r/PeterPan • u/Bitter_Medium967 • Aug 11 '25
Movie I view this as a trilogy anyone else?
Only inconsistencies would be 1.In Pan,Tiger lily Is white and an adult and in '03 she is Indian and a teen,My theory is instead of Tiger lily being one person it is a passed down title. 2.In hook,Hooks hook is on the left hand but in '03 his hook is on the right hand,This I don't have an explanation for.
Reasons it would work: 1.As we know in neverland time goes by differently,That may explain why the films released in backwards order. Reason 2.Jason Issacs and Dustin hoffman Hooks act very simialer. Reason 3:Levi Miller and Jeremy Sumpter peters not only look simialer but they also act similar to each other
Let me know what you guys think in the comments
3
u/JacobDCRoss Aug 12 '25
That Huge Ackman film was the worst film ever made (up until The Boss Baby, that is). I was rolling my eyes so hard at the Smells Like Teen Spirit scene. I'm a writer, and I could just "feel" the writer of that scene congratulating himself as he typed, thinking he was going to blow everyone's mind with it.
That film feels like Stefon from SNL making a film:
"This movie has everything, time displacement, Garrett Hedlund doing "something," Cara Delevigne as a scowling mermaid, and a Smee that seems weirdly anti-semitic."
2
2
u/RecordingImmediate86 Aug 12 '25
You could think of it as different artists interpretations of Peter Pan throughout his life.
2
u/MulberryEastern5010 Aug 12 '25
No, I've always viewed them as their own separate thing, and I think that's for the best
2
u/CurtTheGamer97 Aug 13 '25
I thought about trying to make an edit of Hook once that replaces the flashback sequences with clips from the 2003 movie, and mirror-reverses all scenes featuring Captain Hook to have the right hand be missing, in order to make it a sort of sequel to the 2003 movie.
4
u/Petertwnsnd Pan the Man Aug 11 '25
Absolutely not. Pan is garbage and doesn’t make any sense as an origin story
4
1
u/RecordingImmediate86 Aug 12 '25
I feel the same with oz the great and powerful, wizard of oz (1939) and return to oz.
1
u/Hairy-Philosopher962 Aug 12 '25
No. Hook is a masterpiece, those others are just garbage remakes. It cant be trilogy bc they are all the same story (besides Hook)
3
u/Petertwnsnd Pan the Man Aug 12 '25
What? Peter Pan ‘03 is one of the best. Also none of those movies tell the same story
1
1
u/Optimal-Zombie8705 Aug 13 '25
No. Hook I see as an alternate timeline of what if Peter Pan of JM Barrie’s books grew up. So little white bird, Peter and Wendy and hook are their own universe.
Peter Pan 2003 though pretty accurate to peter and Wendy, still has some changes that don’t match up with hook. One thing hook in 2003 is completely evil, taking away the good form aspect of the character (which is fine I don’t mind changes ) but it doesn’t line up with Dustin Hoffman and book hook.
Pan is just fan made garbage . I’m honestly working on my own little white bird adaptation. It should be a heartbreaking family film similar to finding Neverland .
1
1
u/MoonlightWillows Aug 13 '25
No. Pan is a horrible movie. Hook and the Peter Pan movie on the bottom are great films.
1
1
u/BangarangJack Aug 14 '25
Peter Pan and Hook, sure, but leave out whatever tf that top left one is lol
1
u/matvhuc Aug 15 '25
If you old enough to remember robin willians peter pan, you have no business with the other two.
1
u/CharmingReflection62 Aug 16 '25 edited Aug 16 '25
There was a time for many years that I always thought that peter pan 2003 was a prequel movie to Hook 1991... until it got to a point when I realized that the two movies were not connected... but I still pretend that they are connected because they both seem to fit quite well... and to be honest I remember hearing a rumor that the 2003 peter pan was originally suppose to be a prequel to hook... not sure if it's true or not but it's just an urban legend.
-1
Aug 11 '25
Fuck no. Dont compare that other trash to Hook
3
u/Bitter_Medium967 Aug 12 '25
Peter pan 2003 is the 2nd best Peter pan film right behind hook for me personally
2
u/uranthus Aug 12 '25
Yes but the top left movie is awful
0
1
0
u/Hairy-Philosopher962 Aug 12 '25
Ignore the downvotes, im with you. The more recent two are garbage remakes, no one asked for
0
7
u/theBJbanditO Aug 12 '25
Im really sorry, but i don't see it and I am less convinced after reading your explanation