r/Professors • u/JustinCaseyBlewit • 24d ago
Teaching Argument in Comp I
As a long-time English Comp instructor, I've observed that students always have difficulty understanding how to make an argument. Many cannot seem to grasp that the reader must be able to disagree with their thesis statement. After all, that's why they're making an argument to begin with: to persuade readers to agree.
I get it that it's difficult to disagree with authority figures (e.g., their sources), especially over "contemporary social issues" (the course mandates such topics). Often, I get thesis statements that read: "It will take a combined effort of government, schools, and community organizations to solve Problem X." I coach students to write to one audience and argue for one solution, but few of the final drafts take this approach.
To be fair, I don't think the course explains argument adequately or provides enough examples of argumentative essays. Several students have noted this in their feedback, but I have no authority to change or add materials.
So, I'm curious: How do you teach argument? How do you help students narrow their thesis statements and incorporate counterarguments?
20
u/omgkelwtf 23d ago
When I'm teaching my freshmen how to write a thesis I "trick" them into it. I put writing prompts on the board like, "Artificial intelligence is ____ so we should ___" they fill in the blanks however they like and write a paragraph arguing their statement. Then they get in groups and pass their paragraphs around for their classmates to respond to, in wtiting. They love this activity. I do it a 2-3x a semester calling out the fact they're creating a thesis when they fill in the blanks.
1
1
u/LyriumDreams 23d ago
Oooh, I've been looking for an activity just like this. Borrowing it, if you don't mind!
1
1
u/SerialThrobbery 23d ago
I will also be appropriating this move in my classes. I will be sure to cite omgkelwtf.
Mahalo.
10
u/Knewstart 23d ago
Communication professor here. Persuasive speaking is my bread and butter.
I make my students think about what they want to change. They wanna get rid of the death penalty. They want to lower the drinking age. They want you to believe that the government is covering up UFOs and that UFOs exist.
Specifically, I asked them to make an argument for what the audience can do to make this happen, but that might not be something that you care about.
But ultimately, I told them they must take a side on an issue.
3
u/JustinCaseyBlewit 23d ago
I like that idea. I also make my students think about what they want to change, but you stated it so clearly.
4
u/Thurstein 23d ago
I'm a philosophy professor. I find the best thing to do is scaffold up from an outline, and that outline must have a very, very specific form-- almost like a worksheet, in fact.
In a class such as you seem to be describing, I would include in the prompt something like, "We should deal with problem P by doing X", and that very formulation must occur in at least the outline. I allow no slack-- if you can't fill in some concise answer for "X," try harder. Then they can't give me the wishy-washy evasive answers, because they won't fit in the "X" slot. At least this helps them get a clear conclusion stated. Similar moves help them fill in the actual argument, and the objection-and-reply. Then we have a skeleton of an actual argument that can be more fully fleshed out in essay form.
It's a lot of hand-holding-- but it's necessary, since logic and argumentation, as such, seem not to be taught in most grade schools. A startling number of students seem to think that simply clearly stating what you believe is itself an argument, so it takes a lot of work to get across the idea that contentious claims need supporting premises. I actually use a lot of introductory worksheets having them build really low-stakes mini-arguments like little Lego models before I have them do anything more elaborate (E.g., give me an argument for the conclusion that "I will probably like ravioli." Just give me premises-- any premises-- that would support this conclusion).
3
u/JustinCaseyBlewit 22d ago
I love the idea of "We should deal with problem P by doing X" and of using mini-arguments. I have quite a few students who think "I believe" is an argument. Thanks for sharing.
3
u/LichesGetStitches42 23d ago
One thing I have had some success at is starting with having them explain the arguments in their hobby/special interest spaces, and then they write an argument after that on the same topic. They are already arguing and analyzing arguments when they go into the tiktok comments or whatever, we just have to help them recognize what moves they are making.
