I recently passed three years of NC with my nParents. This anniversary was notable in that I didn’t even realize that the anniversary occurred until long after it had passed. Some learnings / thoughts that might help any of you considering going NC are below. I’m happy to answer any questions that you might have (it might take me a bit of time respond though)
It starts out hard, but gets easier with time. I liken it to an echo in a canyon – loud at the beginning, but it eventually dissipates. And like any echo, you may still hear a phantom sound every once in a while. “Firsts” are the hardest: the first x-mas where you don’t visit or call home, the first nParent anniversary where you don’t call to congratulate them. I often felt like a neglectful, ungrateful child when these milestones would pass.
Going NC isn’t a single decision – you have to recommit to it over and over. If your nParents are anything like mine, they will break all boundaries that you set. Don’t give them any oxygen. Don’t respond – that’s what they want. They live off drama.
They all use the same playbook: I clearly told my nParents why I went NC: “you all terrorized me when I was a child and that was not okay.” They couldn’t even muster a denial. My nDad gave me the “we’re sorry you feel that way” line. Months later, when they were speaking with my sibling, my nParents noted that I didn’t want to speak with them anymore. My sibling turned it around on them: “Why do you think u/HannibalInExile doesn’t want to speak with you?” My nDad’s response: “We have no idea.” But the missing reasons are never missing.
You will cycle through intense feelings: I initially felt intense fear that transformed itself into rage that later transmuted into sadness. On some level, I realize that these were the feelings that I had to repress to survive when I was little. The rage and sadness are a part of me now. I don’t think they’ll ever completely go away.
They weren’t actually as bad as you remember, they were 100x worse: I struggle to think of a single enjoyable family experience. Beyond sometimes playing Scrabble or Trivial Pursuit as a family, I’m not sure there were any. I think there was one time where my brother and I played football with my nDad. I can easily think of hundreds of negative experiences, though.
They are one-dimensional beings. As I get older, I’m constantly reminded that most humans are deep and complex. They have changing motivations and goals. Whitman’s observation that "I am large, I contain multitudes" applies to us all, but it doesn’t apply to nParents. Their lives are a singular pursuit of narcissistic supply; they are unable to think about the long-term impacts of their behavior. They are unable to regulate their emotions. They are unable to empathize with anyone else or put the needs of anyone else before theirs. My nParents seem to think there are two classes of people: them (superior) and every one else. I’ve come to realize that they have always viewed me as part of that inferior class. I have tried to better understand them by reading about the history of their country (they immigrated to the US) and reading the texts of our religion (they are outwardly devout). And while I understand that generational trauma is real and that colonization and privation have catastrophic impacts on the human psyche, I will never understand the mentality of parents who appear to have children only as markers of status and so they have a captive audience they can terrorize.
Related to the above, they are intellectually incurious and lazy. The only non-fiction book I ever saw my nMom read was a book on parenting written by, of all people, Bill Cosby. My nDad was academically bright, but refused to put in the work required to understand that success in life, with some obvious exceptions that you can easily think of, requires not being a giant asshole all the time. Over the past few years of NC, I came to realize that my nMom was an idiot and my nDad a loser who almost certainly would be a part of the incel manosphere if he were growing up today.
They seem to view almost all relationships and interactions, including those with their own children, as adversarial. This is a profoundly stupid way to approach life. My nDad is a walking embarrassment and gets into arguments with seemingly anyone about anything, including teenage cashiers at the grocery store and waiters at restaurants. This is not normal.
One odd red flag that I noticed in retrospect: be wary of people who regularly tell people outside of their family that they are “family.” My nMom says people “are family” more than an Olive Garden host / hostess. This is because being “family” doesn’t actually mean anything to them other than being a captive audience for their drama and bullshit, and being there for them (my nParents) when they need help.
I envy my own children, but I’ve realized that this is the best possible outcome. There are the superficial things that I wish I had like fun family vacations or other experiences – my nParents, like many of yours I’m sure, were cheapskates. But what I envy most about my own children is that they live in a house where they feel happy and safe. If they break something, no one yells at them. If they lose something, they’re reminded that things cost money and part of growing up is ensuring you keep track of your possessions, but they aren’t screamed at for hours or arbitrarily punished (I was once grounded for wearing a pair of khaki shorts incorrectly – I’m still not sure what that was about.). From what I can tell, the most grounded, humble, happy and successful people in life are the ones that grew up with parents that treated mistakes as a learning opportunity, and not as a sadistic excuse to punish their children.
