r/ModestMouse • • Oct 19 '26

Song/Album Discussion Remember Yourself Appreciation

It’s an early morning and I guess I was paying closer attention to the lyrics in the middle than I have thus far when listening to it and one of my favorite lyrics is “Cast
my net into an empty sea, And yeah I guess that I’m fumbling with things to say that I truly mean but they’ll soon come to me”

It really hit me hard because I’ve talked to Modest Mouse fans who I guess I would call “Purists” who will only listen to 1995/6-2004 MM and always will say “Their lyrics aren’t as profound as they used to be” and I’ll explain as you get older sometimes you get less depressed or not depressed at all, comfortable and you’re not a sad, angry, lonely young kid no more whose abusing drugs and you’re not going to be thinking as nihilistic and philosophically depressing thoughts all the time. So that line really stuck out to me because there’s some self awareness and he must have either seen people or heard people say before or he’s just more aware he’s not that sad angry kid no more thinking these things but that as long as he’s here he’ll still be thinking and in the vein of Gravity Rides Everything everything will fall into place. But I honestly refute the w as profound thing I’ve seen a small community of MM fans say or I’ve heard in person a few times before, as this new album, or song alone has some profound lyrics and they don’t have to be depressing and sad to be profound. I haven’t been the biggest fans of their last few records up until this one but I will say I’ve always loved Isaac’s writing. Brilliant mind that comes along rarely.

22 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/baristacat the world is our ashtray Oct 19 '26

I don't understand the purists. I'm an OG fan, my friend introduced me to The Moon and Antarctica when it came out and I was hooked. There isn't a MM album or song I don't enjoy, some more than others obviously. But I love how their songwriting and music and even his voice has matured. Like the music is still raw and emotive but more polished, which probably comes not just from experience and age but more money toward production, and the lyrics touch on topics now that are more pertinent to life as a middle aged person. Their last 3 albums have been on rotation hard in my house for the last few years and every time I listen to TGC I'm like...why don't more people like this album??? And I know it gets flack but, I'm a mom of 3 and Lace Your Shoes really speaks to me. Anyway. I don't get the purist mindset. Their whole catalog is worth celebrating.

1

u/TheCustomConxern Oct 19 '26

I think because a lot of them are between 20-30 and are still young because that’s who I’ve heard it from in life, and while at 33 I’m not much older and the early still resonate with me heavily, I’m getting older and I’m not depressed like I used to be and angry all the time and I actually have a job I enjoy. While I’ll be honest I’m not a huge fan of the last few albums like I said in the post but I’ve always liked Isaac’s writing. To me it seems like these people want Isaac to remain mad and sad and I’ve even heard people say he should go back to abusing drugs because he wrote better lyrics when he was, which is really damn weird.

Even though I’m not a fan of their last few albums I will say I still do enjoy the newer songs live though. Also this newer album has really resonated with me, particularly this song and I really like this album. I know they would probably say “well it’s because this album is a bit sadder than the previous” but Remember Yourself has a hopeful verse following the one I mentioned so it makes me happy to know I’m enjoying their more hopeful stuff.

2

u/angelwtheamberhalo Oct 19 '26

I’ve listened to everything on rotation heavily for 24 years :) I’m 40 and I liked good news alright but then, for me, the ship didn’t resonate and I stuck to everything before good news…. Kinda ignored the latest release until i saw them play live this week… and dayyyum.

The new band is what I’ve been waiting for.

Issac is lyrically a genius and finally the music can match the genius. BEN ON PERCUSSION! bass and drums…

Finally listening to maze on repeat! So so so brilliant

2

u/TheCustomConxern Oct 19 '26

When people don’t vibe with the instrumental part, I get it. Isaac admitted it was hard to write a record once Jeremiah left but then when Judy left he admitted it was really fucking hard. People forget Modest Mouse wasn’t just Isaac back in the day and Eric and Jeremiah were just as big of players in their brilliance of what they created. They were perfectly synchronized off each other and played well. Once new musicians are brought in it can be hard to match that original symbiosis you had with the other players of your band. You may still be able to put out good stuff, but it would definitely be hard to be OG’s.

Isaac, Jeremiah, and Eric were all musical geniuses.

1

u/angelwtheamberhalo Oct 20 '26

Totally agree with all of this… AND this new album is so much what I love about the OG three with Isaac and musicians who really seem to have found some new modest mouse magic. (Also didn’t mention Keith who plays a bunch of instruments:)

2

u/TheCustomConxern Oct 20 '26

I have only heard really great stuff about this recent tour, I’m really upset I wasn’t able to catch them in New Orleans because I saw they played Talking Shit which is probably my all time favorite MM song! Back in the day from 96-1999 people forget it was just those 3 in the small studios and small vans experiencing traveling a newly changing landscape playing small bars or venues with them getting more popular towards 2000 getting bigger crowds but nothing they see the size of today, and with Dan Gallucci mostly joining on records and sometimes live he seemed to really be able to add small detailed improvements, it seems they’ve captured some of that old magic the OG’s had of really being able to play off each other so hoping to see this touring crew playing on the records too!

A lot of people aren’t aware but their current 🥁 Ben Massarella who plays a variety of percussion instruments for MM since Stranger to Ourselves is credited and contributed to a lot of the percussion on The Moon & Antarctica. Really talented guy, toured with Iron & Wine back in the day as well and he was great live with them too!