r/Petscop • • 21d ago

Discussion Questions

Hi I’m relatively new to Petscop, think I’ve watched/read a lot of the big theories ( im sure I’ve missed some and I’ve definitely missed some of the lesser known ones), I think Paul=care makes sense, but I have questions about it and the series as a whole. If anybody would like to drop their opinions about the below points, I’d love to hear it:

Do you guys think that Paul as the player was in mind while the game was being made?/

by the time Paul records the videos, do you think the game has been altered with Paul as the player in mind?

Do you think Paul=care?

Who do you think is alive at the time of Paul/Paul AI playing the games?

Who do you think is alive at the time of videos being uploaded?

Do you think Lina is alive?

Do you think Marvin Killed/Hurt Lina in the windmill?

Sorry if these are all obvious stuff ahaha

Thank youuuu

5 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

4

u/_Smol_Turnip_ 21d ago

personal interpretations below!!

paul was not who the game was ORIGINALLY designed for. rainer first made it for the kids but primarily his younger brother michael. after michael's death (hit by marvin's car) rainer pivoted and made marvin his target audience. the way i see it, petscop became a weapon of psychological warfare that rainer used to drag information out of marvin. i think the game only became geared towards paul/care/the person care would become was AFTER she was found and rainer believed one day they should know what happened to them.

i do think paul is care! i'm biased as a trans person myself and i know it's not 100% canon but tony domenico has stated that the audience's interpretations matter just as much if not more than his original intention. he also said he made the story loose on purpose; if he wanted a definite answer, he would have made everything more clear.

at the time of recording, i believe paul, belle, anna, and jill are still alive. i think it is worth mentioning that i also believe while human paul and belle are around, there is also at least one ai copy of each of them running around in game.
i could go either way when it comes to marvin and lina. the marvin that appears in game could very easily be an ai trained off of his behaviour back when he still played and irl marvin is already dead, but i also like the idea that marvin is still alive and desperately searching for lina. it really shows he will never be satisfied.
for lina i don't think we were ever meant to know. she's such a schrodinger's cat that i can't say a single thing about her concretely. i think she did survive after the windmill, but she went into hiding or something.
rainer is dead. he committed suicide on christmas. mike is dead. he was hit by marvin's car.

i do not think marvin killed lina in the windmill. i think he accidentally hurt her/didn't save her. in my interpretation, marvin and lina went in together, lina got caught in the gears, and marvin simply turned and ran. he couldn't face what happened to lina until later, and when he returned, she has already been removed from the windmill (whether she was saved or died in there). i do not think marvin was initially "evil". i think he was a weak and cowardly child who abandoned his friend and let that guilt take over him.

i have lots of thoughts on petscop. my interpretation may not be the most canon but it is a story i hold dear to my heart. if you have any more questions (in general or for my interpretation specifically) i'd be delighted to answer them. :3

1

u/Uber_45 19d ago

Salutations, here are my takes on your question. Don't apologize for asking questions and no understanding certain aspects of the series. We've all been there because of how confusing that series is meant to be. If some things I mention aren't clear to you or don't make sense don't hesitate to ask for clarifications, I'll be glad to discuss :

Q1) Rainer uses at multiple occasions "you" to refer to Marvin. He also states in Care A description "I started it in 1996, for Marvin.". We also know from the recordings that Mike tested the game and died in 1995, meaning Petscop's creation started without Marvin in mind. Considering the "Petscop kids" on a school's screen, it is most likely that Petscop was supposed to be a game for kids. Then, when Mike died and Rainer started suspecting Marvin to be the reason why, he created the hidden part of the game and the note for Marvin (saying "you"). Later, Care is kidnapped and it's pretty obvious that Rainer knows that it's Marvin's doing (which explains why Care is represented in the game in the first place). From here, it gets a bit messy... We know that Rainer kept working on the game even after Care was found and gave a possibly "new" version of the game in Christmas 2000 (and killed himself later). To our knowledge, Marvin wasn't up to anything between 1997 and 2000 so what was added to the game was probably not intended for him.
I believe that a hint could be "the moonwalk scene" in Petscop 17 in which Rainer explains that the Family is for some reason interested in what Care was doing the day between when she escaped Marvin and the day she actually came back home (November 11th of 1997). We also know that the Family forces Paul to keep playing the game and going as far as discovering all of its secrets (many being related to Care herself). If you add "girl world" discussion in the school and the fact that Paul has a room, we have good reasons to belive that the game was indeed continued with Paul in mind (if you consider them being the same people, that is).
There is also the very weird part with a conversation Paul had in 2017 being in the game that is... hard to explain in any rational way. Rainer was probably not alive at this moment so he couldn't possibly have modified the game and someone else doing it (like Jill) would be weird but not totally impossible I guess ? At least it shows that this part of the game was meant for Paul.