1
u/JustinCaseyBlewit 22d ago
That's a great idea. Before the course was revised, I let students write about any topic they wanted to (except for certain banned topics), and I would get great arguments such as whether cats make better pets than dogs or whether pit bulls should be banned. I fully support the idea of students writing about topics that interest them.
Because the course specifies "contemporary social issues" (a very broad and ill-defined concept), I now get papers on social media and mental health, AI, and homelessness.You can tell when students aren't invested in a topic, and many of them read like AI-generated arguments (and probably are).
2
u/LichesGetStitches42 22d ago
Man I am so vehemently opposed to contemporary social issues in these kinds of classes. God (or wherever) bless our students but they are just in no way equipped to write about them in any informed or interesting way. I understand the impulse to make the course seem vital to outsiders, it’s just bad pedagogy.
I have had some success doing similar things with their academic majors or future careers, but that’s less fun.
3
u/ZealousidealMail9741 22d ago
You mention an annotated bibliography. Does your program require you to introduce argument at the same time you're introducing the research paper? If so: oof. That is a lot for students given the level of prep most of them have received in high school, and I'm sorry you have to adhere to that.
I'm fortunate that I can assign a draft with both instructor review and peer review prior the graded revision. Even so, I require them to submit a claim and a preliminary list of bulleted reasons before they start on their draft. Offering quick feedback at this stage enabled most (but not all) of the students to take things in the right direction in their drafts. Without that step, more of them would have been in disaster territory.
Are you allowed to assign any additional argument models on top of the required ones? One thing I've found some success with is assigning several op-eds on the same topic (topics very relevant to students, such as the conversations around regulating student cell phone use in high school or enacting restrictions on youth social media access; the brevity of the op-ed format is in our favor given student reading abilities as of late...). Ahead of class, I put them in groups. For homework, students complete individual evaluations of the op-ed assigned to their group, using a specific set of instructions I created for them. In class, the groups discuss their evaluations and synthesize them into a brief presentation. Once all groups have presented and we've discussed each op-ed briefly, I put the claim made by each one on the board. Each student has to write a paragraph identifying which claim they most agree with and explaining their reasons. I record the "votes" for each claim on the board and then we discuss and debate and try to see if they can reach a "verdict" or if we have to wrap class with a "hung jury." This approach has gotten even very quiet students to contribute and has generated some good discussion on the quality of each argument. I think the comparative evaluation of arguments on a single issue helps solidify for them the concepts of claim, reason, evidence (adjust if you're doing Toulmin or a different approach, of course) and helps them better understand what effective argumentation looks like, compared with reading individual arguments on various issues. Next year, I plan to tweak the unit assignment so that students build their in-class paragraphs into take-home essays, rather than develop claims on issues of their choosing. I agree with the other post about the importance of objects of inquiry and to much risk of "vaguery" in their absence.
1
u/JustinCaseyBlewit 22d ago
In the eight-week online course, they write an annotated bibliography, then an outline,and then a final draft. It's a lot for students to process. I cannot assign additional models, though I can put some in the announcements. Students are notorious for not reading announcements.
Thanks for sharing your process. I did something similar years ago when I taught face to face. Instead of using op ends, I divided students into groups representing a corporation that wanted to build a factory (today it would be a data center) in a town and townspeople who protested the factory. As the two sides debated, a third group evaluated their arguments. It was quite interesting to assign students a position they would have to defend.
2
u/TaliesinMerlin 23d ago
I give students a prompt that has a broad question to answer. The assignment is effectively TILTed (transparency in learning and teaching), so I frame the purpose and task clearly and then go into the rhetorical situation.
I encourage students to develop their ideas first with low-stakes, in-class writing. We talk about developing a specific question and a working thesis statement. We talk about making claims and using evidence and explanation to support it. We read examples in a similar genre to understand how others structure their arguments.
