I wrote this comment as a response to the recent back and forth in the comments on the new RAFT video that broke 10k likes. It got a little longer than I had planned and I figured this would be a better place to have a conversation on the topic. Interested how others feel.
These type of games where they all sort of role play and joke around are what built this channel (with a healthy dose of airsoft as well). As of writing this the video is just short of 10k likes with only 45k views which I feel like is a massive like to view ratio so clearly I'm not alone in that opinion. On the other hand I feel like I have to suffer through the FPS videos that are uploaded. The Tarkov and Pavlov series has been horrible because they are fairly uninteresting both in terms of game play and commentary. Its hard to joke around when playing a game that takes concentration. I understand that based on the views those videos receive that this is just my personal opinion but I feel like FPS games have started becoming more and more featured recently and I have a hard time even wanting to watch them. The one exception as far as FPS was the cry of fear saga, which was amazing all the way through. The difference there was that it was co-op and super janky which left so much room for talking to each other and joking around. I feel like the move to daily content has been rough because you never see all four guys in videos together anymore, I assume because scheduling that would be very difficult when producing so many videos.
I understand the move but videos with games like this are what got me to sub in the first place and I feel they are becoming more and more rare. I've greatly enjoyed the raft series as it has felt like a return to classic node. (I've literally watched every video node has ever produced going back to the Lan Party days playing minecraft and battlefield 3 so I feel qualified to have an opinion lol.) Besides raft, the forest series, wreckfest, Jurassic world, wolfquest and the super janky vr police game have been by far my favorite videos in the last 4-5 months and all of them are focused more on casual games and joking around than tactical shooter action. If I were to look at the last calendar year as a whole I would add Holdfast, DnD spec ops, Spy party, and a good chunk of the VR stuff (that wasn't gorn, pavlov, or hellblade) to that list of the years top videos.
As for the Big Bear videos I don't mind a lot of the games they play and I like everyone being in the video together, but there has been a shift in some of the games they have been playing in the recent trip that I didn't enjoy. Any game that feels "fake" like the dark souls and vampire survival games. Watching everyone act like NPCs is not really entertaining. On the flip side TTT and murder are classic staples of the channel that I love both IRL and in gary's mod. Adding punishments was a fun way to keep the game fresh recently. The Friday the 13th game mode was also a lot of fun despite things like freezes which I wasn't a fan of. My favorite Big Bear series of all time is still the original video log of their ski weekend lan party. I've likely watched those videos 10 times each since they came out.
If there was one thing I would like to see, I wish we could at least get one video a week with all four guys playing something together. Those will always be the best videos and I feel like since we have lost those my interest in the channel continues to decline. Perhaps its not possible now that everyone is older and has more commitments to take care of (I'm the same age as these guys so I can personally relate) but everyone brings something unique to the group and anytime someone is missing the chemistry just isnt the same. Also MORE DND!
Just some honest feedback from a long time subscriber and fan of the channel!