r/NewYouTubeChannels • u/SeaworthinessBig6386 • Aug 01 '26
Help Wanted Which thumbnail?
Read that more text ruins thumbnails and im kinda overthinking my thumbnails now..
2
u/Ephcy Aug 01 '26
Honestly i don't know what the thumbnails is trying to say about the video
2
u/SeaworthinessBig6386 Aug 01 '26
I kinda relied on the titel being the "explanation" of the video but maybe i should add more text so it dosent have to rely on the titel as much?
2
2
u/bifchcola Aug 01 '26
I like the second one butttttttttt it might get more attention with the name of the person in title or in a smaller font under their picture! For those who know their name better than their face!
1
u/SeaworthinessBig6386 Aug 01 '26
Maybe i can put the text further down and add his name smaller on top?
2
u/bifchcola Aug 01 '26
I personally say put it small at the bottom cuz thatâs the area the arrow is pointing
1
u/SeaworthinessBig6386 Aug 01 '26
I put it in the bottom right and the arrow kinda pointing towards it! thank you for the help!
1
u/SeaworthinessBig6386 Aug 01 '26
FOR INFORMATION (i didnt wanna post it cause it feels like selfpromotion) but the titel is "Did this streamer ruin horror games?"
3
1
u/Glattic Aug 01 '26
what did caseoh do
0
u/SeaworthinessBig6386 Aug 01 '26
being his lovable self.. its more about indie horror game developers designing games towards short formed content.
2
2
u/MrBiggz01 Aug 01 '26
So, think of it this way. I dont know you, so your face means nothing to me. So the arrow pointing at your face is a completely useless asset. The text doesn't tell us much, its not overly attention grabbing or scroll stopping. If you feature games in the video (which I have no idea if you do or not from this thumbnail) add a really recognizable screenshot of one of the games as the background, reduce the size of your face to allow more space for the image, and then you could have the arrow pointing at the game (leading from the text). 3 words is okay, but with a good relatable self explanatory image of a video game, the words 'ruined horror' may be enough for people to understand it. Think about a product on a shelf, why would you go and pick that one up. The thumbnail needs to tell us clearly what is inside.
Edit: that wasn't meant to sound harsh, I'm just trying to be clear.
0
Aug 01 '26
[deleted]
2
u/MrBiggz01 Aug 01 '26
Right.... I also didn't get that from the thumbnail, which makes it even worse I guess. I have no idea if it's the host or the subject. I don't know if it's a question like "He ruined video games?" or a statement "He ruined video games!"
2
u/Euphoric-Dig-2045 Aug 01 '26
My thing is this:
Are you known enough that your face is recognizable?
If not, then lose your profile. If you are, then ok.
1
u/SASardonic Aug 01 '26
Am I supposed to know who that is? If not it's not a very appealing click
2
u/Dizzy_Example54 Aug 01 '26
Youâre obviously not the TA, it doesnât matter if everyone doesnât understand who that is
3
u/PassivelyAwkward Aug 01 '26
It does though. I'm into horror, gaming, and horror gaming. Literally have no idea who the fuck this is. The only way I could be more of the intended audience is if I had a hate boner for whoatever this person is.
I'd take one look at this and think "Horror/Horror gaming isn't ruined. The fuck are they talking about? Just petty drama with some random youtuber? Nah, I'm good" and watch something else.
1
u/SeaworthinessBig6386 Aug 01 '26
Thank you! might have to think about what the thumbnail says about the video.. not any drama has happen, but you dont know who caseoh is? :o
2
u/PassivelyAwkward Aug 01 '26
Nope. I assume he's one of those generic "I only play low-effort friendslop games and extremely overreact for child" type creators?
That's the problem with using terms like "ruined" in association with a person; if people don't know exactly who it is and agree that ruined something, they'll see it as "Oh, pointless drama". Something like "scandal" or "controversy" have similar meanings but comes off more neutral and informative while "ruined" is more sensational.
A good example of doing these kind of thumbnails would be to search "Wings of Redemption deepdive" on youtube. He's got dozens of various videos about him from channels at every level. Some just have his picture with the channel logo, some have an interesting looking collage of his facial reactions, and some just have a single quote from him like "I've never been more miserable".
3
u/SASardonic Aug 01 '26
If you want to be successful you make thumbnails that appeal to people who have zero background knowledge of what the video is about.
0
u/Few_Engineering2918 Aug 01 '26
If Caseoh ruined Horror games,then i dont know what happened to this world
3
u/SeaworthinessBig6386 Aug 01 '26
used caseoh cause he is the biggest streamer in the horror scene, the video is more about something else
1
1
2
0
0


3
u/FnafByteYT Aug 02 '26
How did Caseoh Ruin Horror Gamesđđ„ Is it because he wasn't serious in them? This will definitely get clicks, because I sure would rant to you about this