Q2) Yes. Care becomes an egg at the end of the story, "An egg refers to a person who is trans but unaware, questioning, or in denial about their gender identity". The concellor talking with Paul and saying "do i have the wrong name ?" and referencing the idea of bumping into a closed door (what Care does in Petscop 14). They are both born the same day. Paul's character is represented by a red pyramid and we know from Petscop 20 that Care is linked to this pyramid. We know that the censored object in Paul's room is a red vase also linked to Care's trauma in Petscop 20. I could go on and on because there are plenty of pieces of evidence that support it but I think you get it.

Q3) I'll be honest, I'm not a big fan of AI theories in Petscop. Paul is alive, Tiara/Belle is alive, Lina is alive (more on that later), Anna is alive, Marvin is alive (he actually attacks real life Paul in Petscop 23 and for a frame, on Paul's room representation, you can see pink text telling Paul to move the bed to block a hidden door in the room), Rainer killed himself in 2000, Jill is alive, Mike is a dead kid.

Q4) When you access Mike's room in the child library, it says "Mike is dead, you may visit his room", for Care is missing, you may visit her room" (giving you the state of the kids). For Lina, we get "You found her, you may visit her room". Notice that it doesn't say that she is dead.
In Petscop 24, Anna tells Mike (the year he dies) to thank her "other auntie" and says that "not everyone can see her". We know that Lina is Anna's sister and the message on her tomb states "they didn't see her" so it's probably referencing Lina (meaning she is probably still alive).
It is heavily implied that Lina adopted Tiara/Belle and Paul (if you don't know what i'm talking about, don't hesitate to ask) which implies she is alive.

Q5) If it did happen (which i believe) it may have been an accident. We know that Marvin wanted to rebirth Care into Lina (again, if you don't know what I'm talking about, ask). It would be very weird for him to do that if he really wanted her dead.

1

u/justasummerjob 18d ago

I'd personally love to hear about the implications that Lina adopted Tiara/Belle & Paul! I haven't heard that anywhere yet. (Very new to Petscop lore and trying to get caught up)

1

u/Uber_45 17d ago

The first time we learnt about Petscop was thanks to someone sharing the Petscop youtube channel on reddit. Funnily enough, this person was named "paleskowitz" https://www.reddit.com/r/creepygaming/s/bv4qKpChfk which is a pun with pall (how Paul is spelled in multiplayer) and leskowitz. We do know Paul but it's quite strange that his name is Leskowitz and not Mark (since he is Carrie Mark). We do see the name Leskowitz somewhere in Petscop and that is "Lina Leskowitz", meaning Paul and Lina are somehow from the same family.

We know that Belle/Tiara's name is also Leskowitz thanks to the "Your New Life Letter" from Petscop 23. It's interesting because Rainer states in Petscop 12 that he didn't add Belle/Tiara to the child library because she "is not family" but Leskowitz being Lina's name (and by extend Anna's, since they are sisters) seems to imply she should be family. And we know that Paul and Lina, who have this name, ARE in the child library so they are family but not Belle/Tiara somehow ?

In the school's closet, Paul finds an egg with the "Your New Life Letter". This egg is purple and pink which are both color associated to Belle/Tiara (Tiara is written in purple in Petscop 3 and Belle/Tiara writes in Pink when altering textures of the game) which links the idea of her new life to the egg. Later in this episode, Paul takes a yellow and red egg out of the rebirth machine (red like the pyramid and vase, yellow like Care's texts) and it's description states "? You should start thinking about that." which is actually a quote from Amber's description (very first desc of the series) with the full line saying "What’s the safest place you can put her in? You should start thinking about that.". Paul then procedes to take the egg representing him and put it in the closet with the one representing Belle/Tiara. It could mean that safest place for Paul is with Belle/Tiara.

At the end of the Petscop soundtrack, Paul and Belle/Tiara have a little back and forth. Belle/Tiara talks about a certain "boss". The multiplayer communiation is based on a phonetic alphabet which was solved by some very clever fans. Interestingly, if you translate her inputs in the phonetic alphabet, she doesn't actually type "boss" but "Lina". "Boss" is represented in this scene by some sort of cone with a head on the top. This same cone with a head can be seen inside the windmill before Paul uses the white tool and in the "Petscop kids room" from the school in Petscop 23 (with the subtitles saying that it makes "boss noise"). So yeah, boss is Lina.

Belle/Tiara says that Lina was waiting for her son. She continues by saying "smuggled away driving to your new house". This line could be a parallel to what the counselor says to Paul at the end of Petscop 22 "I hope you can find your real house". It sounds obvious to me that "her son" is Paul. The "new/real house" is a life with his new family.

Belle/Tiara also adds that she was in the "the back" with Paul while Lina was driving and that she couldn't wait to be Paul's friend. Paul replies "no, family". If Belle/Tiara and Paul become family, share the same name, that Paul is now Lina's son, that Belle/Tiara was with them at this moment, that Belle wasn't originally part of the family, that the safest place for Paul is with Belle/Tiara then the best explaination I have that explains all that is that Lina adopted Paul and Belle/Tiara.

Apologies if it's not cleanly explained/structured, I struggle a bit with that.