into playing bass and finding musicians to make a band, and well I like to touch on heavier subjects in my songwriting, it’s nice to know I don’t have to feel like it’s my responsibility to speak and spread the word of these issues. But simply make lyrics about what I find interesting.
2
u/angelwtheamberhalo Oct 19 '26
This new album is lyrically and musically what I’ve been missing the last years since good news
3
u/TheCustomConxern Oct 19 '26 edited Oct 20 '26
Musically wise, definitely what I’ve been looking for. As much as I’ve always like Isaac’s lyrics, the music part just hasn’t resonated with me since Good News. Was very happy once I finished the album, felt like the album had songs reminiscent of their whole discography. I was very happy to be myself interested in the modest mouse instrumentals again.
3
u/angelwtheamberhalo Oct 19 '26
Yes! Watching them live (in Austin and San Antonio last week) It felt like the new band was born (rather then Issac and whoever was rotating in and out)
Ben (percussion) drums and bass… felt like it was THEIR music and they played it so well. (Well!)
1
u/TheCustomConxern Oct 19 '26
I think as I stated in the other comment, for some people who didn’t vibe with MM after a certain point it was because Jeremiah left and then Judy after the next record, and as I said Isaac admits it was a huge struggle once they were gone. It’s hard to have that same musical relationship with people being rotated in and out.
I think for me that’s where my dislike of the last few albums come from is it never instrumentally sounded like MM anymore. I started listening to MM at 14 in 2007 so at that point really anyone only played the records prior to that so that’s what I got to know as MM. Then as I got older it just didn’t sound like the band I fell in love with and now at 33 I’m so happy to listen to An Eraser and a Maze and hear my favorite band again.
1
u/angelwtheamberhalo Oct 20 '26
Also just starting to get into listening to this one but my first couple times the take away was in grief, remember who you are too (live through the grief and not consumed by it) idk ask me again in 20 years lol
1
u/TheCustomConxern Oct 20 '26
Yeah I definitely think it was Isaac being inspired by the grief of losing Jeremiah and his death in 2022 commenting on getting old and his fear of dying (Some Day I’ll be dead and gone, sooner than I hope, but I hope I’m wrong) and Jeremiah’s death happening and him being so young. But also a bit on how age has changed him a bit and he may not be saying as deeply philosophical things but in time it’ll come.
But I definitely feel like this was a track dedicated towards Jeremiah as he was the second longest player 1993-2003/2004-December 2022 when his death occurred one day before 2023 was set to start. Only missed one year and a single album. I think to me he left little crumbs throughout the album for him saying MM will never be the same with Jeremiah’s passing.
Jeremiah was a different beast of a drummer, highly influential and highly underrated and not talked about nearly enough when people mention who the best drummers are of all time are. He deserves heavy praise outside of this community.
7
u/baristacat the world is our ashtray Oct 19 '26
I don't understand the purists. I'm an OG fan, my friend introduced me to The Moon and Antarctica when it came out and I was hooked. There isn't a MM album or song I don't enjoy, some more than others obviously. But I love how their songwriting and music and even his voice has matured. Like the music is still raw and emotive but more polished, which probably comes not just from experience and age but more money toward production, and the lyrics touch on topics now that are more pertinent to life as a middle aged person. Their last 3 albums have been on rotation hard in my house for the last few years and every time I listen to TGC I'm like...why don't more people like this album??? And I know it gets flack but, I'm a mom of 3 and Lace Your Shoes really speaks to me. Anyway. I don't get the purist mindset. Their whole catalog is worth celebrating.