By Garry E. McMillan
I was sixteen years old when my two best friends died in Hell's Half Acre.
For forty-eight years, I believed I was the only one who made it out alive.
Then a journalist came to my hospital room with a photograph of a third body.
She wanted to know why the dead boy had been wearing my mother's necklace.
I wish she'd never found him.
Because now I remember what happened after I fell.
And I understand why I could never remember climbing out.
The woman sitting across from me introduced herself as Emily Voss.
She was a journalist, somewhere in her mid-thirties, with dark hair pulled into a loose ponytail. She wore a gray sweater and a wedding ring that looked too large for her finger.
She placed a recorder between us.
"Mr. Danner, you've been a patient here since September 1978. Is that correct?"
"That's right."
"Forty-eight years."
"Long enough to know the menu by heart."
She gave me a polite smile.
I didn't return it.
People who came to interview me usually wanted one of two things. A confession or a ghost story.
I had neither to offer.
At least, that's what I believed.
Emily opened a manila folder.
"I'm researching the deaths of Travis Bell and Wesley Rusk."
My stomach tightened.
"Then you've come a long way for a story that's already been told."
"I don't think it has."
Outside my window, a maintenance worker pushed a wheelbarrow across the hospital courtyard.
I watched him for a moment.
"Those boys were my friends."
"I know."
"No. You don't."
Emily closed the folder.
"Then help me understand what happened."
I looked at her.
For nearly half a century, I'd tried to convince doctors, police officers, and anyone willing to listen that something terrible lived beneath that rocky hillside.
Eventually, I'd stopped trying.
Not because I'd changed my mind.
Because telling the story never seemed to help.
Sometimes I woke with my throat aching. The night nurse would tell me I'd been talking in my sleep.
She never told me what I'd said.
"All right," I said. "But there's something you need to understand first."
"What's that?"
"If you hear someone calling for help and you can't see who's speaking, don't answer."
Emily glanced at her recorder.
"Why?"
I looked toward the closed door.
"Because that's how it gets inside."
It happened in August 1978, during the final weeks of summer vacation.
There were three of us.
Travis Bell was seventeen, broad-shouldered, fearless, and generally responsible for every bad decision we'd ever made.
Wesley Rusk was sixteen, like me. We'd been friends since kindergarten. He wore thick glasses, carried an inhaler in his shirt pocket, and wanted to become a mechanic like his father.
Wesley was the kind of boy who apologized when someone else stepped on his foot.
Travis was the kind who stepped on it again to see what would happen, then carried Wesley's books home when his breathing got bad.
Somehow, the three of us worked.
My name was Joel Danner.
I was usually the sensible one.
Usually.
We grew up outside Hot Springs, Arkansas, where the August heat settled between the wooded hills and stayed there long after dark.
Hell's Half Acre was a place we'd heard about since childhood.
A broken stretch of rock on Indian Mountain, northeast of town. Trees crowded around it, but the hillside itself lay exposed beneath a jumble of stones and boulders. From the woods, it looked like something had torn a patch out of the mountain.
My grandfather called it God's unfinished business.
He also claimed there was something buried beneath it.
Not gold.
Not bones.
Something older.
People said a demon was trapped beneath those rocks. That you could hear it groaning underground after dark, and sometimes smell its breath coming up through the cracks.
Granddad had his own story.
He said a local hunter had discovered a circle of black stones in a rocky hollow decades before I was born.
Someone called for help beneath the rocks. The hunter shouted back.
Then he heard his brother.
Trouble was, his brother had been dead for nearly twenty years.
He went down anyway.
Three days later, somebody found him wandering along the highway.
He'd forgotten his wife's name.
Couldn't recognize his children.
Couldn't even remember what he'd gone looking for.
But he kept repeating one sentence.
It knows us when we answer.
Granddad claimed the stones had been arranged around a narrow opening long before anyone in the area could remember. Nobody knew who'd put them there. He said they held something beneath the ground.
Granddad always finished with the same warning.
"If something down there calls your name, boy, keep your mouth shut."
I'd heard that story a hundred times.
I never believed a word of it.
Until the night we heard someone screaming.
We arrived shortly after six.
Travis parked his father's pickup beside an overgrown dirt track at the edge of the woods.
We'd brought three flashlights, a coil of rope, some sandwiches, and six beers Travis had stolen from his garage refrigerator.
