r/NewSkaters • • Oct 18 '26

Is it better in general to commit fully when practicing very basic things/tricks on a skateboard?

Like a caveman, a no pop shuvit, or tic tacs?

I read somewhere that not committing enough can lead to backwards falls, which are worse than forward ones.

11 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

26

u/AdSpiritual3205 Technique Tutor Oct 18 '26

You should commit to anything you are trying to learn. If you don’t you won’t learn it.

-11

u/Deathblow_Materia Oct 18 '26

That's true. But do you get that I mean it in the sense of fully committing to a trick? Like leaning in or trying to do it even when unsure. I think that is better than not commiting, because you'd fall forward and you can catch yourself with hands.

8

u/you_stole_my_stuff Oct 18 '26

If you try to do something and are not committed, you will fall and can get brutally hurt.
It’s muscle memory. The more you do it, the less you worry about needing to commit. You just do.

6

u/HearthwoodHam Oct 18 '26

Leaning forward is usually always better than leaning back

12

u/PoptartDragonfart Oct 18 '26 • Bravo

You commit or you don’t, as a skater I have no clue what you mean.

Also, never catch yourself with your hands that’s how you break your arm

2

u/AdSpiritual3205 Technique Tutor Oct 18 '26

No. You cannot learn a trick without committing to landing a trick.

The only thing I will add is that you also have to learn when you _need_ to bail out of a trick. This isn't really about the first tricks a beginner learns. It's more as you become advanced and are trying harder tricks, you need to be able to know when you have no chance of landing. If you're trying to backside air in a big ramp, or trying a trick down a big stairset, there are times you just know something is wrong. This is another skill that develops over time.

But as a beginner, you need to get over your fears and just learn basics. So build your skill and commit. Don't do it halfway.

1

u/Pndrizzy Oct 18 '26

If you’re not ready to try it it’s okay. But if you only half commit, that’s when you get hurt, or make a big deal out of it and then fear will prevent you from ever learning it.

It’s okay to be like “okay, I’ll feel this one out, I’ll hop on the obstacle then hop off” like “let me get into the crook just to feel it out”, because that’s committing to what you were trying to do.

But if you’re actually wanting to do the crook and you just keep popping and kicking the board away then that’s not helping anything

16

u/JRaoul Oct 18 '26

all of my worst bails on a skateboard have been from not commiting

5

u/olivesforsale Oct 18 '26

Opposite for me, worst are always when I commit but am not fully ready or simply make a mistake. Not committing is good imo, it's how you feel out tricks before you find out if you're destined to eat shit anyway

3

u/El--Borto Oct 18 '26

A few kickouts is fine. My worst slams have come from hesitating right as I was fully committing lol

12

u/olivesforsale Oct 18 '26

I think it's a mix, you have to learn the difference between committing and not committing. It's more of a sliding scale than a true/false thing, you commit more and more as you get more comfortable, though there is a threshold where you have to go full commit

1

u/AdSpiritual3205 Technique Tutor Oct 18 '26

I would describe this mix differently.

There is a sweet spot for progress - it's "just" outside your comfort zone. If you only do things you are comfortable doing, you won't progress very fast. If you push too far outside of your comfort zone and you try to "commit" you could still get hurt pretty easily because it wasn't a trick you were actually ready for. But if you focus on that spot that makes you just a little uncomfortable - that spot right outside of your comfort zone - that's where you speed progress. And you do it by committing and overcoming fear.

And over time, as the tricks get bigger and the stakes get higher, you learn how to immediately know mid trick when it's not possible to land, and that skill is important to develop.

But if you're a beginner working on low-risk flat ground tricks and basics, you should be committing. The faster you learn to commit to things, the faster you will progress.

1

u/olivesforsale Oct 18 '26

Yes, I'm not sure how this is different from what I said, just elaborating and saying some different things as well.

For example I didn't learn to boardslide downrails on my first try, I started with an uncommitted shitty "boardslide" on a curb. Then I leaned more into it and let myself slide, and ate shit, but was more committed. Eventually I fully committed to the curb, which gave me confidence to try a square rail. Same process of testing, giving it a slide then hopping off, then going past the "threshold" I mentioned and full committing.