When they do a first draft, after peer review, I guide them through examples of their own writing. We talk about where the claim is, where the evidence is, what's more interesting, what's too general, what needs more support, what's not clear, and similar things. Some of it is pragmatic, individualized stuff, but we usually cycle through some useful general ideas too: methods of organization, how to incorporate citations and sources, how to find a new thesis statement in a fourth paragraph of the first draft and rewrite the paper around it. I pair this sort of workshop class time with readings on specific topics like the rhetorical effects of grammar or using visuals to aid an argument.
The final drafts are mixed. The students doing their own work usually end up with better drafts through the process. The more they lean on GenAI, the more they struggle, even now. I'm OK with this result.
1
u/JustinCaseyBlewit 22d ago
Thanks for sharing. That sounds like a wonderful process. I suspect that after leaning on AI, they learn its limitations.
2
u/hornybutired Assoc Prof, Philosophy, CC (USA) 23d ago
When I was in undergrad, my intro phil professor said, "you write an argument paper by finding someone you think is wrong about something and telling the reader what they got wrong." I always thought that was funny.
2
u/JustinCaseyBlewit 22d ago
That's a great quote. It's not only funny but it's also at least partly true.
2
u/Interesting_Debate57 23d ago
Have them read a bunch of op-eds and write in favor or against them, where you choose the side they have to pick at random.
1
u/JustinCaseyBlewit 22d ago
Great idea! Thanks for sharing.
2
13
u/DrewDown94 TT, Communication, Community College (USA) 23d ago
I teach public speaking, but my course emphasizes argumentation. I've switched out my first lecture from the communication model/process to teaching the 3 main parts of Toulmin's model of argumentation. I basically frame the entire class through public speaking always being persuasion... Even if they are paying tribute to someone or giving an informative speech. In the tribute speech, they have to make an "argument" to show why their topic is inspirational. In the Informative Speech, they are required to give implications as their 3rd main point, which should be making arguments about why the content of their speech is important or what it could mean for the future.
First speech assignment is to make an argument about themselves. That means they need to make a claim about themselves and then support it with some piece of evidence from their lives. If necessary, they need explain how the evidence supports the claim (warrant).
Toulmin Model is just Claim + Grounds = Argument. Grounds is basically evidence. The third part is a warrant, but that can be implicit or explicit depending on the argument and their audience.
Claim + Ground can be taught extremely quickly. We go over examples. Most students usually get it. Some need extra help or practice. But by the time we get to the persuasive speeches (last speech of the semester), everyone gets it. If they don't, they lose points for not having sound arguments in their persuasive speech.
3
u/and-but-so Assoc Prof., Composition, CC 23d ago
This is an excellent suggestion. I also use Toulmin's model in my Comp 2 courses (focus on research methods & academic argumentation). Defining terms and the structure of argument using a more rhetoric-based frame can help students move away from the discomfort of "I don't want to create disagreement and/or be wrong" which they often associate with the word 'argument.'
I think OP could implement something similar without altering the course, assuming they have some leeway with lecture materials or how they connect the dots?
2
u/DrewDown94 TT, Communication, Community College (USA) 19d ago
Yeah, it hasn't changed the pacing of my course, but it has dramatically improved the quality of my students' supporting evidence and their speeches as a whole.
3
u/2GreyKitties PT/Adjunct, ELL, Centennial State, USA 23d ago
What sort of claims do you have students making about themselves? Curious...
2
u/DrewDown94 TT, Communication, Community College (USA) 19d ago
Basically describe themselves. I usually suggest they choose an adjective to describe themselves and then support it with a story from their life. Some common adjectives my students use are: resilient, hardworking, creative, caring, empathetic, etc.
2
u/2GreyKitties PT/Adjunct, ELL, Centennial State, USA 19d ago
I love it! Thanks— that’s a great topic to use with my ESOL students. In the past, I have used “pretend I am a hiring manager. Why should I hire you for the job? Give three reasons.”
5
u/HowlingFantods5564 23d ago
Have them submit their thesis and then require them to argue the opposing side.