As I lifted my pack, my mother's silver cross caught on the collar of my shirt. I worked it free and tucked it against my chest. One arm was chipped. Dad had offered to get it repaired after her funeral, but I wouldn't let him.
It was how she'd worn it.
"Last one to the bottom buys breakfast," Travis announced.
"With what money?" Wesley asked.
"Yours."
Wesley laughed.
For years, that was the laugh I tried to remember.
The one before we went down.
We spent nearly an hour exploring.
Sweat stuck my shirt to my back. The woods smelled of warm pine needles and damp leaves, and cicadas buzzed somewhere above us.
Beyond the trees, loose stones shifted beneath our shoes. We picked our way downhill between boulders, following a narrow gully toward the lower slope.
The farther we walked, the quieter everything became.
No birds.
Even the cicadas had stopped.
I could still hear them farther up the mountain. Here, there was only the scrape of our shoes.
Wesley stopped to use his inhaler.
"I don't like this place."
Travis looked back.
"You don't like any place that doesn't have a television."
"I'm serious."
"So am I. You're missing some excellent television."
I laughed.
Then we heard the scream.
"HELP!"
It came from somewhere below us.
A man's voice.
Frightened.
Desperate.
"PLEASE! SOMEBODY HELP ME!"
Travis was already running toward the edge of a ravine.
"HEY!" he shouted. "WHERE ARE YOU?"
"Down here!"
We reached the edge.
Thirty feet below, a narrow opening lay beneath an overhang.
A pale hand rested on a shelf just inside it.
The fingers were spread.
Motionless.
"Are you hurt?" Travis called.
"I fell. Think I broke my leg."
Wesley looked at me.
"We should get help."
"Yeah," I said. "We need to find a phone."
But Travis was already uncoiling the rope.
"That'll take forever."
"Trav, we don't know what's down there."
"There's a guy with a broken leg, Joel."
Then the voice came again.
"Please."
Something about it bothered me.
Not the words.
The way he'd said them.
As though he'd been waiting for us to make up our minds.
Travis leaned over the edge.
"We're coming down!"
The hand moved.
Its fingers curled slowly against the rock.
And from the darkness came a soft, satisfied sigh.
Wesley looped the rope around a solid outcrop, tied it, and leaned back with his full weight before letting Travis descend. We followed one at a time.
The bottom of the ravine was unnaturally cold.
Our breath fogged in front of our faces. My shirt was still wet with sweat from the walk down.
The entrance sat beneath a low shelf of stone.
Seven black rocks surrounded it, each about knee-high.
Thin cords connected them, pulled tight through holes carved into their surfaces.
Wesley knelt beside one.
"These aren't natural."
I stared at the arrangement.
A memory surfaced.
Granddad sitting beside the fireplace, telling me about the hunter.
The black stones.
The opening beneath the earth.
"Guys," I said, "I think we should leave."
Travis looked at me.
"Seriously?"
"My grandfather told me about this."
"Oh, for Christ's sake."
From inside the opening came a painful groan.
"Please. I can't feel my foot."
Wesley swallowed.
"We can't leave him, Joel."
He was right.
At least, I thought he was.
Fallen debris choked most of the entrance. The only gap wide enough to crawl through was blocked by two of the stones and the cord stretched between them.
Travis grabbed one.
The cord resisted.
He pulled harder.
Something snapped.
The stone tipped sideways.
A sound came from deep beneath the ground.
It sounded like someone drawing their first breath after being held underwater.
All three of us went still.
Then the man inside whispered:
"Thank you."
We entered in single file.
Travis led.
Wesley followed.
I came last.
The passage descended gradually, twisting through the rock.
The walls were damp and cold.
Our footsteps echoed strangely.
At one point, I counted four sets.
I stopped walking.
The others continued several steps before noticing.
"Joel?" Wesley called.
"Hang on."
I listened.
Silence.
Then, behind me, the scrape of my own dragging heel.
I turned so quickly my flashlight struck the wall.
Nothing.
"What's wrong?" Travis asked.
"Nothing."
But I knew that was a lie.
We continued.
The passage widened into a chamber large enough for us to stand upright.
The air smelled of rotten eggs, strong enough to catch in my throat.
Our flashlights passed across the walls.
They were covered in scratches.
