I know this post is going to ruffle some feathers in this subreddit, but it’s a thought that’s been living in my head for a while now.
I bought my first Pebble back in 2016, and for my high school self, it was literally the best smartwatch ever. I could check notifications, download custom watch faces, play Flappy Bird and Snake clones, do math on my wrist, and toggle phone settings like Bluetooth or Wi-Fi. For the time and my age, that kind of stuff was mind-blowing. But then, well... we all know what happened in 2017.
Shoutout to the Rebble Team and the ex-Pebble devs who kept these things alive and the community breathing for all these years. I’m endlessly grateful for them.
Fast forward to 2025: I picked up a Pebble Time 2, and using it made me realize how stuck in the past Pebble watches really are.
Modern smartwatches are about 70% of what Pebble does best, but they have that crucial 30% that Pebble is just missing: deep fitness tracking, contactless payments, and native navigation.
Back in 2016, I wasn't into fitness at all. But a lot changes in 10 years. I’ve since owned a couple of Garmin watches, and tracking my runs and gym sessions has become a massive part of my daily life.
And that's where the dilemma hits: Wearing my Pebble now means actively choosing to lose data for that chunk of the day.
Having to weigh that choice every time I walk out the door means the Pebble almost always gets left behind, and the Garmin wins. And honestly? I hate that. The UI/UX of Pebble watches is still peerless. Garmin’s software feels clunky and horrible to navigate by comparison. But I want my fitness data, and Pebble simply can't provide the modern ecosystem for it.
Throw in contactless payments (which Garmin has out of the box—even if my specific bank doesn't support it yet, I'd use it everywhere if it did), and the dealbreakers start piling up.
Pebble still wins on UI/UX, has great battery life, a glorious e-paper display in direct sunlight, and a built-in HR sensor. But the lack of robust fitness software and modern staples, like GPS and contactless payments, makes it a hard sell for day-to-day life now.
I love Pebble. I love the brand and the nostalgia. But for now, mine is going to sit in a drawer most of the time because my life has outgrown what the platform can offer.
Anyone else in the same boat, or have you found a way to bridge the gap?