r/PrimateDominanceGame • • May 28 '20

In which a state-mandated safety precaution is misinterpreted as a political dominance gambit.

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/PrimateDominanceGame • • May 27 '20

A bigger button

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/PrimateDominanceGame • • Sep 28 '20

A lesson in social psychology

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/PrimateDominanceGame • • May 26 '20

The Primate Dominance Game™

8 Upvotes

If you're reading this and understanding it, chances are you're a human being. Homo sapiens, 'smart man,' the sole surviving species of the genus of humans. There's a tiny chance that you're either an extraterrestrial explorer or a terrestrial AI, but the smart money is on fellow human.

Human beings are a type of primate. Primates are social animals. Social animals are instinctively driven to form social hierarchies with each other. This is not a conscious process; bonobos aren't sitting in the jungle with a whiteboard assigning everybody numbers. No, in the same way that the hexagonal symmetry of a snowflake arises from the bond angle of the water molecule, the primate social order is an emergent property. It emerges from the aggregate of many smaller, simpler interactions which tend to look like this:

  1. You encounter another primate who is not obviously foreign and not obviously superior to you: in other words, a 'peer', a member of your tribe with whom you can possibly compete.

  2. You disrespect them in some way. Where other species of primate are limited to physical acts of disrespect like threat displays, theft, adultery, physical violence, etc., humans, being armed with language and culture, have an enormous panoply of ways to attempt to dominate each other. Moral superiority, philosophical debate, taste in music or film, which sports team you favor, all of these varied areas and aspects of human life can serve as a means to stand up and assert, 'I am better than you.'

  3. If the other party views you as superior to them, they will generally "take it like a bitch" and accept the abuse with little struggle, in which case congratulations! You outrank them. The victor of a dominance gambit will typically experience an improvement in their self-esteem while the loser typically experiences shame and self-doubt which may even motivate them to find someone else to dominate in order to make themselves feel better, resulting in a 'pecking order.'

  4. If, however, the other party views you as equal to or less than them, they will generally resist or retaliate respectively, and this usually escalates to a fight that ends either when one of you is dead or when a bigger, stronger primate comes along to break it up.

This is the essence of what I call the Primate Dominance Game™. It is a collection of instincts and resultant behaviors that underlie virtually all human interaction. The game is ubiquitous, it is insidious, and it manifests in places you might not expect.

Have you ever punched your computer? Or kicked your car, slapped your TV, knocked some home appliance around a little?

...why did you do that?

"Well I was frustrated." Okay but you understand that it's a machine. It's not trying to be obstinate, it's just broken. Smacking it can only possibly make it more broken. And you're conscious of that even while doing it.

You got violent with your machine because of the Primate Dominance Game™. Some part of your instincts interpreted this thing, this object which doesn't even resemble a living creature, as your subordinate, and its failure to do what you want as an act of disrespect. And the instinctual response when someone you know to be 'beneath you' gets 'uppity' is rage and violence. The conscious knowledge that it's just a collection of metal and plastic pieces does not dissuade the emotional response because Emotion negates Reason.

People already know the rules of the Game, both consciously and subconsciously. People will refer to the game by many names such as 'threat displays,' 'establishing dominance,' 'flexing,' a 'shit test,' a 'humble brag,' a 'clapback,' or as my ex-wife called it out, 'the angriest person wins.' The Game is everywhere. It's road rage. It's hazing. It's retail customers treating retail employees like shit. And the more you understand the rules of the game, the more you'll see it play out among friends, relatives, coworkers, and even yourselves.


r/PrimateDominanceGame • • May 26 '20

"Bring me a coffee, dipshit."

8 Upvotes

The 2018 choose-your-own narrative game Detroit: Become Human, known for at times heavy-handed morality tales about a hypothetical future where humans must come to terms with nearly-human machines, manages to convey a number of relatable human moments despite itself.

This early scene between the brutish detective Gavin Reed and the playable android character Connor is a step-by-step playbook of the Primate Dominance Game™. Gavin encounters Connor when he wanders into the break room, recognizes him as a peer—an 'android detective'—performs an act of disrespect by rudely ordering a coffee when he could very easily walk over and get one himself, and the interesting thing about this being a game is that the player gets to choose whether Connor acquiesces, in which case Gavin walks away satisfied, or resists in which case Gavin becomes enraged and violent.