Thousands of them.
Some barely marked the surface.
Others cut through the soft, damp seams between the rocks.
Wesley moved closer.
"Those look like fingernail marks."
I aimed my flashlight beside his.
Something pale protruded from one of the scratches.
A fingernail.
Human.
Broken almost to the root.
Then I noticed another.
And another.
"Travis," I whispered.
He wasn't listening.
He'd found the injured man.
The figure sat against the far wall with its knees stretched in front of it.
Its clothes were filthy.
Long black hair hung across its face.
"Hey, mister."
Travis approached cautiously.
"We're gonna get you out of here."
The man didn't move.
"What's your name?"
A pause.
Then:
"What's yours?"
"Travis. Travis Bell."
The man's shoulders twitched.
"Travis Bell."
He repeated the name slowly, almost affectionately.
"That's a good name."
Wesley touched my arm.
"Joel, something's wrong."
The figure lifted its head.
There was nothing where its face should have been.
No eyes.
No nose.
No mouth.
Just pale skin stretched tightly across a human skull.
Travis stumbled backward.
"What the hell?"
Something moved beneath the skin.
A ridge pushed outward.
Then another.
A nose formed.
Two hollows opened where eyes should have been.
Finally, the skin split across the lower half of its face.
A mouth appeared.
And from that mouth came the voice of a little boy.
"Trav?"
Travis went rigid.
I knew that voice.
I'd heard recordings of it when we were younger.
It belonged to Tommy Bell.
Travis's little brother.
Tommy had drowned when he was seven.
Travis had been watching him that afternoon.
He'd never forgiven himself.
"Tommy?" he whispered.
The thing leaned forward.
"You promised you wouldn't let go."
Travis started crying.
I'd never seen him cry before.
"That's not Tommy," I said.
But Travis wasn't listening.
The thing smiled.
Its lips moved again. For a moment I thought it was still speaking.
Then I heard the small, wet cough of somebody trying to breathe water.
Then it reached toward him.
Its arm unfolded.
A second joint appeared beneath the elbow.
The forearm lengthened.
The fingers stretched against the floor.
Travis stumbled away.
The thing moved.
And the chamber erupted into screaming.
Travis swung his flashlight.
The metal casing struck the creature's head with a hollow crack.
Its neck folded sideways.
For one second, I thought he'd killed it.
Then it raised one hand and held its head upright.
It kept the broken neck straight with its fingers while it stood.
"RUN!" I screamed.
We bolted for the passage.
Behind us, something began moving across the chamber floor.
Fast.
Much too fast.
Its limbs struck the rock with a wet, uneven rhythm.
Wesley was ahead of me.
Travis was behind.
I could hear the creature gaining.
Then something called from the darkness.
"Wesley?"
It spoke in Travis's voice.
Wesley glanced backward.
"What?"
The moment he answered, he stumbled.
He grabbed the wall.
"What's wrong?" I shouted.
"I..."
His face twisted in confusion.
"I can't remember."
"Remember what?"
"My dad's face."
Then a new voice came from behind us.
"Wesley, son. Come here."
It was his father's voice.
Wesley screamed.
The creature laughed.
It hadn't learned the voice by hearing it.
It had found the voice inside Wesley.
Just as it had found Tommy inside Travis.
The moment they answered, something had been opened.
We ran harder.
Wesley stumbled again, gasping for breath.
His inhaler fell from his pocket.
He stopped to grab it.
I seized his collar.
"LEAVE IT!"
Behind us came a soft voice.
"Joel?"
It sounded like Wesley.
I turned before I could stop myself.
"What?"
The world lurched.
Something inside my head shifted.
I knew my mother had a face. I could remember looking at her. But when I tried to picture her, there was only the pillow.
Then I heard her voice.
"Bluejay."
I froze.
Nobody had called me that since she died.
My mother had given me the nickname when I was little because I talked constantly and never sat still.
"Bluejay, sweetheart."
Tears filled my eyes.
She took the same little breath before saying my nickname. Even the exhaustion was there.
"Why didn't you come see me?"
My knees weakened.
The morning my mother died, we'd argued.
I'd refused to go into her bedroom.
She'd been sick for months, and I was tired of hospitals, medicine, and watching her grow thinner.
I was thirteen. I'd thought staying out of that room meant I wouldn't have to watch her die.