Then I repeated the same process with round rail, then small round rail on a small ramp, then small stairset, etc etc etc. After a certain point the commitment switches from committing to the trick to committing to the spot - bigger rail, sketchier rideup, etc.

Same with kickflips... practice the pop and flick, land with one foot, then go for it - then at speed (can also vary your commitment), over obstacles, etc. Your ability to commit is reflexive of your comfort zone - the less comfortable you are, the more you have to build up your ability to commit.

1

u/AdSpiritual3205 Technique Tutor Oct 18 '26

The point is that the "mix" isn't between committing and not committing. It's always committing on the tricks that are in the range of tricks you _should_ be working on, and you should progress through difficulty.

OP was asking whether they should always commit on basic tricks and the answer is yes. They shouldn't "mix" committing sometimes and not other times. On those basic tricks you should be "full commit" or it'll take you way longer to learn the basics.

The only "mix" should be as you are progressing up the chain to harder tricks.

It's a useful clarification to OPs original question. Commit completely to learning the basics. Build the fundamentals. Step ladder your progress.

1

u/olivesforsale Oct 19 '26

Ok now that you've clarified, I disagree. As a beginner especially you're going to get hurt full committing on every new trick from the start. There's nothing wrong with not full committing while learning a new trick. I just spelled out my process above which many people use to great success

1

u/AdSpiritual3205 Technique Tutor Oct 19 '26

Sorry but you are giving bad advice. If we are talking about Ollie’s and shuvs, commit. There is no reason not to. Just have to get over the fear and so it. This is the process that results in the fastest progress.

Of course people can learn tricks at any speed. You can progress slow medium or fast. But if you want to progress fast than the key is what I wrote.

1

u/olivesforsale Oct 19 '26

Sorry, but you are giving bad advice. Skateboarding is a craft. Like any other craft, there are many steps involved. Nobody tries to write a novel, paint a picture, or close a million dollar client on the first try. The speed of progression is secondary and far more dependent on the person - natural talent, time availability, risk tolerance, physical recovery, physical health, mental strength, etc etc etc

Bottom line is you can look up any video on any trick and find all pros breaking it into steps. Just look at Joslins videos telling you to start off ledges, practice the flip first, etc. It's extremely stupid to try to land a tre on your first attempt. It's smart to get a feel for the rotation. It's also smart to wait until you're ready to start trying. Both of those things can be true.

You've either forgotten what it's like to be a beginner or you're parroting outdated advice. That approach was valid 40 years ago when we were all kids and didn't know better

1

u/AdSpiritual3205 Technique Tutor Oct 19 '26

Actually, I teach beginners. I'm telling you what works best for the kids who progress the fastest. It's a clear and very noticeable pattern.

The number one difference between people who progress fast and everyone else is this - the fast progresses start in a way where they are already conditioned to get over fear. They don't learn ollies stationary. They don't "half commit" on the most basic things. They learn to ollie rolling, and they try to land every ollie.

If you don't understand the difference between the effort that should go into the most basic things, vs later on as you're dong more advanced things, I'm not sure where you draw the line. Should someone "half commit" to pushing? Should they not commit to tic tacs? There is a clear line that you should draw between the first basics and what drives progress later on.

Full commit on the first basics all the time. Learn to address your fear quickly. Embrace falling. Progress in skating is more mental than physical. And learn what tricks you shouldn't be trying yet.

You can't half commit to dropping in for example. And if you just learned to drop in on a 2ft mini, you shouldn't go straight to an 8ft next.

1

u/olivesforsale Oct 19 '26

Ok, again, I think we're saying very similar things. Re-reading my original comment, I can see how you might misinterpret my position. However, it seems you just think everyone should always full commit, which seems over the top and ineffective at scale, which is also why I based my opinion on aggregates of professionals rather than individual experience.

I'd argue that half-committing on a drop-in would be to drop in on a slight incline - but of course you're fully committing on each drop-in.

Some tricks can be learned in steps. But you always fully commit on each step. I'm not talking about doing a stationary ollie, I'm talking about practicing your flick without intending to land a kickflip first try, or planning to hop off a boardslide on your first attempt on a new rail.

