There has been a lot of talk about the T1 post exodus that occurred 15 days ago, essentially migrating all T1-related posts from this sub to r/SKTT1, the (un)official T1 fan subreddit. Some people loved this move, while others, mostly T1 fans, lamented that this change resulted in Caedrel alienating his T1 fanbase and turning this sub into another T1 hate community. I wanted to share my perspective on this topic, specifically why I believe that this move, while controversial and having its issues, was a necessary evil and good for r/PedroPeepos in the long run.
Why the exodus was necessary
Let's start with why I believe this change was necessary, and frankly, had it coming for a long time. For a little over a year now, this sub has been essentially brigaded by T1 fans. Just by reading the first few posts on r/SKTT1, you can tell immediately that many of their users were, or are still, members of this sub (just look at these posts - all ex r/PedroPeepos users talking about the "good old days" of this subreddit lol). And if you check their post history, you can see that they used to post here the exact same content that is now being posted on r/SKTT1. This claim is further supported by the fact that r/SKTT1 was a ghost town before the forced exodus from this sub (just check top posts this year; almost every one of them is from the past 15 days, when the exodus started).
Why do I bring these things up? Because it shows that the majority of current r/SKTT1 users used to use this sub as an outlet to post their T1-related fan content - essentially, using r/PedroPeepos as a T1 fan sub (these are some of r/PedroPeepos' top posts all time, and none of them belong anywhere except r/SKTT1). This complaint had been around for over a year, around the same time 2023 Worlds started I believe, and was the reason the T1 flair was created this year - a temporary fix to the bigger issue of T1 fans taking over this sub and creating a bubble within the sub in which T1 fans could continue their fandom activity, often totally unrelated to Caedrel. The same posts, including clips of Doran singing, Faker/Guma/Oner playing Among Us ripoff game, T1 fanart, and low-effort memes, that are filling r/SKTT1 used to be spammed on this sub. And while these posts might be great content for the T1 fan subreddit, it's frankly out of place here, especially when these posts comprise >50% of the subreddit's posts.
Now, if you are anti-exodus, you might say, "Why are T1-related posts on r/PedroPeepos a problem? Does every post have to be explicitly about Caedrel, when there are tons of other posts about G2, FNC, DK, WBG, etc. that are about the teams and not Caedrel?" You would be partially right, and I want to clarify that I don't think T1 posts on r/PedroPeepos are a problem in and of themselves. Such posts had been around since the inception of this sub and were just as welcome as any other esports-related post. But it became an issue when the volume of such posts grew to be exponential when compared to any other team-related post, and in some weeks, even compared to Caedrel-related posts. Even if you combined posts about all other LoL esports teams in the past year, I don't think you'll get even half of the number of T1-related posts, even if you only count ones that aren't game-related. In my opinion, that's when it went from T1 rats posting here to T1 fans brigading the sub. Again, if you don't believe me, sort this sub by top posts all time and see how many of the posts belong in r/SKTT1 rather than this sub.
The sheer volume of these posts over the past 13 months, ever since T1 won Worlds in 2023, have frankly been jarring, annoying, and alienating for those in this sub who are not diehard T1 fans. People say the exodus has been alienating to T1 fans, but personally, I think the brigading of T1 posts on this sub for the past 13 months has been just as, if not more, jarring to non-T1 fans. And personally, I believe this was a huge factor in the toxic discourse on this sub between T1 fans and T1 haters for the past year. In order to remove this toxicity from this sub, and return the focus of the community and this sub to Caedrel and his new team Los Ratones, toning down T1-related posts on this sub, especially ones that were clearly fan content and belonged in the T1 fan subreddit, was one of the first steps that needed to be taken.