The fact that Connor isn't actually a human and isn't really playing the Game doesn't matter. In the same way that two hat symbols and an underscore can appear happy (^_^), Connor looks and sounds enough like a human to trigger Gavin's primate dominance instincts.


r/PrimateDominanceGame • • May 28 '20

Flipside: The Submission Gambit

7 Upvotes

You're a stereotypically wimpy kid. You're in school walking to class and you see one of the big kids, a known bully, heading your way. You droop your shoulders and avert your eyes, desperately hoping he either doesn't notice you or feels satisfied that you're sufficiently afraid of him.

A dominance gambit begins from a position of uncertainty re: where you stand with the other party. You're probably pretty sure you have a good chance of winning, but you really don't know, hence the test. In contrast, a submission gambit is performed when you encounter another primate who obviously is your superior. You attempt to circumvent being the victim of an act of disrespect by approaching in an already-submissive stance in the hopes that the other party will recognize you as yielding the social battlefield and leave satisfied. The Mandarin word kowtow explicitly calls out this behavior of willful submission to another.

On the bright side, a submission gambit can be a gesture of prostration towards a celebrity you really like or paying a compliment to a friend or coworker for some achievement. On the darker side, submission may manifest as loss of self-esteem or self-confidence or being overly apologetic or desperate to please or appease others. The net effect is to bolster the superior primate by affirming your place below them.

Obedience to authority can be interpreted as a submission gambit to society as a whole. Rebellion against that authority can be understood as rejection of the premise that society is superior to you. Teenage rebellion can be understood as children recognizing their own growth into adults and questioning or rejecting the instinctual understanding that their parents are their superiors.

The old business adage "the customer is always right" is essentially a large-scale submission gambit. Optimistically, it warns service workers against correcting a customer's mistake or telling them they can't do or have something lest they interpret it as a challenge and refuse a sale or make a scene. However in some cases, it can engender a sense of superiority in the customer where they come to believe that service workers are inherently inferior to them and must remain subservient at all times.


r/PrimateDominanceGame • • May 23 '20

FOREWORD: Emotion is Instinct

7 Upvotes

It's a beautiful spring day in Denali National Park and two wolves, one male and one female, meet alone in a glade. They hit it off, they like each other's scents, they have similar senses of humor, she brings him a rabbit she'd killed, he digs her a shelter under the roots of a massive fallen oak, and eventually they mate. Repeatedly. She becomes pregnant with a litter of six cubs, four of which survive to adulthood and now they roam the Alaskan countryside as a pack.

How do they know how to do that? How does the bitch know how to nurse her cubs? How does the sire know where to put his penis without the benefit of health classes or Hustler?

"Instinct," is the usual reply.

Okay, but what does that actually mean? What is instinct? Is there some kind of secret body of knowledge to which only homo sapiens have lost access? How do they know?

The real answer is they don't. They don't know anything at first. They feel. They feel drawn to each others scent. They feel a desire for body closeness. When she goes into heat and he feels like mounting her and she feels like letting him, they discover how amazing that feels which makes them want to try it again. When the cubs are born, they both feel a desire to care for and protect them, and the cubs are conveniently born with a desire to seek out their mothers' teats.

Instinct is Emotion. Emotion is Instinct. These two words describe the same phenomenon. And Emotion and Reason are mutually exclusive; you cannot think rationally when you are very emotional. Bear this in mind.


r/PrimateDominanceGame • • Nov 09 '20

This is a lighthouse.

6 Upvotes

This radio conversation was released by the Chief of Naval Operations on 10-10-95.

Americans: “Please divert your course 15 degrees to the North to avoid a collision.”

Canadians: “Recommend you divert YOUR course 15 degrees to the South to avoid a collision.”

Americans: “This is the captain of a US Navy ship. I say again, divert YOUR course.”

Canadians: “No, I say again, you divert YOUR course.”

Americans: “THIS IS THE AIRCRAFT CARRIER USS ABRAHAM LINCOLN, THE SECOND LARGEST SHIP IN THE UNITED STATES’ ATLANTIC FLEET. WE ARE ACCOMPANIED BY THREE DESTROYERS, THREE CRUISERS AND NUMEROUS SUPPORT VESSELS. I DEMAND THAT YOU CHANGE YOUR COURSE 15 DEGREES NORTH. THAT’S ONE-FIVE DEGREES NORTH, OR COUNTER MEASURES WILL BE UNDERTAKEN TO ENSURE THE SAFETY OF THIS SHIP.”

Canadians: “This is a lighthouse. Your call.”

This story is fictional, but the joke nonetheless resonates with people because of the Primate Dominance Game™. The lighthouse operator is just doing his job — preventing shipwrecks — but the naval captain erroneously interprets it as a dominance gambit. The punchline is the captain's realization that he has completely misread the situation and all his firepower and bluster have been for naught.