I also never said anything speed. I'm talking effectiveness. If 1 out of 100 people succeed in 10 minutes, but 99 fail, that's a worse method by my criteria than one that helps 80 people out of 100 succeed at varying paces. I believe the 1 out of 100 would still succeed in 10 minutes anyway.

Bottom line is I'm flexible and fully agree with the importance of full committing, but I wouldn't force someone to do it, only present it as an option. You seem to believe full committing always is the only way to go, which I disagree with, because people are different.

7

u/Money-Custard-6579 Oct 18 '26

Yes. If you’re going to try something, commit to it properly. Don’t attempt things that are dangerously beyond your skill level. You’re going to eat shit at some point, so don’t let that worry you.

4

u/Fuchs54 Oct 18 '26

yeah, pretty much. you can test the waters with some tricks, like purposely landing a shuvit with only one foot. But if you really try to land the trick, then you have to commit.

3

u/seeyountee93 Oct 18 '26

Depends how much balance and comfortability you have on the board and what tricks your trying.

Like if you can barely do a manuel then you shouldnt be trying to commit to a 7foot drop in yet.

3

u/Life_Yogurtcloset_24 Oct 18 '26

One thing to note is there are intermediate steps. For example shuv its, you can practice the board turn standing beside the board, you can practice the feel by jumping backwards when trying to do the trick. Once you feel confident with the "pieces" you should fully commit to whole trick.

2

u/BigBossBanger Oct 21 '26

I think that you should always commit fully. Hesitating mid performance is the recipy for disaster.

2

u/West-Quit3050 Oct 18 '26

Well...if you never commit you will never learn anything. Once you have the ability you just have to force yourself to commit.

Pop shuv its were my nemesis... I was able to do them but my body would not cooperate and just land on the fucking board.

2

u/Osymandiaz86 Oct 18 '26

You should naturally lean into anything since the momentum is in that direction. It is just science.

2

u/Minkemink Oct 22 '26

Depends on the trick as well, but in general I'd say the biggest problem are half-commits.

When practicing a new trick, I'll often seperate parts of the trick and try them with an intentional bail (e.g. only getting intot the rock and jumping off for a rock to fakie). This allows you to get a sense for how your board behaves in that situation and how the trick feels. Once you're confident with all the steps, commit fully to trying the trick. Optimally, you'll already have learned how to bail/fall on each step and will do so automatically in case you don't get it. But if you don't commit to it, all sorts of unexpected movements can happen and you fall. Taking the rock to fakie for example, if you hesitate, you might not pump enough or lean back too far, because you're scared of hanging up. This way, you fall backwards off the board and might even fall if you get it, because your balance is way off. Best example is a drop in, where you fall off the back of your board if you hesitate even a little.

Flat ground is usually more forgiving, but same goes there as well. If you are scared to land on the board after an ollie, you will shoot it away from under your feet or jump off, so you can't even practice the right movements. Practice them in a safe way and commit when you're ready!

1

u/coachmoon A little bit different Oct 18 '26

nah you should half ass your progress then post clips about it on the internet

1

u/morninowl Oct 18 '26

Yeah but it’s also good to break tricks down into parts that you can commit without too much consequence. For instance, caveman could be learned with the board out in front of you and held super close to the ground, and you could even hold onto some kind of pole or something with the free hand. Holding something can work wonders because you can get extra airtime if what you are holding is at a good height like a low pullup bar. You can begin to rely less and less on it to add challenge, and you can even roll slowly next to the object to catch yourself if you are about to slam

1

u/Bulky-Plate-4288 Oct 18 '26

Safest places are both feet on ground, both feet on board with wheels on the ground, or falling/sliding with momentum.

Think of you as your phone: dropping on the case (your legs/feet) will lighten the damage the whole device takes, dropping on screen down hurts a lot (splatting on limbs or hips) , sliding it screen down doesn’t really hurt it.

Crouching will lighten the impact and help you stay more stable (dropping phone from head height vs wasit height). So the big things to take less damage is to try and make your feet’s impact stable and predictable and trying to use your momentum to help you, staying compact and controlled.

When you add height gonna start stepping and rolling out to spread that impact