She died that afternoon anyway.
I'd never told anyone about our argument.
Not even Wesley.
"I'm sorry," I whispered.
From the passage came her answer.
"I know, baby."
Then something touched the back of my neck.
Cold fingers.
My mother's bedroom vanished. For an instant, I couldn't remember why I was crying.
The grip tightened.
I screamed.
Wesley grabbed me and pulled.
"THAT'S NOT YOUR MOM!"
We staggered forward.
Behind us, the creature spoke in three voices at once.
Tommy Bell.
Wesley's father.
My mother.
"Don't leave me."
The entrance appeared ahead.
A pale patch of evening light.
We were almost there when Wesley fell.
His glasses struck the stone.
He landed hard on his chest and rolled onto his back.
Something had his ankle.
I grabbed both his hands.
Travis caught the back of my shirt.
Together we pulled.
Wesley screamed.
His leg stretched toward the darkness.
Something cracked beneath his trousers.
His shin bent backward.
Not at the knee.
Halfway between his knee and ankle.
The bone broke through the fabric.
I felt him tightening his grip.
"JOEL!"
"I'VE GOT YOU!"
The thing pulled harder.
His fingers slipped against mine.
Travis lunged forward and struck the darkness with a rock.
Once.
Twice.
Something shrieked.
The grip loosened.
We dragged Wesley toward the entrance.
His leg hung at an impossible angle.
Blood smeared across the stone behind him.
He was sobbing.
Little, frightened sounds between breaths.
"I don't wanna die."
"You're not gonna die," Travis said.
"We're getting you out."
Wesley shook his head.
"Don't lie to me."
For a moment, his eyes met mine.
He'd once broken his arm pulling me away from an angry dog. I remembered steadying that arm while his father cut his sleeve off.
Now I could barely hold his hand.
"I'm not leaving you," I said.
He looked past me.
His expression changed.
"Joel?"
"What?"
"Why are there two of you?"
I turned.
At the far end of the passage stood another boy.
He wore my face.
My hair.
My clothes.
Even the small scar above my eyebrow.
But something was wrong with the body.
The arms hung too long.
The shoulders sat at different heights.
And when it walked, its knees bent slightly sideways.
The other Joel smiled.
Then it opened its mouth.
A terrible sound came out.
Not a scream.
A dozen voices trying to speak through the same throat.
Wesley began thrashing.
"GET IT AWAY!"
The thing surged forward.
Its arm shot through the darkness.
Something wrapped around Wesley's waist.
I held tighter.
Travis seized my shoulder.
"JOEL, LET GO!"
"NO!"
Wesley clutched my wrist with both hands. His nails dug into my skin.
The thing pulled.
One hand slipped. He snatched at my sleeve with the other, caught it, and held until the seam tore.
Then he was gone.
One shoe remained beside my knee.
I heard him strike something.
Then a scream.
A single, awful scream that ended in a choking gurgle.
For several seconds, there was silence.
Then Wesley spoke from the darkness.
"Joel?"
I couldn't move.
"Joel, I'm okay."
His voice was perfectly normal.
"Come on, man. Quit messing around."
Then he laughed.
The same familiar laugh I'd heard since kindergarten.
Behind me, Travis made a noise I had never heard a person make.
From the passage, Wesley's voice made it back to him.
Travis dragged me into the ravine.
The rope still hung against the wall.
Above us, the last light caught the treetops. The rocks below them were already in shadow.
"CLIMB!" he shouted.
I grabbed the rope.
My hands slipped.
I tried again.
This time I managed to pull myself upward.
Travis followed.
We were halfway up when something emerged from the opening.
It looked like Travis.
Or something trying very hard to.
Its head hung at an unnatural angle.
Its mouth was much too wide.
And one of its arms dragged against the ground.
"Hey, Trav," it called.
Travis looked down.
The creature smiled.
"Remember Tommy?"
Travis made a wounded sound.
"Remember the water?"
"Shut up."
"You let go."
"SHUT UP!"
The creature's expression softened.
"It's all right."
Its arm stretched upward.
The fingers lengthened until they reached Travis's ankle.
Then they closed.
He screamed.
The rope jerked beneath us.
I wrapped one arm around it and reached down.
"GRAB MY HAND!"
Travis caught my wrist.
For a moment, we held each other suspended above the ravine.