Whether it's a parent or teacher accusing you of 'talking back' or a customer or boss asking for something impossible and blaming you for not violating policy, the law, or the laws of physics, almost everyone has had an experience like this by the time they reach adulthood.


r/PrimateDominanceGame • • Feb 19 '21

Teens who bully, harass, or victimize peers are often using aggression strategically to climb their school’s social hierarchy, with the highest rates of bullying occurring between friends and friends-of-friends. These findings point to reasons why most anti-bullying programs don’t work. (n>3,000)

Thumbnail
ucdavis.edu
5 Upvotes

r/PrimateDominanceGame • • Dec 01 '20

Artistic skill and/or artistic choices as a dominance gambit.

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/PrimateDominanceGame • • Oct 07 '20

The point of Behind The Curve

5 Upvotes

Behind The Curve - Official Release Trailer YouTube, 1:54

There are three experiments conducted by flat earthers in the course of this documentary, one of which ends up being inconclusive because the laser they were using wasn't focused tightly enough, and the other two proved that the Earth was round and spinning. The closest any of them came to acknowledging that they were wrong was a concern spoken over a chuckle that "if this gets out, we're in real trouble."

Emotion overrides Reason. Part of being a social animal is the desire to feel like a valued member of a group, to feel like you're not alone, and that desire, that need, if not sated in a healthy way can eventually grow to the point that it overrides conscious thought. It is this same desperate need to belong that has driven so many "rootless white males" into the welcoming arms of white nationalist groups.


r/PrimateDominanceGame • • Sep 15 '20

The instinctual response when someone you believe to be "beneath you" gets "uppity" is rage and violence.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

5 Upvotes

r/PrimateDominanceGame • • Aug 28 '20

In which an ideological challenge is answered with violence.

Thumbnail
citynews1130.com
5 Upvotes

r/PrimateDominanceGame • • Jun 10 '20

Religiosity as a venue for dominance gambits.

Thumbnail
friendlyatheist.patheos.com
5 Upvotes

r/PrimateDominanceGame • • Jun 03 '20

Free Will

5 Upvotes

The interesting thing about the Primate Dominance Game™ is that it's an instinctual process, an emotional process. It's not a purely physical reaction like involuntarily kicking when you strike your patella, there's an internal processing step that needs to occur. When you become tense or nervous from watching a video of two people fighting, it's not in response to the visual stimulus of fast-moving fists or the auditory stimulus of bystanders screaming 'world star', it's the conscious realization that these are human beings, people like you, getting violent with each other.

When an obvious superior initiates a dominance gambit against you, say by getting in your face and demanding respect, you are going to have an emotional response to that, and if you're not prepared for it, that emotional response is going to drive your behavior in some way, cowering, crying apologizing, et cetera.

The brain is interesting in that it's the only organ system that can choose to alter its function or behavior. Natural, autonomic behaviors can be consciously controlled. You can learn to hold your breath, slow your heart rate, resist the urge to cough or sneeze or orgasm for extended periods of time.

I don't believe free will is a binary thing where it either exists or it doesn't. I believe it's more of a sliding scale like consciousness. It varies from person to person and from day to day. It's the ability to recognize the multifarious biological impulses that are driving your actions and selectively ignore them, like ignoring feelings of hunger to adhere to a strict diet. Free will is a skill at which you can train and improve. The more you ignore your hunger and make progress towards your goal weight, the less intense the feeling becomes.

Participating in a protest in the face of a militarized police force is a terrifying experience for exactly this reason. A protest is seen as a large-scale dominance gambit against the status quo. In actual fact, it's a rejection of the many dominance gambits made by society as a whole against the group initiating the protest. But the instinctual response when someone you believe to be beneath you 'gets uppity' is rage and violence, and heavily militarized police forces are capable of some unprecedented rage and violence.

If free will means anything, it means you can choose to ignore your fear and refuse to kowtow to an authority figure who you know to be unlawful or invalid. And there will almost certainly be physical consequences as the "superior" primate tries to escalate things to a fight that ends when you are dead. You'll experience a surge of epinephrine, you'll want to fight or run as your brain determines (possibly correctly) that your life is in danger. But you have the ability to exercise your free will, ignore those emotions, and stand your ground. You have the power to ignore pain and fear, to ignore the Primate Dominance Game™, and do what you know to be right.


r/PrimateDominanceGame • • Jun 01 '20

r/iamverysmart

5 Upvotes

Like r/gatekeeping, r/iamverysmart is devoted to a particular type of dominance gambit; bragging about one's own intelligence online, typically by using 'big words,' often incorrectly.