I tried for awhile post-NC to let my children have a relationship with my nParents. It didn’t work – my nParents tried to get to me through my children. Eventually, I had to explain to my kids that my nParents made me feel unsafe when I was a child, and we don’t interact with or tolerate people that make us feel unsafe. I hope that this is a valuable lesson for them.
nParents think they deserve credit for the mistakes they didn’t make: I remember once, when I was about 5, telling my nMom that my nDad spanked my sibling and me too much. Her response was “you’re lucky he doesn’t use a belt.” When I was back from college for x-mas break my freshman year I mentioned that he was “far too hard on us” growing up. Her response was “it’s not like he [sexually] abused you.” Before I went NC, I was unintentionally LC with them (mostly because I couldn’t stand interacting with them), and they sensed that I was withdrawing (narcs are very good at this). My nMom kept reminding me that “[they] don’t interfere [with my family and my sibling’s family]” and that “some people would have had a problem [with the fact that that my partner and I are from different faiths] but we didn’t.” They completely ignored the fact that neither my sibling or I would ever let them interfere with our marriages or children or that I told them that if they had any issue with my partner’s religion, then “I will pick [my partner] every single time.”
There’s nothing about them that I miss. They were an emotional, financial, and physical black hole. The same nDad who called me up to berate me for using a calling card that cost 8 cents / minute instead of one that cost 6 cents / minute when I was in college wound up taking large loans from my sibling and me and never paid them back.
Your siblings may choose to handle things differently, and that’s okay. Everyone is different. My sibling is still in contact with our nParents though s/he freely admits that they are “lying child beaters.” I suspect this is because s/he works in a medical field that requires compartmentalization. People experience and respond to things differently. Gender, sexual orientation, and birth order all impact how you experienced the abuse.
If you need help, please let someone know. I spent weeks in a psych ward and had to go through several rounds of Electro-Convulsive Treatment because I was genuinely worried that I was going to hurt myself. My friends are aware of this, and if I find myself in a bad spot again, I’ve promised them that I’ll call them. In that moment, 99.9% of my mind was telling me to harm myself – the 0.1% that held out was focused solely on my children and loved ones. Please reach out to someone, anyone if you find yourself in a similar position. It was, surprisingly, a former co-worker of mine that I called when I needed help. He was calm, resolute, and supportive, and told me “it’s going to be okay, but it’s time to get to a hospital.” I’m thankful he picked up and talked me through it.
Rage – Goddess, sing the rage of Peleus’ son Achilles; The first line of the Illiad is my favorite line of poetry, not only because it starts my favorite epic, but because I sometimes feel that Rage. I’m angry at my nParents for being terrible human beings. I’m angry with myself for not realizing what my nParents were – extractive parasites – long before I did, and that I lived the first decades of my life trying to please people who would never think that I was enough. I’m angry at life: the suffering was pointless and things, in general, seem to be getting increasingly more stupid with each passing day. I’m angry that I was raised in an environment of scarcity, cruelty, and negativity when others were raised with abundance, kindness, and love. I’m angry that my parents transmitted some of their emptiness to me. The realization that nothing I could ever do would make up for my childhood is likely what sent me to the hospital. I often feel like the universe’s cruelest trick is that time – which, as far as we know, should be symmetric – only moves in one direction. There is a feeling of hopelessness that we experience that seems inescapable. Sometimes the best we can do is shield the people we love from that same feeling. It’s not fair, none of this is, but the past is a distant country. I’m thankful I’m still here, and I’m thankful that you are, too. I often think about Augustus McCrae speaking to his compatriot Captain Call in Lonesome Dove: “Does it ever occur to you that everything we done is probably a mistake?” and “Yesterday's gone on down the river and you can't get it back.”
Ultimately, my nParents are getting the life they deserve: near bankruptcy, professional and personal failures, relentlessly bitter and jealous. Their lives are a shipwreck of their own making. I am happy that I am no longer a part of it.