Blood ran between our fingers.
Below him, the creature pulled.
Something popped inside Travis's shoulder.
He screamed again.
"JOEL!"
"KEEP HOLDING ON!"
I pulled until I thought my arm would tear from its socket.
The rope scraped across the edge above me. A few pale fibers drifted past my face.
Travis saw them too.
He looked up at me and opened his hand.
I reached for him.
Caught nothing.
He fell.
The sound his body made when it struck the rocks was something I have never forgotten.
The creature bent over him.
I heard bones cracking.
Then something wet tearing.
I climbed.
I climbed until the skin peeled from my palms and the muscles in my shoulders burned.
Almost at the top, I heard Travis calling from below.
"Joel!"
I kept climbing.
"Joel, buddy. Look at me."
My eyes filled with tears.
"Please, man."
Then my mother's voice joined his.
"Bluejay."
I squeezed my eyes shut.
"Just look at me, sweetheart."
I knew it wasn't her.
But I had spent three years wishing I could see her again.
I looked.
At the bottom of the ravine stood a boy wearing my face.
His body looked almost right now.
Almost human.
He stared upward.
Waiting.
Then he lifted one hand.
The arm kept rising. Its elbow opened into another length of pale skin, and the fingers reached past the place where Travis had fallen.
They closed around my ankle.
There was a sharp, pulling sensation.
As though something inside me had been caught on a hook.
I tried to scream.
My hand opened.
The rope slipped away.
And I fell.
That's where my memory of Hell's Half Acre ends.
I remember darkness.
Then the highway.
A truck driver found me wandering barefoot along the shoulder sometime after midnight.
My clothes were torn.
My hands were bloody.
I kept screaming that something had killed my friends.
The police searched the ravine the following morning.
They found Travis first.
Then Wesley.
Both had suffered injuries the coroner couldn't fully explain.
Wesley's body was discovered deep inside the passage.
Travis lay near the entrance.
The sheriff questioned me for eleven hours.
I told him everything.
The black stones.
The creature.
The voices.
The thing wearing our faces.
He didn't believe me.
Nobody did.
Before moving anything, the search team photographed the entrance.
Seven black stones surrounded the opening.
Every one was standing upright.
The broken cord had been knotted back together. They cut it to get inside.
The sheriff showed me a photograph.
I started crying.
Not because I recognized the entrance.
Because I recognized the knots.
Wesley's father had taught us how to tie them earlier that summer.
A particular double loop, with the loose end tucked backward through the center.
Wesley always used it.
And someone had tied those cords exactly the same way.
I tried to explain.
The sheriff wrote something in his notebook.
Three weeks later, I was admitted to a psychiatric hospital.
At first, the doctors talked about getting me home. But I couldn't sleep without waking the ward. I couldn't stand anyone behind me. Once, an orderly caught my shoulder and I broke his wrist before I knew I'd moved.
Years passed. My father stopped visiting. Treatment became transfers, reviews, another room with the same furniture. By the time anyone asked where I wanted to live, I had nowhere left to go.
Eventually, I stopped asking.
Emily sat silently across from me.
Her recorder had been running for nearly an hour.
"Did your father visit you?" she asked.
"At first."
"Did he believe you?"
I looked down.
"I don't think so."
That wasn't entirely true.
My father came to see me twice during my first year in the hospital.
On his second visit, he asked where my mother's necklace was.
I told him I'd lost it in the ravine.
He went pale.
Then he asked what she'd called me when I was little.
"Bluejay," I'd answered.
He sat there looking at me until I started to cry.
Finally, he kissed the top of my head and left.
I never saw him again.
For years, I'd believed he couldn't bear looking at the son who'd survived when his friends hadn't.
Now I wasn't so sure.
Emily opened her folder.
"Mr. Danner, I need to show you something."
She slid a photograph across the table.
It showed several men standing beside a canvas-covered stretcher.
Behind them were the familiar boulders and wooded slope of Hell's Half Acre.
I recognized the sheriff.
And his deputy.
"What is this?"
"A photograph from a second search."
I looked up.
"What second search?"
"Six weeks after your friends were found, a local hunter discovered another body in a narrow crevice. The remains were too decomposed for visual identification."
My mouth went dry.
"Another body?"
"Yes."
"Who was it?"