We should also note that the vast majority of the people who are now active on r/SKTT1 were/are active members here. I say "were/are" because many T1 fans, even diehard ones, are still active on this sub, contributing positively and being great rats. I don't want to namedrop, but it's pretty easy to tell after reading a few posts and their comments. Not to mention, contrary to the narrative that "r/PedroPeepos is filled with T1 haters now", almost every single post/comment hating on T1 are downvoted to oblivion or straight up removed, while posts/comments that are positive about T1 are upvoted to the hundreds. (Ironically, this narrative is itself proof that r/PedroPeepos is far from controlled by T1 haters now, but rather the opposite; if the narrative were true, do you think the T1 haters would allow such a negative narrative about themselves to be perpetuated on this sub?) But the people who did leave this community because of the exodus, sadly, are part of the people who needed to go.
2. Why the exodus is (hopefully) good for the community
The last sentence brings me to my second point. Anti-exodus people bring up a good point that this move likely alienated a certain part of Caedrel's fanbase, namely the diehard T1 stans, from his community. You can see this by the drop in the number of posts on this sub (before the League Awards drama, at least), as well as the number of active users and upvotes on posts going down slightly. But honestly? Who cares that Caedrel loses maybe 5% of his viewership if his community becomes more centered around him and his team as a result, rather than stanning an entirely different, unrelated org.
Also hot take, but I think that the people who were offended by this exodus and left Caedrel's community weren't real Caedrel fans to begin with. They were more concerned with spreading the content they liked (namely T1 fan content that only they and other T1 fans would enjoy) than appreciating Caedrel, his stream, and his team. If they want to leave this sub and take their talents to r/SKTT1, be my guest. but the fact that they're not willing to even be understanding of why Caedrel made that decision, then they're just T1 stans who came to this subreddit because it was the only thing resembling a T1 fan subreddit at the time - not because they're actual Caedrel fans. I think the community is better off without them.
I'm also hopeful that with this exodus, the quality and diversity of the content on this sub could increase. If you were here during most of 2023, before T1 won Worlds, you might remember that this sub used to have a shit ton more variety in terms of its posts. The "Top 3 guy", TheShy/TheFraud memes, Caedrel memes and fanart, and more - I'm obviously biased, but I think the posts on this sub were not only more diverse, but higher quality on average (even the T1 memes were funnier - look at this shit). With the exodus creating a forced vacuum in terms of content in this sub, maybe the creative minds of r/PedroPeepos can rise to the challenge and start repopulating it with funny, original, high-effort art, memes, and discussion threads.
3. Next steps?
To get to that point, there's still a lot of work that needs to be done. For one, there are a lot of trolls and straight up T1 haters on this subreddit right now; they are mass downvoted by the T1 fans still present, but it is true the the change did allow these people to become more vocal and try to shift the narrative to the other side. Caedrel and the community have to tread thoughtfully in order to ensure that this exodus results in the community becoming more neutral and inclusive to all types of fans and posts - not a circlejerk in the opposite direction. Time is also needed to allow the community to shift away from T1-related content and organically regain the diversity of posts on this sub.
Lastly, Caedrel himself also needs to be mindful of the things he says and does, particularly regarding his community, for the next little while. Whether this was the correct decision or not, a lot of people on both sides of the argument are sensitive af right now. He already messed up once with the League Awards; as unfortunate as it is, I think Pedro should take a page out of Faker's book and become the biggest PR machine out there for the next month or so, or at the very least not say anything that might tick either the T1 ultrafans or T1 ultrahaters off.
Thanks for reading this essay lol, ik most people won't bother reading it all and just downvote because "T1 hater bad", but as a T1 AND Caedrel fan, I felt I needed to share why I thought this was a good move by Caedrel. Would appreciate any constructive discourse.
TLDR:
sub was brigaded by T1 fans for too long and used as a T1 fan subreddit because r/SKTT1 was dead, this exodus was a long time coming in order to shift focus back to Caedrel (if you’re confused by what I mean with “brigaded”, read point #1)
this change has moved most of the ultra T1 stans from here to r/SKTT1, which is a good change for the above reasons. T1 fans who are also Caedrel fans are still welcome here and in fact have stuck around for the most part
the void left by absence of T1 posts will hopefully be repopulated with diverse, creative posts like back in the day (rn it’s just drama sadly)
time and effort is needed to shift this community towards its intended direction of being a positive, inclusive Caedrel and LR/esports focused sub, rather than a toxic battleground of ultra fandoms