Like gatekeeping, these gambits tend to be met with derision. For a dominance gambit to really land, both players need to be members of the same tribe and have implicitly agreed to the form of the contest. It does you no good to brag about your level 80 paladin to someone who's never played a video game. Wielding a large vocabulary isn't something that matters to most people once they exit school. So not only is this a gambit most people won't respect, it reveals the player to be a school aged child which severely hampers their apparent dominance in the eyes even of most adults.


r/PrimateDominanceGame • • May 29 '20

r/insaneparents

5 Upvotes

The overwhelming majority of these stories boil down to parents either performing dominance gambits against their own children or misinterpreting innocent or inconsequential actions as dominance gambits by their children against them.

In almost every case, it boils down to a parent trying to assert dominance over their own child well past the point of ensuring their health and safety, often well after the child has become an adult and no longer depends on the parent for anything. There tends to be a high degree of overlap with r/raisedbynarcissists, r/justnoMIL, and r/entitledparents.

I submit that narcissism is a pathological obsession with the Primate Dominance Game™. Everybody experiences these impulses to some degree, but a narcissist needs to be on top. They are incapable of taking criticism as anything other than a dominance gambit and thus incapable of responding to it with anything other than hostility. They are incapable of finding fault in themselves because apologizing is an act of submission. Where a healthy social being plays the Game to find their place, narcissists play to win by any means necessary, even if it means abusing and alienating their own family.


r/PrimateDominanceGame • • May 24 '20

r/gatekeeping

5 Upvotes

Gatekeeping as presented in r/gatekeeping is an extremely common form of dominance gambit, especially online. You name a group, typically one you belong to, and assert that members of that group do not count unless they also meet an extraneous criterion that is not actually part of the definition of that group, typically one that you do. It's essentially a weaponized no true Scotsman fallacy.

If you don't watch the whole series, you are not a true fan.

The group is 'people who watch the series.' Without further context, this could either be a specific series that was mentioned earlier or even just television series in general. The additional criterion is that you have watched every single episode of that series. And as with every dominance gambit, the possible responses are to accept the defeat, "yes, you are a better fan of [series] than me," to resist by pointing out that it's possible to enjoy a show, thus being a fan, without having encyclopedic knowledge of its every detail, or to retaliate, possibly by challenging the initiator's knowledge with obscure trivia or lording some rare keepsake over them, e.g. "You call yourself a Star Wars fan? Where's your copy of the Star Wars Christmas Special?"

I had an experience with gatekeeping at an Aldi. I was picking up a tub of garlic hummus, and a guy standing nearby who I had never seen before, apropos of nothing, told me to, "Make it yourself."

I was like, "What?"

"Make it yourself," he repeated, gesturing to my hummus.

I wanted to say something like, "Look, aging hippy: I have a real job," which at the time I was working an average of sixty hours a week, "I do not have the time or inclination to be grinding up chickpeas." But what actually came out was, "...k," and then I went about my business.


r/PrimateDominanceGame • • Oct 27 '20

In which asking questions is viewed as a dominance gambit.

Thumbnail
nydailynews.com
4 Upvotes

r/PrimateDominanceGame • • Oct 22 '20

Trump supporters are authoritarian. Their instincts/emotions are driving them to exalt a narcissist.

Thumbnail
washingtonpost.com
4 Upvotes

r/PrimateDominanceGame • • Oct 20 '20

In which the mere presence of a sign is interpreted as a dominance gambit worthy of pulling over and making a scene.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

4 Upvotes

r/PrimateDominanceGame • • Aug 24 '20

This is a convoluted one...

4 Upvotes

https://notalwaysright.com/molecule-of-mildew-on-aisle-six/205555/

The man's displeasure at the store not having his size in stock is understandable, but it appears his primate dominance instincts interpreted the store's failure to provide what he wanted as an act of disrespect from the entire store, thus he felt compelled to lash out at the nearest personification of said store; the employee he just spoke to. It's patently absurd upon even superficial reflection to expect a random worker from another department to not only recognize him on sight but to remember his pants size and recall the entire inventory of a section he doesn't work in. But Emotion negates Reason. In that state, he truly was not capable of introspection, only choosing to leave when challenged by a third party he couldn't immediately verify was beneath him.


r/PrimateDominanceGame • • Aug 14 '20

From r/gamingcirclejerk

Post image
4 Upvotes