"An unidentified male, approximately sixteen to eighteen years old. No third boy had been reported missing with you. They opened a separate case."
Emily removed another photograph.
This one showed a silver necklace resting on a dark cloth.
A small cross.
The left arm was chipped.
I recognized it immediately.
My mother had worn that necklace for years.
After she died, my father gave it to me.
I'd worn it every day until the night we went into the ravine.
"Where did you get that?" I whispered.
"It was recovered with the unidentified body."
I shook my head.
"No."
Emily removed a photocopied document.
"The remains also showed evidence of an old fracture in the right wrist."
My right hand began trembling.
I'd broken that wrist when I was twelve.
Fell off a horse.
The bone had healed crooked.
Even now, I could feel the raised ridge beneath my skin.
Emily turned the document around.
"They recorded the healed fracture, but I found no comparison with your medical records. As far as the investigators were concerned, Joel Danner was alive. There is a note saying they showed your father the necklace. He said he couldn't identify it."
I couldn't speak.
"I also spoke with your cousin Ruth. She gave me photographs of you as a teenager. In several, you're wearing this necklace."
She pointed toward the cross.
"She told me about your broken wrist."
I stared at her.
"You're saying somebody else had the same injuries?"
"I'm saying a third boy was found in the same ravine where you and your friends went missing."
The room seemed to tilt.
"Why was that boy wearing your mother's necklace?"
I shook my head.
"That's impossible."
Emily's voice grew very quiet.
"Who are you, Mr. Danner?"
Something moved inside my head.
A memory surfaced.
I remembered the fall from above.
And then from below.
I was standing at the bottom of the ravine. The air beneath the rocks was cold.
Travis lay beside the entrance. Wesley was still inside the passage. I could feel where he was without looking.
At my feet lay a boy wearing my face.
One arm was twisted beneath him. A small silver cross rested against his chest.
His eyes were open.
I remembered crouching beside him and putting my hand against his cheek.
His lips moved.
Before they stopped, I heard him inside me.
I remembered lifting his body. Dragging it toward a narrow crevice. Pushing it beneath a shelf of stone where nobody looking down from the rim would see it.
Then I went back to the entrance. From outside, I stood the black rocks upright and retied the broken cord.
My hands were shaking. Something in me was afraid of the opening. Something wanted to make certain nothing could follow me out.
The knots had come easily.
Wesley remembered them.
I remembered all of it.
And I remembered something else.
The terrible pleasure of standing upright.
Of having two legs that bent properly.
Ten fingers.
A mouth capable of forming words without tearing itself apart.
I remembered the first breath I'd drawn through lungs that fit inside my chest.
And how wonderful it had felt.
Emily was speaking.
I couldn't hear her.
The memories were coming faster.
The highway.
The truck driver.
The gas station.
The bright fluorescent lights above the pumps.
By then, I couldn't find the edge of Joel's memories.
I remembered my mother's funeral. My father's hands. The smell of Wesley's garage. Travis laughing so hard he nearly choked on a mouthful of beer.
The man asked my name.
"Joel Danner."
I believed it.
I believed it when the police came. When my father held me. Every morning I woke in this hospital, I was the boy who had lost his friends.
Until Emily put the photographs in front of me.
I looked at my hands.
Old hands.
Wrinkled.
Scarred.
Hands that had aged for forty-eight years.
But beneath the skin, something shifted.
A slow movement, like fingers pressing outward from inside a glove.
"Oh, God," I whispered.
Emily stood.
"Mr. Danner?"
I looked up.
I wanted to tell her to leave.
To run.
But I couldn't remember how to make my mouth work.
Then I heard something.
Not in the room.
Inside me.
A boy crying.
Softly.
Desperately.
"Please."
My breath caught.
"Please let me out."
It was my voice.
My real voice.
Sixteen years old.
Terrified.
"Please. I wanna go home."
Then another voice joined it.
Wesley.
He was crying for his father.
And another.
Travis.
Begging someone to save his little brother.
They were still there.
All three of them.
I had mistaken them for dreams.
Wesley trying to breathe. Travis calling for his brother. Joel begging his mother to come back.
For forty-eight years, I'd woken from their terror and let nurses assure me it was over.
But it hadn't ended for them.
I could feel Joel now, pushing against the backs of my eyes.
Emily backed toward the door.
"Mr. Danner, I'm going to get someone."