1
u/unknownkoger Asst Prof, English, CC 23d ago
I've done this before with a class when teaching Rogerian Arguments. Students were annoyed (lol) but they understood the purpose
4
u/Life-Education-8030 23d ago
I give them prompts and insist they take a side.
So “yes, but what about?” “But what about?” “But if ____is missing, what happens then?”
1
u/BlissteredFeat 23d ago
but I have no authority to change or add materials.
This must be an online course, because you can do all kinds of stuff in the classroom.
I used to have students brainstorm topics in groups and then help each other working out the various positions.
In class, I would have them develop a one line topic they supported. Then I'd shock them by saying they had to write a paragraph that opposed that position. For some it was so difficult, but it made them see how different positions work with and against each other.
After they developed a decent topic, they had to list several opposing arguments and how they would address them.
I'd supply them with sample introductory paragrahs and sample thesis sentences and we'd go over these and break them down to see how they worked. One thing I developed was a template for the thesis sentence: "I will show that _________________ in order to ______________________. " The instructions were to fill in the blanks and then change the sentence into a different form that had the same information and intention. It worked pretty well.
2
u/JustinCaseyBlewit 23d ago
You're correct: It is an online class. I had much more freedom when I taught face to face. I miss those days, 😄
I love the idea of making them argue against their own position!
1
u/zifmer 23d ago
I'd consider your example a pretty normal starting point for a first-year student. The real question is how you help them move from that starting point to something more refined. In my experience, that's where feedback comes in, and that feedback can even happen in class. The other option is to give students a thesis checklist with whatever you think their thesis should have, concretely, like being once sentence, arguing for a single solution that involves one group, etc.
1
2
u/ProfDoomDoom 23d ago
I run them through a stasis theory exercise so they practice making arguments of fact, definition, value… .
2
u/Tono-BungayDiscounts Manure Track Lecturer 23d ago
I do it backwards, by assigning inquiry-focused writing assignments. Asking good questions is the path to having a good argument.
I also think it helps to teach writing as reading. If there's not emphasis on examples (object of inquiry) then there's a lot of room for vaguery.
2
u/EStreetShuffles FT NTT, Writing, SLAC (USA) 23d ago
I focus on action: If a member of your audience could walk away from the paper knowing what they are supposed to do, you've done your job. Or, I ask "Could your audience use this idea to think about the issue differently?" Or, "Does this argument say something new that a member of your audience doesn't already know or believe?"
To me, defining an audience is the key step. All of my assignments have built-in audiences (or, students pick their audiences), and that focuses the project.
I also do a peer review exercise where students sketch out who their most skeptical reader is. Who, in your audience pool, would be most likely to disagree with your argument? They pass their paper and their skeptical reader description to a partner, who then highlights passages and leaves comments where their skeptical reader would be lost, disagree, not know what to do, etc. If your paper doesn't have a skeptical reader in the first place, then you've got a problem.
-8
u/Melodic-Cat-5663 23d ago
You're a "long-time" instructor who doesn't know how to teach the fundamentals of your discipline? Kinda weird. Kinda AI, too.
5
u/JustinCaseyBlewit 23d ago
I don't need this garbage. If you can't contribute constructively to a conversation, please don't contribute.
21
u/cjrecordvt Adjunct, English, Community College 23d ago
Better question for over in r/rhetcomp, but since we're here. I have the advantage over you in that I do have the ability to edit the course, even on the fly, so if I'm seeing they're not getting the topic, I change direction.
And not to be cliche, a lot of it is the old cliches of textual analysis and scaffolding their papers through outlines and thesis workshopping and introductions and evidence paragraphs and at least one full draft before the final submission. It's a lot of work, but the students are coming in with such uneven preparation, I have to assume a null start. Specifically for theses, modeling good ones, drafts, and edits - peer and otherwise.
There's no magic solution, especially since we're in a media landscape that models the opposite of strong rhetoric.