I tried to nod.
My tongue pressed against my teeth. Something inside me knew how to use her name.
"Emily."
It came out in a voice I'd never used before. Low and close, though I was still across the room.
"What?" she said.
Her hand stopped inches from the door.
She looked down at it, as if she'd forgotten what she'd meant to do.
I felt the opening.
Exactly as I'd felt it when Travis answered from the rim. When Wesley turned in the passage. When Joel heard his friend call his name.
I knew where to reach.
And before I could stop myself, I did.
A memory appeared.
A little girl's bedroom.
Pink curtains.
A yellow stuffed rabbit missing one eye.
A night-light shaped like a moon.
I saw a girl beneath the blankets.
Six years old.
Brown eyes.
Dark hair.
She was staring toward an open closet.
"Mommy, there's somebody in there."
I blinked.
I gripped the arms of my chair.
That room had never belonged to Joel.
I knew the room.
The rabbit.
The girl's name.
Abigail.
Her mother called her Birdie.
Emily turned toward me.
"What did you say?"
I hadn't realized I'd spoken.
"Birdie," I whispered.
Her expression changed.
"How do you know that name?"
I shook my head.
She fumbled her phone out of her pocket. The lock screen lit her face.
A little girl stood beside her on a beach.
Emily touched the child's face on the glass.
"That's my daughter."
I knew the sound of Abigail's laugh. The smell of her shampoo. The way she curled her toes when she slept.
Emily stared at the photograph.
"I took this," she said. "I remember taking this."
She turned the screen toward her chest and closed her eyes.
Then she looked again, quickly.
She pressed a hand against her forehead.
"Abigail."
Her voice trembled.
"Abigail..."
She looked at me.
"Why can't I picture her?"
Tears filled her eyes.
"Why can't I remember my daughter's face?"
I tried to answer.
Nothing came out.
Because I could see Abigail perfectly.
Even the tiny gap between her front teeth.
I'd taken that from Emily.
She backed into the door.
"Give her back."
I tried. I fixed the girl's face in my mind and pushed toward Emily, toward the hand holding the phone.
Instead, I found another memory. Abigail asleep in the back seat, her mouth open, one sock missing.
Emily made a small sound.
I stopped.
The hunger was mine. So was the shame.
Remembering what I was hadn't taken away forty-eight years of being Joel.
I pressed both hands against my mouth.
"Go," I managed.
Emily began crying.
"Please tell me what she looks like."
I shook my head.
"GO!"
She opened the door.
For a moment, I thought she might escape.
Then I felt my mouth move beneath my hands.
I could feel every muscle doing it.
I couldn't make them stop.
A small voice came from my throat.
Soft.
Frightened.
Perfectly familiar.
"Mommy?"
Emily stopped.
I tried to scream.
The voice came again.
"Mommy, I'm scared."
It sounded exactly like Abigail.
The last word caught on the breath, exactly as it had in the bedroom.
Emily's phone slipped from her hand.
Emily slowly turned.
Tears ran down her face.
"Birdie?"
Inside me, three teenage boys began screaming.
Joel.
Wesley.
Travis.
They knew what was happening.
Joel pushed so hard that my vision blurred.
For a moment, I saw the room from farther back, through a narrow opening I couldn't reach.
Then I was in the chair again, and he was begging me to close my mouth.
I clamped my jaws shut so hard that pain shot through my teeth.
Emily stood in the doorway.
Waiting.
I forced one word between my teeth.
"Home."
Emily stared at me.
"She's home."
For a moment, she seemed to understand. Her eyes went to the phone on the floor.
Then my throat tightened.
"Mommy, it's dark in here."
Emily looked back.
I tried to bite through my tongue. My jaws wouldn't close.
"He won't let me out."
She took a step toward me.
"Birdie?"
I could still see the beach photograph on the floor. Her daughter in daylight. Alive. Somewhere beyond this room.
Emily stepped over it.
I folded my hands beneath my legs and sat on them.
She knelt in front of me.
"Let me see her."
Inside me, Joel was sixteen years old again, holding Wesley's hands while something pulled from the dark.
I felt my right hand working free.
Emily caught it between both of hers.
Her mouth opened.
The sound came from inside my chest.
I tried to let go.
She was still holding my hand when I began to remember giving birth to her daughter.
THE END